Jordan, Olivia - Tiara's Foxtrot Fantasies [Studio Seductions 3] (Siren Publishing Ménage Everlasting)

by Olivia Jordan

  Inside, they were seated in a semicircle booth with Tiara between both men. She tried not to drop her jaw when she saw the menu prices. As grateful as she was for the dinner, she couldn’t imagine that this wasn’t going to take a bite out of Jack’s budget.

  “Don’t even look at the prices,” he said, placing his hand over the menu column. “Get whatever you want.”

  When the waitress arrived, Tiara tentatively ordered a steak. After they gave their food orders, Jack requested a bottle of wine that Tiara knew cost even more than her hourly rate for private lessons.

  “Jack, you shouldn’t have,” she said after the waitress walked away.

  “Yes, I should have, because I care about both of you, and I want to do something nice after the long day we’ve had.

  “Thank you,” she said, tired of sounding worried or ungrateful and finally willing to simply accept his generosity.

  She leaned her head against his shoulder, and he placed his hand on her thigh. A moment later, she felt Seth’s hand settle on her other leg. They didn’t talk but kept touching her under the table, their hands hidden from sight. As her pussy grew needier and needier, she opened her legs just enough to allow them access to her clit. Seth reached his fingers beneath the fabric of her panties and began playing with her, teasing her a bit at first but soon rubbing her with a furious intensity. Tiara struggled not to moan in the crowded restaurant, not wanting to spoil their fun by drawing attention to what they were doing. She felt the orgasm building in her cunt. But just before she was about to climax, the waitress approached with their food. Seth quickly pulled his hand away, and it was all Tiara could do not to cry out in desperation.

  “If you two gentlemen will excuse me for a moment, I have something I need to take care of in the restroom.”

  “Oh, no you don’t,” Jack whispered. “I want you to sit here waiting as we eat. I want to make sure you’re going completely crazy with lust by the time we get you back to the hotel.”

  “I’ll never survive.”

  “Somehow, I think you’ll be okay.”

  The silence continued as they began to eat. Tiara was too horny to focus on intelligent conversation, and both Jack and Seth seemed absorbed in their own thoughts.

  As delicious as the food was, Tiara found that she was too aroused even to eat. She only finished half of her dinner before setting her fork down.

  “Not hungry?” Jack asked.

  “I am, but not for food.”

  “What would you like instead?” he asked, leaning toward her.

  Rather than answering, Tiara pressed her lips against his, sliding her tongue into his mouth. She remained there, letting his taste overwhelm her, until she felt Seth grab her shoulders and pull her away.

  “What are you—”

  But she didn’t have time to finish her question before Seth pulled her into another deep kiss, which she reciprocated, and then reciprocated again. Then Jack pulled her to his mouth, and Seth began placing kisses up and down her tingling neck.

  The sound of a throat clearing made all of them pull apart and look up. An irritated-looking waitress loomed overhead.

  “Are you ready for your check?” she asked, irritation seeping out with her words.

  Jack reached into his wallet and pulled out a credit card. “Just ring it up. Don’t worry about the tab.”

  The waitress pinched the card between two fingers, as though it was dirty, and walked off in a huff.

  “If you’ll excuse me, I need to stop by the restroom before we head out,” Jack said. “Don’t have too much fun without me.” He scooted out of the booth and sauntered toward the back of the restaurant.

  “I love you,” she whispered, as soon as Jack was out of sight. She felt guilty for being so secretive about it, but she still wasn’t sure where things were going with Jack yet, and she couldn’t hold back her feelings for Seth any longer. She’d been waiting for three months to say those words.

  Seth pulled away, surprised. “You what?”

  “I love you?” Her stomach suddenly began to clench, and she worried that she’d jumped the gun, that even after years of repressing feelings that had finally come out, he didn’t really love her, or he wasn’t ready yet.

  But after a moment of stunned surprise, Seth smiled. “I love you, too.”

  He leaned forward and brought her into a deep kiss. As their lips pressed, pulled away, and then pressed again, she snaked her fingers through his hair, not caring how they might have looked to the rest of the restaurant. Her pussy began to heat up, to pulse with her.

  “Now it looks like I’m the one walking in on all the fun,” Jack said, taking his seat at the table. “What did I miss?”

  “We were just fooling around a little bit,” Tiara said with a smile. She was conflicted about whether or not to tell him, but she didn’t want to hurt his feelings. Nor did she want to force either of them into saying anything they didn’t mean yet. She decided it was best to keep those thoughts to herself, at least for a few more days, until she had a clearer picture of how things were going to work between the three of them.

  “Is this the kind of fun that would have room for a third person?”

  Tiara smiled even wider. “Always.”

  The waitress returned and dropped Jack’s receipt and credit card on the table without looking anybody in the eye. She silently turned and hurried off to another table.

  Hurrying out the door and into Jack’s car, they drove back to the hotel. They hadn’t made it past Seth’s room the night before, nobody willing to leave the bed after another round of hot sex. This time, they headed straight for Tiara’s bed. She didn’t waste any time as she crossed the room, tossing off every stitch of clothing before bouncing on the mattress. She watched with glee as her men followed suit, tearing off their clothes and shoes before surrounding her with their hands, mouths, and cocks. She kissed Jack, tasting every inch of his mouth, then broke away and did the same with Seth. She alternated the kisses for a while as they fondled her breasts and teased her pussy lips. Then, however, Jack suddenly pulled away and left the bed.

  “Where’s your lube?” he asked, unzipping her suitcase.

  “We don’t need lube tonight,” she replied.

  He looked up at her with a confused expression. “Why not?”

  “Because I want you one at a time this evening.”

  “So what, you fuck one of us, and the other guy has to suffer and watch?” Seth asked.

  Tiara grinned. “Something tells me you’ll actually enjoy the suffering.”

  “So who goes first?” Jack asked.

  “Well, Seth is the one actually in the bed right now, so I guess I’ll start with him.”

  “What am I supposed to do? Just stand here?”

  “Oh, I’m sure you’ll figure it—oh!” she gasped as Seth plunged his cock into her trembling cunt. She lost her train of thought as he began pounding into her, his pelvis slamming against hers as his dick slid in and out of her body. Tiara rolled her head on the pillow, overwhelmed by the sensations filling her body. His fast fucking made her forget the horrible morning, the tense afternoon, the guilt she felt about her feelings toward Jack. All that mattered right then was the way his cock felt in her pussy, the pleasure he brought her as her cunt muscles contracted and released around him, the way her body tried to squeeze every drop of ecstasy out of him.

  But the need to be on top soon distracted her from the sex. Using all of her energy, she flipped them over on the bed so that she was straddling Seth. Casting a glance over her shoulder, she saw Jack stroking himself slowly.

  “Be careful there. You don’t want to blow your load before you have a chance to fuck me.”

  “That’s why I’m not going very fast.”

  “Just watch out. You might be overwhelmed while you watch the rest of the show.” She sat up so that Seth could get a full view of her breasts and then slowly teased her nipples, tugging and pinching, making a show of the way the jolts of pleasure swam throug
h her body. When she heard Seth’s breathing go ragged, she knew he was close. Dropping to all fours, she threw all of her energy into fucking him, pounding into his cock with every ounce of strength. The intensity lit a fire in her cunt, and as his cock gave one final throb, her own body went off, the orgasm causing her to cease all motion as it overwhelmed her. Seth writhed beneath her body, groaning as his own orgasm sent him out of control.

  “You’re right, that was a good show,” Jack said as he approached the bed. “But now I’m concerned that you’ve used up all your energy too soon and aren’t up for another round.”

  “I’m always up for another round,” she said, slipping off of Seth and reclining on the bed, opening her legs for Jack. As he slid his rigid cock inside her, Seth perched on the edge of the bed in rapt attention.

  Jack moved slowly at first, allowing her body to adjust to the switch in partners. But despite the intensity of her first orgasm, Tiara still wasn’t sated, and she didn’t have the patience for slow, gentle fucking.

  “Faster,” she commanded. “I need you to go faster.”

  “You can’t stand a little teasing?”

  “Not today I can’t.”

  Jack obeyed her orders, pushing himself up to full speed in a matter of seconds. Seth seemed to have lost interest in watching and made his way toward the top of the bed. After giving Tiara a deep kiss, he brought his hands to her breasts, caressing them lightly with his fingertips, teasing her the way she had teased herself a few moments earlier. As Tiara began to lose control, as she felt her cunt pulse harder and her breath become shallower, Seth increased the intensity, pinching enough to create sharp pain, tugging enough to make her ache. That perfect edge of agony and ecstasy sent her body spiraling into another orgasm, this one even bigger than the last. She was sure the people in the next room could hear her screams, but she didn’t care. She wanted them to hear what a wonderful time she was having.

  Jack didn’t last much longer than she did. Just as her first orgasm had rendered her motionless, he stopped his thrusting and moaned, adding to the screams that were just beginning to fade. Completely spent, he collapsed on her chest and stayed there until he caught his breath.

  “I like you,” he whispered as he rolled off and snuggled against her side.

  Tiara smiled. At least if she didn’t love him yet, she knew he didn’t love her either. “I like you, too.”

  Seth remained silent but squeezed her hand. She squeezed back, a silent declaration of love, a quiet affirmation of what they shared.

  Chapter Eight

  Tiara struggled to drag herself out of bed the next morning. After staying up late two nights in a row, combined with full days of teaching and rehearsal, she wasn’t getting enough rest.

  “Wake up,” Jack said, giving her a gentle shake. “We need to get to the studio soon. Seth is teaching a private lesson, and you and I have one-on-one coaching, remember?”

  “Could we practice later?” she mumbled. “I’m so tired.”

  Jack gave a soft laugh. “I wish I could let you sleep. I really do. But you and Seth have to rehearse later, as do Catherine and I. Besides, if you come take a lesson with me now, I’m sure Seth and I can make it worth your while later.”

  Tiara perked up. “How so?”

  “That, my dear, will have to be a surprise. But I’m sure you can imagine what might happen.”

  Spurred on by the promise of fun afterwards, Tiara hurried to shower and dress before heading downstairs with her men. She dozed on the way to the studio but tried to perk up as they walked in the building. As tired as she was, she didn’t want to disappoint Jack during their lesson.

  They walked into one of the small private studios, and Jack immediately began choosing a song for a warm-up dance. Tiara rolled her shoulders to loosen them up and then swept her hair up into a tight ponytail.

  Jack grinned as he took her in his arms. “You seem to be changing your attitude a little bit.”

  Tiara felt herself blush. “I guess it does make rehearsals a little easier when it’s not always getting in the way. Maybe I shouldn’t have fought you so much on that one.”

  “I’m glad you’re starting to see my side of things. Though I’ll admit that maybe I shouldn’t have been quite so overbearing. You are a grown woman, after all, and if something was working for you, perhaps I didn’t need to be so demanding.”

  Jack took Tiara in his arms and began their dance. She felt warmth spread across her skin as they moved across the floor and noticed that her energy was beginning to return.

  “I suppose we both made some mistakes when we first met,” she said. “But I’m glad we were able to work through them.”

  Jack led her into a series of quick, complicated spins and then brought her into a deep dip that almost sent her head to the floor.

  “I’m glad, too,” he said. “I didn’t think I could be so happy with another person. But you’ve opened both my heart and my mind.”

  As Jack swept Tiara back up into an upright position and began gliding back around the floor, she couldn’t help but grin. She realized things really were changing between her and Jack. Her feelings were becoming more than just about lust. He’d already sated her body, but her heart was beginning to demand more.

  Jack and Tiara spent the next hour and a half honing her technique. In the back of her mind, though, Tiara kept imagining her and Seth not going to the airport on Monday morning. She imagined the three of them going house hunting and settling down together. She imagined making a home and a life that involved both men. She wasn’t sure how she managed to get through the lesson with these ideas running through her head, but she made it work.

  When they finished the lesson, Tiara’s mind was buzzing, but she was beginning to feel physically drained again.

  “So, remember how you said you’d make it worth my while if I got up and went to the studio?”

  Jack smiled. “Of course.”

  “Before that, do you mind if we go home and take a nap? I feel like if I get another hour or two of sleep, I’ll be good to go for the rest of the day.”

  Seth walked up, slightly sweaty from teaching. “What are we talking about?”

  “Think we have time to go back to the hotel and take a nap before we have to be back?”

  Seth glanced at the clock. “Works for me. Tiara and I don’t actually have to be anywhere until our scheduled rehearsal time this afternoon. And I’m not as tired as she is, but I admit, I could use a little more rest.”

  They left the studio, and Tiara made sure to hold hands with both men as they walked out of the building. She saw Jack blush a little, but he didn’t pull away or seem upset. She was happy that she could show off her affection for both Jack and Seth in public, and that nobody was going to judge them for it.

  Tiara dozed again on the ride back to the hotel. As soon as they were back in her room, she slipped out of her clothes and crawled between the cool sheets. Jack and Seth both stripped down as well and curled up beside her. Tiara briefly considered telling Jack her feelings but was lulled into sleep before she worked up the nerve.

  * * * *

  Tiara woke up about an hour later and smiled as she realized both of her lovers were still in her bed, right where she wanted them. Her cunt immediately started tingling with the desire to be touched, but she didn’t want to wake them right away, preferring to savor the warmth of their skin on hers for a few moments. Finally, though, she couldn’t stand waiting any longer and reached her hands down to play with their cocks. She smiled as they remained sleeping for a few minutes longer as she began to tease and rub them into arousal. However, it wasn’t long before they both sprang awake, gasping, their cocks half-hard.

  “What’s going on?” Seth asked, not quite cognizant of the world around him.

  Tiara gestured toward his cock and shrugged. “I woke up and got tired of waiting. I figured that would be the most pleasant way to get your attention. I hope you don’t mind.”

  “Why would I mi
nd being woken up by a hand job?” Jack asked, leaning over to kiss her.

  “Hand job?” Tiara asked. “Who said anything about giving you a hand job? That was just to wake you up. I’m not going to just get you off and get nothing in return.”

  “I never said we wouldn’t return the favor,” Jack said before moving down to nibble on her breasts. “You give us hand jobs, and we’ll be sure you get off, too.”

  “I think I’d much rather have your cocks inside me,” she said. “I want both of them at the same time.”

  “I don’t know,” Seth said with a wink. “I’m pretty sleepy still. I’m not sure I have the energy for that sort of physical activity, especially with all the late nights we’ve had lately.”

  “You can be on the bottom, then,” Tiara said. “Which gives me an idea.” She hurried over to her suitcase and pulled out a butt plug. “Since you’re too tired to do anything, maybe a little passive stimulation will help.”

  Seth’s eyes widened. “Where did you get that?”

  Tiara giggled. “Yesterday when we postponed rehearsal, I decided to indulge in a little retail therapy to cheer myself up. I was wandering around downtown and came across a sex-toy store. This plug was in the window display, and I bought it on impulse, figuring we’d have the chance to use it sooner or later.”

  “I’ve never tried one of those before.”

  “You’d also never had a threesome before a few nights ago. Are you done with new experiences for the time being?”

  “Hardly,” Seth said with a laugh.

  Tiara lubed up her finger and pressed it against Seth’s asshole. She felt the muscles tremble briefly, and then she slid her narrow finger in, feeling him tighten up around her.

  “Damn, that feels good,” he gasped.

  “It’s going to feel even better in a second,” she said and plunged another finger in.

  Seth writhed and bucked as she slid her fingers in and out, loosening the muscles, preparing him for the black-onyx plug that awaited him. When he was finally stretched out, she poured more lube around the toy, and then eased it up inside of him.