The Fantasy and Mystery Stories of F Scott Fitzgerald

by F. Scott Fitzgerald

  It was a dark afternoon, threatening rain and the end of the world, and done in that particularly gloomy grey in which only New York afternoons indulge. A breeze was crying down the streets, whisking along battered newspapers and pieces of things, and little lights were pricking out all the windows – it was so desolate that one was sorry for the tops of sky-scrapers lost up there in the dark green and grey heaven, and felt that now surely the farce was to close, and presently all the buildings would collapse like card houses, and pile up in a dusty, sardonic heap upon all the millions who presumed to wind in and out of them.

  At least these were the sort of musings that lay heavily upon the soul of Merlin Grainger, as he stood by the window putting a dozen books back in a row, after a cyclonic visit by a lady with ermine trimmings. He looked out of the window full at the most distressing thoughts – of the early novels of H.G. Wells, of the book of Genesis, of how Thomas Edison had said that in thirty years there would be no dwelling-houses upon the island, but only a vast and turbulent bazaar; and then he set the last book right side up, turned – and Caroline walked coolly into the shop.

  She was dressed in a jaunty but conventional walking costume – he remembered this when he thought about it later. Her skirt was plaid, pleated like a concertina; her jacket was a soft but brisk tan; her shoes and spats were brown and her hat, small and trim, completed her like the top of a very expensive and beautifully filled candy box.

  Merlin, breathless and startled, advanced nervously toward her.

  ‘Good-afternoon –’ he said, and then stopped – why, he did not know, except that it came to him that something very portentous in his life was about to occur, and that it would need no furbishing but silence, and the proper amount of expectant attention. And in that minute before the thing began to happen he had the sense of a breathless second hanging suspended in time: he saw through the glass partition that bounded off the little office the malevolent conical head of his employer, Mr Moonlight Quill, bent over his correspondence. He saw Miss McCracken and Miss Masters as two patches of hair drooping over piles of paper; he saw the crimson lamp overhead, and noticed with a touch of pleasure how really pleasant and romantic it made the book-store seem.

  Then the thing happened, or rather it began to happen. Caroline picked up a volume of poems lying loose upon a pile, fingered it absently with her slender white hand, and suddenly, with an easy gesture, tossed it upward toward the ceiling, where it disappeared in the crimson lamp and lodged there, seen through the illuminated silk as a dark, bulging rectangle. This pleased her – she broke into young, contagious laughter, in which Merlin found himself presently joining.

  ‘It stayed up!’ she cried merrily. ‘It stayed up, didn’t it?’ To both of them this seemed the height of brilliant absurdity. Their laughter mingled, filled the bookshop, and Merlin was glad to find that her voice was rich and full of sorcery.

  ‘Try another,’ he found himself suggesting – ‘try a red one.’

  At this her laughter increased, and she had to rest her hands upon the stack to steady herself.

  ‘Try another,’ she managed to articulate between spasms of mirth. ‘Oh, golly, try another!’

  ‘Try two.’

  ‘Yes, try two. Oh, I’ll choke if I don’t stop laughing. Here it goes.’

  Suiting her action to the word, she picked up a red book and sent it in a gentle hyperbola toward the ceiling, where it sank into the lamp beside the first. It was a few minutes before either of them could do more than rock back and forth in helpless glee; but then by mutual agreement they took up the sport anew, this time in unison. Merlin seized a large, specially bound French classic and whirled it upward. Applauding his own accuracy, he took a best-seller in one hand and a book on barnacles in the other, and waited breathlessly while she made her shot. Then the business waxed fast and furious – sometimes they alternated, and, watching, he found how supple she was in every movement; sometimes one of them made shot after shot, picking up the nearest book, sending it off, merely taking time to follow it with a glance before reaching for another. Within three minutes they had cleared a little place on the table, and the lamp of crimson satin was so bulging with books that it was near breaking.

  ‘Silly game, basket-ball,’ she cried scornfully as a book left her hand. ‘High-school girls play it in hideous bloomers.’

  ‘Idiotic,’ he agreed.

  She paused in the act of tossing a book, and replaced it suddenly in its position on the table.

  ‘I think we’ve got room to sit down now,’ she said gravely.

  They had; they had cleared an ample space for two. With a faint touch of nervousness Merlin glanced toward Mr Moonlight Quill’s glass partition, but the three heads were still bent earnestly over their work, and it was evident that they had not seen what had gone on in the shop. So when Caroline put her hands on the table and hoisted herself up Merlin calmly imitated her, and they sat side by side looking very earnestly at each other.

  ‘I had to see you,’ she began, with a rather pathetic expression in her brown eyes.

  ‘I know.’

  ‘It was that last time,’ she continued, her voice trembling a little, though she tried to keep it steady. ‘I was frightened. I don’t like you to eat off the dresser. I’m so afraid you’ll – you’ll swallow a collar button.’

  ‘I did once – almost,’ he confessed reluctantly, ‘but it’s not so easy, you know. I mean you can swallow the flat part easy enough or else the other part – that is, separately – but for a whole collar button you’d have to have a specially made throat.’ He was astonishing himself by the debonair appropriateness of his remarks. Words seemed for the first time in his life to run at him shrieking to be used, gathering themselves into carefully arranged squads and platoons, and being presented to him by punctilious adjutants of paragraphs.

  ‘That’s what scared me,’ she said. ‘I knew you had to have a specially made throat – and I knew, at least I felt sure, that you didn’t have one.’

  He nodded frankly.

  ‘I haven’t. It costs money to have one – more money unfortunately than I possess.’

  He felt no shame in saying this – rather a delight in making the admission – he knew that nothing he could say or do would be beyond her comprehension; least of all his poverty, and the practical impossibility of ever extricating himself from it.

  Caroline looked down at her wrist watch, and with a little cry slid from the table to her feet.

  ‘It’s after five,’ she cried. ‘I didn’t realize. I have to be at the Ritz at five-thirty. Let’s hurry and get this done. I’ve got a bet on it.’

  With one accord they set to work. Caroline began the matter by seizing a book on insects and sending it whizzing, and finally crashing through the glass partition that housed Mr. Moonlight Quill. The proprietor glanced up with a wild look, brushed a few pieces of glass from his desk, and went on with his letters. Miss McCracken gave no sign of having heard – only Miss Masters started and gave a little frightened scream before she bent to her task again.

  But to Merlin and Caroline it didn’t matter. In a perfect orgy of energy they were hurling book after book in all directions, until sometimes three or four were in the air at once, smashing against shelves, cracking the glass of pictures on the walls, falling in bruised and torn heaps upon the floor. It was fortunate that no customers happened to come in, for it is certain they would never have come in again – the noise was too tremendous, a noise of smashing and ripping and tearing, mixed now and then with the tinkling of glass, the quick breathing of the two throwers, and the intermittent outbursts of laughter to which both of them periodically surrendered.

  At five-thirty Caroline tossed a last book at the lamp, and so gave the final impetus to the load it carried. The weakened silk tore and dropped its cargo in one vast splattering of white and color to the already littered floor. Then with a sigh of relief she turned to Merlin and held out her hand.

  ‘Goodbye,’ she said simply
.

  ‘Are you going?’ He knew she was. His question was simply a lingering wile to detain her and extract for another moment that dazzling essence of light he drew from her presence, to continue his enormous satisfaction in her features, which were like kisses and, he thought, like the features of a girl he had known back in 1910. For a minute he pressed the softness of her hand – then she smiled and withdrew it and, before he could spring to open the door, she had done it herself and was gone out into the turbid and ominous twilight that brooded narrowly over Forty-seventh Street.

  I would like to tell you how Merlin, having seen how beauty regards the wisdom of the years, walked into the little partition of Mr Moonlight Quill and gave up his job then and there; thence issuing out into the street a much finer and nobler and increasingly ironic man. But the truth is much more commonplace. Merlin Grainger stood up and surveyed the wreck of the bookshop, the ruined volumes, the torn silk remnants of the once beautiful crimson lamp, the crystalline sprinkling of broken glass which lay in iridescent dust over the whole interior – and then he went to a corner where a broom was kept and began cleaning up and rearranging and, as far as he was able, restoring the shop to its former condition. He found that, though some few of the books were uninjured, most of them had suffered in varying extents. The backs were off some, the pages were torn from others, still others were just slightly cracked in the front, which, as all careless book returners know, makes a book unsaleable, and therefore second-hand.

  Nevertheless by six o’clock he had done much to repair the damage. He had returned the books to their original places, swept the floor, and put new lights in the sockets overhead. The red shade itself was ruined beyond redemption, and Merlin thought in some trepidation that the money to replace it might have to come out of his salary. At six, therefore, having done the best he could, he crawled over the front window display to pull down the blind. As he was treading delicately back, he saw Mr Moonlight Quill rise from his desk, put on his overcoat and hat, and emerge into the shop. He nodded mysteriously at Merlin and went toward the door. With his hand on the knob he paused, turned around, and in a voice curiously compounded of ferocity and uncertainty, he said:

  ‘If that girl comes in here again, you tell her to behave.’

  With that he opened the door, drowning Merlin’s meek ‘Yessir’ in its creak, and went out.

  Merlin stood there for a moment, deciding wisely not to worry about what was for the present only a possible futurity, and then he went into the back of the shop and invited Miss Masters to have supper with him at Pulpat’s French Restaurant, where one could still obtain red wine at dinner, despite the Great Federal Government. Miss Masters accepted.

  ‘Wine makes me feel all tingly,’ she said.

  Merlin laughed inwardly as he compared her to Caroline, or rather as he didn’t compare her. There was no comparison.

  II

  Mr Moonlight Quill, mysterious, exotic, and oriental in temperament was, nevertheless, a man of decision. And it was with decision that he approached the problem of his wrecked shop. Unless he should make an outlay equal to the original cost of his entire stock – a step which for certain private reasons he did not wish to take – it would be impossible for him to continue in business with the Moonlight Quill as before. There was but one thing to do. He promptly turned his establishment from an up-to-the-minute book-store into a second-hand bookshop. The damaged books were marked down from twenty-five to fifty per cent, the name over the door whose serpentine embroidery had once shone so insolently bright, was allowed to grow dim and take on the indescribably vague color of old paint, and, having a strong penchant for ceremonial, the proprietor even went so far as to buy two skull-caps of shoddy red felt, one for himself and one for his clerk, Merlin Grainger. Moreover, he let his goatee grow until it resembled the tail-feathers of an ancient sparrow and substituted for a once dapper business suit a reverence-inspiring affair of shiny alpaca.

  In fact, within a year after Caroline’s catastrophic visit to the bookshop the only thing in it that preserved any semblance of being up to date was Miss Masters. Miss McCracken had followed in the footsteps of Mr Moonlight Quill and become an intolerable dowd.

  For Merlin too, from a feeling compounded of loyalty and listlessness, had let his exterior take on the semblance of a deserted garden. He accepted the red felt skull-cap as a symbol of his decay. Always a young man known as a ‘pusher,’ he had been, since the day of his graduation from the manual training department of a New York High School, an inveterate brusher of clothes, hair, teeth, and even eyebrows, and had learned the value of laying all his clean socks toe upon toe and heel upon heel in a certain drawer of his bureau, which would be known as the sock drawer.

  These things, he felt, had won him his place in the greatest splendor of the Moonlight Quill. It was due to them that he was not still making ‘chests useful for keeping things,’ as he was taught with breathless practicality in High School, and selling them to whoever had use of such chests – possibly undertakers. Nevertheless when the progressive Moonlight Quill became the retrogressive Moonlight Quill he preferred to sink with it, and so took to letting his suits gather undisturbed the wispy burdens of the air and to throwing his socks indiscriminately into the shirt drawer, the underwear drawer, and even into no drawer at all. It was not uncommon in his new carelessness to let many of his clean clothes go directly back to the laundry without having ever been worn, a common eccentricity of impoverished bachelors. And this in the face of his favorite magazines, which at that time were fairly staggering with articles by successful authors against the frightful impudence of the condemned poor, such as the buying of wearable shirts and nice cuts of meat, and the fact that they preferred good investments in personal jewelry to respectable ones in four per cent saving-banks.

  It was indeed a strange state of affairs and a sorry one for many worthy and God-fearing men. For the first time in the history of the Republic almost any negro north of Georgia could change a one-dollar bill. But as at that time the cent was rapidly approaching the purchasing power of the Chinese ubu and was only a thing you got back occasionally after paying for a soft drink, and could use merely in getting your correct weight, this was perhaps not so strange a phenomenon as it at first seems. It was too curious a state of things, however, for Merlin Grainger to take the step that he did take – the hazardous, almost involuntary step of proposing to Miss Masters. Stranger still that she accepted him.

  It was at Pulpat’s on Saturday night and over a $1.75 bottle of water diluted with vin ordinaire that the proposal occurred.

  ‘Wine makes me feel all tingly, doesn’t it you?’ chattered Miss Masters gaily.

  ‘Yes,’ answered Merlin absently; and then, after a long and pregnant pause: ‘Miss Masters – Olive – I want to say something to you if you’ll listen to me.’

  The tingliness of Miss Masters (who knew what was coming) increased until it seemed that she would shortly be electrocuted by her own nervous reactions. But her ‘Yes, Merlin,’ came without a sign or flicker of interior disturbance. Merlin swallowed a stray bit of air that he found in his mouth.

  ‘I have no fortune,’ he said with the manner of making an announcement. ‘I have no fortune at all.’

  Their eyes met, locked, became wistful, and dreamy and beautiful.

  ‘Olive,’ he told her, ‘I love you.’

  ‘I love you too, Merlin,’ she answered simply. ‘Shall we have another bottle of wine?’

  ‘Yes,’ he cried, his heart beating at a great rate. ‘Do you mean –’

  ‘To drink to our engagement,’ she interrupted bravely. ‘May it be a short one!’

  ‘No!’ he almost shouted, bringing his fist fiercely down upon the table. ‘May it last forever!’

  ‘What?’

  ‘I mean – oh, I see what you mean. You’re right. May it be a short one.’ He laughed and added, ‘My error.’

  After the wine arrived they discussed the matter thoroughly.

&n
bsp; ‘We’ll have to take a small apartment at first,’ he said, ‘and I believe, yes, by golly, I know there’s a small one in the house where I live, a big room and a sort of a dressing-room-kitchenette and the use of a bath on the same floor.’

  She clapped her hands happily, and he thought how pretty she was really, that is, the upper part of her face – from the bridge of the nose down she was somewhat out of true. She continued enthusiastically:

  ‘And as soon as we can afford it we’ll take a real swell apartment, with an elevator and a telephone girl.’

  ‘And after that a place in the country – and a car.’

  ‘I can’t imagine nothing more fun. Can you?’

  Merlin fell silent a moment. He was thinking that he would have to give up his room, the fourth floor rear. Yet it mattered very little now. During the past year and a half – in fact, from the very date of Caroline’s visit to the Moonlight Quill – he had never seen her. For a week after that visit her lights had failed to go on – darkness brooded out into the areaway, seemed to grope blindly in at his expectant, uncurtained window. Then the lights had appeared at last, and instead of Caroline and her callers they showed a stodgy family – a little man with a bristly mustache and a full-bosomed woman who spent her evenings patting her hips and rearranging bric-à-brac. After two days of them Merlin had callously pulled down his shade.

  No, Merlin could think of nothing more fun than rising in the world with Olive. There would be a cottage in a suburb, a cottage painted blue, just one class below the sort of cottages that are of white stucco with a green roof. In the grass around the cottage would be rusty trowels and a broken green bench and a baby-carriage with a wicker body that sagged to the left. And around the grass and the baby-carriage and the cottage itself, around his whole world there would be the arms of Olive, a little stouter, the arms of her neo-Olivian period, when, as she walked, her cheeks would tremble up and down ever so slightly from too much face-massaging. He could hear her voice now, two spoons’ length away: