I Bet You

by Madden-Mills, Ilsa

  I sigh and head to the football table, where they promptly hand over the money. “Nice doing business with you, boys,” I say before flouncing off, feeling Ryker’s eyes on me the entire time.

  What’s his deal with me?

  I mean, you’d think he’d want to avoid me because of the article, but it’s as if his mission is to be around me as much as he can. In fact, I’m not even sure he knew who I was before I wrote it since we don’t run in the same circles. I suspect he’s torturing me.

  I push him out of my head and walk over to a table that needs bussing, picking up half-empty soda glasses and putting them on my tray. The door chimes, signaling that someone has come in, and I raise my head to see—

  Whoa.

  I freeze.

  Bring out the angels and cue the hallelujah chorus.

  Now that’s the kind of man I should be writing sexy scenes about.

  Standing at the door is Connor Dimpleshitz—yes, his surname is unfortunate, but his IQ makes up for it. I’ve been crushing on him since our sociology class last semester.

  Framed by a golden halo of sunlight as it glints through the windows, I decide he’s what would happen if Albert Einstein and Henry Cavill had a baby. “A hot genius. The perfect unicorn,” I murmur to myself.

  I chew on my lip, debating on whether to mosey up to him and say hi or hide.

  Hide wins. I know, I’m a little ridiculous, especially since we have calculus together this semester and he’ll obviously see me at some point in class.

  But then I’ll have good hair and ketchup-free clothes.

  I quickly survey the possibilities for my escape as the hostess seats him in another server’s section. My eyes land on the right side of the restaurant, where I could make a mad dash for the kitchen, but he’s bound to see me darting since I’d have to walk past him. Plus, I want to hang around and watch him without him knowing.

  I come to a decision. Wrangling the tray of half-empty sodas I cleared, I quickstep it over to the back left corner, the farthest away from the double doors of the entrance. I maneuver my body into an awkward hunkering position behind a huge potted plant with wide fan-shaped leaves. At least five feet tall with a gnarly brown trunk, the green monster is perfect camouflage.

  I peek around a big leaf that’s in dire need of a good dusting, judging by the motes floating around. Feeling paranoid that someone is a witness to my absurdity, I throw a quick glance over my shoulder to make sure no one’s around.

  Ryker. Shit.

  He’s staring at me from the football table, and there’s a glint in his gaze, as if he’s wondering what I’m doing.

  I scowl and stick my tongue out at him. He makes me feel so rebellious and flustered and…excited.

  I can’t even stop myself. Ugh.

  His expression deepens in amusement, and I grimace, realizing my butt is sticking out. His annoying eyebrow jacks up and says, What the hell are you doing?

  With eye telepathy I tell him to mind his own freaking business.

  I pointedly turn my back on him and focus on The Unicorn.

  A few seconds later, a familiar deep voice resonates from behind me, making me start. “You look a little flustered, Penelope. Spying on someone for your next story, perhaps?”

  I freeze. Blink. His voice is husky and lower than before when he was calling me garçon, the tone reminding me of languid summer nights under a starry Southern sky while he gives me deep, passionate kisses—

  Good Lord. Stop your daydreaming. Must. Stop. Reading. Romances.

  I heave out a sigh and turn around to face Ryker.

  What the hell does he want now?

  “I don’t submit to the Wildcat Weekly anymore,” I say.

  I worked for them most of last year, covering the home games and a few random articles. With a dad who was in the NFL, I know a lot about football, but when Sugar’s offered me more hours, I took it.

  “No more football stories, huh?”

  I shrug, my gaze taking in his chiseled cheekbones, the curve of his full lips, the hint of scruff on his jaw. Dammit, why is he so gorgeous? “What can I say? I covered the most fascinating story last semester—you. Guess I went out on a high note.”

  He nods, taking that dig. “I always noticed you at the games.”

  I scoff. “I didn’t think girls like me were on your radar.”

  “You sat near the third row at the fifty-yard line taking notes at every home game.” His eyes drift over me. “And I didn’t say you were on my radar.”

  “Really? Sounds like you did.”

  “Trust me, I have more discriminating tastes.” He shrugs.

  “Why, how sweet of you.” My Southern accent has thickened, the way it does when I’m sassy. It’s one thing to know he doesn’t like me, but for him to say I’m not up to his standards…well. “Did you pop over here just to be nice?”

  He exhales and rakes a hand through his hair, calling attention to the lighter strands that have been bleached by the sun. “Honestly, I’m not sure why I came over here.” A conflicted expression crosses his face as he tugs at his collar. My eyes stare at the myriad of curly blond chest hairs that are poking out from the V-neck of the light blue Oxford he’s wearing with the sleeves rolled up to his elbows. “I just wanted to make sure you were okay from the ketchup getting all over you, but everything I’m saying is coming out wrong.”

  Oh. This is different. And not what I expected.

  “I’m fine, Baby Llama. No need to worry. You can go. Your girlfriends are waiting for you.” I tilt my head back toward the football table.

  He doesn’t budge. “Baby Llama?” An amused grin flashes over his face.

  I shrug. It’s been my private nickname for him since sophomore year when I stumbled upon him coming out of an upstairs bathroom at the Tau house after a shower with only a white towel wrapped around his trim waist. Some jersey chaser was with him. His hairy chest had both shocked my virgin sensibilities and excited me at the same time. The unruly curls just made him seem more naked, as if I’d seen his cock. Much to my dismay, I’d later dream about rolling around on that bed of golden curls. Seriously, who takes a shower with a chick in the middle of a kegger? Ryker Voss, that’s who. Because he can. And girls do whatever he wants.

  But not this one.

  I respect the game—even love it—but I don’t fall for football players, especially high and mighty quarterbacks who think they walk on water. My dad was the star player at Waylon twenty years ago, and trust me, I know how they operate. They get what they want and then they walk out, leaving broken hearts everywhere.

  “Have you ever seen a real llama?” he asks, continuing our conversation. It’s as if he’s actually trying to be nice. “I saw one at a safari park once. Little bugger tried to eat my hand off when I fed him, but he was cute. Maybe you need a poster of one in your room so when you see it, you’ll think about me. I’ll even sign it for you.”

  And there’s the cocky again.

  “Buy me one. I’ll throw darts at it.”

  “Damn, you never stop.” He huffs out a laugh, his eyes lingering on my neck. “Oh, there’s a bit of ketchup here too,” he says, reaching out to glide his finger across the top of my collar, his knuckles barely brushing against my neck.

  The feather-light touch is brief and not sexual, yet my body hums, tendrils of sparks racing over my skin. I suck in a breath and catch his scent, warm and spicy with hints of leather and sandalwood.

  He blinks and clears his throat. “Um, I actually have this cleaner stuff that I spray on my practice clothes. It’s a miracle worker. You’re welcome to borrow it. Of course, you’d have to come by the football dorm to pick it up. We could even do laundry together if you wanted?”

  He says the words softly, as if they’re nothing, and I’m staring at him full on.

  Do our laundry together?

  I suspect Ryker Voss is flirting with me, though not well. The pimply-faced checkout boy at Big Star has better lines than this.

&nb
sp; Yet…

  Something warm grows inside my stomach and then flutters around, the sputtering of newborn butterflies. He is the hottest guy on campus. Still, I remind myself he’s a player, gather my resolve, and shoot those butterflies down.

  “You’re being weird, Ryker.”

  “Because I’m being nice? Yeah. New year, new start. I want to forget all the bad stuff from last semester.” He pauses. “And the article you wrote.”

  “Is that right? Even the part where I said you dishonored the sport and were a disgrace to college players everywhere?”

  He stares down at his hands. “I had my reasons for what happened.”

  So I heard. He got involved in the fighting to help his friend and fellow teammate Maverick save his disabled sister.

  “Ah, well, I did write a follow-up article, but it wasn’t nearly as popular as the first one.”

  He shrugs, and somehow, he’s closer now. I stare into his thickly lashed cerulean eyes and blink at the force of them. His irises…God, someone should name a crayon after them.

  “So…do you want to do laundry together sometime?”

  This again? My mouth parts. “What? Like a date?”

  “Yeah.”

  I blink rapidly, my brain trying to wrap about this new Ryker. “No. I’m sure you already have jersey chasers lined up outside your dorm vying to do your laundry. I’ve heard they actually beg to rub your shoulders and do your homework. I imagine they even fight to be the one to suck your sweet little toes.” I come to an abrupt halt. Suck his toes? SUCK HIS TOES? OMG. Where did that random comment come from? I don’t have a foot fetish. I blame it on his presence and carry on. “And don’t worry about me—I don’t need your laundry advice. A little ketchup never hurt anyone.”

  Determination crosses his face and with a flurry of movement, he drops a small piece of paper onto the tray I’m holding.

  I stare down at it. Sexy as Hell Athlete is written in masculine handwriting with a phone number after it. I look back up at him, my eyes tracing the enigmatic half-smile on his face.

  “I wrote it down for you earlier and wanted to give it to you after the ketchup thing, but I chickened out.”

  Several seconds go by.

  “Will you give me yours?” he asks after a few moments of us just standing here.

  “My what?”

  “Number.” He grins.

  I indicate the tray and my obvious impediment. “I don’t have any paper on me.”

  “Just tell me. I’ll remember.”

  I’m flustered, and that’s the only reason I rattle off my phone number. He grins and repeats it back to me.

  He lowers his voice in a conspiratorial way. “So…you’re watching someone, I take it. Anyone I know?”

  Feeling bemused by his attention, I shake my head, quickly losing control of this situation.

  “For a writer, you seem to be at a loss for words. Do I make you speechless, Penelope?”

  I scoff. “No.”

  “I’m curious as to what has your attention back here.” He slides in next to me behind the plant, his shoulder brushing against mine. He’s a giant next to my slender frame, and all at once, I feel protected and safe, which is entirely wrong. It’s probably his male pheromones, lulling me into softness before the kill—and damn if it isn’t working. He murmurs something about us hiding together and spying on people, but I’m distracted because my face is up close and personal with the chest hair that pokes out of his shirt. I want to trail my fingers through it and see if it’s as soft as it looks. He smells like alpha male and sex. Hard, passionate sex that makes you orgasm fast and furious.

  Not that I have any firsthand knowledge of that, of course, but I have my fantasies.

  Gird your loins, Penelope.

  Resist the quarterback.

  But I’m getting sucked in.

  I blame it on the dimple that appears when he smiles. My stomach does that fluttering thing again, and this time, I can’t shoo the butterflies away. I’m weak. I move my eyes up the strong column of his tanned throat to meet his gaze. At least ten seconds go by as we take each other in.

  What. Is. Happening?

  “You’re pretty,” he murmurs. “Have I ever told you that?”

  “We don’t usually talk except for when I take your order.”

  His hand reaches up and briefly touches a piece of my hair that’s fallen out of my topknot. He rubs it between his fingers. “Your hair…it’s—”

  “Auburn,” I manage, clearing my throat.

  “It reminds me of a new penny, the way the amber color catches the light…” His voice trails off, and he bites his bottom lip. “God, that has to be the stupidest thing I’ve ever said.”

  “You have worse lines. Tell me, is doing laundry code for sex?” I say, staring up at him. I’m itching to straighten my glasses, a nervous reflex, but my hands are holding the tray.

  “I only use lines on jersey chasers. You’re the kind of girl I have to work for.”

  “What about your discriminating tastes?”

  “Pure bluff. I think we have a real connection, Penelope.” His face is closer now, and I swallow, wondering how we must look to everyone else in the restaurant. I realize that in the process of talking, we’ve backed up to the wall behind the plant, and I figure the only table we’re visible to is the football one, but I don’t tear my eyes away from Ryker to check.

  “You smell like rainbows,” he says.

  My chest rises. I’m enjoying his full-court press. It’s…intoxicating. “What does a rainbow smell like?”

  “Sweet and delicious.”

  “It’s the suckers.” His eyes land on my lips, and it almost feels as if he’s touched them. Heat rushes over my skin. “The red ones are my favorite. I think they’re cherry or strawberry or raspberry…definitely not cranberry…that’s disgusting,” I say, rambling, feeling disoriented.

  “It’s crazy, but I really want to kiss you right now,” he murmurs.

  My eyes drift over his shoulder to where Connor’s table is. I can’t see his face, but I know he’s there, and even though I’m drugged by Ryker’s proximity, I remind myself he’s the one I should kiss.

  Not Ryker.

  Ryker is a player—just like my dad was.

  He watches the direction of my gaze and follows it. “You’ve been watching Dimpleshitz, haven’t you?” he says, a frown line appearing on his forehead. “Are you into him?”

  My stomach dips. “Why would you say that?”

  “Because you hightailed it over here when he walked in and you’ve been hiding ever since. So, I figure he either did you wrong or you’re infatuated, and since I haven’t heard any gossip about you and him, I’m guessing you must have a thing for him.”

  Abort! Abort! He knows too much!

  Sanity slowly returns to my brain in small increments, and I take a deep breath, orienting myself as questions race through my head. What if he uses my crush against me? Maybe he wants revenge for the article. I don’t know!

  Flustered and unsure, my eyes dart around the restaurant, looking for an exit so I don’t have to answer his question.

  My gaze lands on the football table he came from, and I notice Archer watching us with focused interest, a calculating look on his face as he whips his eyes from me to Ryker. He leans over and whispers to Blaze, who turns to peer in our direction. I pause, my brain analyzing and decoding. Why is Archer suddenly interested in what Ryker is doing over here with me—especially when there’s a pretty co-ed sitting right next to him, tracing little circles on his bicep?

  Yet Archer’s eagle eyes are on us. Watchful.

  I notice all three players at the table have suddenly given us their attention, anticipation evident on their faces.

  Alarms go off in my head and things start to click into place.

  How nice he was to me. How we ‘have a connection’. Yeah, right.

  Mortification washes over me.

  How could I not have seen it sooner?

/>   God, I am an idiot. I was so distracted…

  I’m a bet. A stupid freaking bet.

  I feel like someone just punched me in the gut.

  My survival instinct tells me to get away from Ryker, and obviously, I could just walk away and hold my head high, but I want to make a point and show those football players they can’t toy with me. I release the tray I’ve been balancing for what seems like days in his direction. The contents of the glasses spill out and crash to the floor, watered-down soda and ice drenching us before dripping down to the floor. The plastic glasses make a horrible clattering noise on the wooden floors, and I imagine most everyone in the restaurant heard it. I don’t look to see their faces. I only glare at Ryker.

  He jumps back and stares down at the mess on his khaki pants then looks back at me. “Remind me to never bring up Dimpleshitz again.”

  “Stop your games, Ryker.”

  His face stills. “What games?”

  My teeth snap together. Enough.

  Penelope

  Tension is thick as we eye each other, both of us ignoring the mess to continue our stare-down. The apron around my waist took the brunt of the water that came in my direction, but Ryker’s pants are soaked—only he barely seems to notice now that we’re facing off.

  “It was nice chatting, Ryker. Oh, and by the way, it looks like you peed yourself.” I move to walk past him to grab some towels from the back, but he takes a small step, blocking me.

  “Wait, what’s wrong?” Frustration flashes over his features. “Look, I never know how to ask a real girl out. Can we start over? Without all this water everywhere?”