Sisters in Law

Home > Other > Sisters in Law > Page 46
Sisters in Law Page 46

by Linda Hirshman

Olson, Theodore, 240

  Oncale v. Sundowner, 221, 222

  O’Neill, John E., 96–97

  Palme, Olof, 22, 26

  Palmieri, Edmund, 21

  “partial birth” abortions, 250–51, 268–70

  Paul, Alice, xvii

  Paul, Weiss, Rifkind, Wharton & Garrison, New York, New York, 20

  Pennsylvania’s sex-segregated schools, 237

  Peratis, Kathleen, 65

  peremptory challenges of state vs. defendant, 228–29

  Perkins, Charles, 140

  Peters, Ellen Ash, 231–32

  Pickrell, Bob, 23

  Planned Parenthood, 79

  Planned Parenthood v. Casey, 190–96, 295

  Plessy v. Ferguson, 118, 144

  politics

  and abortion issue, 191, 204–5

  in Arizona, 19–20, 119–20

  of equal rights, 88–89

  and judiciary, xvi, 53, 183

  and makeup of the Supreme Court, 181–82

  O’Connor’s, 255, 257–58

  women and Republican Party, 130

  Posner, Richard, 215

  Post, David, 211–12

  Post, Suzy, 38

  Powell, Lewis

  Califano v. Goldfarb, 104, 107

  Clark as clerk, 88–90, 91, 98–99, 105, 144

  ERA argument in Frontiero v. Richardson decision, 76–77

  Hishon v. King & Spalding, 160

  Hogan v. Mississippi, 143–46

  Nixon’s appointment of, 75

  and O’Connor, 135, 136–37

  as swing vote for Ginsburg, 90–91

  Weinberger v. Wiesenfeld, 98, 100–101

  and whites-only country club membership, 138

  Powell, “Mims,” 135

  preclearance process, Voting Rights Act, 288

  pregnancy discrimination, 14, 59, 60, 78, 81, 82, 261–62

  Price Waterhouse, 178–79

  Price Waterhouse v. Hopkins, 178–80, 182–83, 285

  protective institutions, harm from, 143, 287

  protective legislation for women, 28, 37–38, 47, 52–53, 86

  P.S. 238, Brooklyn, New York, 6

  psychological injury standard, 165–66, 216–17, 218

  Pulliam, Eugene C., 19

  Pyles, Carol, 60

  racial social movement

  overview, xvi, 30–31, 169

  and affirmative action, 169, 286–87

  and Civil Rights Act, xvii

  and country clubs, 137–38

  discrimination allowed by Supreme Court, 70

  exclusion of women, 37–38

  and Fourteenth Amendment, 35

  Ginsburg on racial minority, 204–5

  and jury of peers concept, 90

  and jury service, 224

  Rehnquist vs., 117–18

  and schools, 144–45

  sex segregation as weapon against, 140

  Sotomayor’s insights, 301

  whites-only club memberships, 137–38

  See also affirmative action; Civil Rights Act

  Ragsdale, Lincoln, 137

  Rasmussen, Irene, 48, 50

  Rasmussen, Rachel, 50

  Rathbun, Harry, 7–9, 258

  rational basis of review. See strict-scrutiny vs. rational basis standard of review

  “RBGuicy” video, 290–91

  Reagan, Ronald, xiv, 123, 130, 131–32

  Redding, Safford School District v., 276

  Redding, Savanna, 276

  Reed v. Reed, 34–35, 36, 39–44, 70, 71, 141–42

  Rehnquist, William, 197

  overview, 117–18, 121

  Bush v. Gore, 256

  clerkship and job, easily found, 18, 19

  and Craig v. Boren, 107

  on employees’ right to sue employers for damages, 265

  and Ginsburg, 223

  Meritor Savings Bank, FSB v. Vinson, 166–67

  Nixon’s appointment of, 75

  and O’Connor, 118–21

  Planned Parenthood v. Casey, 191, 192

  thyroid cancer diagnosis, 267

  Webster v. Reproductive Health Services, 188–89

  Weinberger v. Wiesenfeld, 96–97, 101

  religion and abortion rights, 150–52

  Religious Freedom Restoration Act (1993), 293

  Reno, Janet, 206

  reproduction, burden of, 82, 295

  Reproductive Health Services, Webster v., 186–90

  reproductive rights, 81, 185, 187–90, 193–94. See also abortion issue; anti-abortion movement

  Republican Party

  anti-abortion shift, 130, 151

  and ERA, 49, 122–23, 130

  New Right, 186

  in Texas, 126

  Richardson, Frontiero v., 69–77, 97, 142–43

  Rigelman, Diana, 39–40

  right-to-life movement. See anti-abortion movement

  Roberts, John, 267–68, 287–88

  Roberts, Sylvia, 63–64

  Robinson, Spottswood, 163

  Rockefeller Foundation award, 108–9

  Roe v. Wade, 60–61, 62

  Court of Appeals for Third Circuit refusing to follow Roe v. Wade, 190–91

  and Ginsburg, 61

  Ginsburg on, 204–5

  and O’Connor, 60, 153–54, 184, 189

  religious organizations vs., 150–52

  and Stewart, 151–52

  Supreme Court decision, 62, 78, 80

  and Webster v. Reproductive Health Services, 188–90

  Rogers, Judith, 231

  Rosenblatt, Paul, 124–25

  Rosen, Jeffrey, 256

  Rossi, Alice, 46

  Rutgers Law School, Camden, New Jersey, 22–23, 25–30

  integration of, 57

  Ruth Bader Ginsburg archive, Library of Congress, 27

  Sachs, Albert, 20–21

  Safford School District v. Redding, 276

  Salzburg, Austria, 19

  same-sex marriage, 64–65

  Santa Clara Transportation Authority, Johnson v., 170–72, 208–9

  Scalia, Antonin

  and abortion issue, 188

  on affirmative action, 119

  and Bush, George W., 257

  Bush v. Gore, 256

  constitutional interpretation, 209–10

  on Fourteenth Amendment, 283

  and Ginsburg, xxii

  J.E.B. v. Alabama, 229

  and Kennedy, 193

  United States v. Virginia, 243

  Schafran, Lynn Hecht, 113, 134

  Schizer, David, 211, 212

  Schlafly, Phyllis, 49, 83, 186

  Schlanger, Margo, 211, 212

  Schlesinger v. Ballard, 89–90, 227

  schools

  Brown v. Board of Education, 40, 117–18, 140, 144–45, 273

  illegal search of a young girl, 276

  integration of, 55–56, 138, 139–40, 141, 237

  sexual harassment of students, 246–48, 276

  See also specific schools

  Schrag, Philip, 84

  Schroeder, Mary, 129, 132

  Schwab, Stewart, 158

  Second Shift, The (Hochschild), 28

  Secretary of Defense, Struck v., 61–62, 188

  self-realization concept, 7, 8–9

  Setear, John, 174–75

  severe psychological injury standard, 165–66, 216–17, 218

  sex discrimination

  overview, 84, 163, 233–34

  Brennan raising the standard sex discrimination laws, 107

  burden of reproduction, 82, 295

  and Civil Rights Act, 246–47

  Clark’s memo to Powell on upcoming Supreme Court cases, 88–90, 98–99

  Craig v. Boren, 105–8, 142

  drinking age in Oklahoma, 105–8

  Frontiero v. Richardson, 69–77, 97, 142–43

  in girls intramural sports, 265–66

  Hishon v. King & Spalding, 157, 158–60, 161

  J.E.B. v. Alabama, 224–28<
br />
  and judicial interpretation of the Fourteenth Amendment, 209

  Kahn v. Shevin, 85–87, 96–98, 99

  at law firms/partnerships, 157, 158–60, 161

  Lilly Ledbetter v. Goodyear Tire and Rubber, 274–76

  men filing complaints, 143–44

  for pregnancy, 14, 59, 60, 78, 81, 82, 261–62

  presumption that women were dependent on spouses and men were not, 71

  sex segregation as weapon against racial integration, 140

  stay-at-home dads as indolent, 98–99

  Supreme Court justices’ refusal to hire women as clerks, 21, 37

  Utah law on child support for boys vs. girls, 105

  woman’s responsibility for proving, 182–83

  against women who contributed to Social Security and died, 98–99, 100–101

  See also Ginsburg’s strategy for equality feminism; Hogan v. Mississippi; Reed v. Reed; United States v. Virginia; Weinberger v. Wiesenfeld

  sex discrimination in jury service

  Duren v. Missouri, 111, 227

  Edwards v. Healy, 90

  effect of, 170–71

  Ginsburg’s strategy for equality, 90

  Hoyt v. Florida, 36, 90, 91–93

  J.E.B. v. Alabama, 224–29

  sex-integration of schools, 55–56, 237. See also Hogan v. Mississippi; United States v. Virginia

  sexual equality

  overview, xiii–xiv

  equating to racial equality, 40–44, 88–89, 95, 104, 264

  for men, 22, 26

  at Virginia Military Institute, xi–xii

  See also feminist movement; sex discrimination

  sexual harassment

  overview, 162–68, 172–73

  adoption of Ginsburg’s standard, 221

  clarifying abusive work environment, 218

  and EEOC, 164, 216, 217

  lower court opinions, 215, 216, 218

  Meritor Savings Bank, FSB v. Vinson, 164–68, 216

  severe psychological injury standard, 165–66, 216–17, 218

  sex-based descriptions of how to get promoted, 178–80

  of students, 246–48

  Vance v. Ball State, 284

  Shapiro, Alexandra, 212

  Shelby County v. Holder, 287–88, 289

  Shevin, Kahn v., 85–87, 96–98, 99

  Shulman, Alix Kate, 27–28

  slaves, women compared to in literature, 40

  Smeal, Eleanor, 133–34

  Smit, Hans, 21

  Smith, Chesterfield, 110

  Smith, William French, 131

  social change

  in 1960s, 24, 25–30

  in 1970s, 65–66

  in 1980s, 148–49, 161–64

  in 1990s, 234–35

  and abortion battles, 185–90

  See also racial social movement

  social revolution through law, xvi, xviii

  Social Security widows preferences, 103–4. See also Weinberger v. Wiesenfeld

  sodomy laws, 260

  Sotomayor, Sonia, 277, 300–301

  Souter, David, 190, 192–94, 197

  Spaeth, Carl, 12

  Spann, William, 111

  Stanford Law School, Stanford, California, 12–14

  Stanford University, Stanford, California, 5, 7–9

  Stanton v. Stanton, 105

  Starr, Kenneth, 132

  Steinem, Gloria, 214

  Stenberg v. Carhart, 250–53, 296

  stereotypes and stereotyping

  overview, 252–53

  effect of women as caregivers, 283

  Kennedy on women as natural parents, 263–64

  O’Connor on, 264

  of parents’ relationships to children, 249

  sex-role stereotyping vs. sexual equality, 26, 28–29, 83, 86, 100, 142, 234

  Stern, Paula, 45

  Stevens, John Paul, 197

  Califano v. Goldfarb, 104

  Ferguson v. Charleston, 262

  Hishon v. King & Spalding, 159

  Miller v. Albright, 246–47

  nomination to Supreme Court, 127

  on O’Connor, xv

  Webster v. Reproductive Health Services, 186–90

  and women on the Supreme Court, 151

  Stewart, Potter, 42, 137, 151

  Stoessel, Mary Ann, 255

  Stone, Geoffrey, 44, 75

  Strausbaugh, Toni, 59–60

  strict-scrutiny vs. rational basis standard of review

  overview, 36, 41–42, 70

  Ginsburg’s argument in Frontiero v. Richardson, 75–77

  and tax break for widows, 86–87

  and United States v. Virginia school sex-segregation case, 239

  See also Ginsburg’s strategy for building women’s equality

  Stromseth, Jane, 187

  Struck, Susan, 61

  Struck v. Secretary of Defense, 61–62, 188

  “Subjection of Women, The” (Mill), 243

  substantive comparability, 239

  Sullivan and Cromwell, New York, New York, 156–57

  Sundowner, Oncale v., 221, 222

  Supreme Court. See U.S. Supreme Court

  Suzman, Helen, 233

  Svirdoff, Michael, 63

  Sweden’s feminist movement, 21–22, 26

  Taylor, Billy, 92

  Taylor, Sidney, 164–65, 168

  Taylor v. Louisiana, 90, 92–93

  Tennessee, 216

  Term of the Woman, Supreme Court, 87–90, 102–3

  Thomas, Clarence, 190, 197, 256

  Thompson, John, 280–82

  Time magazine, 108

  Title IX, 247, 265

  Title VII. See Civil Rights Act (1964)

  Tocqueville, Alexis de, xvi

  Toobin, Jeffrey, 257, 266

  Totenberg, Nina, 41, 66, 113

  Tribe, Laurence, 108

  Troll, F. Robert, Jr., 165–66

  T-shirts for Ruth and Sandra, xxii, 208

  undue-burden standard for state laws on abortion, 153–54, 194–96, 251–52

  United States legal system, 36–37, 42, 93

  United States v. Virginia

  and Hogan precedent, 232, 237

  and landscape of sex discrimination, 233–34

  lower court rulings, 238–39

  rationalization for sex discrimination, 234–35, 238

  results of, 243–44

  Supreme Court ruling and opinion, xi–xiii, 239–43

  trial, 235

  VMI male-oriented rituals, 235–36

  VMI preemptive action, 237

  VMI resistance to race desegregation, 236–37

  University of Chicago Law School, Chicago, Illinois, 25

  University of Texas, Fisher v., 285–87

  University of Texas Southwestern Hospital v. Nassar, 284–85

  U.S. military

  attempt to force an abortion, 61–62, 188

  and dependence of male vs. female spouse, 69–77

  fear about integration of, 52, 55

  male soldier suing for unfair promotion opportunity for women, 89–90, 227

  U.S. Supreme Court, 197

  overview, 246

  and affirmative action, 170–72, 286–87

  days for decision and decision day, xi, xii–xiii

  decision day, xii–xiii

  and dissents read out loud, 274, 291–92

  dissents read out loud in, 291–92

  and equality of women, 282–83, 295–97

  justices voting at conference, 230

  lawyers presenting before, 72, 111

  O’Connor’s anticipated effect, 134–35

  political election betting pool, 181–82

  on pregnancy discrimination, 82

  raising the standard for sex discrimination cases, 107

  reviewing requests for case review, 95–97, 138–39, 158, 191–92

  and sexual harassment, 163–68, 172–73

  “split in the Circuit” cases, 158

&nb
sp; swing votes, 9, 90–91, 279

  Term of the Woman, 87–93

  and “The Year of Our Lord” on lawyers’ certificates of admission, 213

  See also strict-scrutiny vs. rational basis standard of review; specific cases

  U.S. Supreme Court clerks

  Berzon, Marsha, 87–88, 99

  Blackmun’s, 228

  Bush v. Gore effect on, 259

  Clark, Penny, 88–90, 91, 98–99, 102–3, 105, 144

  Ginsburg’s, 210, 211–12, 213, 273

  O’Connor’s, 174–75, 187, 222–23

  pool procedure for reviewing case review requests, 95–97, 138–39, 158

  resistance to women as, 21, 37

  status attributed to, 12

  Stone, Geoffrey, 44, 75

  Term of the Woman, 87–93, 98–99

  See also specific clerks

  Utah law on child support for boys vs. girls, 105

  Vance v. Ball State, 284

  Vietnam, children resulting from Americans in, 248–49, 262–64

  Vinson, Mechelle, 164–65, 168

  Vinson, Meritor Savings Bank, FSB v., 164–68, 216

  Virginia, 43–44, 136, 144–45

  Virginia Military Institute, xi–xii, 234–36. See also United States v. Virginia

  volunteerism of O’Connor, xx

  Wald, Pat, 160–61

  Warren, Earl, 41

  Washington Post, 113

  Weber, Brian, 170

  Webster v. Reproductive Health Services, 186–90

  Wechsler, Herbert, 15–16, 52

  Weddington, Sarah, 80, 112–13

  Weinberger v. Wiesenfeld

  celebration party, 103

  as discrimination against women who contributed to Social Security and then died, 98–99, 100–101

  facts of the case, 94–95

  fallout from, 103–4

  Ginsburg’s expectations, 99

  O’Connor’s use of in Hogan v. Mississippi, 143

  ruling, 101–3, 227

  and Supreme Court pool procedure, 96–97

  trial, 99–100

  Weitzman, Lenore, 28

  welfare law discrimination, 111–12

  Westcott, Califano v., 111–12

  wet T-shirt (bathing suit) contest at King & Spalding, 157–58, 162

  White, Byron, 42, 76, 197, 205

  White House special assistant for women, 126–27

  widows vs. widowers, deferential treatment for, 85–87, 97, 103–4. See also Weinberger v. Wiesenfeld

  Wiesenfeld, Jason, 100, 103, 213, 244–45

  Wiesenfeld, Paula, 99

  Wiesenfeld, Stephen, 94–95, 100, 103, 274. See also Weinberger v. Wiesenfeld

  Wiley, John, 141

  Wilkey, Ada Mae, 3

  Williamsburg, Virginia, 136

  “Will London Bridge? or Women’s Lib?” (American Bar Association mock arbitration), 51

  women’s equality

  overview, 238

  and abortion rights, 185, 187–88

  Ginsburg on, 269–70

  “injury to women” and “legitimate state interest” standards, 89

  Mill’s essay on, 243

 

‹ Prev