Double Dare: A Fake Fiancee MMF Romance

by Cassandra Dee

  I could see why. The little girl was stuck on a huge fuck rod, it was pushed all the way in her now, that sweet, heavenly vise accepting him all. The female was literally lifted in the air a bit, like a pig on a pole, unable to move, completely fucked.

  “Ohhh!” she moaned again, face a visage of pain. “It stings.”

  And this time, I swooped in. Catching her mouth with mine, I soothed her with words, hands stroking her breasts as Mason held still in her pussy, letting her adjust.

  “Slow, baby girl,” I chanted, the low growl a rumble in my throat. “Slow baby girl, it gets better, we promise.”

  She squirmed again, still unable to focus on anything but the sweet, stinging pain in her cunt.

  “Unnh!” Katie moaned, “It hurts!”

  But this time Mason came to the rescue.

  “Here baby girl,” he growled, reaching under her. “Daddy will stroke you, does that make it better?”

  And the female let out a yelp then, jerking a bit, because Mace had just touched her button. Oh yeah, his fingers ran all over that stiff clit, massaging, rubbing as his pole burrowed in from the back, and that did the trick.

  “Ohhh,” Katie cried out again, but this time it was an “oh” of ecstasy blended with agony. “Ohhh,” she breathed again.

  Mace chuckled behind her.

  “That’s right,” he grunted. “All girls like a little finger when they get fucked for the first time. Do it,” he commanded me, leaning back once more. “Take over and crank that pussy up.”

  And I was only too happy to oblige. Slipping one hand beneath Katie’s torso, I let my fingers trail over her bud, stroking it, pinching it as the girl cried out.

  “Unnh, unnh, unnh!”

  But even more, Mace took up the pace again, and I could literally feel his pole grazing against my hand as he entered her slick sheath. Oh yeah, juices oozed everywhere now, the female creaming as that dick slid in and out. But even more, it was the fact that I was touching another man’s cock as it fucked a woman. Oh shit, it was arousing. I looked up to meet my lover’s eyes, the blue clashing on blue, and he was just as aroused as me, slipping again and again into Katie’s hot insides as I alternately massaged his shaft and her slick cunt.

  “Fuck,” he grunted. “Fuck, fuck, fuck.”

  And maybe it was Katie’s tight pussy, or maybe it was that he was fucking a woman with a man right there with him, but Mace burst without warning.

  “Awww SHIT!” he roared, pushing forwards one last time, almost bouncing off the brunette’s ass cheeks, it was so rough and forceful. “Shit!”

  The intense drive, the crazy rhythm, pushed our girl over the edge too because at that very moment, her pussy shuddered and then exploded, creaming all over my hand.

  “Mmmm!” the girl cried out, head back and eyes closed, tits swaying with lust as shudders overcame that lush form. “Unnh!”

  But it was so right. There was nothing better than seeing my male lover come in our girl, emptying his jism into her, balls pulsing and quivering as the seed spurted out. Mason roared again and again, the cries ringing in my ears, blending with the soft mewls and ecstatic shrieks of a woman experiencing her first orgasm.

  I almost burst myself, my hand going up and down my stiff shaft, juicing the length with everything I had. But Mace stopped me, the sheer look in his eyes made my hand halt. Because without any warning, he pulled out mid-spurt, baby batter creaming all over Katie’s back and gestured me to get on all fours again.

  “Your turn,” was all he said.

  And holy shit, but the blood rushed to my shaft then, my own ten inches spring hard, hot and hungry out. I should have been afraid, I’d just seen what he’d done to the girl, the red circle at the base of his dick, how Katie had barely been able to fit him. It’d be even harder for me, my back hole was so small, so tight and resistant, just as virginal.

  But the look in Mason’s eyes is what made the difference. He wanted me, his dick was wet with our girl’s juices, and even now, Katie turned to kiss me, to whisper so that only I could hear.

  “It’s amazing Derek,” she murmured, our lips grazing one another, her body still wracked with the aftermath of her first orgasm. “I promise you’ll love it.”

  And cocooned in the support of both my lovers, I could only give in. After all, the impossible had happened. We were a trio that was never supposed to be, two business partners hooking up with a naïve virgin.

  But now, it didn’t seem so wrong. So what if there was this dumbass will? So what if this was supposed to be pretend? Suddenly things were alright, and my doubts fell away like a sheet of ice cracking off a glacier. With a crash into the ocean, they were gone and I was their plaything. Yes, I wasn’t just a toy for Mason or a fuckrod for Katie. I belonged to them both, and they would guide me through my first time.

  CHAPTER SEVEN

  Mason

  As I watched, Derek shot me an intense look, kissing Katie once more before getting on his hands and knees. Shit, this was so unreal. I just took the virginity of a teen girl, the proof of her hymen a red stain on my dick. And yet now, I was gonna fuck a man for the first time? Not just that, but my best friend, my buddy since college?

  Because never in a million years would I have dreamed that Derek was into this. Mofo is a blonde giant, a Brad Pitt look-alike, except even better. The blue eyes are more intense, the charisma rolling off him in waves, making women swoon and men cower. Yeah, this guy is blessed and then some.

  But it’s not just that Derek’s a charmer personality-wise. It’s also that body, the huge, ripped chest, the thick thighs and oh fuck, that ass. Because his brown pucker was tiny, winking at me from in back, and I wanted to taste, to feel it squeeze my shaft. Oh god, my lover was gonna to push that ass onto my dick so that I broke in both my girl and boy at once.

  “Give it to me,” he growled, turning his head to shoot me a glance. Shit, I almost collapsed, the Viking was so gorgeous in this position. There’s something strangely arousing about a powerful, ripped alpha male in a subservient pose, crouched over, displaying his asshole, ready to be fucked. It only made me want him more, it only made my dick grow hard with lust once more, seed boiling in my balls.

  “I will,” I ground out, never breaking eye contact. “Trust me, you’re gonna be drilled deep.”

  But never bet against our best girl because Katie was on her knees in a flash, kneeling by our poised forms.

  “Mason,” she said sweetly. “Let me help you.”

  And despite the fact that my cock glistened with her pussy juice, she reached down her slit and scooped up the liquid pooling at the base.

  “Here,” she cooed, wiping it onto my stiff shaft. “This will help it go in easier. And some for you too,” she added, massaging her hand all over Derek’s butthole. His ass clamped reflexively, the pleats going tight. But Katie merely giggled.

  “Big guy, you have to relax,” she assured him. “Trust me, I was just there and it’s so much better if you let go.”

  My friend took a deep breath, summoning his Zen, and sure enough, that dark star unclenched a bit. But that wasn’t even near enough, so Katie leaned forward again, meeting my eye.

  “Let me play with him a little,” she cooed persuasively. “Let me play with his butt to stretch it out, it’ll be easier that way.”

  I almost pushed her out of the way, I was so intent on being inside my male lover. But that was no way to treat an anal virgin, so decency took over and I sank back onto my heels, rod almost painful as it bobbed in the air.

  “Fine,” I grunted. “But be fast, this stiffie ain’t gonna hold out much longer.”

  Katie winked at me.

  “I’ll just be a sec,” she murmured, and with that, the brunette dove right into Derek’s ass. Holy shit, but virgins are the dirtiest of them all because Katie totally went for it. The girl had her tongue all over that rim, licking, sampling, and making the man moan.

  “Unnnh,” Derek ground out, head lolling as Katie tongued his
butt. “Unnnh, god.”

  She giggled above him.

  “But I haven’t pushed in yet. Ready? Three … two … one.”

  And oh shit, but she wormed a finger in there. The female’s got small hands so it wasn’t a massive penetration by any means, but lo and behold, I watched eyes shocked as her pinkie slid in, enveloped by that tightness.

  “Feel good, big boy?” she cooed, nibbling at Derek’s ass as she pushed a little deeper. “Feel good?”

  A series of harsh pants were all that that escaped my lover’s lips.

  “I guess it is,” she giggled, and with that, slid another finger in with the first. Fuck, the sight was arousing. His butt hole resisted, clenching hard, but it was too late because Katie already had a foothold. Slowly, she stuffed him with the second digit before wiggling them both in his bottom, making the big man jerk.

  “Feels good, hmmm?” she murmured sweetly. “Feels good to get your butt stretched.”

  There was no sound from Derek except harsh pants, but I knew how I felt. My dick was gonna explode watching this nasty scene, the dirtiness unbelievable, yet so fucking arousing.

  “Hurry,” I panted myself. “This boner ain’t gonna last much longer.”

  Katie show me a knowing look, breasts swaying as she fingered Derek’s ass.

  “Don’t worry, I’m almost done,” she cooed. “Almost there.”

  And lo and behold, the girl started a series of finger exercises in his backside. She went in and out a bit, pushing deep before pulling out, and then wiggling in circles before scissoring within that darkness, making the blond huff and moan with ecstasy.

  “Oh yeah, you’re gonna do just fine,” she assured him. “You’ll be just fine.”

  And with that, Katie popped her digits out, examining them under the light, before lifting them into her mouth and sucking wickedly. Fuck, this was one fucked-up virgin.

  “Tastes fantastic,” she murmured coyly, shooting me another glance. “I think you’re gonna like it in there, Mason.”

  And the time was now. I couldn’t hold back anymore. I had to be in my lover, I had to feel those hot ass walls clamp around me, sucking me dry. So in a flash, I was behind Derek once more, gripping that muscular ass.

  “This is gonna be rough big guy, but I’ll make it up to you, I promise,” I rasped hoarsely. And with one mighty thrust, I breached Derek’s anus. Oh yeah, there was no mercy for the male. There was no slow push, no gentle slide. It was one fast push, and he roared with agony.

  “Fuck you!” Derek cried out, ass shaking on my dick, trying to get away. “Fuck you!”

  But Katie wasn’t having it. She caught his mouth with hers, much like Derek had done for her earlier.

  “Calm,” she soothed. “Calm it’ll feel good after a while, I promise.”

  The Viking was almost unable to speak, but the big form subsided a bit, still shaking.

  “Fuck,” he grunted hoarsely again, breathing deep. That ass quivered on my dick, but at least he was no longer thrashing around, no longer struggling like a slippery fish. The male held still, just letting his bottom absorb.

  “That’s right,” I ground out, caressing one flank with a roughened hand. “That’s right, feel it, feel it.”

  This wasn’t exactly the time to sound like Vanilla Ice, but still, it was the best I could do given the circumstances. Because holy shit, being in a man’s ass blew my mind. It was like a woman, but also different, deliciously so. His ass was stronger than a pussy, the walls clamping tight, hot and dry. Plus, there seemed to be more acreage in there. A lot of times when I fuck women, my dick pushes up against cervix, there’s just no room. But Derek is a big man and his rectum was long, I was seated fully inside him, balls to the wall no problem.

  So I grunted again, this time grinding a little.

  “Feel better?” I rasped, holding his hips. “Feel better?”

  Katie was still kissing him, breathing words of assurance against his lips.

  “Oh yeah, he’s much better,” she assured me, turning away for an instant. “Go for it, push it in.”

  And with that, I pulled my dick back, edging out slowly. Shit, the pole glistened wetly, there was so much ass sweat and pussy cum mixed on it, veins pulsing as his rim gripped me. But again, when it comes to men I’m no shy pansy, so I wasn’t gonna do some slow fuck. I was gonna ream him hard, make him take it, and with another whoof, I slammed back inside.

  “FUUUUCK!” roared Derek, hips jerking, bucking involuntarily.

  “Shh, cowboy,” I soothed. “Shh, just let us make you feel good.”

  And with that, Katie and I went for it. I began drilling him, smooth and hard in back, deep and so intense while the girl kissed and soothed him, murmuring sweet nothings the whole time.

  “You’re gonna be okay,” she whispered against his ear before licking at the lobe. “You’re gonna be okay, it’ll feel good soon,” she promised.

  And after a few more draws, oh yeah, Derek began going with it. His hips rocked in rhythm with mine, a sweat breaking out across that broad back, and he kissed Katie back, their mouths sealed as I reamed him.

  “Ohhh,” he ground out, chest heaving. “Fuuuuck.”

  But by now, Katie had wormed her way back onto all fours so that her ass faced me as well, legs split, pink slit gleaming. And it wasn’t part of the plan, it wasn’t what I intended, but oh shit, I’m a man who can’t say no. Because on the next stroke I pulled out all the way and shifted to kneel behind the female.

  “Derek,” I rasped harshly. “I’m just gonna get my dick wet in her before coming back to you. I will come back to you, I swear.”

  And with that, I fucked into Katie’s sweet slit. Oh yeah, it was different but just as good. She was tight as a virgin, that glove fitting me like a second skin, wet and pulsing. I pushed in a couple times, until my cock glistened with her goodness before moving back and fucking once more into my boy.

  “Unnnh!” he roared as Katie mewled wildly. “Unnnh!”

  And did I stop then? No, fuck no. I rotated between fucking my girl and fucking my guy, doing a couple strokes in one before moving to the other. I’d wet my dick in Katie’s pussy, giving her the deep drill, before moving onto my boy, pushing into that nasty ass. And shit, it practically tore me apart because after a couple minutes, I couldn’t hold back. Derek, sensing the coming insanity, looked back at me over a massive shoulder.

  “Into her,” he growled between rough pants. “Into her.”

  I knew what he meant. A virgin pussy deserves hot cum, so shutting my eyes, I gave in and let go. My dick spurted wildly into her creamy chamber, semen blasting that vaginal passage again and again, the hot white devastatingly virile.

  “Mmm!” she cried out, head dropping between her hands to rest on the floor. “Mmmm,” the girl moaned again, big boobs dragging.

  But I was determined to share. Katie was getting the good stuff, for sure, the first few spurts. But there’s plenty of sperm to share and after a few more heavy blasts, I pulled back and aimed my dickhead right at Derek’s hole.

  “Fuck!” I exclaimed as my hose pulsed, dousing the dark star with white hot jizz. “Fuck!”

  And Derek loved it. Oh yeah, he’s a whore for man seed, and the blond held perfectly still as I spurted over his private space, cum coating his butt with a translucent white film.

  “Mmm,” he ground out, trembling with ecstasy. “Mmmm.”

  And after a couple more powerful blasts, I was done for. My cock finished itself, balls drained dry, everything gone to my lovers. I literally collapsed then, glutes tingling, thighs worn out from the strain.

  “Fuck,” I gasped, “fuck fuck fuck.”

  And both Katie and Derek crawled to me, taking turns kissing me, stroking my pecs and abs, soothing words melting over my body.

  “That was wonderful,” my girl cooed. “I’m full of it now.”

  Derek grunted.

  “And so am I,” he muttered between wet kisses to my chest. “Your jizz is in me
too.”

  My eyes flew open. Holy shit, had my sperm really seeped into his body, dripping into that dark star? I guess it was possible. I’d blasted his butt with a gallon of the good stuff, and it was absolutely possible that some had edged its way inside. He shot me a knowing glance.

  “Oh yeah, it’s in me,” he confirmed, voice raspy. “I can feel it,” he confirmed once more before sucking on my nipple, making me moan. “That was fucking awesome.”

  And I didn’t answer, consumed with lust for my lovers, blown away by the meaning of this all. Because I’d de-virginized two people. I’d bust through Katie’s hymen, while also owning Derek’s ass cherry. It was dirty, nasty, and unbelievable, but also exactly what I wanted.

  Because there was nothing better than this. I was worshipping the male of my dreams while also sampling a curvaceous, inspiring female, one who’d been very much a part of the session despite her own inexperience. So given the weird circumstances, the kidnapping and the fake fiancée, what could be better? This was right, no question. Katie was right for us, I was right for her, and Derek was the final leg of our triangle, closing the precious arc. We were perfect together … for the moment at least.

  CHAPTER EIGHT

  Katie

  We’ve settled into a strange state of things. On the one hand, I’m Mason’s fake fiancée, supposedly pregnant with his baby. It’s not hard to convince people that I’m pregnant, given that I’m a big girl.

  “She’s five months along!” ran one headline.

  “Six and counting,” ran another.

  “DELIVERY EXPECTED ANY DAY NOW!” screamed the last.

  So yeah, life’s taken a left turn. I’m still me, curvy, sassy Katie, the one with brown curls and a big smile, but the difference is that my smile is real now, there’s so much more bounce and spring to my step because with Mason and Derek’s support, I feel like I can’t fail. I feel like the world’s at my fingertips, that anything can happen, and that in fact, it already has.

  But sometimes I get worried. We were shopping the other day, the three of us, and I turned to Derek and Mason with a small smile.