All Hallows Eve

by Heather Graham

“But?”

  “I came into the woods and didn’t see a soul, except the woman hanged from the tree.”

  “Cigarette butt,” Martin yelled.

  “Great. Bag it,” Sam called back. “Jenna, what happened to the person you were chasing? You think that they might have done this, or do you think it was a spirit?”

  “No, nothing like that. And I don’t know if they were a possible suspect or not. The guy in costume might have headed straight for the road, while I cut into the woods deeper. And it’s Halloween. Finding someone in costume is going to be ridiculously hard. Half the world around here is going to be dressed up.”

  “What costume, Jenna?” he asked, holding her shoulders and trying not to grip too hard.

  “It was a boo-hag.”

  Chapter 6

  They were sitting in a meeting room at the police station when Craig Rockwell called Sam to say that he and Devin Lyle had landed and were on their way. Sam had seldom been more grateful to have other Krewe members around.

  Lt. Bickford P. Huntington, Supervisor for the Criminal Investigations Unit, had called a meeting to inform a task force from Salem and the surrounding areas about the two murders and bring them up to speed on what was known. He had Gary Martin speak and introduced Sam and Jenna as representatives from the federal government. Some there were old friends, some on the force new, not around four years ago when the murders had taken place at Lexington House, which Jenna and Sam had worked.

  Sam thought Huntington seemed competent as he laid out all of the information they knew. He also provided a good assessment for what they might be looking for. Someone with a deranged historical sense of revenge, or someone with a contemporary sense of it, or someone who just wanted to kill people. Huntington looked over at Sam and suggested that he provide the group his thoughts. Before he could speak one of the officers spoke up.

  “This woman you found today, she was a major commercial-style star Wiccan. Does that mean that we’re really looking for someone in a coven?”

  The answer was probably yes, but Sam was careful with his reply. He couldn’t say that a ghost had told a young woman that his killer had been talking about the witch trials and cults.

  “It’s my understanding that a feud has been ongoing. So I think it’s going to be important to discover if there’s someone in some kind of an offshoot cult that might be doing this, not necessarily Wiccan. We all know that today’s pagan religions, especially here in Salem, believe in treating everyone with love and respect. Murder would be a terrible sin to anyone truly practicing the Wiccan religion. There are many ways to look at this without stereotyping anyone.”

  “But, the two victims were killed in the same manner as those executed during the witchcraft trials,” another officer said.

  “You all know your history here. Anything was witchcraft. If you looked into the future, silly girls playing at love potions, even goodwives trying medicinal herbs, all of that was considered witchcraft. Of course, none of those executed was a witch. It was hysteria, fueled over petty squabbles and simple hatred among the people who lived here then. The pagans, or Wiccans, we have in Salem today have nothing to do with all that. Should we look at strange cults and fundamentalism of any kind, be it Wiccans or another group? Absolutely. Do we need to question people spouting against Gloria Day? Definitely. But the medical examiner’s office hasn’t even started on the second autopsy yet. Let’s see what comes of that.”

  Jenna was introduced—she smiled and greeted old friends and thanked those she’d worked with before, asking that they be especially vigilant in the areas surrounding the mortuary, graveyard, and forest, and to listen to what they heard around town. “You know Salem. You’ll know when something isn’t right or when it feels strange. We need to keep a close eye on the mortuary. The first murder apparently happened at a time when those in charge were busy or unaware. And we need to watch out for local situations. Crack pots, cults, culture clashes of any kind.”

  The meeting ended and Sam and Jenna wound up discussing their next moves in one of the conference rooms while Lieutenant Huntington went on to speak to the press. The community, Sam knew, would be talking about nothing else. But, none of it would stop Halloween or Samhain celebrations. Salem had a life of its own at this time of year. A pulse. A beat. Like a living entity.

  Gary Martin was working hard. He hadn’t wanted a murder, but he’d wound up with two. His men had retrieved a fair amount of evidence from the forest where Gloria Day’s body had been found. All of the cigarette butts, cans, bits and pieces of hair, and everything else would go to the DNA lab. And while TV shows might get their results back in an hour, it would be days, possibly weeks, before these would be ready. Sam harbored no illusions. They were not going to get anything off an old cola can. Their killer wasn’t sitting there enjoying a soda before hanging a woman. Results would come from walking and talking and discovering what was going on in the community. Someone had to have seen a car. The hill upon which the mortuary sat alongside the cemetery wasn’t in walking distance from town. And Gloria Day’s killer had not forced her to walk up the hill then into the forest to be hanged. It made sense that John Bradbury had been in the basement of the mortuary. He worked there. But Gloria Day was another matter. Her shop and school sat in the middle of town, down the street from the Hawthorne Hotel. Had she been lured up there to see something unusual? To participate in some kind of ceremony? Sam was anxious to get to her shop, but he also wanted to know more about the various groups in the community now. And much of it, he thought, needed to be done by himself and Jenna, or Rocky and Devin. The local police were good. But the Krewe team was better.

  Alone with Gary Martin and Jenna in the conference room, Sam looked over the files on locals, along with the notes they’d received from Angela Hawkins, Jackson Crow’s wife and top assistant. She’d found pages and pages of Facebook, Instagram, Google, and other social media communications that spoke of an all-out verbal war between two factions in the city. Two main rivals were clear. The Coven of the Silver Moon, Gloria Day’s group. And the Coven of the Silver Wolf, Tandy Whitehall’s people. Each of the two had hives, where the overflow went when there were too many people in a coven. Thirteen was considered the ideal number, but that wasn’t etched in stone. Hives, he knew, kept their membership low so as not to become unwieldy, the perfect place for a newly ordained high priest or priestess. Both Day and Whitehall had enjoyed a lot of popularity, their hives numerous and, on occasions like Samhain, they gathered together. In Salem, that usually happened at Gallows Hill, which, frankly, Sam didn’t agree with, and for good reason.

  Just seemed the wrong place.

  “There’s been a lot of talk on the web,” Martin said, reading through some of the notes Angela had e-mailed. “The word ‘bitch’ seems overly popular. Gloria Day seems to be accused of being a greedy, manipulative usurper, determined to rule all of Salem. She gives good cause for the world to believe modern-day witches to be old hags with saggy brooms and warts flying across the moon on broomsticks.’” He paused and looked at them. “Now that’s just mean. She’s old, yes. But certainly not ugly and doesn’t have any warts.”

  Officers had tried to pay a visit to Tandy Whitehall, but she’d not been at her shop, Magical Fantasies, nor at her house. Everyone was on the lookout for her. If she wasn’t found soon, sterner measures would be used. Sam believed Whitehall had to know they were looking for her. The media had sniffed out the latest murder with the speed of light. So quickly, in fact, that Jenna had wondered if they shouldn’t be looking for someone involved with the media. But Sam kept remembering Elyssa’s words. That the ghost mentioned the witchcraft trials and cults. That didn’t necessarily mean modern-day pagans. But the well-publicized feud between the two most prominent covens could not be ignored.

  Among the information Angela had sent was details on a legend. Sam had specifically asked about the Gullah culture and the boo-hag.

  “Listen to this,” he said, reading the informa
tion.

  And he told them about an old folk story and a boy named Billie Bob who just could not find a wife. So his father fixed him up with the daughter of a swamp woman. He was stunned when he met her. She was gorgeous, with dark eyes, dark hair, and a beautiful body. She didn’t want to be married by a priest, but was willing to stand before a judge. So they were married and she was the perfect wife by day. But at night she never came to bed. Suspecting the worst, Billie Bob, armed with sugar and honey and all manner of gifts, went to see a local conjuring woman. The old woman told him to pretend that he was asleep, then watch what his wife did. The next night Billie Bob did just that, following his wife up to the attic where she sat at a wheel and spun off her skin. All bloody muscle and bone, she headed out into the night. Billie Bob was terrified, so he went back to the old conjuring woman who told him he had to paint every window and door in the house blue, except for one. She also told him to splash salt and pepper on her discarded skin. He did both, and when she returned home, she found herself trapped, as the blue doors were a weakness. When she slipped back into her skin, the salt and pepper burned her horribly. In a panic, she crashed through an attic window and turned as bright as a falling star, her body exploding into chunks of flesh that were enjoyed by the swamp gators. Billie Bob was sad. The conjuring woman told him that he should not be. He’d had no wife, only a boo-hag. Once she’d tired of him, she would have brought him to her boo-daddy, who would have eaten his flesh, drank his blood, and gnawed at his bones.

  “But Billie Bob didn’t become chow,” Sam said. “It’s a bit like a vampire story, or even a story about our old concept of witches, bringing their new recruits to Satan. Their version of a boo-daddy.”

  “And what does a boo-hag have to do with Salem?” Martin asked.

  “What about the Gullah culture up here?” Sam asked.

  “We have a few transplants, but—”

  A uniformed officer entered the room, escorting Devin and Rocky. Jenna rose to quickly hug and welcome the newcomers. As it turned out, Rocky knew Detective Gary Martin. They explained what had just happened.

  “A second murder?” Rocky asked. “People are being killed in period costume. Not to profile anyone here, but—”

  “We’re looking for the head of the opposing Wiccan coven now,” Martin made clear.

  Rocky looked at Sam. “Divide and conquer? We’ve been reading the briefs on the murders all the way here.”

  “What do you mean ‘divide and conquer?’” Martin asked.

  “We’ll go off and interview members of the opposing team,” Devin explained. “The more of us talking to people in a more casual manner, the better.”

  “And you think––”

  Rocky leaned forward, “Gary, these are our old haunting grounds. We’ve dealt with murder here before. Bad things, involving people we knew. Out on the streets, we can do a lot of good.”

  Martin nodded. “But I need to be in the loop on everything. I was planning on heading to the mortuary tonight. I want to keep an eye on the place now that it has reopened. Two people are dead either in or near that place. But John Bradbury was no Wiccan.”

  “No, but he supported Tandy Whitehall,” Sam said.

  “How did you know that?” Martin asked.

  “From hanging out in a bar.”

  “We don’t have any viable suspects,” Sam said, “except for Tandy Whitehall. And that’s just because she seems to have a motive. She might also have an alibi.”

  “And unless we get out on the street, we’ll have no idea about anything,” Rocky said. “Hey, this is Salem. And Salem at Samhain and Halloween? That means hope.”

  “I’m pretty sure a little nook or hole-in-the-wall bar is where we’ll find Tandy Whitehall,” Jenna said. “Surrounded by those who’ll protect her.”

  Martin seemed both indignant and worried. “And that could be bad. They could be armed with more than curses. Man kills his wife. Son-in-law kills father-in-law. Junkie kills for drugs. That’s the usual things. But these people around here are fanatics. You don’t think they’ll turn this into a stand-off, do you?”

  “This killer doesn’t want to get caught,” Devin said. “He, or she, or they. And as for my real thoughts, I can’t help but think that it’s not this Tandy Whitehall at all. It’s too obvious. We have to be casual. Walk in like customers. Hey, I still own my great aunt Myna’s cottage. I’m almost a real live local girl. And Rocky is from Marblehead. Let us do this our way. We’ll find what we’re looking for.”

  “I don’t have a lot of choice, now do I?” Gary said, an edge in his voice alluding to the influence of the Krewe of Hunters agents. “I’ll be watching things over at the mortuary. We’ll keep in close contact.”

  “I’ll hang out at the mortuary with Gary,” Jenna said. “You guys handle the streets. How’s that?”

  Sam looked back at her, surprised and annoyed. He didn’t like being away from her in Salem. But she was already up, ready to leave with Gary Martin. Sam stood as well, gently laying an arm on her shoulder.

  She smiled at him. “I’ll be fine.”

  He accepted that, just as he accepted who she was, what she did, how they were different, and how they were alike. He loved her. And part of that involved letting her be who she was. But there was still the matter of the boo-hag.

  “Where are we meeting up? And when?” he asked.

  “Last tour at the mortuary is midnight,” Martin said. “We can do it then. The next two days promise to be long. The day before Halloween, then Halloween itself. We need to catch this killer quickly, before this goes any further.”

  * * * *

  Apparently nothing stopped Halloween.

  The Mayberry Mortuary was packed, the parking lot full. Jenna and Martin arrived in a police car, uniformed officers everywhere. Two at the entry, two by the ticket booth, one man watching the parking lot.

  “I can only imagine the overtime,” Jenna said, looking around.

  “We don’t really have a choice. Salem’s economy would be totally in the trash if we had to start closing down things like this. Winter is cold as a witch’s tit! Whoops, sorry. I’m sure that’s politically incorrect now. But you know what I mean. Christmas is great, New Years, Wiccan holidays, we get people then. Summer is a fantastic time with school kids and families. But we can’t lose Halloween. A lot of the locals only survive the off months thanks to what they make at Halloween.”

  “So the overtime is worth it,” Jenna said.

  But she doubted this killer intended to strike in the same place twice.

  Martin used his phone, checking in with headquarters. Jenna paused in the parking lot, staring out over the cemetery, toward the trees and the edge of the forest. She’d volunteered to come with Martin only because she wanted to get back to the cemetery. She wanted the ghost of John Bradbury to come to her. She also wanted to know why she’d seen a boo-hag heading into the trees moments before she found a woman hanged.

  “Still no sign of Tandy Whitehall,” Martin said, hanging up. “Your coworkers are out, and we have officers trying to reach her. But she’s seen the news by now and has to know we’re looking for her. Probably long gone. I’m going in to do a walk-through. You coming?”

  “I’ll hang out here for a bit. I want to watch some of the people coming and going. I’ll be in soon.”

  He left and she headed over to the busy ticket booth. She saw Micah working, but no Naomi Hardy or Jeannette Mackey. A young woman she’d never seen before sat next to Micah.

  “Everything going all right?” she asked, watching him hand out tickets that were available from a pre-sale online.

  He looked over at her. “We’re sold out. But people get in line for cancellations. We’re always crazy, but tonight is extra rushed.”

  Jenna overheard whispers from the crowd, where some of the visitors were commenting on how they could go to the place where the man’s corpse had been hanged.

  “You’re a creep, Joe,” someone said.

&nb
sp; “Come on, creepy is fun. Afterward, we can go in the woods and find where that other corpse was hanging. The witch. Yeah, man, they hanged a witch.”

  Jenna grimaced at the nonsense. “Best of luck,” she told Micah, moving down the porch steps, smiling and excusing herself as she moved through the crowd. Her smile faded as she made her way to the cemetery. She hated not being truthful with Sam. She loved him so much. He’d gone through the FBI Academy just for her, becoming a crack shot and a proficient agent. True, he talked to ghosts, and it wasn’t a bad thing to be a lawyer who could talk to the dead. He seemed to be really worried about the boo-hag.

  She entered the cemetery.

  Most ghosts didn’t roam around, moaning. Ghosts stayed for a reason, mainly to tell the living what happened to them. She’d seen fathers stay for children, mothers for a family, and children in a sad attempt to ease the pain of their parents. She knew ghosts who’d remained for centuries, hoping to see that history was not repeated. And, yes, she’d met a few in cemeteries. But, usually, they preferred being elsewhere. Tonight, however, one was here, following her. She threaded a path through the tombstones, glancing back to see the glow from the mortuary through the trees. If any of the visitors decided to head into the woods tonight, they’d be in for a surprise. The crime scene from the murder earlier was roped off, two officers watching over it. Finally, she stopped, noting a death’s-head on the stone at her feet.

  She turned.

  John Bradbury faced her, still attired in his Puritan dress.

  “We’re truly trying,” she said to him. “Elyssa tried to repeat what you told her. But we’re not sure we understand.”

  He seemed to waver for a moment, gathering strength. Then he managed a weak smile. “I knew you would come. I tried hard to get someone to see, someone to know. It’s not easy. I knew about you from Lexington House.”

  Jenna nodded. “Tell me exactly what happened.”

  He was a tall, nice-looking man, big enough that it must not have been easy to get his neck into a noose.