Bardell v. Pickwick

by Charles Dickens

  A REVELATION.

  But now we come to a very critical passage in Mr. Pickwick's case: onethat really destroyed any chance that he had. It really settled thematter with the jury; and the worst was, the point was brought outthrough the inefficiency of his own counsel.

  But let us hear the episode, and see how the foolish Phunky muddled it.

  Mr. Phunky rose for the purpose of getting something important out of Mr. Winkle in cross-examination. Whether he did get anything important out of him, will immediately appear.

  [Picture: Mr. Phunky]

  'I believe, Mr. Winkle,' said Mr. Phunky, 'that Mr. Pickwick is not a young man?'

  'Oh no,' replied Mr. Winkle, 'old enough to be my father.'

  'You have told my learned friend that you have known Mr. Pickwick a long time. Had you ever any reason to suppose or believe that he was about to be married?'

  'Oh no; certainly not;' replied Mr. Winkle with so much eagerness, that Mr. Phunky ought to have got him out of the box with all possible dispatch. Lawyers hold out that there are two kinds of particularly bad witnesses, a reluctant witness, and a too willing witness; it was Mr. Winkle's fate to figure in both characters.

  'I will even go further than this, Mr. Winkle,' continued Mr. Phunky, in a most smooth and complacent manner. 'Did you ever see any thing in Mr. Pickwick's manner and conduct towards the opposite sex to induce you to believe that he ever contemplated matrimony of late years, in any case?'

  'Oh no; certainly not,' replied Mr. Winkle.

  'Has his behaviour, when females have been in the case, always been that of a man, who having attained a pretty advanced period of life, content with his own occupations and amusements, treats them only as a father might his daughters?'

  'Not the least doubt of it,' replied Mr. Winkle, in the fulness of his heart. 'That is--yes--oh yes--certainly.'

  'You have never known anything in his behaviour towards Mrs. Bardell, or any other female, in the least degree suspicious?' said Mr. Phunky, preparing to sit down, for Serjeant Snubbin was winking at him.

  'N--n--no,' replied Mr. Winkle, 'except on one trifling occasion, which, I have no doubt, might be easily explained.'

  Now, if the unfortunate Mr. Phunky had sat down when Serjeant Snubbin winked at him, or if Serjeant Buzfuz had stopped this irregular cross-examination at the outset (which he knew better than to do, for observing Mr. Winkle's anxiety, and well knowing it would in all probability, lead to something serviceable to him), this unfortunate admission would not have been elicited. The moment the words fell from Mr. Winkle's lips, Mr. Phunky sat down, and Serjeant Snubbin rather hastily told him he might leave the box, which Mr. Winkle prepared to do with great readiness, when Serjeant Buzfuz stopped him.

  'Stay, Mr. Winkle--stay,' said Serjeant Buzfuz, 'will your lordship have the goodness to ask him, what this one instance of suspicious behaviour towards females on the part of this gentlemen, who is old enough to be his father, was?'

  'You hear what the learned counsel says, Sir,' observed the Judge, turning to the miserable and agonized Mr. Winkle. 'Describe the occasion to which you refer.'

  'My lord,' said Mr. Winkle, trembling with anxiety, 'I--I'd rather not.'

  And Winkle had to relate the whole Ipswich adventure of the doublebeddedroom and the spinster lady.

  It is surprising that Dodson and Fogg did not ferret out all about Mr.Pickwick's adventure at the Great White Horse. Peter Magnus lived intown and must have heard of the coming case; these things _do_ somehowleak out, and he would have gladly volunteered the story, were it only tospite the man. But further, Dodson and Fogg must have made all sorts ofenquiries into Mr. Pickwick's doings. Mrs. Bardell herself might haveheard something. The story was certainly in the Ipswich papers, forthere was the riot in the street, the appearance before the mayor, theexposure of "Captain FitzMarshall"--a notable business altogether. Whata revelation in open court! Conceive Miss Witherfield called to deposeto Mr. Pickwick's midnight invasion. Mr. Pickwick himself might havebeen called and put on the rack, this incident not concerning his breachof promise. And supposing that the ubiquitous Jingle had heard of thisbusiness and had gone to the solicitor's office to volunteer evidence,and most useful evidence it would have been--to wit that Mr. Pickwick hadbeen caught in the garden of a young ladies' school and had alarmed thehouse by his attempts to gain admission in the small hours! Jingle ofcourse, could not be permitted to testify to this, but he could put thefirm on the track. Mr. Pickwick's reputation could hardly have survivedthese two revelations, and sweeping damages to the full amount would havebeen the certain result.

  This extraordinary adventure of Mr. Pickwick's at the Great White HorseInn, Ipswich, verifies Dodson's casual remark to him, that "he was eithera very designing or a most unfortunate man," circumstances being sostrong against him. As the story was brought out, in open court, owingto the joint indiscretion of Phunky and Winkle, it will be best, injustice to Mr. Pickwick, to give practically his account of the affair.

  'Nobody sleeps in the other bed, of course,' said Mr. Pickwick.

  'Oh no, sir.'

  'Very good. Tell my servant to bring me up some hot water at half-past eight in the morning, and that I shall not want him any more to-night.'

  'Yes, sir.'

  And bidding Mr. Pickwick good-night, the chambermaid retired, and left him alone.

  Mr. Pickwick sat himself down in a chair before the fire, and fell into a train of rambling meditations. First he thought of his friends, and wondered when they would join him; _then his mind reverted to Mrs. Martha Bardell_; and from that lady it wandered, by a natural process, to the dingy counting-house of Dodson and Fogg. From Dodson and Fogg's it flew off at tangent, to the very centre of the history of the queer client; and then it came back to the Great White Horse at Ipswich, with sufficient clearness to convince Mr. Pickwick that he was falling asleep: so he aroused himself, and began to undress, when he recollected he had left his watch on the table down stairs. So as it was pretty late now, and he was unwilling to ring his bell at that hour of the night, he slipped on his coat, of which he had just divested himself, and taking the japanned candlestick in his hand, walked quietly down stairs.

  The more stairs Mr. Pickwick went down, the more stairs there seemed to be to descend, and again and again, when Mr. Pickwick got into some narrow passage, and began to congratulate himself on having gained the ground-floor, did another flight of stairs appear before his astonished eyes. At last he reached a stone hall, which he remembered to have seen when he entered the house. Passage after passage did he explore; room after room did he peep into; at length, just as he was on the point of giving up the search in despair, he opened the door of the identical room in which he had spent the evening, and beheld his missing property on the table.

  Mr. Pickwick seized the watch in triumph, and proceeded to retrace his steps to his bed-chamber. If his progress downwards had been attended with difficulties and uncertainty, his journey back, was infinitely more perplexing. Rows of doors, garnished with boots of every shape, make, and size, branched off in every possible direction. A dozen times did he softly turn the handle of some bedroom door, which resembled his own, when a gruff cry from within of "Who the devil's that?" or "What do want here?" caused him to steal away on tiptoe, with a perfectly marvellous celerity. He was reduced to the verge of despair, when an open door attracted his attention. He peeped in--right at last. There were the two beds, whose situation he perfectly remembered, and the fire still burning. His candle, not a long one when he first received it, had flickered away in the drafts of air through which he had passed, and sunk into the socket, just as he had closed the door after him. 'No
matter,' said Mr. Pickwick, 'I can undress myself just as well by the light of the fire.'

  The bedsteads stood, one each side of the door; and on the inner side of each, was a little path, terminating in a rush-bottomed chair, just wide enough to admit of a person's getting into, or out of bed, on that side if he or she thought proper. Having carefully drawn the curtains of his bed on the outside, Mr. Pickwick sat down on the rush-bottomed chair, and leisurely divested himself of his shoes and gaiters. He then took off and folded up, his coat, waistcoat, and neck-cloth, and slowly drawing on his tasseled night-cap, secured it firmly on his head, by tying beneath his chin, the strings which he always had attached to that article of dress. It was at this moment that the absurdity of his recent bewilderment struck upon his mind; and throwing himself back in the rush-bottomed chair, Mr. Pickwick laughed to himself so heartily, that it would have been quite delightful to any man of well-constituted mind to have watched the smiles which expanded his amiable features, as they shone forth, from beneath the night-cap.

  'It is the best idea,' said Mr. Pickwick to himself, smiling till he almost cracked the night-cap strings--'It is the best idea, my losing myself in this place, and wandering about those staircases, that I ever heard of. Droll, droll, very droll.' Here Mr. Pickwick smiled again, a broader smile than before, and was about to continue the process of undressing, in the best possible humour, when he was suddenly stopped by a most unexpected interruption; to wit, the entrance into the room of some person with a candle, who, after locking the door, advanced to the dressing table, and set down the light upon it.

  The smile that played upon Mr. Pickwick's features, was instantaneously lost in a look of the most unbounded and wonder-stricken surprise. The person, whoever it was, had come so suddenly and with so little noise, that Mr. Pickwick had had no time to call out, or oppose their entrance. Who could it be? A robber? Some evil-minded person who had seen him come upstairs with a handsome watch in his hand, perhaps. What was he to do!

  The only way in which Mr. Pickwick could catch a glimpse of his mysterious visitor with the least danger of being seen himself, was by creeping on to the bed, and peeping out from between the curtains on the opposite side. Keeping the curtains carefully closed with his hand, so that nothing more of him could be seen than his face and nightcap, and putting on his spectacles, he mustered up courage, and looked out.

  Mr. Pickwick almost fainted with horror and dismay. Standing before the dressing glass, was a middle-aged lady in yellow curl-papers, busily engaged in brushing what ladies call their "back hair." However the unconscious middle-aged lady came into that room, it was quite clear that she contemplated remaining there for the night; for she had brought a rushlight and shade with her, which with praiseworthy precaution against fire, she had stationed in a basin on the floor, where it was glimmering away, like a gigantic lighthouse, in a particularly small piece of water.

  'Bless my soul,' thought Mr. Pickwick, 'what a dreadful thing!'

  'Hem!' said the lady; and in went Mr. Pickwick's head with automaton-like rapidity.

  'I never met with anything so awful as this,'--thought poor Mr. Pickwick, the cold perspiration starting in drops upon his nightcap. 'Never. This is fearful.'

  It was quite impossible to resist the urgent desire to see what was going forward. So out went Mr. Pickwick's head again. The prospect was worse than before. The middle-aged lady had finished arranging her hair; had carefully enveloped it, in a muslin nightcap with a small plaited border, and was gazing pensively on the fire.

  'This matter is growing alarming'--reasoned Mr. Pickwick with himself. 'I can't allow things to go on in this way. By the self-possession of that lady, it's clear to me that I must have come into the wrong room. If I call out, she'll alarm the house, but if I remain here, the consequences will be still more frightful.'

  [Picture: The Double Bedded Room, Great White Horse, Ipswich]

  Mr. Pickwick, it is quite unnecessary to say, was one of the most modest and delicate-minded of mortals. The very idea of exhibiting his nightcap to a lady, overpowered him, but he had tied those confounded strings in a knot, and do what he would, he couldn't get it off. The disclosure must be made. There was only one other way of doing it. He shrunk behind the curtains, and called out very loudly--

  'Ha--hum.'

  That the lady started at this unexpected sound was evident, by her falling up against the rushlight shade; that she persuaded herself it must have been the effect of imagination was equally clear, for when Mr. Pickwick, under the impression that she had fainted away, stone-dead from fright, ventured to peep out again, she was gazing pensively on the fire as before.

  'Most extraordinary female this,' thought Mr. Pickwick, popping in again. 'Ha--hum.'

  These last sounds, so like those in which, as legends inform us, the ferocious giant Blunderbore was in the habit of expressing his opinion that it was time to lay the cloth, were too distinctly audible, to be again mistaken for the workings of fancy.

  'Gracious Heaven!' said the middle-aged lady, 'what's that!'

  'It's--it's--only a gentleman, Ma'am,' said Mr. Pickwick from behind the curtains.

  'A gentleman!' said the lady with a terrific scream.

  'It's all over,' thought Mr. Pickwick.

  'A strange man,' shrieked the lady. Another instant and the house would be alarmed. Her garments rustled as she rushed towards the door.

  'Ma'am,'--said Mr. Pickwick, thrusting out his head, in the extremity of desperation, 'Ma'am.'

  Now although Mr. Pickwick was not actuated by any definite object in putting out his head, it was instantaneously productive of a good effect. The lady, as we have alreaded stated, was near the door. She must pass it, to reach the staircase, and she would most undoubtedly have done so by this time, had not the sudden apparition of Mr. Pickwick's nightcap driven her back, into the remotest corner of the apartment, where she stood, staring wildly at Mr. Pickwick, while Mr. Pickwick, in his turn, stared wildly at her.

  'Wretch,'--said the lady, covering her eyes with her hands, 'what do you want here.'

  'Nothing, Ma'am--nothing whatever, Ma'am,' said Mr. Pickwick, earnestly.

  'Nothing!' said the lady, looking up.

  'Nothing, Ma'am, upon my honour,' said Mr. Pickwick, nodding his head so energetically, that the tassel of his nightcap danced again. 'I am almost ready to sink, Ma'am, beneath the confusion of addressing a lady in my nightcap (here the lady hastily snatched off her's), but I can't get it off, Ma'am (here Mr. Pickwick gave it a tremendous tug in proof of the statment). It is evident to me, Ma'am, now, that I have mistaken this bedroom for my own. I had not been here five minutes, Ma'am, when you suddenly entered it.'

  'If this improbable story be really true, Sir,'--said the lady, sobbing violently, 'you will leave it instantly.'

  'I will, Ma'am, with the greatest pleasure,' replied Mr. Pickwick.

  'Instantly, Sir,' said the lady.

  'Certainly, Ma'am,' interposed Mr. Pickwick very quickly. 'Certainly, Ma'am. I--I--am very sorry, Ma'am,' said Mr. Pickwick, making his appearance at the bottom of the bed, 'to have been the innocent occasion of this alarm and emotion; deeply sorry Ma'am.'

  The lady pointed to the door. One excellent quality of Mr. Pickwick's character was beautifully displayed at this moment, under the most trying circumstances. Although he had hastily put on his hat over his night cap, after the manner of the old patrol; although he carried his shoes and gaiters in his hand, and his coat and waistcoat over his arm, nothing could subdue his native politeness.

  'I am exceedingly sorry, Ma'am,
' said Mr. Pickwick, bowing very low.

  'If you are, Sir, you will at once leave the room,' said the lady.

  'Immediately, Ma'am; this instant, Ma'am,' said Mr. Pickwick, opening the door, and dropping both his shoes with a loud crash in so doing.

  'I trust Ma'am,' resumed Mr. Pickwick, gathering up his shoes, and turning round to bow again, 'I trust, Ma'am, that my unblemished character, and the devoted respect I entertain for your sex, will plead as some slight excuse for this'--But before Mr. Pickwick could conclude the sentence, the lady had thrust him into the passage, and locked and bolted the door behind him.

  Whatever grounds of self-congratulation Mr. Pickwick might have, for having escaped so quietly from his late awkward situation, his present position was by no means enviable. He was alone, in an open passage, in a strange house, in the middle of the night, half dressed; it was not to be supposed that he could find his way in perfect darkness to a room which he had been wholly unable to discover with a light, and if he made the slightest noise in his fruitless attempts to do so, he stood every chance of being shot at, and perhaps killed, by some wakeful traveller. He had no resource but to remain where he was, until daylight appeared. So after groping his way a few paces down the passage, and to his infinite alarm, stumbling over several pairs of boots in so doing, Mr. Pickwick crouched into a little recess in the wall, to wait for morning, as philosophically as he might.

  He was not destined, however, to undergo this additional trial of patience: for he had not been long ensconced in his present concealment when, to his unspeakable horror, a man, bearing a light, appeared at the end of the passage. His horror was suddenly converted into joy, however, when he recognized the form of his faithful attendant. It was indeed Mr. Samuel Weller, who after sitting up thus late, in conversation with the Boots, who was sitting up for the mail, was now about to retire to rest.

  Imagine this story told by Miss Witherfield in open court, with all itsdetails, the lady's narrative being coloured by the recollection that shehad lost a suitable husband owing to her adventure. Mr. Peter Magnuswould have deposed to Mr. Pickwick's extraordinary interest in the matterof the proposal, and have added his suspicions on recalling Mr.Pickwick's ambiguous declaration that he had come down to expose acertain person--even one of his own sympathetic friends, who hadwitnessed the scene with Mrs. Bardell, and recalled the Boarding Houseincident, might murmur, "How odd that he is ever thus in pursuit of thefair under suspicious circumstances? _could_ it be that after all?--Whatif he had some previous knowledge of the lady, and secretly admired her,and stung to fury at the notion of Mr. Peter Magnus marrying, had takenthis strange mode of declaring his passion?" Even the sagacious Sam,devoted as he was to his master, was taken aback on meeting him in hismidnight wanderings.

  'Sam,' said Mr. Pickwick, suddenly appearing before him, 'Where's my bedroom?'

  Mr. Weller stared at his master with the most emphatic surprise; and it was not until the question had been repeated three several times, that he turned round, and led the way to the long-sought apartment.

  'Sam,' said Mr. Pickwick, as he got into bed, 'I have made one of the most extraordinary mistakes to-night, that ever were heard of.'

  'Werry likely, Sir,' replied Mr. Weller, drily.

  'But of this I am determined, Sam,' said Mr. Pickwick, 'that if I were to stop in this house for six months, I would never trust myself about it alone, again.'

  'That's the wery prudentest resolution as you could come to, Sir,' replied Mr. Weller. 'You rayther want somebody to look arter you, Sir, ven your judgment goes out a wisitin'.'

  'What do you mean by that, Sam?' said Mr. Pickwick. He raised himself in bed, and extended his hand, as if he were about to say something more; but suddenly checking himself, turned round, and bade his valet 'Good night.'

  'Good night, Sir,' replied Mr. Weller. He paused when he got outside the door--shook his head--walked on--stopped--snuffed the candle--shook his head again--and finally proceeded slowly to his chamber, apparently buried in the profoundest meditation.

  It will be seen that Sam went near to being disrespectful in hissceptical view of his master's story.

  When Mrs. Sanders was examined, "the Court" put a few questions to her,as to the customs of love-making among persons of her position. She had"received love letters, like other ladies. In the course of theircorrespondence Mr. Sanders had often called her a 'duck' but never'chops' or 'tomato sauce.' He was particularly fond of ducks. Perhapsif he had been as fond of chops and tomato sauce, he might have calledher that, as a term of affection."

  Mrs. Sanders was clearly one of the same class as Mrs. Cluppins, andchiefly deposed to the general impression in the neighbourhood that Mr.Pickwick had "offered" for Mrs. Bardell. Tupman, Snodgrass and Sam werealso examined. Being friends of the defendant, they were from the outsetassumed to be "hostile" and treated accordingly. It may be doubted,however, whether it is permissible to treat "your own witnesses" in thisrough fashion, until at least they have shown some overt signs of theirhostility, either by reserve, or an obvious determination to let aslittle as possible be extracted from them. In such case, it is usual toapply to the court for its sanction to deal with them by the severity ofcross examination.

  When Sam entered the witness box, the Serjeant addressed him: "I believeyou are in the service of Mr. Pickwick, the Defendant in this case._Speak up_, _if you please_, _Mr. Weller_." Sam had not had time to sayanything, so the admonition might seem superfluous. But this is awell-known device. Sam had been "briefed" to the Serjeant as a ratherdangerous witness--somewhat too wide awake. It was necessary thereforeto be short and summary with him. He thus conveyed to the jury that thisSam was one whom he could address in this curt way, and who by his low,uncertain accents might try to hide the truth. Sam, however,disconcerted the plan by his prompt, ready answer, "I _mean_ to speak up,sir." Sam, as we know, clearly brought out the Dodson and Fogg'sdamaging assurance to Mrs. Bardell, that no costs should be charged toher personally.

  When the Plaintiff's case was closed, things did not look particularlybright for Mr. Pickwick. It had been shown on the evidence of his ownfriends that he had been surprised with his landlady in his arms; (2)That he had been corresponding with her on most familiar terms--at leastSerjeant Buzfuz had made it appear so; (3) Language that _almost_amounted to a proposal had been overheard; (4) And finally, it had beenrevealed that the Defendant had been "caught" in a lady's bedroom, at anInn, at midnight! To answer which a "strong" case was absolutelyessential. This, we grieve to say, was not forthcoming.