Best Friend's Ex Box Set (A Second Chance Romance Love Story)

by Claire Adams

  Chapter 28

  Elana

  I got up early and made the promised apple pancakes in the morning with a special side of ham that I knew he loved. Ollie was in heaven, and he couldn’t stop talking about the pancakes, even after the seventh one. I just sat back and laughed, feeling more than proud that I had created something that he loved that much. One thing about knowing Ollie for as long as I had, I knew when he was lying, and he definitely wasn’t lying about the pancakes. The smell of the apples and the breakfast in front of me, coupled with sitting closely to Ollie made me feel something I hadn’t felt in a really long time. I finally felt like I was exactly where I was supposed to be. It was the strangest feeling, especially since it had been gone for years. It felt perfectly natural to have Ollie at my breakfast table with me.

  The last few days had been absolutely amazing. We had done so many things that I never thought I would actually get the chance to do with someone. It was this huge moment in my life, something I just couldn’t stop beaming about, and the best thing was, I was pretty sure Ollie was feeling it, too. I’d had a crush on Ollie since I was in college, never saying anything to anyone because he was with Lillie. But now that things were different and we had given ourselves permission to be together, I could feel my crush expanding into full-blown love. When I looked at Ollie, I didn’t just see this beautiful man. I saw a friend, a confidant, a lover. I saw the future when I looked at him, one filled with all the things I had wanted my whole life from a partner. “Partner” was the operative word there. I felt like Ollie was truly a partner to me, someone that stood beside me, not in front of me or behind me, but side by side, tackling the world and all its fucked-up mess together. It sure made me feel a lot braver knowing he was by my side.

  Later that day, we took showers and got dressed, heading over to my mom’s like I always did to watch this week’s game and enjoy dinner with her. Of course, that wasn’t all that it was going to be, but that was the best part about it. After slaving away helping her around the house with whatever it was that she wanted done, we would get to drink some beers and relax, laughing and talking in front of the football game. Ollie was really excited, and it made me laugh how gung-ho he was to see my mother.

  Just as I had predicted, my mother instantly put us to work, asking Ollie to take care of the things that she “couldn’t reach.” He was all about it, so out he went to clean the gutters and fix the leaning cabinet in the kitchen, smiling the entire time. I seriously couldn’t have asked for a better man to bring to my mother’s house. He loved being there, and he couldn’t wait to find out what she was cooking for dinner. It was just like him to be in it for the food. I shook my head and laughed as he winked at me before heading outside, decked out in pink gardening gloves and my mother’s floppy sun hat.

  While he was outside, my mom put me to work pulling down all the cookbooks she would need for Thanksgiving. It was over a month away still, but this woman was like the queen of Thanksgiving dinners, even when it was just the two of us. I could see her staring at me from the corner of my eye, and I knew she had some kind of question to ask.

  “What is it, Mom?”

  “Oh, nothing,” she said, taking the stack of books from me. “I was just curious about what was going on between you and Ollie, that’s all.”

  “Well, I guess I can tell you now,” I said, taking a deep breath. “We’re dating.”

  She squealed excitedly, putting down the books and pulling me into a bear hug. “That is the best news I’ve gotten in, like, ten years. I’m so excited about this. I knew there was something between the two of you. I just couldn’t put my finger on it. He’s so wonderful, Elana.”

  “Mom,” I said, laughing. “Calm down, please. I don’t want you to jinx it.”

  “Okay, okay,” she said, squealing again. “I’m going to go put these books in the dining room.”

  I shook my head, watching my mom walk into the other room. I looked up as Ollie came back into the house and headed down the hallway to check on the drip in the bathroom sink. I trailed quickly behind him, not wanting my mom to notice that I’d disappeared. I just wanted a minute alone with him before we were bombarded by my love-crazy mother again. Ollie pulled out a tool of some sort and started to tighten a pipe under the sink. I looked down at him, and he pulled his head out.

  “What’s up?”

  “I just wanted to say I was sorry,” I replied. “I mean, you come over here to relax on a Sunday, and my mother puts you to work like you’re her private handyman.”

  “Hey,” he said, standing up and putting his arms around me. “I don’t mind this at all. In fact, when I get to do stuff like this, it makes me feel good. It makes me feel handy.”

  “Oh yeah?” I looked him in the eye and bit my lip. “I think that you’re very handy.”

  “Is that right?”

  “Yep,” I replied, wrapping my arms around his neck. “I actually enjoy feeling that handiness all over me on a regular basis.”

  “Well, I’ll have to make sure I do that more often.” He chuckled.

  We pressed our lips together, kissing deeply as I pulled him backward into the hall. I looked up and down, making sure my mother wasn’t around and pulled him by the shirt collar into the room across from us, my old bedroom. We made out in there for about twenty minutes before deciding it was probably time to get back to my mother before she became suspicious, if she wasn’t already. The night went off great, dinner being awesome as always, and Ollie and my mother ranting and raving over the football game.

  When it was time to go, we hugged my mother goodbye and jumped into the car. Ollie talked the entire way home about my mother’s ravioli, and I laughed, wondering how someone could love food as much as he did and still be in amazing shape. We pulled up in front of my house, and I took in a deep breath, not wanting the weekend to be over. He got out of the car and came around to my door, reaching his hand down and helping me out. I tripped over the curb, and he caught me in his arms, holding me tightly for a moment before letting go and taking my hand. We walked slowly up to the top of the stairs, and I waited for him to kiss my forehead and leave. This time, though, he went straight for my lips, pleasantly surprising me.

  We had kissed a lot that weekend, but this one was emotional and passionate, like there were words being said without speaking. I closed my eyes and leaned into him, feeling every bit of his emotional connection and giving it back to him tenfold. All I could think was how much I didn’t want to be without him. How my home had really felt like a home with him in it, and how falling asleep without his arms around me sounded pretty much impossible. I didn’t want to let him go. I wanted him to stay right there with me all night.

  At the same time, though, I had to remind myself that we were trying to take it slow. He had been very adamant about making sure that we took our time, not rushing into anything so that we were able to handle any speed bump that came our way. The thing was, I couldn’t imagine anything at that point that could throw me off his course. Maybe it was the fact that I had gone several days without feeling the depression and guilt that I had lived with for so many years, but at that moment, I didn’t give a shit about going slow. To hell with it.

  I pulled away, kissing him on the nose and then leaning forward, pursing my lips by his ear. I breathed in the smell of his cologne, feeling that familiar feeling in my chest. There was no way I could do without this man when I went to bed.

  “Stay with me tonight,” I whispered. “Just stay and sleep next to me. I know we’re taking things slowly, but I’m not ready to give up on this weekend. I don’t want to go to bed without you next to me, your arms wrapped tightly around me. What do you say?”

  He pulled back and smiled, looking at me with his kind eyes. He leaned back, brushing the hair from my face. I waited patiently, trying not to show the desperation on my face. I didn’t need sex; I just didn’t want to end the bond that we had developed over the last few days. He leaned in and kissed me softly, grabbing my
hand and shaking his head.

  “Of course, I will stay with you,” he whispered.

  I smiled and turned to the door, unlocking it and leading him inside. We kissed a few times, but as I had promised, I just wanted to feel his arms around me. We fell asleep not long after laying down, intertwined with each other. That night, while we were asleep, I was woken at the sound of Ollie’s voice. I sat up slightly and looked over at him, realizing very quickly that he was still asleep. He was saying something that woke me up, but it was muffled and mumbled. I sat there for several moments trying to make out what he was saying. Whatever it was that he was dreaming about had him upset, and it hurt me to see him that way.

  I got up from the bed and walked into the bathroom, grabbing a glass of water for him. As I walked back out to the room, ready to wake him from his dreams, I stopped, holding the glass firmly in my hand. In his sleep, during his mumbles, he called out her name. Lillie.

  “Lillie,” he whispered in a calm tone.

  I sat down on the edge of the bed and ran my hand over his head, watching him smile and mumble something incoherent. He continued to call her name, several times, but the rest of what he was saying was mostly mumbles. I turned and sat the glass on the side table, deciding that it was probably best that I just let him dream. I would talk to him about it in the morning. Before I could climb into bed, though, he spoke again, this time a lot clearer.

  “I love you. I always will.”

  I froze, my heart beating wildly in my chest. It felt like I had been punched in the gut, and instantly, I wanted to cry. He had been dreaming about Lillie, and those weren’t the words I was hoping to hear.

  Chapter 29

  Ollie

  When I woke in the morning, my first instinct was to reach for Elana, hoping to get in some cuddles before I had to drag myself off to my house to get ready for work. However, as my hand ran across the cold sheets next to me, disappointment hit me. The bed was completely empty, and the blankets were wrapped tightly around me. I wondered how long I had been sleeping on my own.

  I knew I had a tendency to move in the night, but I hoped it hadn’t forced her out of the bed. I pulled myself out of the bed and pulled on my pants and shirt, heading to the bathroom to take a piss. When I was done, I walked around the house, hoping to find Elana somewhere getting ready for work. However, as I walked through the last area of the house, the kitchen, I realized that Elana was nowhere to be found. She wasn’t anywhere in the house, not even in the kitchen where she loved to cook breakfast or in the bathroom doing her hair and makeup. I stood there for a moment feeling utterly confused, not sure what to do now.

  I looked around, feeling a bit of an uncomfortable knot in my stomach. I realized then how horrible it must have been for her to wake up in the middle of the night and have me already gone. I glanced over at the coffee pot and saw a note that she had left me. Smiling, figuring she had said something sweet or funny to start my day, I walked over and picked it up. To my disappointment though, it really didn’t say much. She had gone to work early and told me she would talk to me later, signing her name at the bottom. I could feel a twinge of fear as I looked down at her signature. Elana was a happy woman now, and as of the night before, it seemed like she couldn’t believe how amazing life had become, just like me. For some reason, though, I couldn’t help but feel like there was something going on that I hadn’t picked up on quite yet. I felt like she left early for work for a reason, and I could almost picture her standing here, fighting with herself on whether to leave a note or not.

  By the look of her signature, just haphazardly drawn across the paper, she put little thought into the note. There was no cutesy closing, not even a “fondly” or “yours truly” before her name was written. Maybe I was being paranoid. I knew there were plenty of mornings that I had woken up on the wrong side of the bed. Maybe she’d done her best, and I was way overanalyzing it. Elana had become extremely important to me, so part of me was terrified to lose her. I knew, though, I couldn’t spend my life terrified that I was going to lose her. It would drive me and her insane to say the least.

  I set the note back down on the table and took a deep breath, shrugged it off, and made my way back upstairs to gather my things. I needed to get home, so I too could get to work, and now that she was gone, there was no reason to dilly-dally. Still, I couldn’t escape the feeling that something just didn’t feel right, and I didn’t like it at all. I needed this relationship to stay strong. I cared far too much for Elana to let it all fall to pieces now.

  I went home, took a shower, and changed my clothes, stopping to grab a breakfast sandwich on my way to work. I texted Elana several times throughout the morning, hoping that I would hear back from her. Work was crazy, so my mind had drifted to other things, but every time I checked my phone, I was definitely disappointed. She hadn’t responded to any of my text messages, which was unlike her. I tried to put it out of my mind and convince myself it wasn’t on purpose, but it was becoming harder and harder to do with every passing minute.

  I always texted her funny things I heard at work, memes that popped up on my phone, or anything that made me laugh. Usually, she would send back similar things, and we would go back and forth the entire day. It made getting through the work day completely bearable, but it also kept me close and connected with Elana. I knew that she worked on campus, and I knew that had to be hard sometimes, so I wanted to make sure that she always knew that I was there for her. Today, however, was a completely different story.

  When lunchtime rolled around, I skipped out on going with everyone else to the diner down the street and grabbed a sandwich from the shop next door. I made my way back up to my office and sat down, looking at my empty inbox on my phone. I scrolled through my contacts and stopped on Elana’s name, pressing send and waiting for her sweet voice to pick up the phone. However, instead of Elana, I immediately got her voicemail.

  I left a short message to tell her I was thinking about her and hung up, not wanting her to know how I was really starting to freak out. I sat back in my chair and tried to think rationally. It was Monday, one of the busiest days of the week at work. Everyone was coming back from the weekend, trying to get their bearings and picking up where they left off on Friday. She was probably having a busy day at work. I took that explanation and went back to my own work, trying not to think about it. However, by the afternoon, with no phone calls or texts, I found myself more anxious than ever.

  At the end of the day, I said goodbye to Mike and packed up my things, keeping my phone close by. I decided that instead of calling again, I would just take a drive over to her house and see what was up. I jumped in my car and headed over, glad to see that I had missed a lot of the major traffic. When I got there, however, she wasn’t home, and her car wasn’t parked anywhere close by. This immediately struck fear into my heart. I was really worried by this point, unable to even think about what was going on. A familiar feeling of panic ran through me, thinking about the day that Lillie died, and how none of us could find her all day until her parents had come to let us know what had happened. I pushed the thought out of my head, knowing that there was most likely a much simpler explanation to all of this. I put the car in drive and headed back toward the campus, pulling into the library parking lot and sitting there for a moment.

  There were a lot of students going in and out of the building, and the parking lot was pretty full, although I didn’t actually see Elana’s car anywhere. Knowing she usually took public transportation to work, I went inside and looked around for her. I rambled through the dusty stacks looking for any sign of her, stopping at the base of a large Phoenix statue. I glanced down at the nameplate and realized it was Lillie’s work. I stared at it for a moment, thinking about Elana and where she could have possibly gone. I checked with the librarian on duty, but she said that Elana had left early. I looked at the statue again and then headed back out to my car, glad that it hadn’t sent me spiraling into depression like it would have before. Elana must h
ave had that piece put into the library as a tribute to Lillie. It warmed my heart instead of making me feel sad.

  I sat there tapping my phone against my leg, trying to decide what to do next. The last place to check was her mother’s, but if she wasn’t there, I didn’t want to alarm Tammy. If Elana had just needed some time alone, she would be pretty upset to come back and find the entire town looking for her. Just as I thought about doing it anyway, my phone buzzed in my lap. I looked down and let out a deep sigh, seeing that it was Elana who was texting me. Instantly, I felt better knowing that she was okay and safe. However, that happy feeling was fleeting as I stared down at the message on the phone. At first, I couldn’t compute what I was reading, so I rubbed my eyes and started over, trying not to let my emotions take hold.

  Elana: Ollie, I’m sorry for not calling you back. I know you must be worried. I just wanted you to know that I was okay. That being said, I think that I need to take a break. I need some time to myself, and I hope that you will give me some space.

  I read the message over and over again, trying to take in every single letter that she wrote. I put the phone down on my lap and gripped the steering wheel, sitting still in my parking spot. I didn’t understand, and the words just seemed to be jumbled up in my head. To say that I was crushed by this news would be a complete understatement. I could feel a lump in my throat and burning at the corner of my eyes, something I had never experienced before from a girl telling me she needed space. In reality, no girl ever had, but even if they had, it wouldn’t have affected me with the magnitude in which this was sidelining me. I didn’t see it coming. How could I? Everything had been so perfect, right up until the moment I went to bed the night before, with Elana wrapped in my arms.