The Other Side of Love (Forever Love)

by Cooper, J. S.

  “I don’t know.” She bit her lip and looked up at me with a confused expression. “I want to, but it just seems too soon.”

  I tried not to groan as I collapsed on the bed next to her and gave her a soft smile. “It’s okay. We can go at your pace. Like I said before, this isn’t about sex for me.”

  “I know. You’re a sweetheart.” She turned over to face me and I tried my hardest to keep my eyes on her face and not on her naked body.

  “Why, thank you.” I reached over and stroked her hair away from her eyes. “You have beautiful eyes, did you know that? They go from green to brown to green, and they haunt me every time I look into them.”

  “Some people just call them hazel.”

  “Oh, but they’re not just hazel. They’re so much more bewitching than just regular hazel.” My fingers traced her lips, and she held her breath as I stuck my finger into her mouth. She slowly sucked on it and I groaned as I felt my cock growing hard again. I pulled my finger out of her mouth slowly and lay back again and closed my eyes. “Sorry,” I mumbled. “We need to just pause for a moment or I’m going to explode.”

  “Little Noah, you mean?” She giggled and I felt her breasts against my chest as she leaned into me.

  “Who you calling little?” I growled and opened my eyes and pushed her onto her back. “I’ll have you know that big Noah is ready to play.”

  “But I put him in time out.” She laughed up at me and I held her hands up by her head. I looked down at her, and my heart caught in my throat as I saw the total innocence and trust in her eyes.

  “No one puts Big Noah in the corner.” I winked at her, and she groaned.

  “Please tell me you are not misquoting Dirty Dancing.”

  “Or what?” I let go of her wrists and moved my hands down to her breasts, allowing my fingers to gently graze her nipples as I squeezed them.

  “Or nothing.” She breathed up at me and squirmed beneath me. She then reached up and pulled me down on top of her so that my body was pressed firmly against hers. “Fuck me, Noah.”

  “Are you sure?” I looked into her eyes to make sure she was not saying the words out of pressure.

  “I’ve never been more sure of anything in my life.” She laughed and reached up and grabbed my cock and positioned it between her legs.

  “I don’t want you to think this is all about sex.” I pushed the tip of my cock into her opening and paused. “Are you sure?”

  “Oh, my gosh, Noah. Just do it.” She moaned and pushed my bottom down and squeezed her legs around my waist so that my cock plunged into her. We both gasped as I slid inside of her, and a spark of electricity passed through us both. I moved slowly at first, loving the feel of her clenched around me. She felt warm and tight, and I had to control myself to stop myself from coming too soon. Robin bucked her hips beneath me and I increased my pace, slamming in and out of her so fast that I could feel my balls bouncing against her with every thrust.

  “Touch me,” she moaned as I moved in and out of her. Her eyes were blazing with desire. “I need you to touch me at the same time. Please.” She groaned and I realized she wanted me to rub her clit as I thrust in and out of her. I adjusted my position so that her legs were up over my shoulders and I reached my thumb down to manually stimulate her as my cock plunged into her.

  “Oh, yes. Oh, my God, yes!” she screamed and closed her eyes as I felt my climax building up and I rubbed her clit harder so that I could ensure I didn’t come before her. “Oh, Noah!” she screamed out loud and her eyes popped open as she started climaxing. Her body wiggled against me and across the sheets, and her breasts bounced up and down as she gyrated against me. She screamed as she came and I plunged into her hard two more times before I exploded inside of her. We stared at each other as we climaxed together and I collapsed on top of her, my cock still inside of her as we both finished at the same time. I gave her a long hard kiss and rolled onto my side. I quickly pulled off the condom and threw into the trashcan on the other side of the bed.

  “You’re amazing.” I leaned over and pulled Robin into my arms. “That was amazing.”

  “Thank you.” She looked up at me apprehensively. “I don’t know what to say. I’ve never orgasmed like that before.”

  “Really?” I grinned, happy at her admission.

  “Really.” She laughed. “I think I would have come even if you hadn’t rubbed my clit.”

  “Do you need to be touched to come?” I cocked my head to the side and ran my fingers down her stomach to her pussy.

  “Yes. Well, I’ve never come without manual stimulation as well.”

  “Oh. That’s sad.” I reached down and rubbed her clit and she moaned.

  “Oh, don’t.” She squealed and tightened her legs against my hand. “I’m not sure I can handle another orgasm again so soon.”

  “Oh?” I laughed and slipped a finger inside of her. “Are you sure?”

  “Noah,” she closed her eyes. “You’re the devil, you know that?”

  “No.” I removed my finger and watched her stare at me with wide eyes as I put it into my mouth and sucked it. “You taste amazing.”

  “I can’t believe you’re growing hard again already.” She looked down at my cock, which was already growing rigid again, and placed her fingers around the shaft. “I didn’t expect you to be so well endowed.”

  “Was I too big for you?” I raised an eyebrow at her and she laughed.

  “No.” She shook her head. “It felt just right.”

  “Yes, it did.” I groaned as I felt her fingers moving up and down the length of me. “Don’t start something you can’t continue.”

  “Or?” She stopped and rolled over back onto her back. “What?”

  “You are not going to just leave me hanging here, are you?” I groaned. “Big Noah is ready to play again.”

  “Well, little Robin needs a longer break.” She laughed.

  “What about back door Robin?”

  “Back door?” She looked confused and then she shook her head at me. “Really?”

  “Have you ever done it?” I grinned at her. “You shouldn’t knock what you don’t know.”

  “Actually, I tried it once. And I wasn’t a huge fan.”

  “He most probably didn’t know what he was doing.”

  “And you do?”

  “I just gave you the best orgasm of your life, right?”

  “I never said that.” She blushed and I laughed as I reached down and nibbled on her nipple while allowing my fingers to play with her other nipple.

  “I think you pretty much did.” I smirked at her. “But that’s okay, that was pretty much the best orgasm I’ve ever had as well.”

  “Really?” She looked surprised. “And what do you mean pretty much?”

  “Well, I only orgasmed once, so I can’t be sure.” I laughed as she pushed me onto my back and rolled over on top of me.

  “Well, I guess I’ll have to prove it to you.” She looked down at me with glossy eyes, and I laughed as she trailed her breasts along my face and allowed her nipples to brush against my lips. I tried to catch one in my mouth, but she moved it away quickly.

  “Oh, no you don’t. I’m in control now.” She sat back and shifted positions so that she was straddling me.

  “I love a woman in charge.”

  “Really?” She traced her fingers along my nipples and squeezed them hard before moving her fingers back down to my stomach.

  “Yes.” I laughed and lay back, happy to allow her to take me on her sexual journey.

  “Good.” She moved forward and then shifted backwards quickly and before I knew what was going on, I felt my cock sliding inside of her.

  “Oh.” I reached over to the nightstand to grab the other condom, but she shook her head.

  “It’s okay. I’m on the pill.” She slowly moved back and forth on me, and the sensation of her bare skin against mine made me grow harder even faster. “I want to feel all of you inside of me.”

  “Fuck.” M
y body tensed as she bounced up and down on me and swiveled her hips back and forth. She was moving so quickly that I was sliding in and out of her effortlessly. I could feel every sensation even more deeply as she moved up and down. I felt my cock going so deeply into her that I almost felt that she was becoming a part of me. I knew that I was also hitting the right spot because she had closed her eyes and was moaning as she increased her pace. Her hair was flying everywhere and her breasts were bouncing up and down with abandon as she rode me. I reached up and squeezed her nipples as she rode me and I felt her climax a few seconds later. This time she increased her pace, and I found myself climaxing into her a few seconds later. She collapsed on top of me, and I grabbed her face and kissed her hard.

  “You proved your point.” I muttered against her lips. “That was the best orgasm of my life.”

  “You proved your point as well,” she whispered against my lips. “That was my first orgasm from penetration alone.”

  “There are plenty more where that came from.” I drew her hair away from her face and stared up into her face. “You’re so beautiful, Robin.”

  “You’re not bad yourself.” She rolled over onto her side and grinned. “I’m ready to watch that movie now.”

  “I’m ready for a quick nap.” I laughed and she shook her head.

  “Typical man.”

  “To know us is to love us,” I replied quickly, and I laughed as she stuck her tongue out at me. I jumped off of the bed and grabbed the remote control and threw it at her. “Here you go. Feel free to choose a channel. I’m just going to the bathroom. I’ll be right back.”

  “Okay.” She smiled and bit her lip.

  “Everything okay?”

  “Do you have a t-shirt I could wear?” She looked down at her naked body. “I feel a little awkward lying here naked.”

  “I don’t mind you staying naked.” I licked my lips and then laughed as she rolled her eyes. “Hold on.” I walked to the closet, grabbed a t-shirt, and threw it to her. She caught it and pulled it on quickly.

  “Thank you.” She smiled and sat back. My breath caught as I stared at Robin and realized which t-shirt I had given her. It was the same t-shirt I had worn all the time in Palm Bonita. It was the same t-shirt that she had worn after we made love. I felt my heart thudding as I realized that I was now thinking about her while I was with Robin. And I hadn’t even told Robin about her. I closed my eyes briefly, not wanting to think of her in this moment. This was a special new beginning for Robin and me. I didn’t want the past to ruin us. I had to live in the present now. I had a real future with Robin. I didn’t want to mess that up.

  “You okay?” Robin looked at me with an anxious look.

  “Yeah.” I nodded. “Sorry, that t-shirt reminded me of my time in Palm Bonita.”

  “Oh.” She looked down at the graphic of a lone palm tree and the caption ‘No man is alone in Palm Bonita.’ “Did you get this while you were there?”

  “Yeah. A friend gave it to me.” I turned around. “I’ll be back. I just need to go to the bathroom.” I hurried to the bathroom and closed the door and poured some water on my flushed face. “Stupid idiot.” I muttered to myself as I pissed. “Why don’t you just tell her that she’s wearing the t-shirt your ex-girlfriend gave you? The same t-shirt that she used to wear after you fucked her senseless?”

  “You okay, Noah?” Robin knocked on the bathroom door, and I froze. How loud had I been?

  “Yeah, coming.” I washed my hands and walked out of the bathroom and looked at Robin’s worried face. “What’s wrong?”

  “You seem like you got upset.” She looked up at me with a concerned face. “I guess you have bad memories about your time in Palm Bonita, huh?”

  “I guess,” I mumbled, wanting to change the subject but not knowing how.

  “What was it like?” She walked back to the bed with me and we sat down. “I understand if you don’t want to talk about it, but I’d love to know more about it.”

  “It was a small town.” I sighed and leaned back on the bed. “It was full of criminals. A lot of bad people.”

  “Wow, how bad were they?”

  “Pretty bad.” I shrugged. “Murderers, thieves, tax evaders. Anyone who wanted to get away from mainstream society and didn’t want to be found moved to Palm Bonita.”

  “Eww, that sounds horrible. No wonder you have bad memories of the place. Were there any good people?”

  “There was one.” I started and my eyes lit up at the memory of Skylar. “Out of everyone that I met, there was one person who was an angel with a heart of gold.”

  “A girl?” Robin’s tone was light, but her eyes looked at me with deep interest.

  “Yeah. She was my little princess.” I stared at Robin and sighed. “She was a beautiful light in that town of darkness.”

  “I didn’t realize that you had someone special there.”

  “Sorry,” I shook my head. “I didn’t mean to or want to talk about this. It’s not something I like to dwell upon.”

  “Do you miss her?” Robin’s tone sounded jealous, and I felt worry fill me.

  “Let’s not talk about it.” I grabbed her hands. “Let’s just think about us.” I pulled her against my chest and stroked her head, but all I could think was, ‘What if I am successful in bringing Skylar to Los Angeles? What am I going to tell Robin?’

  Chapter 11

  “What’s your favorite flavor ice cream?” Skylar grinned at me as she licked her ice cream cone eagerly. “I think mine is chocolate, but I love strawberry cheesecake and mint choc chip as well. Oh, and vanilla.” She giggled. “I guess I love a lot of them.”

  “I think mine would have to be rum raisin.” I smiled at the joy in her eyes, and felt a surge of happiness inside. It was a rare occasion to see her so happy.

  “What’s rum raisin?”

  “It’s not a popular flavor.” I laughed. “And it’s not one you should eat.”

  “Why not?” She frowned. “I want to try it.”

  “It’s high in alcohol.”

  “I like alcohol.” She licked her lips and I shook my head at her, trying to hide the sorrow in my gaze.

  “Alcohol is bad.” I grabbed her hand. “Come on, let’s go bowling.”

  “I’ve never been bowling before.” She paused to bite off a big chuck of her wafer cone. “Is it hard?”

  “You’ve never been bowling before?” I forgot to hide my surprise and I saw her react to my statement. She looked a little bit sad and worried and I wanted to slap myself for making her feel bad. “No worries, it’s not hard and I can teach you.”

  “You should be a teacher.” She smiled at me, happy again.

  “I don’t think I would be a good teacher. You’re the only one I like teaching.”

  “That’s because I’m your favorite.” She nodded happily. “And you’re mine.”

  “I’m glad to hear that.”

  “You’re my most favorite person ever.” Skylar’s eyes were wide open as she stared at me with her innocent beautiful face. “I never want you to leave.”

  “I never want to leave, either.” I bit my lip and looked away, not knowing how to tell her that one day I was going to have to leave.

  “Promise you will never leave me.” Her eyes were earnest as she spoke the words so simply.

  “I don’t know if I can promise that.” I paused and looked down at her. “You know I love you very much, but I don’t know that I can promise that I’ll never leave.”

  “If you leave, you have to take me with you.” She gulped and started breathing fast. “You have to.” Tears starting building up in her eyes and they quickly became moist. “You can’t leave me here.”

  “Let’s not talk about it now, Skylar.” I pulled her towards me and hugged her hard.

  “You can’t leave me, Noah. Please never leave me. Promise me.” She whispered as I held her and I felt my heart freeze over at the sound of her voice pleading with me. I wanted to tell her that I would never leave, b
ut I knew that was one promise I couldn’t make.

  “You’re up early.” Lucky walked into the kitchen as I was making coffee. “Early night?”

  “Not really.” I smiled at her and turned back to the French press. I groaned as I saw Zane walk into the kitchen behind her. He looked me up and down and frowned at my half naked body. All I was wearing was a pair of boxer briefs and I knew he was not happy to see me that way in his kitchen.

  “Morning, Noah. Were you hot last night?” Zane gave me a look and I shook my head.

  “No, not really.”

  “What did you do last night?” Lucky spoke up, obviously sensing that Zane was going to continue to go on about my appearance passive aggressively.

  “Watched a movie.” I grinned, thinking about all the hot sex before and after the movie. “What about you two?”

  “Zane and I went down to Santa Monica to an art show, then we had dinner at a new Italian place and talked.”

  “Are you okay?” I looked at Zane searching to see if he was still upset.

  “I’m surprisingly okay.” He gave me a reassuring nod. “And don’t worry, I’m not mad at you.”

  “You’re not?” I looked over at him in surprise and he laughed.

  “Shocker, right?” He shrugged. “I understand why you didn’t want to tell me. I don’t hold it against you. I most probably wouldn’t have told you, either.”

  “So, we’re still brothers?”

  “Try getting away from me.” He walked over to me and gave me a slap on the shoulder. “Now please pass me a cup of coffee.”

  “Oh, sorry, I only made enough for two.”

  “Right? One for me and one for you. Lucky can’t have caffeine right now.”

  “Well, actually the other cup isn’t for you.”

  “Huh?” He looked at me in confusion. “You’re going to drink two cups of coffee?”

  “No,” I shook my head and bit my lip. “The other cup of coffee is for …”

  “Me.” Robin’s voice rang out as she walked into the kitchen looking sexy as hell in just my shirt. “Good morning, everyone.” She smiled and looked at me shyly.