Naughty & Nice: A MFM Christmas Romance (Surrender to Them Book 7)

by Kelli Callahan

  “We can afford to spend a little bit of money.” Andy nodded quickly.

  We counted out the kids on the list, looked at their ages, and started picking out toys that appeared to be popular while Holly scrolled through her phone to tell us whether or not the fad for them was over. Fidget spinners were out. Barbie dolls were still in—somehow. Some sort of animatronic baby monkey was popular, so we grabbed a couple of them. Elmo was still popular, so a few dancing ones went into the buggy. I picked out a few Lego sets, Andy grabbed some Star Wars toys, and Holly picked out some Wonder Woman stuff. We found some foam swords along the way and had a quick battle in the aisle before a concerned employee came over to stare menacingly at the three of us. I felt like a kid again, except I could buy anything in the store that I wanted instead of waiting for Santa to deliver it.

  “If we keep going we’re going to need a new buggy.” I pushed mine forward and heard a weak wheel squeak like it was giving up on life—or in need of oil.

  “Yeah, you guys are being more than generous at this point.” Holly chuckled and nodded.

  “Nah, I want to get some more stuff. Let’s go look at the board games.” Andy motioned towards us. “Let’s at least get some gifts that everyone can play with.”

  “We can do better than this—I mean, get them, but let’s go pick up something else too.” I stared at the assortment and nodded.

  “What did you have in mind?” Andy tilted his head inquisitively.

  “Let’s get some gaming systems. They can share those, right?” I shrugged and smiled.

  “We’re about to go way, way over budget.” Andy chuckled and nodded. “Let’s do it.”

  “Kids are going to be begging to get abandoned by their parents so they can live at this orphanage.” Holly shook her head and giggled as she pushed her buggy.

  “Giddy up.” I leaned over and slapped the back of her dress. “You like to race, right?”

  “Ow, hey!” She turned towards me and grimaced.

  “I didn’t hit you that hard.” I raised an eyebrow and chuckled.

  “Oh, she might be a little sore. She made the naughty list earlier today after you left for work.” Andy pushed his buggy ahead of us.

  “You’ve been cheating on me?” I gave Holly a playful nudge.

  “Not really cheating—I mean, he looked just like you.” She feigned surprise and then bit down on her lip. “Don’t worry, you’ll get to put me on the naughty list later too if you want.”

  Fuck, she isn’t making it easy to stop thinking about her.

  We went to the electronics section and our buggies were incredibly overloaded by the time we finished stocking up on gaming systems and the latest games. I felt like we had enough for every kid to have a few presents, plus stuff for the house. As I pushed the buggy further, I suddenly had a thought. Ms. Winters probably wouldn’t be getting anything for Christmas—at least not from the orphans. I thought back to the way she was dressed, the jewelry she wore, and the purse she was carrying. It was all fairly plain, and probably second hand. I had no idea what she would actually like, but after asking a few questions, Holly picked out a nice gift basket for her. I grabbed a gift card for the store to put in it that would at least let her do a little shopping for something nice.

  “Okay, we’re definitely all set now.” Andy nodded and pushed his buggy towards the counter.

  “Now I really do believe you guys are Santa Claus.” Holly giggled and gritted her teeth as she started moving her buggy forward.

  We checked out and after we got to the car, Holly asked how we were going to wrap everything we bought. I groaned as the realization hit me and while a wrapping kiosk would have been nice, it would have required a lot of on-the-spot coordination. I headed back inside and grabbed some wrapping paper, tape, and a package of gift tags. When I walked back towards the SUV, I saw that Andy and Holly were tangled up in an embrace. Their lips were pressed together and there was so much steam coming from them that the windows had started to fog. My brother was definitely in over his head—just like me. It was going to be impossible to simply go home and forget about her.

  “Okay, you two—get a room.” I opened the back door of the SUV.

  “We were going to have one once the windows fogged up.” Andy grinned and wiped his hand across his lips.

  The three of us went back to the house and decided to eat leftovers while we started the process of wrapping gifts. That would have been a terrible way for my brother and I to spend an evening, but it was a lot of fun with Holly there. We told jokes, had a couple of glasses of eggnog—which Andy decided to spike—and were laughing our asses off before everything was wrapped. With the wrapping out of the way, the teasing started, and before I knew what was happening, Holly was naked between us on the couch and our lips were devouring every inch of that gorgeous body. We were definitely headed to the bedroom. I craved her like an addict craves the sting of a needle in their veins. She was pure addiction and I didn’t care.

  Who blindly falls for a woman they just met? I guess that would be me.

  Holly

  “I wish I could stay in bed with the two of you all day.” I reached out and ran my fingernails down Zach’s stomach.

  “Why can’t you?” Zach looked over at me. “Only two days until Christmas and your parents are out of town.”

  “I’m supposed to meet my friend Beth today. Her family is visiting and she needs to get out of the house.” I sighed and sat up. “We’re supposed to exchange Christmas gifts.”

  “Ah.” Zach nodded. “I guess our Mom won’t get her gift until after Christmas.”

  “It’s incredible that you’re skipping Christmas with your parents just to help those orphans.” I wiped a stray hair away from my eyes. “I wish my parents liked the holiday season, but I’m sure the Caribbean is a lot warmer right now.”

  “There’s a balance between liking it and being fucking crazy about it.” Andy sat up and chuckled. “I’d settle for something in the middle.”

  “You can spend Christmas Eve with us if you want—if I wake up next to you, it’ll be the best Christmas present ever.” Zach reached out and took my hand. “I’m sure Andy is itching to redo Christmas dinner all over again.”

  “Fuck that.” Andy rolled his eyes and shook his head. “We’re having takeout for Christmas.”

  “I’ll wear the suit on Christmas Eve if you cook.” Zach looked over at him and grinned.

  “You’re an asshole—fine.” Andy grumbled and slid over to the side of the bed. “I guess I’m going to the fucking grocery store again.”

  “I meant what I said. If your parents are out of town, you should definitely spend the night with us. Santa Claus might even pay you a visit.” Zach nudged me and winked.

  “He has paid me several visits.” I rolled over to the side and nibbled Zach’s ear. “It gets better every time too.”

  “If you keep that up I’m going to be late for work.” Zach gasped and reached back to grab the back of my head.

  “I’m just giving you something to think about while you are at work all day—that’ll make it even better when I see you tonight.” I giggled and pulled back from his ear.

  We drank coffee, ate breakfast, and then I said my temporary goodbye, but that didn’t come without a passionate make-out session with the two of them before I finally made it to my car. I was already craving them as soon as I left their house. I was definitely in over my head because there was no way I was going to be able to forget them once they were gone. I didn’t even want to think about that, even though life was going to pull us in different directions once our holiday vacation was over. I never imagined myself falling for one guy that hard, much less two. The things they did to me was criminal, but I didn’t care. I didn’t even care if lust was what brought us together initially. They were unbelievably good guys, and that was a rarity. Andy might have been rough around the edges, but underneath that bad boy exterior was a heart that deserved to be loved. Zach had struggled with love
in the past, but he was finally ready to embrace it again. I just wished I could be the one who claimed those hearts as my own.

  Later that day

  “Oh my goodness, I love it!” Beth looked like a kid on Christmas morning and nearly started to cry when she saw the ornament. “I thought about buying it myself when I was in the mall the other day, but they were already sold out!”

  “I figured your parents would forget that you wanted this Snow White ornament, or forget until the last minute.” I smiled and nodded.

  “They did, trust me. I mentioned that I might buy it, and my mother told me to go ahead—she’d even wrap it for me.” Beth groaned but immediately started laughing again as she pulled it close to her chest. “Okay, time for you to open your present.”

  I nearly teared up just like Beth when I tore open the box and saw what she got me. It was a memory from childhood, a picture of us when we were kids, hanging out by the treehouse in her backyard. What I didn’t know until she told me the story, was that the frame was actually made from the wood that was used to build the treehouse. Her parents had finally decided to tear it down, and she had someone local create two pictures frames so that we would always have those memories with us. I couldn’t hold back the tears after that. It was incredibly thoughtful and in a way, a symbol of our childhood that would always be so incredibly special to the two of us. We had a lot of good memories in that treehouse and even spent the night there a few times when our parents would agree to it during the summer.

  “This is amazing.” I hugged the picture and smiled through my tears. “You always give me the best presents.”

  “I’m glad you like it. I love mine!” She held out the ornament and stared at it. “They are releasing a new one next year, and the price always gets crazy when they’re discontinued. This is probably the last year I would have been able to get it.”

  “Maybe your parents will actually get you the next one before it goes out of stock.” I grinned and wiped away a few tears.

  “I doubt it.” She groaned and shook her head. “Things are so fucking crazy at home right now. I don’t even want to go back.”

  “Hang out with me then.” I leaned back against the couch and shrugged. “It’s not like I’m doing anything.”

  Not until much later tonight at least…

  “Do you want to go to the mall and stalk Santa Claus, or did you decide to give up on that after realizing he had a girlfriend?” Beth giggled and turned towards me on the couch.

  “He doesn’t have a girlfriend.” I shook my head back and forth. “He was buying a present for his Mom.”

  “Wait—hold on.” Beth leaned forward and grabbed my arm as her head tilted to the side inquisitively. “What haven’t you told me?”

  I couldn’t keep the secret from Beth, and truthfully, I needed to tell someone. It felt like a dream until I said the words out loud. Her mouth fell open in shock when I told her about meeting Andy—and her jaw was rolling across the floor when she found out he had a twin brother named Zach. I hadn’t even gotten to the good part yet, and she was already speechless. Once I told her that I went to their house—and ended up in bed with them both, I thought her eyes were going to bulge out of her head. I understood because I was still floating on a cloud myself, unsure if it was just some fantasy I cooked up, or the best reality imaginable. Talking about it let me bring all of that into focus, even if it did leave Beth with a dumbfounded stare on her face once I was done telling her everything.

  “You—you lost your virginity—to two guys?” She stammered over her words as she spoke.

  “I did.” I nodded and I couldn’t suppress the grin on my face.

  “That’s so fucking scandalous! I didn’t know you had it in you!” Her shocked expression finally shifted to a half-smile. “Wow!”

  “I didn’t know it myself until I met Andy and Zach. They really are amazing. I wish you could meet them.” I sighed and shrugged. “Unfortunately, it’ll probably be nothing more than a holiday fling once I head back to school.”

  “That sucks because they really do sound awesome.” She leaned back against the couch, still shaking her head in surprise. “I’ve never even considered something like that, and I thought I was the freaky one.”

  I left out a few details that would clinch that title, but I can’t share the most intimate moments—I’ve already said more than I’ll ever admit to anyone else.

  “I guess I’m finally coming out of my shell.” I nodded quickly.

  “You definitely are.” She giggled and nodded. “I’m going to have to put a leash on you next year! Who knows how many guys you will end up fucking!”

  Beth and I continued talking for a while, and she made several jokes at my expense, but they were all in good fun. We decided to watch a movie, and I found one that starred Andy and Zach’s grandfather. The family resemblance was there, especially in those ocean-blue eyes. You could tell that he truly enjoyed being Santa Claus and it wasn’t just a chore to put on the suit. I had started to see that same glimmer in Zach’s eyes. He might end up following the family tradition, even if he didn’t expect it initially. After the movie, Beth had so many missed messages from home that she had to dive back into the chaos. I stretched out on the couch for a little bit and then realized that I probably needed to go to the mall.

  If Zach and Andy do get me something, I should at least have something that I can give them in return.

  The mall was so packed that I could barely move through the crowd, and I considered going somewhere with fewer shoppers on a mad dash for last minute items, but I really wanted to go to Things Remembered. It was cheesy to get them something sentimental, especially after our short time together, but I wanted them to know that I cared about them. It might be nothing more than a fond memory, but I didn’t care. I looked around the store until I found a snow globe that had a mall Santa in it, surrounded by kids. I grabbed two globes and had the girl behind the counter engrave Sometimes it’s Nice to be Naughty on the front of them. She gave me a bewildered look but did as I requested. I was ready to go, but I couldn’t help swinging by the middle of the mall to see if Santa Claus was in his chair.

  Hmm, his break is coming up—maybe I can stick around long enough to say hello.

  I headed to the car and dropped off the snow globes because I didn’t want to risk him seeing them before Christmas morning. When I got back, he was already gone from the chair, and I was afraid I wasn’t going to get to see him. It took some convincing, but the guard near the back part of the mall eventually let me in once I told him that Zach was one of my friends. I turned the corner to the dressing area and saw him removing the beard. He twisted the top off a bottle of water and guzzled some of it before turning around to see me. His face immediately lit up and he extended his arms as I approached.

  “A personal visit?” He hugged me as tight as he could.

  “I was in the neighborhood.” I looked up at him and grinned.

  I’ll never get tired of seeing those gorgeous eyes light up when they see me.

  Zach

  “There are too many eyes out here. Come with me.” I grabbed Holly by the hand and led her to towards one of the secluded areas.

  It had been a pretty normal day outside of being incredibly busy. The manager was losing his mind because we weren’t able to see all the kids that wanted to spend time with Santa Claus, but there wasn’t much I could do about that. The manager was more concerned with the money the made from selling photographs than holiday cheer. The elves were trying to rush the kids, but they weren’t having any of it, which was humorous to watch at times. I was surprised there were so many that still hadn’t made it see Santa since it was so close to Christmas. If Santa really did have a workshop in the North Pole, the poor elves would have never been able to put together that many last minute lists. The mall drama could wait though, because I had the most beautiful visitor in the world, and I wasn’t going to let her leave without tasting her lips one time.

  “Thi
s is good. Sorry, the mall manager freaks out if he sees people back here, and—I definitely want more than a hug.” I grinned and pulled Holly close.

  Kissing Holly was always a slice of heaven. I crushed her pouty lips beneath mine and began to ravage her mouth with my tongue. She made me temporarily forget about my duties, or where we were, and my hands quickly began to explore her gorgeous curves. We were out of sight, so it was safe to kiss her, but I wanted more than that. After our tongues intertwined and my cock started getting hard, I stopped thinking rationally. I pulled Holly towards one of the storage rooms that they used to store holiday decorations. I was afraid it would be locked, but it wasn’t. Once we were behind closed doors, I started kissing her neck and pushed my hands under her shirt so I could squeeze her tits.

  “We can’t do this—not here.” Holly gasped and started to squirm in my arms. “You have to stop.”

  “I don’t want to stop.” I kissed her neck with more ferocity. “I want you.”

  “I just came to say hello—we have to wait until tonight.” Holly moaned and even though her words were trying to show resistance, her body definitely wasn’t.

  “No.” I unbuttoned the front of her jeans.

  “Oh god.” She moaned louder when I pushed my hand into her panties and started rubbing her pussy.

  “You’re so fucking wet. You want this as much as I do.” I slid a finger into her wetness and felt her shudder.

  “It’s not about what I want.” She gasped and leaned against my shoulder. “You’re going to get fired if someone catches us.”

  “They’re not going to fire Santa on the day before Christmas Eve.” I pulled my hand away and turned her toward the shelves. “We’ll just have to be quick.”

  Holly grabbed the bars on the shelves and moaned when I started sliding her jeans down her hips. I squeezed her ass and rubbed her pussy a few more times before shoving my pants down to my ankles. I wanted her too bad. I wrapped a hand around her thigh, lowered my boxers, and shoved my cock into her pussy. She nearly screamed when she felt me go in, and she was so fucking tight that I immediately started to groan. We didn’t have much time, but that wasn’t going to stop me. I had to have her. I needed her. I started to thrust and I heard gasps rushing from her throat. I was caught up in the moment before I even thought about the fact we didn’t have protection, but I couldn’t stop once her pussy started squeezing my cock.