Paying the Price

by C Davis

  “Fuck!” Benjamin roared, punching the decayed wood of the cabin.

  I remembered bringing Jenna here once to the woods about four years back. We stumbled onto private property and were forced to leave by some old man.

  “I think I might know somewhere she might be. Follow me.”

  I led Benjamin to the South and led him to an old trail. We walked up it and came to a clearing. In the distance, there was an old run-down cabin. I could dim lights illuminating through the windows. I turned to Benjamin and whispered, “Jenna and I found this place four years ago. I don’t know who owns it, but it was occupied back then. Maybe—”

  “Look, there’s Tommy’s car. Let’s go. You go in the front and I’ll go in the back.”

  I wiped the dust off the window at the front, and looked through the window. Oh, yeah, we were at the right place, that’s for sure. I could see Jenna sitting at a table with Tommy right next to her. I curled my lips in disgust as he touched her shoulder. I smiled when she jerked away from him.

  That’s my girl.

  I slowly opened the door and slid inside stealthily. This was something I learned from Javier. I looked to my right and grinned when I saw the gun. I wasn’t going to shoot him, but I wouldn’t give him the opportunity to use it. I picked it up and put it in the back of my pants. Just as I did, I heard Benjamin’s voice bellow through the room. “Tommy, Tommy, Tommy. Did you think you would actually get away with this? I know you’re crazy, but I didn’t peg you for being a stupid cunt. Grab him, boys.”

  Tommy turned to run to the front of the cabin, but froze. I locked eyes on him and stalked towards him and gave him a sickening grin. His eyes widened and he stuttered. “N-no! You’re supposed to be in—”

  “Prison.” I finished, “I know. Isn’t it sweet?”

  “No!” he shook his head ferociously, “You’re ruining everything! It’s not supposed to be this way. You’re fucking it all up!”

  “I agree. You see, here’s the thing, Tommy boy—Jenna is mine and always has been. I get out and I find out you’ve taken from me. You know what else?”

  “What?”

  “Even though, I was locked up, I heard all about you. The little psycho that killed his own mama all because she was going to have you committed. Poor little deranged Tommy boy.”

  “Don’t talk about that. She was the crazy one, not me. I-I—”

  “Look at that, I think he’s more than crazy. He’s completely off his rocker.” Benjamin chuckled as Jeff and Drew circled him.

  I turned to Jenna and our eyes locked. Everything seemed to slow as I watched tears form in her eyes. I could hear Benjamin in the background telling the boys to restrain Tommy, but I didn’t care. My focus was on Jenna, the mother of my child. I walked slowly to her and knelt down, untying her wrists and whispered close to her ear. “Daddy’s home, sweetheart.”

  “Colton, you’re here. Is this another dream?” Jenna asked as I picked her up gently.

  She reached up and cupped my cheek and laid her head on my chest. So many nights I’ve dreamed of touching her like this. I pressed my lips against hers and swept my tongue across her bottom lip, deepening the kiss. I pulled away slowly and carried her out of the cabin. Away from where Tommy tormented her.

  “It’s not a dream, sweetheart. I’m here and I’m never letting you out of my sight. I fucking love you. I love both of you.”

  “Take me home, Colton and make love to me.”

  “That’s the plan, babe.”

  Tonight I would be making everything up to my girl. I was going to devour her. Inch by inch. With my mouth. Lick every part of her body. And then, I would hold her in my arms and fuck her like there’s no tomorrow.

   Chapter 18

  ___________

  Colton

  I can barely believe it. I’m here with her, and she wants me to take her home with me. I cupped her face and brushed my thumbs against her cheeks. “Are you okay?”

  “I’m more than okay, now that you’re here.”

  “He didn’t hurt you or the baby, did he?”

  “I’m fine Colton. He just—he slapped me, but it was my fault. I provoked him.”

  Jenna took my hands and placed them on her belly. I could feel my baby kicking. My eyes watered as I felt the life inside her growing. My baby. My hands laid flat on her swollen belly as I lowered myself and pressed my cheek to her belly. I closed my eyes and took a deep breath and exhaled. Her fingers combed through my hair and held me closer. I turned my head and pressed my lips to her stomach. Looking up to her, I whispered. “Let’s get out of here sweetheart and get you cleaned up.”

  As we passed by the bed of the truck, I glanced down to Tommy and spit on him. “Fuck you, asshole. I hope you rot in hell.”

  “Colton?”

  “Shh, don’t look. Let’s just get you out of here.”

  “What’s going to happen to him?”

  “He’s—going to pay for what he’s done.”

  I set her in the backseat of the extended cab Chevrolet and kissed her forehead. “I’ll be right back.”

  She leaned in and whispered, “Hurry, I’m very wet for you.”

  Fuck, and now my cock is hard.

  “Baby, I’ll be fucking you tonight. Over and over until your body gives out.”

  I stepped back and closed the door gently. Turning back to Benjamin, he smiled and clapped me on my back. “I didn’t get the chance to tell you before, but welcome home, brother.”

  “What do we do with him?”

  “Jeff called in some special reinforcements for that.”

  “Like the police?”

  “All I’ll say is Jeff still has the connections from the city. He’s connected to the right kind of people. Come on, I’ll take you to my place. You and Jenna can stay there until you can figure out where you’re staying.”

  I glanced to Tommy and back to Benjamin, narrowing my eyes into slits. “Make sure he suffers.”

  “Oh, he will.”

  ___

  After Jenna and I got cleaned up, I trapped her against the wall and kissed her. My hands roamed down her chest and cupped her breasts. Her nipples hardened in my hands as I kneaded them. She moaned, letting her hands tug on the towel and let it drop to the floor. Jenna wrapped her hand around my cock, making me groan in her mouth as she pumped me.

  “Fuck sweetheart, I’ve dreamed about this for so long.”

  “Take me to bed, Colton.”

  I reached under her legs and picked her up, carrying her into the bedroom. Gently placing Jenna on the bed, I placed my hands on her thighs and whispered. “I need to taste you, sweetheart.”

  Jenna grabbed the back of my head with both hands and shove my head between her legs. I inhaled her sweetness and spread her slit, running my tongue flat along her clit.

  “So. Fucking. Delicious.” I wrapped my lips around her clit and took it between my teeth.

  Sucking.

  Nibbling.

  Biting down.

  She gasped, “Yes, harder.”

  I looked up as I devoured her pussy and watched her eyes close. She moaned as I let my hands roam up her belly and take her nipples between my index finger and thumb. I pinched them, causing her to arch her back and part her lips.

  “You look so good like this, babe. Bending at my will for me.”

  “Please, Colton.”

  I lapped at her clit and inserted two fingers, pumping my digits into her. So warm. Wet with desire. All for me. I groan against her, “Beg me. Tell me all the dirty things you want me to do.”

  “I want you to fuck me. Take me and never let me go.”

  “Tell Daddy more, sweetheart.”

  “I want you to slide into my pussy and fuck me. Hard. Fast. Take me like you’ve never taken me before.”

  Slithering my body upwards, I slide between her legs and fist my cock. Sliding it up and down her slit. Teasing her with the head. My cock slides into her wetness and I suck in a breath. She cries out and throws her
head back as I wrap her legs around my waist. She cries out again, making me cover her mouth and whisper. “Is this what you want, sweetheart?”

  “Yes.” She moans into my hand, scratching her nails down my back. Digging them into my ass as I plow into her. Sending me into a drug induced state of mind.

  “Come for me, sweetheart. Let your pussy clench around Daddy’s cock.”

  “Daddy, yes. I’m going to—come.”

  “Shit sweetheart, it’s been too long since I fucked you. I’m not going to last much longer.” I buried my face into her neck and spilled inside her. I removed my hand and pressed my cheek against hers, whispering to her. “I love you, Jenna. I’ve always loved you since the night of that party.”

  I pulled out of her and reached around the back of her neck, crashing my lips against her. Jenna deepened the kiss and whispered against me. “I love you, too. Always have.”

  I was free. Tommy was no longer a threat to my girl. Now, it’s time to make up for lost time and spend time with Jenna. Let her know how much I adored her. How much I loved her. And, eventually I would make her my wife. Just as soon as I could.

  I stroked her cheek and whispered, “Are you hungry?”

  “Starving.”

  “Let’s get dressed and see what they have in the kitchen.”

  Finally, I can breathe easy knowing maybe there was still hope for us. Hope that she would accept me and take me as I am.

  Chapter 19

  __________

  Four years ago

  Colton

  I entered the house and glanced around the party. There were couples grinding on each other as the music blared from the speakers. On one side, some were chugging down beer with a beer bong. I glanced to the other side to see a half naked girl lying on the counter as one of the members of the football team took a body shot from her. I glanced to the corner of the room to see a pretty little blonde sitting all alone. I think her name is Jeanne. No, Jenna Bradley. Yeah, that’s the name.

  I tugged the collar of my shirt and made my way over to her. I sat down and asked, “What are you doing here all alone, beautiful?”

  “Me?” She squeaked.

  “Well, I don’t see any other beauties here?”

  “You think I’m beautiful?”

  “You are the most gorgeous woman I’ve ever laid eyes on.” I said, tucking a strand of her hair behind her ear.

  “You must be drunk.” She rolled her eyes and took a sip of her drink.

  I yanked the red solo cup from her and sniffed. She hissed, “Hey, that’s mine!”

  “You shouldn’t drink anymore of this. It’s drugged.”

  “Give. It. Back.”

  “I’m trying to help you out, darling. Do you really want to get raped?”

  “I-no, I guess not.”

  “Colton.”

  “What?”

  “My name is Colton Davenport, and you are?”

  “Jenna.”

  “Pleasure to meet you. Just, be careful. I’ll be seeing you around.”

  I didn’t want to leave her. I wanted to stay there all night and make sure nobody approached her. The thought of one of these punks touching her made my blood boil. I walked through the party and picked up a bottle of Jameson. I didn’t bother with a cup because I would just be drinking from the bottle. I couldn’t stop thinking about Jenna. How her eyes widened as I yanked the cup out of her hands. The way her nipples protruded through the skin-tight top as I tucked her hair behind her ear. The reason I had to walk away was because my cock was hard. It was raging and angry. Wanted to grab Jenna and take her upstairs and spread her thighs. Fuck her until the sun came up.

  “Fuck, stop perving on her. She’s too good for me.” I whispered to myself.

  “Colton, there you are.” Candy, one of the cheerleaders cooed. She ran her hands down my arm and pressed herself against me. Any other time, I’d jump right on her, but now I only had one girl on my mind.

  “Not now, Candy.” I hissed, gripping her wrist.

  Candy let her free hand roam down and place her hand over my cock. “Is this all for me, big boy?”

  “Candy, get your hands off me before I make you regret it. You don’t want that, do you?”

  “But you know I love it when you hurt me. It makes me so wet.”

  I spun her around and pulled her wrists behind her back forcefully, shoving her against the wall. “Don’t fucking play with me!”

  “Yes, there he is. The man that gets me off.”

  “Candy, go find someone else to fuck tonight. I’m not in the mood.”

  “So you can go fuck Jenna?”

  “What the fuck did you just say?”

  She turned her head and glared, “You heard me.”

  “Candy, you knew what you were getting into when you agreed to just sex no feelings. You’ve become attached. This is over—we’re over.”

  Candy frowned, tears forming in her eyes, “Please, you don’t mean it.”

  “I do. Maybe you’ll get lucky and Benjamin will fuck you. I’m sorry, but we’re done.”

  I released her and walked away from the crying girl. I know it was a dick move, but it had to be done. She was acting like we were exclusive. Candy and I weren’t a thing. Just fuck buddies. And now, it’s over. I had a new conquest to chase. The beauty with the striking blue eyes. The one who had my cock hard as a rock. I returned where Jenna had been sitting and clenched my jaw. Tommy was sitting next to her with his arm around her shoulders. I stormed over to them and raised a brow, “Jenna, is he bothering you?”

  Tommy glared, “Fuck you, Colton. She’s free to talk to anyone she wants.”

  “I’m okay. He was just leaving.” Jenna replied, taking his arm off her shoulders.

  “Jenna?” Tommy asked, hurt in his face.

  “Please, Tommy. I don’t want to cause a scene. You should just go.”

  “Fine. You know where I’m at if you need me.”

  I glared at him as he stormed off. I hated Tommy. He hated me. And, why was that? Because of this girl. I knew he wanted her, but I also wanted her. I didn’t deserve her, but I also didn’t want anyone else to have her. I was selfish. I knew it, but I couldn’t help it. She intrigued me.

  “Thank you, Colton.” Jenna said, rising from her chair. She wrapped her arms around my neck and kissed my cheek.

  “Anytime, sweetheart.” I whispered, inhaling her cherry-vanilla perfume.

  Jenna stumbled as she pulled away. Fuck. She was drunk, or was she drugged. My arms wrapped around her waist before she fell, and she began to sway. She giggled as she wrapped her arms around my neck, pulling me closer. “Do you want to go to my place? I don’t want to be alone tonight.”

  “What to you mean tonight? Where’s your parents?”

  “I’m all alone. My family is gone.” She slurred.

  “Shh, sweetheart. Where do you live?”

  I picked her up and carried her to my car. By the time I placed her in the backseat, she’d fallen asleep. I sighed as I closed the door and leaned against the car. Jake, the quarterback, stumbled towards me and leaned on the car for support. “I need a ride. They took my keys.”

  “Sure. Hey, I need a favor. Can I crash at your place?”

  “Sure. You know you can. Is that Jenna Bradley?”

  “Yes.”

  “You do know she’s a virgin, right?”

  “I’m not fucking her. Someone drugged her, and she passed out. I don’t know where she lives.”

  “She lives on Chestnut and Avenue B. The white house with a wrap-around porch.”

  “Okay. I’ll take you home and get her to her house. I do need a favor. I want to know who was giving her drinks. I have my suspicions, but I just want to be sure.”

  “It was Tommy. I don’t need to ask around to know. He was slipping her drinks all night.”

  I nodded my head, but clenched my fists. Tommy’s plan was clear to me now. He was going to get her good and fucked-up, so he could take her against her will
. I dropped off Jake and took Jenna home. I carried her inside and tucked her into bed. I leaned down and kissed her forehead, “I’ll protect you Jenna. Even if I have to go to jail over it.”

  Chapter 20

  __________