Attraction: A MFM Menage Romance

by Maverick, Henley

  “We have to help you shower because you’re still injured,” Aleister said while nodding sagely as if he were a doctor.

  “You two are so silly,” I giggled and then squealed when Sioux ran towards me and scooped me into his arms. He and Aleister practically bolted up to the bathroom.

  “Relax!” I laughed at them and watched as Aleister stripped down and turned on the shower. Sioux set me down on the sink counter and undressed as well. I sat back and enjoyed the view. They had the same builds, of course, and they were the same height and all. It really was as if they were each other’s clones.

  “The water is warmed up. Are you going to bathe with your clothes on?” Aleister asked me playfully.

  “Well, I just might,” I said cheekily. I hopped down from the counter and bent down to pull my boots off. They stood side by side in front of me, waiting for me to get with the program. But an idea struck me, well more of a fantasy I’d been wanting to live out. Especially as it was easy to see that they were both getting increasingly aroused. I finished getting out of my boots, and they were impatient enough to help me out of the rest of my clothes.

  We stepped into the shower stall, and I wrapped my hands around both of their cocks and began to stroke them. Aleister’s moan was soft and breathy. A low rumble came out of Sioux’s chest. He cupped my neck and kissed me deeply, his tongue licking into my mouth on a heated caress.

  Meanwhile, Aleister nuzzled my check before nibbling on my ear. “What are you doing?” he asked.

  “I’m playing with my men,” I said against Sioux’s lips. Aleister laughed.

  “By all means, have your way,” Sioux chuckled. I gave him another peck and knelt down to run my tongue around the tip of Aleister’s cock. He groaned when I sucked him deep, I made sure to keep pumping Sioux’s in my fist. As I switched between them, I became more than turned on, just by the sounds they were making and how rigid and aroused they were.

  “Holden…” Aleister’s strained tone was a warning. I knew he was close. I took him to the back of my throat and massaged his sac as he lightly thrust his hips. It was only a few seconds until I tasted his release and felt it sliding down my throat. Sioux’s orgasm caught me by surprise, he practically exploded all over my hand.

  “Damn it…” Sioux breathed. I looked up at him with a small smirk and Aleister pulled me up onto my feet. He pushed me under the warm spray of water and hooked one of my legs over his forearm. I glanced down and found he was still erect. Honestly, the stamina of those two was something serious.

  Aleister slid into me on one slow stroke and I held onto his shoulders to keep my balance against the shower wall. Behind him, I watched as Sioux stroked himself while he watched us. Along with the undeniable pleasure of Aleister inside me, I knew I wouldn’t last watching Sioux do that. Then Aleister stopped for a moment to pick me up completely, holding me from underneath my knees. He pressed me more firmly against the wall and pounded into me. I cried out as the orgasm swept through me. My entire body seemed to shake with the force of it. Aleister slid out of me, passing me to Sioux who bent me over. I braced against the glass door, but Sioux held me up mostly. My legs were jelly, they turned to liquid when he slid inside. Sioux’s pace was just as fierce as his brothers and my orgasm built impossibly quick. I didn’t know how my body was capable of another. But it all seemed to blur into one giant kaleidoscope of pleasure and sensation. Until I was freefalling with the climax, my vision blurring and my joints seemingly giving out entirely.

  I wasn’t aware of anything that happened after that. Until I opened my eyes and found I was in bed. Sioux was curled around me and I was curled towards Aleister. He was still awake and watching me sleep with a soft look in his eyes that made my chest feel all warm.

  “You should sleep,” he whispered.

  “You guys will stay for breakfast, right?” I asked, my voice sounded like I was drunk.

  “Of course,” he said and tucked a curl behind my ear.

  “I don’t want you guys to go,” I added, my eyes drooping closed.

  “We wouldn’t think to leave you,” Aleister said, smiling. He kissed my nose, of all things, and I fell sound asleep.

  Come morning, I woke to what sounded like Scout’s voice. My eyes flew open and I sat up, heart pumping, and listened to make sure it was really her.

  “Holden, why aren’t you answering your phone?” Her voice was getting closer, and it sounded like she was on the stairs. I glanced to my side and found Aleister stretched out next to me, his head propped up on his elbow. He was shirtless and wearing jeans thankfully, his expression seemed like he wanted to laugh. Sioux was pulling on a pair of jeans by the foot of the bed and he actually sat back down. Perched by my feet.

  “So, we’re just going to wait for the inevitable I see.” I sighed and they both laughed. I was still completely naked, covered only by the blanket. “Can I get a shirt at least?” Sioux quickly found an oversized pajama shirt for me to pull on. Scout came barreling into the room, but she gasped and stopped dead in her tracks as soon as she saw I had company. I was kind of relieved that she saw them, at least I could definitively conclude that they were real. And that my mind hadn’t been playing tricks on me the entire time I’ve known them.

  “Oh my god, Holden!” Scout exclaimed. Her hazel eyes were as wide as I’ve ever seen them and it was hard for me not to laugh.

  “Wow, I’d almost forgotten how similar the two of you look. It seems beauty runs in the family,” Sioux said brightly.

  “Who are you two?” Scout asked, still shocked.

  “We’re Holden’s boyfriends. I’m Sioux, he’s Aleister.” Sioux told her. I pressed my lips together and studied Scout’s reaction. She didn’t look at him like he was crazy, surprisingly. Instead, she was more shocked and incredulous than anything.

  “Wait…are you…” she took a hesitant step forward, her eyes flitting between Aleister and Sioux. “Do you guys know Isaac?” she said suggestively. I remembered then that they told me Isaac was a friend of theirs the night before.

  “Yep,” Sioux said, his tone still bright and chipper. Scout turned her gaze to me and I saw she would soon become pissed if she wasn’t already.

  “How long have you been seeing them, Holden?” she asked suspiciously.

  “Really…it’s only been a few days,” I said honestly though it felt like longer. It felt as if I knew them for years.

  “I’m…I’m going to wait downstairs,” Scout said, and she sent Aleister and Sioux another glance before backing from the room.

  “That went well, yeah?” Sioux asked me and I shrugged.

  “It’s hard to say, Scout is complex,” I sighed. I got up to go put on some real clothes and freshen up for the day. Aleister and Sioux got ready with me, though they had the same clothes they wore the day before. Sioux wore a fitted pullover and Aleister a simple white t-shirt. We found Scout perched on the breakfast bar in the kitchen. She looked up from her phone as soon as she heard us coming.

  “So…” I began, of course making the whole thing more awkward than it needed to be.

  “So, you know about the men, obviously,” Scout said. When she looked at Aleister and Sioux, her gaze was more curious than anything else.

  “How about I get some breakfast started?” Aleister offered, and I nodded.

  “Yes, please,” I said gratefully. “And yeah, I know about them…” I said to Scout.

  “What happened with Isaac? Do you love each other?”

  “Um…it’s way too early to say!” she said, sort of whisper-yelling, even though Aleister and Sioux could hear everything she said, even if we were outside whispering.

  “I just didn’t know how to tell you about Aleister and Sioux yet,” I said, glancing at them. They were having their own conversation, about sausage seemingly. Sioux was holding up the packet while Aleister contemplated. Scout grabbed my arm and pulled me across the room.

  “What about them, though? Are you seeing both of them?” she asked curiously.r />
  “Yes…I suppose I am,” I said, not knowing what else to say to that effect. It was a weird thing our trio had going. A good thing though, and I didn’t want to mess it up.

  “How does that work?” she asked, her eyes wide. “You know what, I don’t want to know the details,” she admitted.

  “I don’t know how to explain it…I feel like they’ve been a constant in my life or something, I just feel connected to them.” I said in a low voice.

  “Weirdly enough…that’s how I feel about Isaac,” Scout sighed.

  “So…why are you here?” I asked her.

  “It’s like I told you! Men who live in the woods? And dad knew!” she exclaimed.

  “It seems kind of fitting for dad to have known about them, don’t you think?” I mused. I realized that I’d had more time to come to terms with everything whereas with Scout it was just beginning.

  “You’ll get used to it quicker than you think you just have to accept it and go with the flow. Where’s Isaac now?” I asked her.

  “At his house, I think,” she murmured.

  “Did you hear that?” Aleister’s tone was a bit urgent. Scout and I glanced over at him; Sioux was already moving towards the kitchen door.

  “What is it?” I asked. Aleister inched towards the back door and quickly followed his brother out back. Scout and I rushed to the door to look through the window. We both gasped when we saw the huge man barreling through the tree line. He stopped and stood up straight when he saw Aleister and Sioux.

  “Oh my god!” Scout screamed. They both attacked the huge thing, lunging at it. The man fought hard, swiping at them and trying to fling them off of it. But Sioux and Aleister weren’t going to get beaten back. They kept charging at him and getting hits in. Until the big man was brought down and stopped moving altogether. The men dragged the beaten one into the woods, quickly going out of sight.

  “What just happened?!” Scout yelled.

  “Calm down Scout…” I told her, putting my hands on her shoulders. “That man was part of a group who are moving in on the boys’ territory. I forgot to tell you, Aleister and Sioux saved me from the bear,” I told her. Scout stared at me, still in shock.

  “So, they just killed whoever that man was?” she whispered.

  “It’s what they do…” I said softly.

  “This is crazy…I have to go,” she said. Obviously shaken up by what she just saw.

  “You can’t leave now, what if another man comes out?” I said.

  “I’m not going near the woods. I’m getting in my Jeep and driving home. You’re more than welcome to come,” she said while she fished her keys out of the bag.

  “Scout…” I tried to get her to stay, but she was adamant. She left, sped away from the house like a bat out of hell.

  “Where did your sister go?” Aleister asked. I turned around to find him and Sioux coming back into the house.

  “She’s going home; she got freaked out,” I sighed. “I should talk to her about all of this.”

  “She has to come to terms with it first. I’ll call Isaac and tell him to check on her,” Sioux said. For having just killed a huge man and dragged it to who knows where, they both looked surprisingly calm and collected.

  “They’re getting bolder with coming into town, huh?” I asked Aleister.

  “They are. I just want to know how he got past our defense patrols. I have to check in with the rest of the men,” Aleister said. “Sioux will stay here with you, is that alright?”

  “Okay…” I sighed. “But—” I wanted to tell him not to go, but it was his group of men, and the danger was very real. “Never mind. You go take care of it,” I said. He gave me a soft kiss on the lips before passing his brother to head back outside.

  “We may have to have another huge meeting. That man wasn’t supposed to slip through our ranks…” Sioux said.

  “Are you worried?” I couldn’t help but to ask him.

  “No, more like annoyed,” he said and that much I believed to be true. If he were worried, he’d be out there with Aleister. He finished texting Isaac and went back to making the pancake batter.

  “I don’t want you to feel like there’s some huge army trying to push into town to kill the locals,” Sioux said with a smirk. He knew exactly how to make light out of a situation. “There’s probably like fifteen left and they’re just trying to find an angle to get at our land,” he assured me.

  “Yeah well…they certainly seem aggressive about it,” I murmured.

  “Of course they would be, they’re searching for a home for whatever reason. But by going about it so aggressively, we have no choice but to protect what’s ours and drive them away,” he said.

  “So it’s a big deal…but not a big deal?” I asked, making him smile.

  “Exactly. It’s a not big-big deal,” he chuckled.

  “Okay,” I trusted Sioux to be completely honest with me. He wouldn’t try to sugarcoat something just to spare my feelings. “So, how long do you think it’ll take my sister to calm down?” I asked.

  “Well, she was completely blindsided, so I’d say it might take her a while.”

  I finished cutting up breakfast sausage and got it onto the stove just as he was pouring his first pancake into the pan. “I just don’t want her to get too freaked out and then move across the country or something,” I mumbled.

  “If she shares a bond with Isaac and doesn’t fight it, I think she’ll stay,” Sioux assured me.

  “Do you think that if my dad never caused our paths to cross, that we would have clicked if we say ran into each other at the movies or something?” I glanced at Sioux who grinned back at me.

  “Of course I do. You were meant for us and we for you,” he said sincerely. The fact that he believed in every word he said made my chest all kinds of warm and bubbly.

  8

  “Okay, I can’t wait any longer. I’m going over there,” I said, getting up from the table. Sioux had been trying to distract me from worrying about Scout all day. But there’s been radio silence from her ever since she left.

  “Holden, maybe you should just give her some time, give her the night,” Sioux grabbed my wrist and pulled me down onto his lap.

  “I can’t, this is really bothering me. I have to go see her,” I said. I kissed him softly on the lips and got up to find the keys to my truck. “I’ll be back in a couple of hours,” I told him once I found them. Sioux walked me out, and I hurried to get to Scout’s place. I found her inside, alone, with Luis. They were in the living room watching Netflix on the couch.

  “I told you I needed some time, Holden,” she said without even looking up.

  “Well, I’m worried, so I came over. Talk to me, tell me what you’re thinking,” I urged her while sitting down. Luis greeted me by rubbing his entire body on my leg.

  “It’s just crazy when think everyone is who they say they are, and then you find out something completely different! There are men living in the woods! And not always in a cabin! And Isaac was one of them!” she exclaimed.

  “But…if dad trusted them, can you give Isaac a chance? I think he might be the one for you,” I said, thinking of what Sioux explained to me earlier.

  “Yeah, I can give Isaac a chance…he’s great in bed,” she admitted. “Speaking of! I can’t believe you’re with identical twins! Do you have sex with both of them at the same time?” she asked.

  “Well, yes and no…” I said, wondering how much to outline to her about that.

  “Like, is one in the back while the other takes the front?” she asked.

  “Oh my god, Scout!” I complained.

  “What? The least you can do is indulge me; you’ve kept this from me for days,” she said, trying to guilt trip me.

  “Literally it’s been like two days,” I said.

  “So what, spill,” she said.

  “Well… it hasn’t happened quite like that yet. But we’re getting there,” I said vaguely.

  “What does that even mean?” she a
sked. I sighed and gave her a more detailed recounting of how I manage sex with Aleister and Sioux.

  “Wow…I never knew you were that much of a sex expert,” she said, sounding impressed.

  “You’re an idiot,” I chuckled and stretched out on the couch.

  “So, do you have feelings for both of them, like in all seriousness?” she studied my expression closely as I answered her.

  “I do, I really do,” I said. “As weird as it is, I can imagine being with them…forever.”

  “Well, I’m happy for you then,” she smiled. We made a late lunch and afterward when I felt she was okay about the wolf thing, I got into my truck to head back home. When I got to the house, neither Aleister or Sioux were home. Bored, I thought about going for a walk but thought better of it. I didn’t want to get surprised by a stranger. Then again, wasn’t that my problem? Being scared of the woods when I never used to be before? Plus, Sioux said there were only fifteen more outsiders left. What were the odds they’d be back in this area?

  I chewed on my bottom lip as I pondered going out on the trail. I thought better of it, figuring I shouldn’t be stupid. Instead, I thought about making dinner for Aleister and Sioux. After doing a quick inventory, I went to grab a few groceries and then started preparing the food. I was making them baked chicken, eggplant parmesan and some salad, which was mostly for me. It was around eight in the evening when they got back, freshly changed and bearing overnight bags for once.

  “You guys thought ahead, huh?” I smiled and gave them both a kiss on the lips when they came into the kitchen.

  “Holden, whatever you’re making, it smells amazing,” Sioux said eagerly.

  “I’m starving. You’re a godsend,” Aleister said.

  “Go put those away, I’m just about to put everything out on the table,” I told them. Sioux took the bags up while Aleister helped me out. “So, is everything okay with the guys? Did you have another meeting?” I asked him. My curiosity was already overtaking me.

  “We had the meeting, yeah. But we quickly figured out that the migrants are getting smarter. Their actions are random, so we can’t predict their movements. We’re still doing the patrols of course. We’re still being vigilant, but there’s no real way to know what they might attempt next,” he told me.