False Scent

by Ngaio Marsh

  ‘Me, I suppose,’ Gantry said. ‘I’m a hot-tempered man.’

  ‘Yes, Timmy, dear, you! But only in boiling hot blood with one blind swipe, not really meaning to. And that doesn’t seem to fit the bill at all. One wants a calculating iceberg of a person for this job, doesn’t one?’

  There followed a period of hideous discomfort during which nobody looked at anybody else.

  ‘An idle light of speculation, I’m afraid, Bertie,’ said Marchant. ‘Would you be very kind and bring me a drink?’

  ‘But of course,’ said Bertie, and did so.

  Gantry glanced at Richard and said: ‘Obviously there’s no connection – apart from the shock of Mary’s death having precipitated it – between Charles’s tragedy – and hers.’ Nobody spoke and he added half-angrily: ‘Well, is there! Harkness – you were there.’

  Dr Harkness said quickly: ‘I don’t know what’s in Alleyn’s mind.’

  ‘Where’s that monumental, that superb old ham, the colonel? Why’s he gone missing all of a sudden?’ Gantry demanded. ‘Sorry, Dicky, he’s a friend of yours, isn’t he?’

  ‘He’s … Yes,’ Richard said after a long pause. ‘He is. I think he’s with Alleyn.’

  ‘Not,’ Marchant coolly remarked, ‘under arrest, one trusts.’

  ‘I believe not,’ Richard said. He turned his back on Marchant and sat beside Anelida on the sofa.

  ‘Oh, lud!’ Bertie sighed, ‘how wearing has been this long, long day and how frightened in a vague sort of way I continue to feel. Never mind. Toujours l’audace.’

  The handle of the door into the hall was heard to turn. Everybody looked up. Florence walked round the leather screen. ‘If you’ll just wait, miss,’ the constable said and retired. Philpott cleared his throat.

  Richard said: ‘Come in, Floy. Come and sit down.’

  She glared stonily at him, walked into the farthest corner of the room and sat on the smallest chair. Pinky looked as if she’d like to say something friendly to her, but the impulse came to nothing and a heavy silence again fell upon the company.

  It was broken by the same sound and a heavier tread. Bertie half-rose from his seat, gave a little cry of frustration and sank back again as Colonel Warrender made his entry, very erect and looking at no one in particular.

  ‘We were just talking about you,’ said Bertie fretfully.

  Richard stood up. ‘Come and join us,’ he said, and pushed a chair towards the sofa.

  ‘Thank you, old boy,’ Warrender said awkwardly, and did so.

  Anelida leant towards him and after a moment’s hesitation put her hand on his knee. ‘I intend,’ she said under her breath, ‘to bully Richard into marrying me. Will you be on my side and give us your blessing?’

  He drew his brows together and stared at her. He made an unsuccessful attempt to speak, hit her hand painfully hard with his own and ejaculated: ‘Clumsy ass. Hurt you, isn’t it? Ah – bless you.’

  ‘OK,’ said Anelida and looked at Richard. ‘Now, you see, darling, you’re sunk.’

  There was a sound of masculine voices in the hall, Pinky said: ‘Oh, dear!’ and Gantry: ‘Ah, for God’s sake!’ Marchant finished his drink quickly and PC Philpott rose to his feet. So, after a mulish second or two, did Florence.

  This time it was Alleyn who came round the leather screen.

  There was only one place in the room from which he could take them all in at one glance, and that was the hearthrug. Accordingly, he went to it and stood there like the central figure in some ill-assembled conversation piece.

  ‘I’m sorry,’ he said, ‘to have kept you hanging about. It was unavoidable and it won’t be for much longer. Until a short time ago you were still, all of you, persons of importance. From the police point of view, I mean, of course. It was through you that we hoped to assemble the fragments and fit them into their pattern. The pattern is now complete and our uncomfortable association draws to its end. Tomorrow there will be an inquest and you will be required, most of you, to appear at it. The coroner’s jury will hear your evidence and mine and one can only guess at what they will make of it. But you have all become too far involved for me to use any sort of evasion. Already some of you are suspecting others who are innocent. In my opinion this is one of those cases where the truth, at any cost, is less damaging in the long run, to vague, festering conjecture. For you all must know,’ Alleyn went on, ‘you must know even if you won’t acknowledge it …’ his glance rested fleetingly on Richard –’that this has been a case of homicide.’

  He waited. Gantry said: ‘I don’t accept that,’ but without much conviction.

  ‘You will, I think, when I tell you that the Home Office analyst has found a trace of Slaypest in the bulb of the scent spray.’

  ‘Oh,’ Gantry said faintly, as if Alleyn had made some quite unimportant remark. ‘I see. That’s different.’

  ‘It’s conclusive. It clears up all the extraneous matter. The professional rows, the threats that you were all so reluctant to admit, the evasions and half-lies. The personal bickerings and antagonisms. They are all tidied away by this single fact.’

  Marchant, whose hands were joined in front of his face, lifted his gaze for a moment to Alleyn. ‘You are not making yourself particularly clear,’ he said.

  ‘I hope to do so. This one piece of evidence explains a number of indisputable facts. Here they are. The scent spray was harmless when Colonel Warrender used it on Mrs Templeton. At some time before she went up to her room with Mr Dakers, enough Slaypest was transferred to the scent spray to kill her. At some time after she was killed the scent spray was emptied and washed out and the remaining scent from the original bottle was poured into it I think there were two, possibly three, persons in the house at that time who could have committed these actions. They are all familiar with the room and its appointments and surroundings. The presence of any one of them in her room would, under normal circumstances, have been unremarkable.’

  A voice from outside the group violently demanded: ‘Where is she? Why hasn’t she been brought down to face it?’ And then, with satisfaction: ‘Has she been taken away? Has she?’

  Florence advanced into the light.

  Richard cried out: ‘What do you mean, Floy? Be quiet! You don’t know what you’re saying.’

  ‘Where’s Clara Plumtree?’

  ‘She will appear,’ Alleyn said, ‘if the occasion arises. And you had better be quiet, you know.’

  For a moment she looked as if she would defy him, but seemed to change her mind. She stood where she was and watched him.

  ‘There is, however,’ Alleyn said, ‘a third circumstance. You will all remember that after the speeches you waited down here for Mrs Templeton to take her part in the ceremony of opening the presents. Mr Dakers had left her in her room, passing Florence and Mrs Plumtree on his way downstairs. Mrs Plumtree had then gone to her room, leaving Florence alone on the landing. Mr Templeton went from here into the hall. From the foot of the stairs he saw Florence on the landing and called up to her that you were all waiting for her mistress. He then rejoined the party here. A minutes or so later Florence ran downstairs into this room and, after a certain amount of confused ejaculation, made it known that her mistress was desperately ill. Mr Templeton rushed upstairs. Dr Harkness, after a short delay, followed. With Florence, Colonel Warrender and Mr Gantry hard on his heels.

  ‘They found Mrs Templeton lying dead on the floor of her room. The overturned tin of Slaypest lay close beside her right hand. The scent spray was on the dressing table. That has been agreed to, but I am going to ask for a further confirmation.’

  Dr Harkness said: ‘Certainly. That’s how it was.’

  ‘You’d make a statement on oath to that effect?’

  ‘I would.’ He looked at Gantry and Warrender. ‘Wouldn’t you?’

  They said uneasily that they would.

  ‘Well, Florence?’ Alleyn asked.

  ‘I said before: I didn’t notice. I was too upset.’

  �
��But you don’t disagree?’

  ‘No,’ she admitted grudgingly.

  ‘Very well. Now, you will see, I think, all of you, that the whole case turns on this one circumstance. The tin of Slaypest on the floor. The scent spray and the empty bottle on the dressing-table.’

  ‘Isn’t it awful?’ Pinky said suddenly. ‘I know it must be childishly obvious, but I just can’t bring myself to think.’

  ‘Can’t you?’ Gantry said grimly. ‘I can.’

  ‘Not having been involved in the subsequent discussions,’ Marchant remarked to nobody in particular, ‘the nicer points must be allowed, I hope, to escape me.’

  ‘Let me bring you up to date,’ Alleyn said. ‘There was poison in the scent spray. Nobody, I imagine, will suggest that she put it there herself or that she used the Slaypest on herself. The sound of a spray in action was heard a minute or so before she died. By Ninn – Mrs Plumtree.’

  ‘So she says,’ Florence interjected.

  Alleyn went on steadily: ‘Mrs Templeton was alone in her room. Very well. Having used the lethal scent spray, did she replace it on the dressing-table and put the Slaypest on the floor?’

  Florence said: ‘What did I tell you? Clara Plumtree! After I went. Say she did hear the thing being used. She done it! She went in and fixed it all. What did I tell you!’

  ‘On your own evidence,’ Alleyn said, ‘and on that of Mr Templeton, you were on the landing when he called up to you. You returned at once to the bedroom. Do you think that in those few seconds, Mrs Plumtree, who moves very slowly, could have darted into the room, rearranged the scent spray, and Slaypest, darted out again and got out of sight?’

  ‘She could’ve hid in the dressing-room. Like she done afterwards when she wouldn’t let me in.’

  Alleyn said: ‘I’m afraid that won’t quite do. Which brings me to the fourth point. I won’t go into all the pathological details, but there is clear evidence that the spray was used in the normal way – at about arm’s length and without undue pressure – and then at very close quarters and with maximum pressure. Her murderer, finding she was not dead, made sure that she would die. Mrs Plumtree would certainly not have had an opportunity to do it. There is only one person who could have committed that act and the three other necessary acts as well. Only one.’

  ‘Florence!’ Gantry cried out.

  ‘No. Not Florence. Charles Templeton.’

  IV

  The drawing-room now seemed strangely deserted. Pinky Cavendish, Montague Marchant, Dr Harkness, Bertie Saracen and Timon Gantry had all gone home. Charles Templeton’s body had been carried away. Old Ninn was in her bed. Florence had retired to adjust her resentments and nurse her heartache as best she could. Mr Fox was busy with routine arrangements. Only Alleyn, Richard, Anelida and Warrender remained in the drawing-room.

  Richard said: ‘Ever since you told me and all through that last scene with them, I’ve been trying to see why. Why should he, having put up with so much for so long, do such a monstrous thing? It’s – it’s … I’ve always thought him – he was so …’ Richard drove his fingers through his hair. ‘Maurice! You knew him. Better than any of us.’

  Warrender, looking at his clasped hands, muttered unhappily: ‘What’s that word they use nowadays? Perfectionist?’

  ‘But what do you … Yes. All right. He was a perfectionist, I suppose.’

  ‘Couldn’t stand anything that wasn’t up to his own standard. Look at those T’ang figures. Little lady with a flute and little lady with a lute. Lovely little creatures. Prized them more than anything else in the house. But when the parlourmaid or somebody knocked the end off one of the little lute pegs, he wouldn’t have it. Gave it to me, by God!’ said Warrender.

  Alleyn said: ‘That’s illuminating, isn’t it?’

  ‘But it’s one thing to feel like that and another to … No!’ Richard exclaimed. ‘It’s a nightmare. You can’t reduce it to that size. It’s irreducible. Monstrous!’

  ‘It’s happened,’ Warrender said flatly.

  ‘Mr Alleyn,’ Anelida suggested, ‘would you tell us what you think? Would you take the things that led up to it out of their background and put them in order for us? Might that help, do you think, Richard?’

  ‘I think it might, darling. If anything can.’

  ‘Well,’ Alleyn said, ‘shall I try? First of all, then, there’s her personal history. There are the bouts of temperament that have increased in severity and frequency: to such a degree that they have begun to suggest a serious mental condition. You’re all agreed about that, aren’t you? Colonel Warrender?’

  ‘I suppose so. Yes.’

  ‘What was she like thirty years ago, when he married her?’

  Warrender looked at Richard. ‘Enchanting. Law unto herself. Gay. Lovely.’ He raised his hand and let it fall. ‘Ah, well! There it is. Never mind.’

  ‘Different? From these days?’ Alleyn pursued.

  ‘My God, yes!’

  ‘So the musician’s lute was broken? The perfect had become imperfect?’

  ‘Very well. Go on.’

  ‘May we think back to yesterday, the day of the party? You must tell me if I’m all to blazes but this is how I see it. My reading, by the way, is pieced together from the statements Fox and I have collected from all of you and from the servants who, true to form, knew more than any of you might suppose. Things began to go wrong quite early, didn’t they? Wasn’t it in the morning that she learnt for the first time that her …’ He hesitated for a moment.

  ‘It’s all right,’ Richard said. ‘Anelida knows. Everything. She says she doesn’t mind.’

  ‘Why on earth should I?’ Anelida asked of the world at large. ‘We’re not living in the reign of King Lear. In any case, Mr Alleyn’s talking about Husbandry in Heaven and me and how your mamma didn’t much fancy the idea that you’d taken up with me and still less the idea of my reading for the part.’

  ‘Which she’d assumed was written for her. That’s it,’ Alleyn said. ‘That exacerbated a sense of being the victim of a conspiracy, which was set up by the scene in which she learnt that Miss Cavendish was to play the lead in another comedy and that Gantry and Saracen were in the “plot.” She was a jealous, ageing actress, abnormally possessive.’

  ‘But not always,’ Richard protested. ‘Not anything like always.’

  ‘Getting more so,’ Warrender muttered.

  ‘Exactly. And perhaps because of that her husband, the perfectionist, may have transferred his ruling preoccupation from her to the young man whom he believed to be his son and on whom she was loath to relinquish her hold.’

  ‘But did he?’ Richard cried out. ‘Maurice, did he think that?’

  ‘She’d – let him assume it.’

  ‘I see. And in those days, as you’ve told us, he believed everything she said. I understand, now,’ Richard said to Alleyn, ‘why you agreed that there was no need to tell him about me. He already knew, didn’t he?’

  ‘She herself,’ Alleyn went on, ‘told Colonel Warrender, after the flare-up in the conservatory, that she had disillusioned her husband.’

  ‘Did Charles,’ Richard asked Warrender, ‘say anything to you, afterwards? Did he?’

  ‘When we were boxed up together in the study. He hated my being there. It came out. He was …’ Warrender seemed to search for an appropriate phrase. ‘I’ve never seen a man so angry,’ he said at last. ‘So sick with anger.’

  ‘Oh, God! ‘Richard said.

  ‘And then,’ Alleyn continued, ‘there was the row over the scent. He asked her not to use it. She made you, Colonel Warrender, spray it lavishly over her, in her husband’s presence. You left the room. You felt, didn’t you, that there was going to be a scene?’

  ‘I shouldn’t have done it. She could always make me do what she would,’ Warrender said. ‘I knew at the time but – isn’t it?’

  ‘Never mind,’ Richard said, and to Alleyn: ‘Was it then she told him?’

  ‘I think it was at the climax of this
scene. As he went out she was heard to shout after him: “Which only shows how wrong you were. You can get out whenever you like, my friend, and the sooner the better.” She was not, as the hearer supposed, giving a servant the sack: she was giving it to him.’

  ‘And half an hour later,’ Richard said to Anelida, ‘there he was – standing beside her, shaking hands with her friends. I thought, when I was telephoning, he looked ill. I told you. He wouldn’t speak.’

  ‘And then,’ Anelida said to Alleyn, ‘came the scene in the conservatory.’

  ‘Exactly. And, you see, he knew she had the power to make good her threats. Hard on the heels of the blow she had dealt him, he had to stand by and listen to her saying what she did say to all of you.’

  ‘Richard,’ Anelida said, ‘can you see? He’d loved her and he was watching her disintegrate. Anything to stop it!’

  ‘I can see, darling, but I can’t accept it. Not that.’

  ‘To put it very brutally,’ Alleyn said, ‘the treasured possession was not only hideously flawed, but possessed of a devil. She reeked of the scent he’d asked her not to wear. I don’t think it would be too much to say that at that moment it symbolized for him the full horror of his feeling for her.’

  ‘D’you mean it was then that he did it?’ Warrender asked.

  ‘Yes. Then. It must have been then. During all the movement and excitement just before the speeches. He went upstairs, emptied out some of the scent and filled up the atomiser with Slaypest. He returned during the speeches. As she left the drawing-room she came face to face with him. Florence heard him ask her not to use the scent.’

  Warrender gave an exclamation. ‘Yes?’ Alleyn asked.

  ‘Good God, d’you mean it was a – kind of gamble? If she did as he’d asked – like those gambles on suicide? Fella with a revolver. Half-live, half-blank cartridges.’

  ‘Exactly that. Only this time it was a gamble in murder.’ Alleyn looked at them. ‘It may seem strange that I tell you in detail so much that is painful and shocking. I do so because I believe that it is less damaging in the long run to know rather than to doubt.’