Naughty & Nice: A MFM Christmas Romance (Surrender to Them Book 7)

by Kelli Callahan

  That’s what I get for giving in to my desires—no wonder I’m still a virgin. I can’t even get the first kiss right.

  “Holly, I’d like you to meet my twin brother Zach.” Andy motioned with his hand.

  “I guess it’s safe to say we’ve already met.” I blinked and took a deep breath. “I promise that isn’t how I normally greet strangers.”

  “It was a mistake. I get it.” Zach nodded quickly. “Maybe we can put this behind us and just enjoy our Christmas dinner—unless you want me to leave.”

  “No.” I shook my head back and forth. “It smells so good that I think it would be criminal to deprive you.”

  We went to the dining room table and the awkwardness seemed to pass. I was amazed by how different they were, despite being twins. They had common interests, but different directions. Zach wanted to move to the city and find a job at a big company once he graduated in hopes of working his way up the ranks. Andy wanted to go to law school and possibly open his own firm one day. He really wanted Zach to be there with him when he did, but Zach seemed rather apprehensive about the idea. Andy was rough around the edges, but he was confident. Zach was a lot sweeter, and I felt like there was more to him than what I could see on the surface. He carried some turmoil behind those ocean-blue eyes while Andy would have probably rushed into a tornado without even thinking about it—smiling the whole time.

  They’re both so fucking hot and every time I make eye contact with one of them, my stomach tries to breed butterflies.

  “So, are you finally going to tell me how you figured out I was Santa Claus?” Andy tilted his head to the side and sipped his beer.

  “I’d be interested in hearing this story too.” Zach leaned back in his chair.

  “Well…” I sighed and shrugged.

  I might as well tell them at this point.

  “And don’t tell me it was a lucky guess. I don’t buy that for a second.” Andy narrowed his eyes suspiciously.

  “Yeah, you’re right. It wasn’t a lucky guess. I saw you guys swapping the costume behind the mall.” I reached for my glass of water and smiled.

  The day I fell head over heels in lust—the reason I finally had the courage to actually show up here.

  “Interesting.” Zach nodded and sipped his beer again. “I thought we were well hidden back there.”

  “Not if you have to park that far out.” I chuckled under my breath. “I had no idea why Santa Claus was changing in the parking lot until I realized you were twins.”

  “That’s why you were looking at me the other day.” Andy sipped his beer and smiled. “And here I thought you just liked what you saw.”

  Oh I did, there’s no denying that.

  “I mean…” I stammered over my words and looked down.

  “Did you like kissing my brother?” Andy’s expression twisted into a grin.

  What the fuck?

  “Come on man, that isn’t nice,” Zach grumbled under his breath and turned towards me. “You don’t have to answer that.”

  “She doesn’t have to answer it, but maybe she wants to.” Andy leaned forward. “It happened. It’s okay to talk about it.”

  There’s the guy that I sat across in the food court. I guess it was foolish to think he had changed his stripes.

  “The kiss was obviously a mistake.” I stared at my plate and sighed. “Leave it to me to walk in here and embarrass myself.”

  “You didn’t embarrass yourself.” Andy shook his head quickly. “You went after what you wanted—now I’m doing the same.”

  I’m afraid of what I want—and maybe even more afraid of what you want.

  “I feel like you’re just humiliating me.” I lifted my head slowly. “And I don’t like it.”

  I should have just kept going when I was outside. I shouldn’t have let him lure me back in here with a kiss.

  “I’m not trying to humiliate you. I saw the way you kissed Zach—and I’m pretty sure Zach wouldn’t have hesitated for a second if you weren’t supposed to be meeting me tonight.” Andy looked over at his twin brother.

  He sure didn’t try to push me away…

  “If we’re being honest, my reaction when I saw you—it wasn't just surprising. I recognized you from the mall. I followed you earlier today because I wanted to talk to you, but I didn’t make it before you disappeared. That wasn’t the only time I’ve seen you—I saw you at Spencer’s a few days ago with your friend.” Zach blinked a couple of times and sighed.

  “What he’s trying to say is that he likes you too. I’ve seen that far away look in his eyes all night.” Andy nodded and sipped his beer.

  “I was just thinking about things. I’m not trying to steal your date.” Zach shook his head and looked almost offended.

  “It’s okay to want something. There’s no harm in that.” Andy slid his chair back and stood, locking his eyes on mine. “You wanted something the day we met in the mall—when you left that message on my phone.”

  “I—I don’t know. I wasn’t thinking clearly.” I drew a breath in as Andy walked around the table and put his hands on my shoulder.

  “You don’t have to hide from what you want, because right now, we want the same thing.” Andy leaned down and pressed his lips to my neck. “You can have us both. Just admit that you want it.”

  Both? Oh my god.

  “I—I can’t.” I pushed my chair back and hopped to my feet. “Thank you for dinner, but I should be going now.”

  Andy

  “Don’t go.” I caught Holly’s arm as she started to walk towards the door. “There’s nothing to be afraid of.”

  “Just let her go, Andy,” Zach growled under his breath and stood to his feet. “I didn’t ask you to share your date with me.”

  “You didn’t have to.” I looked over at him and grinned. “I’ve only seen that look in your eyes a few times, and I know how much you like her.”

  “This is heading in a direction that I didn’t expect.” Holly shook her head quickly and pulled away from me.

  Holly started walking towards the door at a hurried pace, but as she got closer, her steps slowed to a halt before her hand touched the doorknob. She took a deep breath and turned around to face us. I had shared girls with my brother before. I knew how intoxicating the idea of being shared was for some women. If they looked at me with the lust-filled stare, then it was hard for them not to have those same thoughts when they saw Zach. Holly had that look in her eyes even if she didn’t want to admit it to herself. It wouldn’t have been fair for me to claim a woman as hot as her without giving her a chance to have us both. We didn’t have to fall in love, but we could set the bedroom on fire, even if the fire burned out when the sun came up. I liked her more than I was willing to admit, and perhaps I was trying to pull my brother into the mix in order to keep myself from falling for her. That would be a lot easier if we shared her.

  “Let that hesitation guide you towards what you truly crave.” I walked up to Holly and took her hand. “You don’t have the strength to run because you know what you want.”

  “I’ve never done anything like this before.” She looked up at me and swallowed hard.

  “Let us show you how amazing it can be.” I pulled her close and ran my fingers across her lips. “You wanted to make the naughty list. We’ll show you that it is so much better than being nice.”

  She looked away from me and looked at Zach. He was still standing by the table, practically frozen in place. Her stare snapped him out of his stupor and he slowly walked towards us. I took a step back as he approached and watched as the fire raged inside both of them. He took Holly’s hand and I saw goosebumps form on her arm. She wanted to be shared, and her inhibition was slowly fading away. Zach pulled her close and hesitated for a moment, but her lips were begging for his and he didn’t disappoint. As soon as he started to devour her gorgeous lips, I walked over and put my hands on her arms. My lips teased Holly’s neck and I lightly nibbled her earlobe until she started to squirm. There was no way s
he was going to run after that. She was letting her need flourish and it was beautiful.

  “There’s something you should know before this goes any further.” Holly took a deep breath as her lips pulled away from Zach. “When I said I’ve never done anything like this before, I didn’t just mean being with two guys.”

  “You’re a…” Zach’s eyes got wide.

  “A virgin.” I grinned and took a step back. “Well, this is the best Christmas present ever.”

  “That doesn’t bother you?” She looked at me and then turned towards Zach.

  Bother us? No—that just makes tonight even more special than I realized.

  “I really don’t know what to do—and I’m a little terrified of losing my virginity to two guys at the same time.” Holly sighed and looked down at the floor.

  “We will take very good care of you.” I looked at my brother. “Won’t we Zach?”

  “We’ll make it a night you’ll never forget.” Zach took her hands and smiled.

  “Okay.” She swallowed hard and I saw the final lingering hint of concern fade from her eyes.

  Now she belongs to us, and I’m going to enjoy devouring that gorgeous cherry.

  “After tonight, you won’t even remember what it’s like to be a virgin.” I put my hands on her hips and slowly moved them down to cup her ass.

  Zach

  Things spun out of control before I even realized what was happening. I had no intention of encroaching on my twin brother’s girl. I wouldn’t have even followed her in the mall if I realized she was the one he was talking to. I couldn’t stop thinking about the kiss and even a slice of pie didn’t make me stop wishing for something a lot sweeter—the lips that were mine for a second. I did my best to conceal things, but Andy could read me like a book. He saw the way I had to quickly look away anytime my eyes wandered in her direction—he sensed the desires I was struggling to bury. Holly was different than the girls we shared before. She wasn’t just looking to hook up with twins—and she was a virgin. Normally that would have made me want to run in the other direction, but Holly was so enticing I couldn’t imagine pulling away from her if she wanted us both.

  “Are you sure this is what you want?” I brought my lips up to Holly’s ear.

  “Yes.” Holly moaned as Andy’s lips moved up the opposite side her neck and teased her ear.

  The woman in our arms was gorgeous, and we were going to do everything in our power to make sure she enjoyed every second she was with us. I was concerned that she was a virgin, but not enough to stop—nothing could make me stop once I tasted her skin on my lips. She was so fucking delicious that I had to have more. The first kiss was just the beginning. I was already addicted to her lips, and I constantly moved back over to kiss them every opportunity I got. If my lips weren’t there, then Andy was making her gasp for breath with his. I slid my hands up her abdomen and squeezed her tits through the fabric of her dress. They were simply amazing, perfect in my hands, and I could feel her nipples turning into nubs. Andy slid his hand around her back and I heard the zipper of her dress sliding down. Her dress became loose against my fingers, and I pulled it off her shoulders.

  “You’re so fucking beautiful.” I moved my fingers against her exposed abdomen. “We’re going to make you cum so many times tonight.”

  “Oh god.” Holly twinged and moaned.

  Andy unsnapped her bra and I pulled it off immediately. Her tits were just as amazing as I imagined with perfect nipples that called out to my lips. I bent forward and explored her areolas with my tongue. Her nipples were so fucking hard, and she moaned when I rolled my tongue around them. Andy kissed along her shoulder blades, making her squirm between us as his hands went down to her panties. Her dress was still hanging around her hips, but it hit the floor with a flick of his fingers. I moved my hand to her panties and pulled on the front while Andy pulled on the back. My fingers explored the wetness between her thighs. Her panties were soaked. My cock was already engorged, but feeling how wet she was made it throb.

  “I can’t wait to taste this delicious cherry.” I pulled harder on her panties.

  Andy twisted her panties around his fist and ripped them off her hips. The torn fabric quickly fell to the floor and I felt her pussy clench as it fell away. I couldn’t wait another second. I dropped to my knees and started kissing up her thighs. She moaned and rubbed her fingers through my hair as I got closer to the pretty pussy that had never known the kind of pleasure it could truly feel. My tongue slid against her labia and her moans got louder, followed by quick gasps. I pushed into her wetness and tasted her lust—it was like ambrosia on my tongue. I moved my tongue to her clit and felt her nearly collapse against me when she felt the bliss surge through her body. Andy held her steady, continuing to kiss and tease her neck, wrapping his hands around her so that he could squeeze her tits.

  “That feels so good!” Holly’s fingernails dug into my scalp and her head fell back against Andy.

  “We’re just getting started.” He took Holly’s free hand and moved it to his cock. “Don’t you want to unwrap your present? I’ve already unwrapped the best one I’ll ever get.”

  “Yes.” She moaned and started fumbling with the front of his pants.

  Holly pulled away from my tongue and turned towards Andy. She unbuckled his belt and unbuttoned his pants, eagerly going after his cock with a lot more vigor than I expected. I pushed her legs apart and started licking her pussy from behind, thrusting my tongue up into her wetness. She was so fucking tight—her pussy was going to feel amazing on my cock. It was so tight I could barely get my tongue inside her. My dick was throbbing in my pants so hard that I thought it was going to explode if I didn’t free it soon. I heard a groan of satisfaction from Andy and knew he was finally getting some of the relief I craved. Even a touch would have sufficed. It was definitely time to move to the bedroom because I needed to be able to ravage her body with my lips as I prepared her for what was coming. I heard her moan when my tongue was pulled away and I started to stand.

  “Do you miss my tongue already?” I chuckled under my breath as I kissed her neck.

  “Yes.” She nodded quickly and moved her hand along Andy’s shaft.

  “Let’s go to the bedroom.” Andy’s head rolled back and he gasped before her hand finally fell away.

  This is going to be the best night of my fucking life.

  Holly

  I felt the concern I had begin to melt away when I felt their lips on my skin. I knew there was a chance that Andy could charm me out of my panties if I accepted his invitation to Christmas dinner. I never imagined that I would end up between the two of them—being teased and touched like never before. I had no idea that the thought of it would turn me on so much, but my mind was spinning with dirty thoughts once we got to the bedroom. They were both so fucking gorgeous, and as they peeled off their clothes, I got to see their marvelous physiques on full display. I didn’t want to think about what would happen in the future, I just wanted to live in the present where the two men crawling into bed belonged to me. I might only get them for one night, but it would be burned into my memories forever.

  “This delicious cherry is going to be mine until you cum.” Zach slid his hands down my body and started to sink between my thighs.

  “You don’t get to have all the fun.” Andy pressed his lips to my stomach and started kissing down towards my clit.

  Zach pushed his tongue into my pussy and started to slowly thrust it inside me until the tip was pressed against my hymen. Andy used his fingers to expose my clit and started circling it with his tongue. I had never felt anything like that. The combination made the vibrator feel like a tease that could never bring me to climax. Their tongues worked furiously and it was a bliss that I never realized I could experience. Pleasure surged through my veins and I felt a pressure swelling up inside me. I couldn’t tell which tongue I liked better. I had never been penetrated before, and Zach was doing everything he could to make my pussy beg for his cock without
shattering my hymen in the process. Andy’s tongue was on my clit, which had always been my greatest source of pleasure. The combination was intense, but it was euphoric. It wasn’t like the vibrator where I could control the motion and make myself cum. I was at their mercy with a steady rhythm making the build even more intoxicating.

  “That feels really good—please don’t stop!” My back arched against the bed and I gasped.

  They didn’t stop—they started moving their tongues faster. I thought I had tasted the height of bliss, but I was wrong. The increased pace made it even more intense. My body started to squirm on the bed and I dug my nails into Andy’s shoulder while grasping Zach’s hair with my other hand. The pressure continued to swell and it felt like I was going to burst if I didn’t cum soon. It was turning from desire to a gnawing need that tore at me from within. The need was turning ravenous. My muscles got tight and I felt my pussy squeeze on Zach’s tongue, but he forced it inside me with even more vigor. My clit was a hard knot, and every single one of the sensitive nerves were stimulated at the same time underneath Andy’s furiously swirling tongue. I felt like I was seeing for the first time—like a veil I wore my whole life was ripped away in an instant to reveal what kind of splendor the world truly held.

  “Oh fuck.” My hips started to buck against them and I felt the pressure getting so tight I could barely breathe. “I’m gonna cum!”

  My back arched so far I thought I was going to be folded in half. I started to writhe, on the bed, trapped beneath their generous tongues, yet it was the only place I wanted to be. The pressure began to release and it was like lightning bolts exploding in the sky during a violent storm. The thunder raged inside me. I wanted to charge headfirst into the storm and let it consume me. I felt pleasure rushing through my body like currents of electricity that made my hair stand on end while my body trembled. I tasted the edge of bliss and lingered there until their tongues shoved me across the threshold of euphoria. I fell straight into my lust as the cliff of desire welcomed me to my first true orgasm. There was simply no comparison. My muscles tightened so much that my toes curled and my fingers trembled. All I could do was exist at that moment. I wasn’t in control of it, but it was mine—I was in heaven.