Sisters in Law

Home > Other > Sisters in Law > Page 45
Sisters in Law Page 45

by Linda Hirshman


  Ferrari, Mary, 59

  Finkbine, Shari, 79

  Fisher v. University of Texas, 285–87

  Florida

  Bush v. Gore, 256–58

  Hoyt v. Florida, 36, 90, 91–93

  Ford Foundation, 61, 63

  Fordham University School of Law, New York, New York, 149

  Forklift Systems, Harris v., 215–19, 220–22, 223–24

  Fortas, Abe, 41

  Fourteenth Amendment

  and choice availability, 145

  ERA vs., 35–36

  and jury selection, 228–29, 230

  legal scholars criticism of, 54

  and substantive comparability, 239

  Title IX, 247, 265

  and women’s equality, 40–44, 88–89, 95, 104, 264

  France, American jurists in, 176

  Frankfurter, Felix, 21

  Freedman, Ann, 39–40, 42

  Freund, Paul, 53

  Fried, Charles, 188

  Frontiero, Sharron, 69–70

  Frontiero v. Richardson, 69–77, 97, 142–43

  F.S. Royster Guano v. Virginia, 43–44

  FWOTSC (first woman on the Supreme Court), xi. See also O’Connor, Sandra Day

  Gaines, Ebersole, 137

  Gavin, Elizabeth “Beth,” 290–91

  gay rights, 292

  Gebser, Alida Star, 247

  Gebser v. Lago Vista Independent School District, 246, 247

  Geller, Steven, 8

  George Washington Law School National Conference on Women and the Law, 154–55

  Gibson, Dunn & Crutcher legal secretary position offer to O’Connor, xiv, xix, 13–14

  Gilbert, Fred, 106

  Gilles, Stephen, 167–68

  Gilligan, Carol, 202–3, 234

  Ginsburg, Ruth Bader, 1, 67, 197, 271

  and abortion issue, 60, 61, 80–81, 184–85, 204, 205, 209

  and affirmative action, 170–71, 208–9, 286–87

  awakening to women’s rights issues, 11, 25–29

  and Clinton, 6, 206–7

  and Constitution of the United States, 26–27, 28, 30–31

  and criminals or poor people, 210

  criticism of, 210–11

  delegation to France, 176

  and ERA, 26, 27, 35–36, 50–52, 53–55, 108

  and Hoyt v. Florida, 91–92, 93

  lobbying Congress for women’s rights, 30

  and MacKinnon, 202, 203

  and near-beer case in Oklahoma, 106–8

  and O’Connor, 115, 222–24, 231–33, 270

  on O’Connor’s cancer survivor speech, 178

  and Reed v. Reed, 39–44

  on sex discrimination, 56, 102, 241–43, 283, 301

  supporters for seat on the bench, 84–85, 109–10, 112–13

  on Voting Rights Act preclearance process, 288

  whites-only country club membership, 138

  See also ACLU Women’s Rights Project; Ginsburg on the Supreme Court; O’Connor and Ginsburg comparisons

  Ginsburg, biographical information

  childhood, 5–7

  as clerk for Palmieri, 21

  at Columbia Law School, 16, 21, 57, 66

  at Cornell, 7, 9–11, 14

  demeanor, 76, 95, 102–3, 113, 207, 282

  at federal Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit, 112–14, 207

  at Harvard Law School, xix, 14, 15–17, 56–57

  health issues, 253–54, 277, 297

  as newly-graduated lawyer, 20–23

  pregnancy prevents promotion, 14

  pre-Supreme Court, xvii, xix, xx

  at Rutgers Law School, 22–23, 25–30, 57

  and Swedish feminist movement, 21–22, 26

  as wife and mother, 14–15, 17–18, 22

  Ginsburg’s cases before the Supreme Court

  Craig v. Boren, 105–8, 142

  Edwards v. Healy, 90

  Frontiero v. Richardson, 69–77, 97, 142–43

  Kahn v. Shevin, 85–87, 96–98, 99

  Stanton v. Stanton, 105

  United States v. Virginia, xi–xiii

  See also Ginsburg on the Supreme Court; Weinberger v. Wiesenfeld

  Ginsburg’s strategy for equality feminism

  overview, 30–31, 70–72, 107–8, 253, 300

  applying Civil Rights Act to sexual harassment cases, 217–19

  case selection, 59–60, 63–64

  and Craig v. Boren, 106–7

  difference feminism vs., 201–3

  gains lost after Ginsburg goes to the bench, 139

  and Kahn setback, 97

  Kennedy vs., 252–53

  O’Connor’s use of in Hogan v. Mississippi, 141–43

  and United States v. Virginia opinion, 235, 241–43

  See also sex discrimination in jury service; strict-scrutiny vs. rational basis standard of review

  Ginsburg on the Supreme Court

  overview, xv, 69, 220–22, 230, 273, 298–99

  Burwell v. Hobby Lobby, 292–95

  clerks, 211–12, 213, 273

  consideration for nomination, 200–207

  dissents read out loud, 274–76, 279–82, 284–88, 292–95

  Gonzales v. Carhart, 268–70, 274, 296

  “happy face dissents,” 218–19

  J.E.B. v. Alabama, 224, 225, 226–27

  and Kennedy’s opinion for Planned Parenthood v. Casey, 193–94

  Lilly Ledbetter v. Goodyear Tire and Rubber, 274–76

  nomination and confirmation, 6–7, 91–92, 199, 207–11

  office, 210

  retirement suggestions, 278–79, 296–97

  Shelby County v. Holder, 287–88, 289

  summer travel and public speaking, 244–45

  swearing-in ceremony, 213–14

  United States v. Virginia, 240

  Ginsburg, James (son), 22, 108

  Ginsburg, Jane (daughter), 14, 15, 102, 108, 213

  Ginsburg, Martin “Marty” (husband)

  cancer and death of, 277

  cancer diagnosis, 17–18

  courtship and marriage, 14–15

  and Harvard vs. Columbia for Ruth, 16

  lobbying for Ginsburg’s appointments, 110–11, 112, 205, 278

  as loving husband, 23, 278

  and Moritz case, 32

  teaching at Columbia, 109

  Goesaert v. Cleary, 26

  Goldberg, David, 212

  Goldfarb, Califano v., 104, 106

  Goldfarb, Leon, 104

  Goldwater, Barry, xxii, 49, 123, 131, 181

  Gonzales v. Carhart, 268–70, 274

  Goodman, Janice, 39–40, 66

  Goodyear Tire and Rubber, Lilly Ledbetter v., 274–76

  Gore, Bush v., 255–59

  Greco, Joan, 175

  Greenburg, Jan Crawford, 267

  Grimké, Sarah, 28, 75

  Griswold, Erwin, 15–16, 62, 206

  Gunther, Gerald, 20–21

  Haft, Marilyn, 112

  Hand, Learned, xix, 21

  Hardy, Charles, 215–16

  Harlan, John Marshall, 41, 273

  Harlan, Malvina, 273

  Harris, Barbara, 161

  Harris, Teresa, 215–16

  Harris v. Forklift Systems, 215–19, 220–22, 223–24

  Harvard Law Review, 12, 37

  Harvard Law School, Cambridge, Massachusetts, xix, 14, 15–17, 56–57

  Harvard Law School dean and Ginsburg place in law school, xiv–xv, xix

  Hatch, Orrin, 113

  Hazeltine, Sherman, 120

  health insurance and birth control case, 292–95

  Healy, Edwards v., 90

  Hess, Stephen, 200

  Hibbs, Nevada v., 265, 282–83

  Hibbs, William, 265

  Higginbotham, Patrick, 110

  Hirshman, Linda, xiii, xiv

  Hishon, Elizabeth Anderson “Betsy,” 157

  Hishon v. King & Spalding, 157, 158–60, 161

  Hobby Lobby, Burwell v., 292–95


  Hochschild, Arlie, 28

  Hogan, Joe, 140, 146

  Hogan v. Mississippi

  overview, xii–xiii, 233

  decision and opinions, 138–39, 141–46, 232, 237

  outcome, 146

  prosecution and defense, 140–41

  Holder, Shelby County v., 287–88, 289

  Holes, Harry, 137

  Holmes, Oliver Wendell, Jr., 273

  Hopkins, Ann, 178–79

  Hopkins, Price Waterhouse v., 178–80, 182–83, 285

  House Un-American Activities Committee, 10, 11

  Hoyt v. Florida, 36, 90, 91–93

  “If” (Kipling), 8

  Illinois, Bradwell v., 92, 269–70

  immigration and parentage, 246–50

  INS, Nguyen v., 263–64

  Internal Revenue Code on men as caretakers, 32–33

  Internet blog: Notorious R.B.G., 289–90, 292, 295, 299

  Jackson v. Birmingham Board of Education, 265–66

  James Madison High School, Brooklyn, New York, 6

  J.E.B. v. Alabama, 224–28

  Jewish lawyers and “The Year of Our Lord” on certificates of admission, 213

  Johnson, Josh, 292

  Johnson v. Santa Clara Transportation Authority, 170–72, 208–9

  judiciary and politics, xvi, 53, 183

  Junior League, 20

  juries, defendant’s right to shape, 228–29, 230

  jury service, 224. See also sex discrimination in jury service

  Kagan, Elena, 278, 298–99

  Kahn, Melvin, 85, 94

  Kahn v. Shevin, 85–87, 96–98, 99

  Keith, Judith, 233–34

  Kelly, Mary F., 39–40, 156

  Kennedy, Anthony, 197

  appointment, 174

  Bush v. Gore, 256

  Ferguson v. Charleston, 262

  Gonzales v. Carhart, 296

  Jackson v. Birmingham Board of Education, 266

  Nguyen v. INS, 263–64

  Planned Parenthood v. Casey, 192–94, 250–51, 295

  post-Bush v. Gore liberal votes, 260

  and Scalia, 193

  Stenberg v. Carhart, 250, 251, 253

  as swing vote, 279

  University of Texas Southwestern Hospital v. Nassar, 284

  and women’s equality, 219–20, 252–53, 260–61, 262–65, 269–70

  Kennedy, Cornelia, 151

  Kennedy, Edward, 133

  Kenyon, Dorothy, 38

  King & Spalding, Atlanta, Georgia, 157–58

  King & Spalding, Hishon v., 157, 158–60, 161

  Kipling, Rudyard, 8

  Kiser, Jackson, 237, 238

  Klain, Ron, 208

  Klein, Joel, 207–8

  Knizhnik, Shana, 289–, 299

  Kolbert, Kathryn, 191, 192

  Kozinski, Alex, 215

  Krauskopf, Joan, 54

  Kurland, Philip, 52–53, 102

  Lago Vista Independent School District, Gebser v., 246, 247

  law firms and women

  Ginsburg’s dead-end summer job at Paul, Weiss, 20

  Hishon v. King & Spalding, 157, 158–60, 161

  lawsuits for equal treatment, 156–57, 158–60, 161

  O’Connor offered legal secretary position post-graduation, xiv, xix, 13–14

  O’Connor’s rejections, 13

  women presumed to be incompetent, 160–61

  Lazy B (O’Connor and Day), 3–4

  legal equality, 102

  legal profession and ERA, 51–53

  legal social change movements, xvi, xx–xxi. See also Ginsburg’s strategy for equality feminism; racial social movement

  legal system in the United States, 36–37, 42

  lesbianism, 64–65, 146

  Levin, Joseph, 69–70, 71–73

  Lilly Ledbetter Fair Pay Act (2009), 276

  Lilly Ledbetter v. Goodyear Tire and Rubber, 274–76

  Lindh, Patricia, 126–27

  Lippman, Mark, 176

  London, England, legal conference, 129–30

  Louisiana, 90, 92–93, 280–81

  Lutzker, Shelly, 59

  MacKinnon, Catharine, 163, 202, 203

  MacKinnon, George, 163

  Madison, Dolly, 40

  Madison Lecture series at NYU, 203–5

  Mandil, Daniel, 187

  Mann, Jonathan, 295, 296

  “Marriage Agreement, A” (Shulman), 27–28

  Marriage of Figaro, The (Mozart), 293

  Marshall, Thurgood, xvi, 42

  Brown v. Board of Education, 40, 117–18, 140, 144–45, 273

  case selection, 65

  Mary Baldwin College solution to VMI, 238–39

  McBridge, Andrew, 187

  McCain, John, 181

  McCarthy, Joseph, and McCarthyism, 9–10, 11

  McFeathers, Ann, 131

  McGregor, Ruth, 132–33, 136, 138–39

  McKissick, Floyd, 38

  Mellor, Mary-Audrey Weicker, 136

  Meritor Savings Bank, FSB v. Vinson, 164–68, 216

  Michelman, Kate, 205

  Miller, Charles, 246

  Miller v. Albright, 246–47

  Mill, John Stuart, 243

  Mills, Cheryl, 205

  Millstein, Ira, 110, 113

  Mississippi University for Women (MUW, the W), 138, 139–40, 141. See also Hogan v. Mississippi

  Missouri, 111, 150–52, 186–90, 227

  Missouri Citizens for Life (MCL), 150, 186

  mixed-motive cases, 284–85

  Moberg, Eva, 21–22, 26, 27

  Monaghan, Henry, 278

  Monroe County Board of Education, Davis v., 247–48

  Monsoor, Debra, 60

  Moore, Frank, 112

  Morgan, Charles, 158

  Moritz, Charles, 32–33

  Moritz v. Commissioner of Internal Revenue, 33–34, 39, 43, 55

  Moynihan, Daniel Patrick, 200–201

  Murray, Bob, 137

  Murray, Pauli, 38, 65

  Myrdal, Gunnar, 40

  Nassar, University of Texas Southwestern Hospital v., 284–85

  National Association of Law Women, 29

  National Association of Women Judges, xxii, 208

  National Conference on Women and the Law, George Washington Law School, 154–55

  National Organization for Women (NOW), 63–66, 133–34

  near-beer case in Oklahoma, 105–8

  Nebraska, 250–51

  Neier, Aryeh, 39, 57–58, 61, 63, 66, 108–9

  Ness, Susan, 111

  Nevada, 265

  Nevada v. Hibbs, 265, 282–83

  New England School of Law, Boston, Massachusetts, 149

  Nguyen v. INS, 263–64

  Nicastro, Robert, 281–82

  Nixon, Richard, 42, 117, 121–22, 131

  Notorious B.I.G., 289

  Notorious R.B.G. Internet blog, 289–90, 292, 295, 299

  Nussbaum, Bernard, 201, 206–7

  Oberly, Kathryn, 180

  O’Connor and Ginsburg comparisons

  abortion issue, 60, 184–85, 209

  affirmative action, 170–72, 208–9

  constitutional interpretation, 209, 210

  and ERA battle, 49–50

  mentors, 8–11

  pre-Supreme Court, xvii–xix

  relationships with others, xxi–xxii

  road to the Supreme Court, xv–xix

  self-respect and regard for others, xx–xxii

  speaking about Ellen Ash Peters, 231–32

  on Supreme Court, xxii–xxiii

  visions of the present world, 210

  O’Connor and Ginsburg differentiation with T-shirts, xxii, 208

  O’Connor, Sandra Day, 115, 197, 271

  and abortion issue, 60, 131, 134, 150–54, 184, 251

  on blessings of marriage, 46

  and Burger, 128–31, 135, 168–69

  and Bush, George H. W., 181, 182, 192

  cancer diagnosis, 181


  and cap on taxes issue, 123, 124

  constitutional interpretation, 152–53, 189, 209, 210

  criticism of, 196

  delegation to France, 176

  demeanor, xxiii

  and different-voice theory, 203–4, 233, 300

  and ERA, 47, 48–50

  family first philosophy, xviii, 46, 131, 132, 147–48

  and feminism, 118–19

  and Ginsburg, 155, 178, 222–24, 231–33, 270, 298–301

  and Goldwater, xxii, 123, 131, 181

  at Mormon church service, 133

  and Nixon, 46–47, 117, 119, 122

  and Reagan, xiv, 123, 130, 131–32

  and Rehnquist, 118–21

  and social change, 172

  on women in the law profession, 161–62

  See also O’Connor and Ginsburg comparisons

  O’Connor, biographical information

  as Arizona Court of Appeals judge, 129

  as Arizona State Senator, 23–24, 25, 45–50, 122–24, 134

  as assistant attorney general, 23

  cancer diagnosis, 176–78

  childhood, xxiii, 3–5

  as criminal trial judge, 124–25

  legal secretary position offer, xiv, xix, 13–14

  as newly-graduated lawyer, xiv, xix, 13–14, 18–19

  photographic memory, 148

  pre-Supreme Court, xv–xvi, xvii, xviii, xx

  and Rathbun, 9, 258

  at Stanford, 5, 7–9

  at Stanford Law School, 12–14

  on Supreme Court, xv, xxii, xxiii

  as wife and mother, 20, 24–25

  O’Connor on the Supreme Court

  overview, 174–75, 183, 195–96, 219, 221, 222, 230–31, 298, 299, 300

  abortion issue analysis, 150–54

  and affirmative action, 119, 171–72, 208–9

  all-female aerobics class, 147, 175, 244

  appointment and confirmation hearings, xiv, 130–35

  Bush v. Gore, 255–59

  clerks, 174–75, 187, 222–23

  on defendant’s right to shape juries, 228–29

  Harris v. Forklift Systems, 217, 218

  Hishon v. King & Spalding, 160

  Hogan v. Mississippi, xii–xiii, 141–43, 145–46

  Jackson v. Birmingham Board of Education, 266

  J.E.B. v. Alabama, 228–29

  Johnson v. Santa Clara Transportation Authority, 171–72, 208

  legacy, 266–68

  Meritor Savings Bank, FSB v. Vinson, 165–66, 167–68, 216

  office disorder on arrival, 136

  Planned Parenthood v. Casey, 192–96

  post-Bush v. Gore support for women’s equality, 259–60

  Price Waterhouse v. Hopkins, 182–83, 285

  public speaking and events, 147–49

  road to, xv–xix, 127–30

  Stenberg v. Carhart, 251

  swearing-in ceremony, 135, 146–47

  United States v. Virginia, xii, 241–42

  O’Connor, John, III (husband), 13, 18–19, 46, 132–33, 137–38, 255, 267

  Ogg, Mary Fran, 124–25

 

‹ Prev