Careless Love

by Robinson, Peter

  ‘What did you find in the room?’

  ‘Nothing of interest. She shared a house with three other students, communal living and eating areas and each with their own bedroom-cum-study. It was just as you’d expect a student’s room to be. A bit messy, discarded jeans and T-shirts and stuff scattered about, books, piles of paper and research material. But it was basically well ordered. No sign of handbag or shoulder bag there, either.’ Blackstone paused. ‘There was another odd thing, too, though.’

  ‘Yes?’

  ‘Her mobile. It was still in her room. It was quite an expensive new model, too. A ten or something. I mean, have you ever known a teenager who doesn’t pick up her mobile first thing when she goes out anywhere?’

  ‘Tracy certainly does,’ said Banks. ‘I can only think of one who didn’t, and that’s Adrienne Munro.’

  ‘Your dead girl in the car?’

  ‘Yes.’

  Banks finished his pie and washed it down with some IPA. The other similarities with the Adrienne Munro case weren’t lost him. She was also a second-year student, dressed for an occasion, found dead in an out-of-the-way spot. Only the way it looked, Adrienne had committed suicide and Sarah Chen had been murdered. The timing was also curious. Nobody Banks or Blackstone had spoken to so far knew exactly when either girl had been seen last, but it appeared that they had disappeared around the same time. The weekend before last. Saturday.

  ‘So apart from the superficial similarities, why am I here?’ Banks asked. ‘Not that I’m complaining.’

  Blackstone smiled. ‘I was just coming to that.’ He reached for his briefcase, and passed a photograph and a torn-off slip of paper protected by a plastic cover over to Banks. The photograph showed a smiling, beautiful Sarah in full bloom. It was easy to see her different ethnic characteristics, and how they helped form her particular kind of beauty. Blackstone tapped the slip of paper. ‘We found this on the desk in her room.’

  Written on the slip were a name and a telephone number. The name was Adrienne Munro, but the telephone number wasn’t hers.

  9

  Dr Anthony Randall’s house formed quite a contrast to Adele Balter’s and Annie’s tiny cottages, though it wasn’t quite as large and ostentatious as Rivendell. Nor was it built in the art deco style. It was an old detached house of brick and stone with mullioned windows and a slate roof, surrounded by a couple of acres of garden dotted with trees, all enclosed by a moss-covered wall. It was probably a listed building, and perhaps at one time had belonged to the lord of the manor. Dr Randall clearly didn’t restrict his duties to NHS work.

  Neither Annie nor Gerry had phoned Dr Randall to let him know they were coming. They wanted the element of surprise, so they had to be prepared for his being out. The sight of the BMW parked in the semicircular driveway by the front door seemed to indicate that he was at home, however. Gerry had told Annie that Randall was a cardiothoracic surgeon, not a GP, and that he was sixty-five years old and divorced. The rest they would find out when they talked to him.

  They parked the car in the street, opened the heavy wrought-iron gate and walked around the drive. There seemed to be no doorbell, so Annie banged the brass lion’s-head door knocker.

  A few moments later, the door was opened by a tall, rangy man with a shock of curly grey hair, wearing a V-neck jumper over a white shirt unbuttoned at the throat, and grey trousers with creases sharp enough to cut yourself on. His bushy eyebrows were raised in a questioning arch. Annie and Gerry introduced themselves and flashed their warrant cards. Randall managed to look put out as he gave up his precious time and led them through a cavernous hall into a large sitting room. There was no decorative fireplace, but the room was warm enough without. Most of the furniture seemed antique to Annie, except for the three-piece suite, which was far too comfortable to be old. The doctor offered no refreshments or small talk, but simply sat at the edge of his armchair with his hands clasped on his lap as if he were about to head off somewhere at any moment and said, ‘What do you want with me? You’ll have to be quick. I don’t have much time.’

  ‘Busy surgery?’

  ‘As a matter of fact, it’s a private consultation.’

  ‘Ah,’ said Annie. ‘We’ll try to be as quick as we can, then, sir. Have you been following the news?’ Annie asked.

  ‘If I had, I wouldn’t be asking what you want, I assume. Anyway, I’m afraid not. I’ve been away at a conference in Malta for the past week.’

  Nice for some, Annie thought. Why couldn’t the police training college run courses in Malta instead of Hendon? ‘Then I’m afraid we have some bad news for you, Dr Randall.’

  ‘It’s Mr,’ said Randall, ‘but no matter. What’s wrong?’

  ‘Sorry, my mistake. I’m afraid a friend of yours has been found dead. At least we think he was a friend. Laurence Hadfield?’

  Randall flopped back in his chair, rather theatrically, Annie thought. ‘Larry? Dead? Good Lord. That’s a shock, all right.’

  ‘So he was a friend of yours?’ Annie asked.

  ‘Yes, indeed, I’d say he was. To the extent that we played golf together frequently and enjoyed a convivial pint in a local hostelry every now and then. Larry also handled some of my investments, though they were rather small fish compared to his usual fare. I can’t understand this. As far as I know he was in good health. What on earth happened to him?’

  ‘We don’t rightly know yet,’ said Annie. ‘His body was found at the bottom of a gully on Tetchley Moor last Wednesday, skull fractured and neck broken as if from a fall, but we weren’t able to identify him until Friday.’

  Randall frowned. ‘Bottom of a gully. I don’t understand. Was it some sort of accident?’

  ‘It very much looks like an accident,’ Annie replied.

  ‘But we’re not ruling out anything at the moment,’ Gerry added, glancing up from her notebook. ‘And we’ve no idea what he was doing there or how he got there. Can you help us at all with that?’

  ‘Me?’ Randall shook his head slowly. ‘I’m afraid not. It sounds like a tragic accident.’

  ‘The thing is,’ Gerry went on, ‘Mr Hadfield was wearing a suit and tie, and there was no sign of a car. We were also wondering if you could help us in regard to his movements over the past while?’

  Randall ignored Gerry and kept looking at Annie as he spoke. ‘As I said, I’ve been away in Malta. From last Tuesday until this Saturday, as a matter of fact. Valetta. You can check, of course, if you feel it necessary.’

  ‘Thank you,’ said Annie, ‘but I shouldn’t think it will come to that.’

  ‘Just in case, though, sir,’ Gerry said, smiling, ‘would you give me the name of the conference and the hotel where it was held?’

  Randall looked from one to the other, his face reddening slightly. ‘Of course,’ he said, and gave out the details more slowly than necessary for Gerry to write them down. He was treating her as if she were thick, Annie thought.

  ‘Thank you, sir,’ said Gerry.

  Randall smirked. ‘What is this? Good cop, bad cop?’

  ‘Sir?’ said Gerry.

  ‘I don’t know what you mean,’ Annie said. ‘Who’s playing bad cop? We’re simply doing our job.’

  ‘I didn’t mean to be disparaging. It’s just that you seem quite polite and friendly, whereas your sidekick over there interrupts with rather rude implications.’

  ‘Sidekick? Implications?’ Gerry said. ‘What exactly have I implied?’

  ‘That I have something to hide. That I may have to provide an alibi.’

  ‘I assure you it’s just routine,’ said Gerry.

  ‘Do you?’ Annie asked.

  ‘What?’

  ‘Have something to hide. Need an alibi.’

  ‘I’ve told you where I was.’

  ‘Ah,’ said Gerry, ‘but we haven’t told you when Mr Hadfield died. All we said was he was found last Wednesday. I mean, it would be no use you telling us you were in Malta last Tuesday, say, if he was killed last Monday, would it
?’

  ‘Was killed?’ Randall glanced at Annie again, his eyes narrowing. ‘Are you telling me now he was murdered? You said it was an accident.’

  ‘I said it looks like an accident, sir. It was you who called it a “tragic accident”.’

  ‘In our experience,’ Gerry added, ‘almost anything can look like an accident.’

  ‘Who’s asking you?’ Randall shifted in his chair. ‘Do I need to call my solicitor?’ he asked Annie.

  Annie was starting to regard Gerry in a new light. At first, they hadn’t got on at all, then they had managed to build a few bridges, but now she was beginning to seem like a natural. They hadn’t agreed on a strategy for interviewing Randall, but had planned to play it by ear. That clearly suited Gerry. Annie decided to let things follow the course they were on for the moment rather than trying to placate Randall’s ruffled feelings.

  ‘Now, why would you need a solicitor?’ she asked. ‘You haven’t done anything wrong, have you? We certainly haven’t charged you with anything.’

  ‘It’s just the way this interrogation is going.’

  ‘It’s just an interview, sir,’ said Gerry. ‘Not an interrogation. We’re just here to talk to you. There’s nothing to be afraid of.’

  ‘I’m not afraid, damn you, I—’ Randall took a deep breath and clearly held his anger in check. ‘I am not afraid,’ he repeated with hushed fury. ‘I simply want to avoid being tricked into saying something I would regret.’

  ‘I don’t know what you mean,’ said Annie. ‘Why would you do that? I mean regret saying something. What do you think you have to say that you would regret?’

  ‘Look,’ Randall growled, ‘can we just get on with it and get it over with? I’m a busy man.’

  ‘Of course, sir,’ said Annie, with a pointed glance at Gerry that clearly discomfited Randall even further. ‘So far we’ve gathered that you were a friend of Laurence Hadfield’s, that you had financial dealings with him, and that you have been out of the country at a medical conference from Tuesday last week until the Saturday just past. Am I right?’

  ‘A world cardiology conference,’ Randall said. ‘I was giving a paper.’

  ‘So you’re a heart doctor, then?’ Gerry commented.

  ‘A cardiothoracic surgeon.’

  ‘Got it.’ Gerry made a scribble in her notebook.

  Randall pointed to Gerry and said to Annie, ‘I don’t think she’s taking me seriously.’

  ‘Oh, I assure you, she is, sir. It’s one of the first rules we learn, to take everyone seriously, especially the professional classes. That way we can avoid misunderstandings later.’

  ‘Later? What misunderstandings?’

  ‘Well, if there is a later,’ Annie explained. ‘You know. Court. Solicitors. Judges. Stuff like that. The CPS are very strict about us getting all our ducks in a row.’

  Randall sighed. ‘Can we please get this over with?’

  ‘Of course. Hearts to bypass and all that. Won’t be a jiffy,’ Annie went on. ‘The main reason we’re here is that you phoned Laurence Hadfield three times on the day we believe he disappeared.’ She glanced at Gerry. ‘You have the details, don’t you, DC Masterson?’

  ‘Yes, ma’am. Three fifty-nine, eight-o-two and eleven twenty-six. All p.m.’

  ‘Can you perhaps tell us why you called Mr Hadfield and what you talked about?’

  ‘I’ve told you. Larry was a friend. What’s so odd about ringing up a friend?’

  ‘On that quiz show, were you, sir?’ Gerry said, grinning. ‘Needed help with a tricky question?’

  Randall ignored her.

  ‘Well, as far as we know,’ Annie went on, ‘those were the only phone calls Mr Hadfield received that day. Can you remember what you talked about?’

  ‘Not especially. Plans for a round of golf the following day, I think, a new investment opportunity. Something of that sort.’

  ‘The next day would have been Sunday, right?’ Annie pressed on.

  ‘It usually comes after Saturday.’

  ‘I don’t believe I mentioned that we think Mr Hadfield disappeared on Saturday.’

  ‘You didn’t,’ said Randall, smirking again. ‘But I remember the day I last spoke with him. It was Saturday. A week last Saturday. I’m sure his telephone records will confirm that.’

  ‘Oh, they do,’ said Annie. ‘They just don’t tell us what you talked about. You mentioned golf on Sunday.’

  ‘Yes. We arranged to play. A foursome. We had the round booked at my club.’

  ‘And that would be, sir?’ Gerry asked.

  ‘Lyndgarth’, Randall said, in a tone that was clearly meant to impress her.

  ‘Did Mr Hadfield turn up?’ asked Annie.

  ‘Well, no, as a matter of fact, he didn’t.’

  ‘Did he phone to apologise or explain his absence?’

  ‘No, he didn’t.’

  ‘So what did you do?’

  ‘Got another member to make up the foursome.’

  ‘Weren’t you worried?’

  ‘Why should I be?’

  ‘Well, you’d talked to your friend three times the day before about a round of golf the following day, and he didn’t show up. I mean, I’d be a bit worried, wouldn’t you DC Masterson?’

  ‘I would, ma’am,’ said Gerry.

  ‘Did he say he was ill when you talked on Saturday?’ Annie pressed on. ‘Did he sound depressed or anything?’

  ‘No. Of course not. We’re grown men. Busy men. Things come up that need urgent attention. Are you now trying to suggest that Larry committed suicide, with all your talk of depression?’

  ‘I don’t think so,’ said Annie. ‘But it’s a theory. I was simply wondering if there was anything in his tone or in what he said to you on Saturday that caused you to think he might have a reason for not turning up for a prearranged golf game the following day. That’s all.’

  ‘No, there wasn’t.’

  ‘Do you know where he was when you phoned him?’

  ‘At home. He said he was working. What does it matter?’

  ‘Did he like playing golf?’ Gerry asked.

  ‘Of course he liked playing golf.’

  ‘Did you phone him to ask what was wrong?’ Annie asked. ‘On Sunday?’

  ‘I . . . er . . . no, I didn’t.’

  ‘May I ask why not?

  ‘You may, but I’m afraid I can’t really tell you. And I’m not hiding anything. Don’t read anything into it. There just wasn’t any particular reason. I suppose it never crossed my mind that something might be wrong.’

  ‘Why would it?’ Annie agreed. ‘If Mr Hadfield was in good health.’ She glanced at Gerry, who put her notebook away. ‘We should go now, DC Masterson, and leave Mr Randall to his important business.’

  Randall didn’t accompany them to the door, but Gerry turned around before they left, ‘Sorry to do a Columbo on you, sir,’ she said, ‘but I’m curious about the third time you rang Mr Hadfield. That was at eleven twenty-six on Saturday night, and you got no answer. It seems very late to be calling someone, especially if you can’t remember why. Was that normal?’

  ‘Well, I’d hardly say it was abnormal. Not everyone clocks off at five, you know.’

  ‘You didn’t think he might have gone to bed?’

  ‘I can’t say I thought about it much at all.’

  ‘Bye, Mr Randall,’ said Annie, taking Gerry’s elbow. ‘And thanks for your time. We’ll be seeing you.’

  Before the bewildered doctor could respond, Annie ushered Gerry out. ‘You bloody minx,’ she said with a grin as they walked down the drive to the car. ‘Like to tell me what you think you were up to back there? Better still. Tell me over a drink. After all, it’ll be five when we get back to Eastvale. Clocking-off time.’ They laughed as Annie started the car.

  Banks hadn’t been expecting to spend his afternoon tramping across damp grass, so his choice of footwear could have been better. Fortunately, the ground wasn’t too waterlogged, and the paths they occasionally
found were either cinder or gravel.

  ‘No chance of any trace evidence surviving out in the open after so long,’ said Blackstone. ‘The team’s done their best, but there’s nothing so far. Just a lot of rubbish from inside the bothy to sort through. As you can see, it’s not actually that far off the B road, so someone could easily have pulled into a lay-by, dragged Sarah, or chased her to the bothy and killed her, or killed her first and then carried her body there. It’s not a busy road, so it could have been done almost anytime, but common sense suggests it was probably after dark. And we think she was killed inside the bothy. The doc says there’d have been quite a lot of blood from a head wound, and that matches what we found there.’

  ‘If she was killed in the bothy,’ said Banks, ‘then surely there must be prints? His and hers?’

  ‘We’re still working on it, but the surfaces are hardly ideal. Rough-hewn stone and rotten old wood.’

  ‘Fair enough.’

  The small stone bothy, basically a free shelter for anyone who needed it, stood just off the path and was surrounded by crime-scene tape. The body had been taken away, of course, but a constable stood on guard and a couple of CSI officers were still going over the place, which was just an empty shell with a dirt floor and no windows. You’d have to be pretty desperate for shelter if you were willing to spend a night there, Banks thought. Still, there were dozens of these places all over the north; you saw them on walks and from roads, all in various states of disrepair. They had once been used for storage or shelter by groundsmen or gardeners on the large estates, now divided up into smaller farms. Most of them were uninhabitable, with missing roof slabs, doors or caved-in walls, and this one was no exception.

  The area on the floor where the body had lain was marked out, and the CSIs told them to avoid the spots where little flags had been placed. Banks was content to stand in the doorway and look in, not wanting to disturb anything. It smelled of urine and rotten vegetation. What a place to die, he thought, trying to imagine the poor girl’s last thoughts and impressions. Had she fought desperately for her life? Had she not even seen the end coming? Had she perhaps been drugged first? Why had she gone to such a place, and with whom? And how did she know Adrienne Munro?