by Alice Harper
“Have a nice meal, assholes,” Shane said and walked away. They all ate in the parking lot with the AC on high to compensate for the hot food and weather.
“It's a shame they're homophobic,” Martin said. “The food tastes amazing.”
Martin drove them back to his home while Shane slept in Jimmy's lap all the way. Shane had a habit of napping after large meals. Jimmy looked at Shane’s beautiful face as he napped. What does Shane have that I don’t, he thought. Was it his full pink lips, his lean and tall stature, or his tight bubble butt? Even if he were hotter than Shane, Martin would still easily pick Shane between the two. Shane had a strong personality, while he was jittery and unsure in all situations.
Now he wondered what Martin must have seen in Jimmy. Why couldn’t Martin forget him if he had someone as hot as Shane by his side? He himself would have chosen Shane if he were in Martin’s place. He had never seen Shane naked before, but he could tell he had a big cock. Shane was the center of attention whenever he was in his briefs for the college swim team. It looked like the briefs could barely hold his bulge in. Now that they were both dating Martin, he expected to see them naked side by side. He was sure Martin would have a bigger cock, but they Shane’s might be close enough. Too bad Shane was a bottom. He’d make a great top with his package and strong personality.
Jimmy woke him up when they reached and Shane was oblivious about falling asleep, and to Jimmy’s staring. Martin held onto each of their hands and led them inside his home.
Chapter 19 - Martin
“I’ll have a quick shower and be right back,” Martin said.
Jimmy and Shane sat onto his bed and Shane looked at him with a wicked smile. He knew exactly what that smile meant. It meant Shane was horny and was having sexy thoughts about him. He gave him that very same smile every time in the class, and it never failed to make him feel hot and bothered. Martin wanted nothing more than to fuck him in the middle of the class when that happened. He would then forget what he was teaching and would have to look away. He wondered if that was the only reason Shane came to his class anymore, to stare at and have sexy thoughts about him.
As he turned the shower on and stepped in, he wondered what it meant to be in a relationship with two men at the same time. Would he have to take turns making love to them? He could take them both at the same time, he knew he had the stamina for it, but he wasn’t sure Jimmy would be up for something like that.
Shane was adventurous and liked it rough in bed, but Jimmy was so inexperienced and passive. He might never get to make love to them at the same time. Jimmy might never be ready. His cock grew hard at the thought of making love to them together. He badly needed release. He had two men who would be willing to take his cock, but he would have to choose between them. He couldn’t fuck one without hurting the other. So he would have to wait until he’s alone with one of them, which didn’t look like anytime soon. Jimmy and Shane were too close. Now that they were both dating him, it would be hard to meet one of them alone.
He got out of the shower and dried himself off, then waited for his boner to go down. When it did go down, he wrapped a towel around himself and walked out into his bedroom. His heart almost skipped a beat at what he saw. Jimmy and Shane were in their briefs and inches apart from one another.
“He’s here,” Shane exclaimed and motioned Martin to come and join them in bed. “Remember what I taught you, Jimmy.”
Jimmy nodded and began making out with Shane. Martin’s jaw almost dropped at the sight of his lovers making out with each other. They were taking turns wildly sucking onto each other’s tongues and grabbing onto each other’s bodies. His boner was back, struggling hard against the towel and wanting to get out. He pulled his towel off and let his cock spring free. He climbed onto the bed between them and crawled towards their joined mouths.
“Room for one more?” he asked and joined his mouth with theirs. Their hands moved onto his body and went lower until they reached his cock. He moaned and broke the kiss when they grabbed it and began jerking it off.
Shane smiled and moved his face down towards his crotch. Martin lay on his back and Shane wrapped his lips around Martin’s erect cock. Shane could only fit Martin’s glans and upper part of the shaft. It was then Jimmy’s turn to break the kiss. Jimmy ran his mouth and tongue down towards his crotch, kissing and licking him as he went. Once he reached his crotch, he sucked onto Martin’s balls and began jerking him off. His cock was big enough to take both Shane’s mouth and Jimmy’s hands.
“Give me your ass,” Martin managed to say between moans. “I need your ass.”
They both scooted their bottoms towards Martin while they continued working on his cock. Martin pushed a finger in each of their asses, making them whimper. He continued fingering them, joining a finger each time they stopped whimpering until they both had three fingers each inside them.
“It’s so warm inside you,” he said. He fingered them harder and it drove him wild.
“I can’t take it like this anymore,” Jimmy said and whimpered. “I want to ride it.”
That was all Martin wanted to hear. He got up from the bed and positioned them both bent along the edge of the bed. Their feet were on the ground and Martin was standing behind them. He lifted Shane off the ground and stacked him over Jimmy. Now both their asses were one above the other and he had easier access to them.
He spanked Jimmy’s ass at the bottom first, and before he could moan, pushed his tip inside Jimmy, making him moan loud. He slowly pushed all of him inside him and it made Jimmy whimper. He slowly pushed in and out of him until Jimmy got used to it.
“Damn, you’re so tight, Jimmy,” he said and spanked Shane’s ass, making Shane moan.
“Can I get some too now, professor?” Shane asked turning around and rubbing his ass. “I don’t want to miss out.”
“Patience, Shane,” he said and bit onto Shane’s cheeks. He might have been wrong about satisfying both of them in bed. Seeing both their asses before him was driving him mad. He didn’t know if he’d last long.
Jimmy’s hole was beginning to gape from his big dick. When his ass was beginning to feel loose, he pulled out of Jimmy and quickly pushed into Shane’s ass. The new warmth and tightness around his cock made him moan. Now it was Shane’s turn to whimper as he picked up the pace. Seeing Jimmy’s gaping hole below Shane’s turned him on. He shoved a few fingers inside Jimmy so he wouldn’t feel left out.
Jimmy’s hole was beginning to tighten again around his fingers. He entered Jimmy now and then immediately pulled out of him to enter Shane. He was alternatively penetrating them both, using his hand to help him guide his cock towards their holes.
The feeling of penetrating two men at the same time was too much. He couldn’t hold it in any longer. He winced and yelled their names at the top of his lungs as he began cumming in Jimmy’s ass first. He quickly pulled out and came in Shane’s ass for the rest of the orgasm. Once his hips stopped jerking, he pulled out and lay on the bed.
Shane and Jimmy crawled on either side of Martin and offered their cocks. Martin took each of them in his hand and jerked them off for a few moments. Shane came first and then Jimmy followed soon. Martin’s chest was covered with their cum. The two of them kissed each other one last time before cleaning up and falling asleep in Martin’s strong arms. They were all very exhausted and could barely move.
Martin woke up late in the evening when the doorbell rang. It seemed to have been ringing for quite some time now, but he was too tired to answer the door. He got out of bed with his eyes still closed and walked out of the bedroom. Just as he was about to answer the door, he opened his eyes and realized he was stark naked. He ran back to the bedroom and put on a bathrobe. As he was leaving the bedroom, he glanced at his naked lovers wrapped up in each other’s arms. They looked so beautiful together. He was lucky to have their cooperation. He almost wanted to wake them up and go for round two. But instead, he walked out and answered the door.
“Nate, it’s
so nice to see you,” Martin said and hugged his son. “I didn't know you were coming. I'd have cleaned the place.”
"It's alright." Nate stepped in and took a seat. "I was in the neighborhood, so I thought I'd drop in to say hello."
"What brings you to this neighborhood?" Martin took a seat beside him. "Visiting a friend?"
"Girlfriend, actually," Nate said. "I just broke up, though."
"I'm sorry to hear that," Martin said and rubbed his back. "I didn't know you were dating."
"Michelle," Nate said. "I had chosen Michelle. Looks like I chose the wrong one. I hope you're not busy."
"You're just in time.". Martin got up from his seat and walked towards the kitchen. "I was about to make dinner. You can help me."
They made dinner together, and just as Martin was about to go wake his boyfriends up, they both walked out into the living room. Their hair was messed up and their briefs were badly wrinkled. There was no way Nate couldn't tell they were all having sex before Nate arrived.
Nate smiled and looked at Martin. Martin just smiled sheepishly and shrugged.
"Hi, Nate." Jimmy froze like a deer in headlights when he saw Nate. "I didn't know you were coming over. We'll put some clothes on."
"Don't," Nate said. "Pretend I'm not here. I'm open-minded for a straight guy. High-five, dad. You're finally moving on from mom. I'm happy for you."
Nate held his hand up and Martin embarrassingly high-fived him.
Jimmy still stood there in shock. Shane, on the other hand, hugged Nate tight and kissed him on the cheek.
As they all sat down for dinner, Martin proudly told him everything about his boyfriends, how they met, how he was conflicted on whom to choose, and how they reacted when they found out.
"I'm happy for you, dad," Nate said and nodded. "I truly am."
After Nate left, the three of them were doing the dishes. Shane placed a cup in the shelf and gave Martin a quick peck on the lips.
“I have an announcement to make,” Shane said. “I’ve decided to move out of my parent’s house.”
“Are you not getting along?” Martin asked and placed a hand on the small of his back.
“We don’t agree on a lot of things and it’s been frustrating lately.” Shane looked away and paused as if lost in thought. “Besides, I’m getting too old to live there anyway. I’ve started working part-time. I can afford my own place in this neighborhood, as long as it’s cheap. Do either of you want to help me pick one?”
“I’m free all this week,” Jimmy said. “We could go look together.”
“You don’t have to look for a new place, Shane,” Martin said. “You could move in with me. I’d love to have you here. I hope it isn’t too soon to ask. I don’t want you to freak out.”
“I’d love to, Martin.” Shane squinted and looked at him with a smile. “But are you sure about that? You only have one room. I don’t want to be a burden.”
“I wouldn’t let you sleep in a different room even if I had one.” He moved his hand further down and grabbed Shane’s ass before slapping it. Shane winced and then laughed out loud.
“I’m gonna pay half the rent, though. It’s the least I could do. I’ll move in tomorrow. I haven’t got many things.”
Martin nodded and kissed Shane. He looked behind him and noticed that Jimmy’s face fell.
Chapter 20 - Jimmy
Jimmy couldn’t believe his eyes. He wondered if Shane had planned this all along. Shane was known to be cunning and manipulative towards other people, but never towards Jimmy. He never knew if he did it consciously.
He wondered if Shane really wanted to move out of his parent’s house or if he just wanted to move in with Martin. He hadn’t been talking to Shane for a while now, so he couldn’t tell. Maybe things were going bad with his parents, but there was no way to know now. He had to assume the worst.
As Martin kissed them both goodnight, Jimmy noticed the concern on Martin’s face. Martin probably knew how he felt, and what he felt was jealousy. Just as he was getting used to being in a throuple, Shane had to ruin everything. He knew what Martin would say, that he loves both of them equally.
He couldn’t just watch Shane live with Martin. It would drive him nuts. He would spend all his waking time wondering what the two of them were doing without him, possibly making plans to kick him out of the throuple. He knew they wouldn’t actually do something like that, but he couldn’t convince his mind otherwise.
He made a plan on his way back home. If Shane was going to be manipulative, he needed to be manipulative too, else lose Martin forever. He would go home, come out to his parents the next day and then deliberately get kicked out of his home. Martin would take him in for sure.
He hoped that sleeping on it would change his mind, but he was equally determined to do it the next morning. During lunch, he kept staring at his family while they watched TV. He knew this might be the last time he would ever see them if he went through with it. The things people do for love, he thought and stood up from his seat after he finished his meal.
“I have something to say,” he said and walked towards the TV. He switched it off and stood before it. “I am in a relationship with a man who has another boyfriend. It’s nothing to be ashamed of. I want you to accept me as I am, or you’ll never see me again. I don’t want to lie and hide anymore.”
Just as he had predicted, his father threw a fit about him betraying his family and choosing the devil over god. Then his father announced his choice, to never see him again.
“I would rather have my son die than let him live as a sinner under my roof,” his father shouted. Even though it was the outcome he wanted and predicted, tears rolled down Jimmy’s cheek as he ran towards his bedroom. It was done now and there was no going back. He’d thought it would give him happiness, but the sorrow of leaving his family was far greater than joys of new beginnings.
He packed up bare necessities in a suitcase while his mother tried to convince his father to change his mind. He wondered if there was an outcome where he didn’t have to choose between Martin and his family. Was Martin more important to him now than his family? Martin’s love was very new, and yet he chose it over the family who loved him all his life.
He wiped tears off his mother’s cheeks as she hugged him one last time. Then he hugged his sister and dog and left his family home.
When he knocked on Martin’s door and no one answered, he wondered if he was having sex with Shane. Shane must’ve moved in by now, and Jimmy was there to rain on their parade.
Just as he was about to ring the doorbell again, Martin answered the door. He had come prepared to lie to Martin, that he was kicked out because his father had accidentally found out his gay magazines. But now that he looked into his eyes, he couldn’t lie to him. He didn’t want to begin his new life with a big lie, so he started off small.
“I’m here for a sleepover,” he lied and then smiled sheepishly. “I hope you don’t mind.”
“You’re welcome here anytime.” Martin kissed him and lead him inside. Shane sat shirtless on the sofa watching TV. His face lit up when he saw him, and he knew Shane was genuinely happy to see him. He felt ashamed to be jealous of Shane. Shane was such a good friend, he was always there for him, he would never try to break them up. He was the same Shane he had always known and loved.
“You’re sleeping over?” Shane hugged him tight and kissed him on the cheek. “It’s gonna be so much fun!”
They played board and card games, and when they were all sleepy, Shane said he was going to bed and went to the bedroom.
“I’ll sleep here on the couch.,” he said as he got up from the floor and sat on the couch.
“You don’t have to.” Martin took his hand and lead him to a small locked room, which he then proceeded to open. “I have a spare bed in this storage room. You can sleep in here. I hope you don’t mind.”
Jimmy’s jaw almost dropped looking at the storage room. The room barely had enough space to stand, and everything was co
vered in dust. He knew Martin only moved here a few months ago, but it looked like the room hadn’t been opened in decades. He had left his comfortable bed back home to live in a storage room, while Shane and Martin sleep in a giant comfortable bed. His eyes began to grow wet.
“I prefer the couch, but I’ll use the bed since it’s just one night.” He walked into the room and dusted off the bed. “I’ll clean it up before going to bed. See you tomorrow. Goodnight.”
He decided to clean the entire room instead of just the bed. By the time he was done, he was exhausted. He jumped onto the bed and a cloud of dust blew up in his face.
“Fuck my life,” he whispered to himself and closed his eyes. The smell of the room was too strong for him to fall asleep. It smelled like a family of rats had just died in there, but he didn’t have the energy to find the source of the smell. He rolled around in his bed for what seemed like hours. Just as he was about to fall asleep, he heard the bed creak in the other room. The pace only grew faster and the creak louder. They were waiting for him to fall asleep so they could have sex! They couldn’t keep their hands to each other for one night.
He could hear Shane’s moans grow louder while Martin’s pants grew faster. Shane was making wild noises at the top of his lungs that Jimmy had always thought to be fake when he heard them in gay porn.
Shane was getting to have sex with Martin while he had to sleep in a dusty storage room. He couldn’t help but feel like he was a concubine or a mistress. After about half an hour more of fucking Shane’s brains out, Martin finally announced that he was about to cum and moaned loudly one last time before pin drop silence was restored. They must’ve been so tired from great sex that they’d immediately fallen asleep.
He could finally get some sleep, or so he thought. After about a minute, the bed creaked again and he heard footsteps approaching his room. He pretended to be asleep and didn’t move. The footsteps got closer and closer before someone got into his bed and lay a hand on his ass. The hand began to massage his ass before slipping inside his briefs.
