The Blue Rose

by Kate Forsyth

  David saw, over Viviane’s head, Briaca standing with the maids.

  ‘Pierrick, will you take Mamzelle to your mother? She is distressed.’

  The young man nodded and came forward, putting his arm about Viviane’s shoulders and leading her away.

  ‘What do we do with them all?’ David asked, staring down at the tragic heap.

  Pierrick turned his head, with a flash of his usual grin. ‘Eat them, of course!’

  Ten days later, a letter arrived from Viviane’s father.

  She opened it with a sick knot of anxiety in the pit of her stomach.

  Versailles, 6th November 1788

  Mademoiselle,

  It has most regrettably come to my attention that you have entered into a friendship of some intimacy with the English gardener. I hope I do not need to remind you of the honour due to your birth and position. I must inform you that any further conversation with the man in question shall lead to his dismissal, without pay or referral.

  Yours etc,

  Louis-Auguste-César de Ravoisier, the Marquis de Valaine.

  7

  A Rose as Red as Blood

  12–20 November 1788

  In November, the starlings flew from the cold north.

  Viviane leant her chin in her hands and gazed out at the twilight sky. This year there seemed to be more than ever before. Swirling and eddying and spiralling against the rose-coloured clouds, black sparks in a rising wind.

  Viviane felt she could not bear to be confined indoors anymore. ‘Pardon me, madame. I must take Luna out for a moment.’

  ‘Must you always be so restless?’ her great-aunt complained. ‘Sit still and finish your embroidery.’

  ‘Of course, madame. As long as you do not mind Luna piddling on the rug.’

  ‘Do not be so vulgar!’

  ‘A thousand pardons, madame. I will not be long. Shall I order you up some hot chocolate?’

  ‘And some more sweetmeats,’ her aunt sighed, dusting the sugar from her plump fingers.

  Viviane went out demurely, Luna trotting behind, then gave her aunt’s order to Agathe. She caught up her coat and muff and hat, and ran down the stairs and across the bridge. David was overseeing the paving of the avenue of linden trees. She halted momentarily, then walked swiftly past him, pretending not to see him. He leant on his shovel and gazed at her with bleak eyes.

  Viviane walked slowly, feeling the pain of their separation deep within her, like some kind of internal wound. She had not realised how much she had come to rely on him for comfort and companionship. Each day seemed leached of colour and vitality. Even the pastimes that had once brought her joy – her garden, her stillroom, her books – were now nothing but chores to fill in the dead hours of her days.

  It was not just David’s companionship that she was missing. Viviane hardly dared to speak or even look at Pierrick now that she knew the truth of his parentage. She wished that she could run to him and fling her arms about him and call him ‘brother’, but feared her father’s reaction if the truth was to come out. He would be merciless, she knew.

  The fields stretched out, ashy under the twilight sky, fringed with skeletal trees. It was cold. Viviane burrowed her hands into her ermine muff. She felt very alone.

  ‘Mamzelle!’

  The sound of David’s voice like a bolt of lightning to a metal key. She began to walk faster. He called again. She said, without turning, ‘No … you must not … he will find out.’

  ‘He?’

  ‘Monsieur le Marquis, my father.’

  He caught her by the arm and drew her to face him. ‘Is that why? Your father? But there is no-one here to see …’

  ‘They will have seen you follow me.’

  ‘No. I was discreet. I promise you.’

  She allowed herself to look up at him. The strong jaw, a little bristled this late in the day. The thick disobedient hair, the colour of old bronze. His eyes, grey as the sky.

  ‘He will dismiss you without pay.’

  ‘Only if someone sees us.’ He caught her gloved hand and drew her fast across the fields, away from the château. Viviane gripped his hand tightly. She felt like running, or dancing, or weeping.

  A distant rushing and roaring sound. Viviane pointed up into the sky.

  ‘What is it? A fire?’ David gazed at the dark billows swirling above his head.

  ‘No, it’s birds. Thousands and thousands of birds.’

  A torrent of starlings, pouring through the sky like a vast shape-shifting whirlwind. A swift elusive ballet, birds swooping and swerving and soaring as if they thought and responded with a single mind. For a moment, a spinning vortex was formed, then a shape like a leaping fish, then a parabolic curve, and then a great dragon with wings of shadows. David and Viviane watched, mesmerised, as the birds flashed overhead, so free and jubilant it made her chest ache.

  ‘Sacré bleu,’ she whispered. ‘What would I give to be so free?’

  At last the sun sank away, and stars began to prick out. The birds sank away. Silence dropped.

  ‘Why do they fly like that?’ Viviane wondered.

  ‘A hawk must have been threatening them,’ David said. ‘It’s an evasive manoeuvre, a feint.’

  ‘I think they do it for the joy of it. I feel it in my bones.’

  ‘Perhaps it is both. A flight for life and freedom, made more urgent by the threat of danger.’

  How she loved him. No-one else spoke to her the way David did. He seemed to know her own thoughts before she did herself.

  The ground seemed to rock beneath her feet. It is true, she thought. I do love him. I have loved him all this time and not known it. It is like I have found the missing piece of myself.

  Her first feeling was one of pure joy. Desolation soon cast its shadow upon her, however. Her father would never permit such a mésalliance.

  Slowly they began to walk back to the château, Luna frisking away after the scent of rabbits. Viviane’s hand was still on David’s arm, keeping her steady on the rough ground. She could feel the strength of his muscles, the warmth of his body so near to hers. It was so dark now she could only see the shape of him against the luminous sky. She would have liked to have stepped closer still, into his embrace, but instead she dropped her hand and drew away. Her jaw ached with misery.

  ‘Is your father cruel to you?’ David asked suddenly and unexpectedly.

  Viviane did not know how to answer.

  David stopped and turned her to face him. ‘Viviane, tell me. Is he cruel to you? Does he hurt you?’

  ‘He is my father. It is his duty to chastise me,’ she said at last.

  ‘Is that why you ran away?’ he asked. ‘When you tried to go to Saint-Malo and become a corsair?’

  She saw the white plume of his breath. Luna came to her, sensing her distress, pressing her body against Viviane’s leg.

  ‘I … did not wish to marry as my father ordered,’ she answered at last.

  David’s jaw tensed. ‘Who did he want you to marry?’

  ‘The Duc de Montmaront. He is much older than my father, but very rich.’

  ‘So you ran away?’

  She shrugged. ‘Oui. I stole some of Pierrick’s clothes and some food. I made it nearly all the way, sleeping in haystacks and under trees at night. Oh, my feet, they were so sore and blistered! But my father found me and brought me back. He was most displeased.’

  ‘But he relented? He said you did not need to marry the duke anymore?’

  ‘Oh no,’ she answered matter-of-factly. ‘He beat me till I could not stand, and then he took me to Versailles. I was to be presented at court, and then married. This was last spring, a few months before you came to Belisima.’

  ‘So what happened?’

  Viviane looked up at him, trying to see his face in the darkness. ‘My father and the king spend every day hunting. They like to see how many poor defenceless animals they can kill. Me, I do not like killing. One day I rode out into the forest on my horse. I made the sound of a
hunting horn, like so.’ She put both hands to her mouth and gave a startlingly good rendition of a hunting horn being blown.

  Luna began to bark in her deep voice.

  Viviane laughed and soothed her with loving strokes. ‘All the hounds ran after me, as you can imagine, and the hunters too. Oh, I led them a merry chase! Not one stag did they shoot that day, not one sparrow. My father, he was most angry, and the Duc de Montmaront, he said that he would not marry a girl with so little decorum.’

  ‘So you were sent back here in disgrace?’

  ‘Oui. My father, he thinks to punish me by keeping me from court, but me, I do not like court and I do not wish to marry anyway. So! He is happy thinking I am being punished and I am happy because I am home. It is only poor Madame who is miserable. She misses court very much. Even though all she ever did there was sleep and eat and play cards, just as she does here.’

  ‘You do not wish to be married? I thought all girls did.’

  ‘Yes, but you are an imbécile who knows nothing about women,’ she answered, turning away from him and beginning to walk once more across the fields, slashing at the thistles with a stick she seized from the ground.

  ‘Well, yes, so my sisters tell me,’ he answered, falling in beside her.

  ‘They are right.’

  ‘But will you not explain to me, then?’

  ‘Why would I wish to marry? I would have to leave Belisima and go away to court, and wear clothes of the most uncomfortable kind, and be bored to tears, while my husband gambled away my dowry and forced himself upon me, regardless of what I wished, all while flaunting his mistresses in front of me and ruining all that I hold dear to buy silk stockings and velvet coats and silver snuffboxes …’ Tears stung her eyes, and angrily she rubbed them away.

  David was appalled. ‘But … it doesn’t have to be like that, does it? What about love? What if you married for love?’

  ‘Those of my kind do not marry for love,’ Viviane answered.

  They walked along in silence. David had pushed both hands into his coat pocket, and his head was bent.

  After a long while Viviane said, a note of pleading in her voice, ‘I wish it were not so. Miss Hayward and I used to read novels together, like La Vie de Marianne or Julie, and I used to dream that one day I too would find a love like that, even if it was to end most tragically. But I know it is impossible. My father would never permit.’ She looked up at him, trying to smile. ‘So you see, it is better I do not marry at all. I would rather grow old and die than marry someone I do not love.’

  ‘That would be a crying shame,’ David said with some difficulty.

  Viviane coloured and looked away. ‘I must go in,’ she said. ‘I must not stay out here.’ Yet she lingered a moment longer, biting her lip. At last she looked up at him again and whispered, very low. ‘Pardon. Je suis désolée.’

  Only then did she turn to run across the fields towards the château. Luna bounded beside her, whining in distress.

  At last Viviane reached her room and flung herself down on the bed, hiding her face in the crook of her arm.

  Imbécile, she told herself. He is a gardener. And a Welshman. And a Protestant. Such a thing is impossible.

  But Viviane was tired of being told that all the things she wanted were impossible.

  When the roses finally arrived, it was a chilly day in late November.

  The sky was leaden, the lake silver. All the men were put to work carrying the roses across the bridge and through to the château’s outer bailey. Their thorny branches were bejewelled with rosehips, their roots carefully bound in hessian.

  At last the roses were all set in place, ready to be planted in the morning, and the men went inside in search of warm fires and hot cider. David stayed out in the half-twilight alone, smoking his pipe, gazing over what he had created from a patch of turf and weeds.

  Suddenly he became aware that Viviane was watching him from the steps of the château, Luna pressed against her leg. She was dressed in a long black velvet coat, lined and trimmed with ermine, with a matching cap trimmed with white heron feathers. Her hands were hidden within a white fur muff. Her face was very pale, her eyes very black. It was the first time he had seen her since the murmuration of starlings, the first time since he had discovered that she could not marry for love.

  She must have been watching from the banqueting hall, waiting to find him alone. Her breast was rising and falling hurriedly, as if she had run down three flights of stairs to meet him, out here in the garden where no-one would see. His blood quickened all through his body.

  Slowly she came down the snowy steps, Luna limping at her side. Her eyes met his for a moment, then she flushed and looked away.

  ‘The garden looks magical,’ she said. ‘It’s like a miracle, to see what you have wrought out of nothing.’

  ‘Thank you. Come, let me show it to you.’

  His hands clenched behind his back to stop himself from reaching for her, David led her towards two stone griffins, their wings laden with snow.

  The maze had been planted with more than seven hundred yew trees, six-foot-high and brought by a procession of oxen-drawn drays from Paris. Already David had begun clipping them into shape, so that they walked through dark shadowy corridors hung with tiny red berries. The only sound was the faint crunch of their feet on the snow-powdered gravel.

  At last they reached the inner garden, where a long oblong pool had been installed and filled with water piped in from the lake. It was now hazed with ice.

  At the northern end of the pool stood a statue of a young woman wearing a garland of marble roses. At the southern end was a sculpture of a young man kneeling, one hand braced on the ground, the other held out in entreaty to the Rose Maiden. The God of Love stood to the east, the tips of his marble arrows gleaming gold, standing beneath a fig tree trained into the shape of a fan. The statues were all caped with snow, and the roses stood in serried ranks of thorny trunks.

  ‘They look dead.’

  ‘They are just sleeping,’ David told her. ‘In spring, they shall bud again.’

  ‘Spring seems a long time away.’ Her voice was subdued, her face downcast. ‘And summer even longer.’

  Both knew that David’s work at the château was almost at an end.

  In a soft voice, David began to describe how the garden would look in full and voluptuous bloom when midsummer finally came.

  ‘Imagine to the south, where the Lover kneels, banks of red roses, symbolising passion and yearning. Then to the north, billowing around the Rose Maiden, white roses with golden hearts, meaning purity and innocence and awakening love. Then, to the east and the west, huge pink roses with a thousand petals and the sweetest scent imaginable.’

  ‘It will be lovely in summer. What a shame roses last such a short time!’ she said.

  ‘Yes. We will need to plant carefully to make sure there is colour and interest all year round. Red poppies and peonies and columbines to the south, white delphiniums and clematis to the north, and pink lilies with yarrow and apple-blossom beebalm to the east and west. I’d like to keep the flow of colour consistent but not rigid. And, of course, all will be enclosed within low box hedges to tie it all together.’

  ‘I wish we knew what colour the roses were,’ Viviane said, fingering a spray of orange hips.

  ‘It is written on their labels,’ David said. ‘See, the ones with Rosa Alba written on them are white, and the ones with Rosa Gallica written on them are a deep crimson-pink.’

  ‘Not red?’ she asked in surprise.

  ‘There are no true red roses,’ he answered. ‘Not in Europe anyway. I have heard rumours of a ruby-red rose in China, but all attempts to bring one back have failed. Sir Joseph Banks has invested a fortune in trying! But the journey is too long, and there are too many pitfalls for such a delicate flower.’

  ‘But all the medieval romances talk of red roses,’ she argued.

  ‘That was only because they did not have a word for “pink”,’ he said with
a wry grin. ‘Saying “pink” to describe a colour only began less than a hundred years ago. At first it meant flowers in the Dianthus genus, like carnations or sweet Williams or the common pink, which all have frilled or serrated petals, as if they have been cut with pinking shears. Gradually the word came to mean the colour as well as the flower.’

  ‘The things you know,’ she said in wonder.

  ‘My old lecturer Humphry Sibthorp loved stories like that. He knew dozens of fascinating facts about flowers and plants that he insisted on sharing with us at length.’

  ‘And so what colour is this rose?’ Viviane asked, bending over a plant that seemed quite different from the other two. She read the label. ‘It’s called Rosa Centifolia. Is that not from the Latin? Meaning a hundred leaves?’

  ‘Yes, it means a rose with a hundred petals. It’s a newly invented rose, and has tightly clustered petals of the loveliest pale pink colour, and a heavenly scent. It will look so beautiful.’

  ‘How can you invent a rose?’ she asked.

  ‘It’s easy enough. You take the the pistils from the heart of the mother rose, and dust it with pollen taken from the anthers from the father rose, and then you let it swell into a rosehip.’

  David suddenly became aware that discussing the sexing of a rose was not at all the type of conversation he should be having with a young, gently nurtured lady.

  ‘Then what do you do?’ she prompted him.

  He continued, with heightened colour and a constricted voice, ‘In spring, you cut open the rosehip and plant the seeds. In time, you will see the new rose you have invented. Hopefully it will have the qualities you want, the rich colour, the sweet scent, the many petalled-shape. Sadly, this does not happen nearly as often as you’d like.’

  ‘If I was to invent a rose, I’d make one that flowered more than once,’ Viviane said. ‘The rose blooms for such a short period, and the rest of the year it is just a thorny bush.’

  ‘I’ve heard that roses in China bloom again and again, even when the first frosts have fallen.’