Crazy Twisted Love (Crazy Love Series Book 3)

by MF Isaacs

  Jimmy started to walk away from the group but I quickly followed him. Without even looking at me, he knew I was beside him, “Why did you do that? And don’t tell me it’s because you want to play soccer.”

  “Okay I won’t. I did it because I miss you.” I could practically hear the whoosh of air as he whipped his head around to look at me. The look was a question that he didn’t need to speak out loud, the look asked if I was crazy.

  “I’m not having this conversation with you right here, right now. I don’t know what you think is going to happen, but I can tell you right now whatever you think, it’s wrong.” Again, he tried to walk away and again I followed him.

  “Can we at least go somewhere else and talk about it?” I could hear the desperation in my own voice. In a flash of sobriety, I realized my desperation sounded like Cody. I could vividly hear him begging my sister to take him back. It was the day before he killed her and my parents. The day he scared the shit out of our whole family and Sophia refused to let us step in. I couldn’t wait for Jimmy to answer, I had to get out of there.

  I couldn’t drive, but I could run. I knew Sierra was mad because I didn’t pick her and Hannah up for the party, but I also knew she wouldn’t turn her back on me. I think she could take one look at me and know I just needed her support. I ran to her dorm, where I used my own key to get in since she didn’t answer when I knocked. Her empty room was explained in a text message from Steve letting me know that she and Hannah were safe in our room back at the frat house. I didn’t bother responding, instead I clumsily stripped down to my boxers and crawled into Sierra’s bed for the night.

  I didn’t go out of my way to avoid Jimmy, but I also didn’t go seeking him out either. The following Thursday night, I got a text asking if I was going to fill in for the soccer game. I responded that I would, but just for the one game. He sent me the details and that was all I heard from him until the Sunday game.

  Uncomfortable with more than just the idea of playing soccer for the first time, I invited Sierra to come watch. She is more observant than she lets people believe, which could be a good thing in this situation. It’s not that I want to talk about what is going on, but quite frankly it scared me when I realized I sounded like Cody. I know Sierra loves me more than anyone else does and that won’t change if I tell her everything. Shit, I’ve told her more than I should have at this point. She knows Jimmy and I have swapped girls and shared girls so this might just be the next progression, or not.

  I dropped my gear bag next to Sierra and made my way down onto the indoor turf. A few of the guys were already stretching, including Jimmy. I quickly fell in step with them warming up my legs. Everyone but Jimmy took off to run a few laps, I hung back with him. Neither of us spoke, until we started on our own laps. He spoke first, “Before you say anything, I need you to know that I met someone. She is amazing and I am not willing to risk my relationship with her to talk about what may or may not have been with you.”

  I think I tripped on thin air, because before I could formulate a response I was face first on the turf. I did not expect to hear him say that. He met someone, someone being a female. What the hell? He put out his hand to help me up but I managed on my own. My thoughts are racing a million miles an hour but before said anything he closed the door on me. “I can’t share her with you. I know that is what you’re thinking, but stop. It won’t happen.”

  I stayed silent the remainder of our warm up laps. I was so lost in my head that I hardly even noticed that I was playing a team sport again for the first time in years. I didn’t even allow myself the opportunity to miss my parents being in the stands. I played better than I thought I would, given how long it had been. Several of the guys invited Sierra and me to lunch after the game, which she quickly accepted.

  The group of us were already sitting around a huge banquet size table when Jimmy walked in holding hands with the prettiest woman I have ever seen. She was tall and curvier than what I normally would find attractive. I wouldn’t consider her fat, but I imagine she probably thought she was. She looked like she just stepped out of a salon, her long dark hair had the most natural looking highlights. Her pale skin was perfect, I knew she had makeup on but it wasn’t caked on; she didn’t need it. Her eyes were what drew me in the most, they were dark brown and looked like chocolate. When Jimmy introduced Shelley to the group, it became apparent that she was new to everyone not just me.

  Shelley and Jimmy took the seats directly across for Sierra and me. I observed silently as Sierra visited with Shelley and Jimmy made small talk with a few of the other guys. Listening to the girls talk, I learned that Jimmy and Shelley went to High School together but didn’t start dating until recently. They both grew up less than a half hour away, which is where she still lives. She appeared shy but Sierra managed to get her talking by asking all the right questions. Shelley had a huge crush on Jimmy throughout High School, so when he looked her up on Facebook over the summer, she ditched her girlfriends at the opportunity to hang out with him.

  I could feel Jimmy looking at me but I couldn’t make eye contact. I couldn’t mask the thoughts flooding my system. I couldn’t stop the roller coaster from twisting and turning. When our food arrived, I was the first one to finish eating. Sierra was still picking at her food when I told her it was time to go. She quickly made her way around the table and gave Shelley a warm embrace, telling her how nice it was to meet her. My sister is like me, she doesn’t make friends with people easily. So to see her hug Shelley like they have been friends forever, made the whole situation hurt just a little more.

  I walked away from the table knowing that there would never be a chance for Jimmy and me to reconnect. Whatever could have been between us, wasn’t anymore. In that moment, I knew I had to move on with my life.

  One Week Later

  My world changed while standing on the street corner waiting for the crosswalk to change. Sierra, Steve, Calvin, Hannah and I were heading to meet up with Norma and Alfred to tail gate before the away football game for Western State when a group joined us at the crosswalk. I don’t know who started the conversation first, but it was apparent, looking at me with the others in my group, that I was odd man out. In hindsight, I know it was Will who made the comment that there was a vacancy in their group if I wanted to join them.

  We were all headed in the same direction so the conversation continued until we made it to the waiting motor-home. Jay introduced himself to me first, telling me he was their bonus friend. Will introduced himself and Callie before Rich introduced himself and Marissa. Marissa broke the ice even further and explained that she and Rich are married but have an open relationship which is where Jay comes into play sometimes. By the time we arrived at the motor-home, Alfred already had the grill going and quickly invited my new friends to join us. I continued getting to know the group as we ate more food than anyone could possibly need.

  They invited me to join them in their open seating section for the game. I could see that Steve was wrapped up in Hannah and Calvin had Sierra covered so I didn’t think twice about ditching them in favor of the group of people I’d just met. Throughout the game, I spent most of the time talking with Will; we had the most in common. Just looking at him, it was clear he spent as much time in the gym as I did and he wasn’t shy about being openly affectionate with Callie. More than once I watched as he pawed her ass or caressed her tit as he kissed her, while making eye contact with me. Each time, I was forced to adjust myself so it wasn’t obvious to the crowd that watching them was turning me on. He saw me and it was clear I didn’t need to hide it from him.

  When the game ended, I touched base with Steve to make sure he had Sierra covered before I quickly agreed to head out with Will and Callie. I didn’t care where we were going, I didn’t even care if Rich, Jay, and Marissa were coming too; I just knew I wasn’t ready to walk away from them yet.

  Turns out that they all live in the same apartment complex not far from the stadium. Jay has a studio to himself. Marissa an
d Rich have a ground floor unit that looks across the courtyard towards Jay’s unit. Callie and Will have the unit directly above Marissa and Rich. Which is where Will was headed as Marissa wished us a good night before closing the door to their unit. Callie was directly behind Will. As they started up the stairs she reached out for my hand, showing me that they wanted me to follow them.

  Once inside their apartment, I was instantly impressed with their set up. It was clear they weren’t your normal broke college kids; their furniture was quality and clearly expensive. The living room was decorated nicely with a large leather sectional that took up most of the room. Callie asked if I wanted a beer as she made her way into the kitchen. I accepted before asking where I could find the bathroom. Will told me it was down the hall as he got comfortable in the middle seat of the couch. I watched him from behind the couch briefly before heading down the hall. I couldn’t make out everything he was doing but it appeared to me from where I was standing, that he freed his cock and was stroking it.

  I stayed in the bathroom longer than I needed, trying to get myself under control. I didn’t want to walk out there with any expectations, but I also wasn’t going to hide the obvious excitement I had straining in my pants. I could hear them before I could see them and there was no mistaking the sounds of their actions. As I made my way into the living room, I just watched as she shamelessly took pleasure from riding him. She saw me from the corner of her eye which caused her motion to falter. She slowed as Will spoke, “Come watch.”

  Her gaze followed me as I walked all the way into the room. I made my way to the far side of the couch, where I adjusted myself before sitting down. Will was busy sucking as much of her tit into his mouth as he could. I wasn’t sure if he heard her when she told me, “Play with yourself while you watch.”

  I had my dick in my hand within seconds. As soon as I had him free, I took the time to strip off all my clothes. With my legs spread wide I slowly stroked myself as I watched her ride him as he watched her and she watched me. I followed her directions without reservation or concern for what Will wanted, “Come closer so I can see better.”

  I stood just out of her reach as I slowly stroked myself. Will had released his suction on her tit and was using his hands to caress them. Callie looked up at me through her lashes, never stopping the motion of her hips. There was no missing the precum that poured from my straining cock. It was Will who told Callie and me what to do, “Move closer. Callie taste him.” his directions were short and breathless, but it didn’t stop either of us from following them. As soon as I was within her reach, she cupped her tongue as she swept it along my leaking slit. She swallowed before opening her mouth for more, carefully she kissed the tip of my cock using her lips, teeth and tongue. The kiss sent instant shivers down my spine; there was nothing I could do to stop the thrusting of my hips as I desperately wanted further into her mouth. She gave me exactly what I wanted when she opened wide, allowing me to hit the back of her throat in one thrust. I could hear Will smacking her ass, but I couldn’t pull my eyes away from her mouth as she took as much of me as she could. She gagged but didn’t stop, it was impossible for me to stay silent as she sucked me so good. “Holy shit, oh fuck yeah. Just like that.”

  Within minutes I was ready to unleash in her mouth. I know she could feel the swelling of my already fat cock, along with the constant flow of precum. Before I could unleash fully, she released me from her perfect fucking mouth. There was nothing I could do to stop the whimper that escaped me at the loss of her mouth. She continued to stroke me, which felt good, but nowhere near as good as her fucking mouth. But when she looked at me through her lashes, I quickly forgot the disappointment I felt moments ago. With her swollen lips and fuck me eyes, I almost shot my load when she told me, “I want you to cum on my ass.”

  I darted a quick glance at Will to make sure I wasn’t crossing any boundaries they might have. With a quick nod, he gave me the go ahead that I needed to move behind her as I straddled Will’s legs. I used my hardness to smack her on the ass leaving a trail of my dripping wetness behind in its path. I held my breath as I watched her dip her middle finger into her tightest hole. Will must have felt the pressure, because he used one hand on each ass cheek to pull her open. Without warning, I lost my load, spurt after spurt all over her ass just like she wanted. I watched in awe as the two of them spread my seed all over her ass, using it as lube for his finger to join hers.

  Without hesitation, he spanked her ass and instructed her to flip over. I took a half a step back as she followed his instructions. Facing me she hovered over his pussy drenched cock and slowly lowered her ass. She started to lose her balance, so I held her steady as she continued working until he was fully seated. As soon as she took him in completely, she let go of my hold so she could use one hand to play with her nipples and the other to play with her pussy. Seriously, the hottest fucking thing I have ever seen. I didn’t hold back on telling them exactly that, “So fucking hot. Watching him fuck you in the ass while you play with your pretty pussy. Oh fuck yeah, I can smell your pussy from here.”

  “You want to taste her? Go ahead, she tastes better than she smells. Let him taste you Callie.” I didn’t need any further encouragement. I was on my knees between their legs before either of them could change their mind. Normally I would swipe my tongue ass to clit, but since her ass is already full I started at the bottom of her folds. It wasn’t until I was on my third bottom to clit swipe did I realize my stubble covered chin was brushing against Will’s balls. I didn’t let it distract me from my mission to make her cum on my mouth.

  Her orgasm hit without much effort. The result, I am sure, of having Will in her ass and groping her tits as I went to town eating her pussy. I lapped up every last drop of her release before backing away from her still twitching folds. As I sat back on my heels, she begged us both, “Please fuck me, both of you. I want you both. Curtis fuck my pussy while he’s fucking my ass.” One more quick glance at Will to make sure he’s still okay with what is happening, I could see that he’s lost in his own pleasure, eyes closed head tilted back. I paused for a half a second before she pleaded, “Please Curtis.”

  I scrambled for the condom I had in my wallet and had it on before she could beg again. I slid my condom covered cock between her folds until she made eye contact with me and said “Yes, fuck me.” It was all I needed; Will was still lost in his own world of pleasure. As soon as I inched my way inside her slick folds Will’s eyes popped open locking with mine.

  We just stared at each other for a second before I told him, “She begged me man” my eyes rolled from the pleasure and it took effort to look at him as I continued to tell him, “Please don’t make me stop, I’m balls deep and she feels fucking amazing.” We were alternating our thrusting, he pulled out as I thrust in, neither sensation felt better; both were amazing. Even with the condom on I could feel the ridges of his cock along with the already amazing feel of her pussy. He didn’t tell me to stop, so I continued with the most amazing sex of my life. I could feel her orgasm approaching and there was no way I would be able to maintain once it hit. “Give it to us Callie, I can feel you pulsing. I can feel you, oh fuck yeah. Oh shit, I’m gonna cum too.” She started the chain reaction of massive proportions. Before I could hold the condom in place as I pulled out I could feel wetness on my balls. With three of us there, I couldn’t be certain whose fluids they were. I inspected the condom as I removed it, I felt relief seeing that it was still fully intact. Last thing I need is to knock her up.

  I made my way to the bathroom without any discussion of what happens next. I wasn’t smart enough to grab some, or all of my clothes, as I made my way down the hall. I jumped a little when Will opened the bathroom door after giving a short quick knock. He was still totally naked and completely comfortable with the fact that I was too. He walked over and started the shower before telling me, “Let’s clean up, Callie will be here in a minute she is just ordering some pizza first.”

  The shower was big
enough to fit a party of five. There were seriously four shower heads and he’d turned them all on. I made my way to the far end, thinking he’d stay on the other end. He didn’t, he took the shower head right next to mine. I tried keeping my eyes closed as I rinsed myself off, but I could feel his eyes on me. When I opened my eyes, I discovered I wasn’t wrong. He was watching me and the knowledge made my dick thicken. He took a half a step closer to give me a squirt of body wash and rather than taking the half a step back once I had it, he stayed close. I tried not to notice his already hard cock, I tried to keep my eyes on the glass door hoping I would see Callie walking in.

  Callie wasn’t there and Will was getting closer. Before my mind could run wild with all the familiar panicked thoughts I felt his touch. I tried to back away, but only ended up with my back against the cold tile wall. Within seconds Will was on his knees stroking my quickly growing cock. He mimicked Callie’s kiss from earlier and he got the same response as she did, my body’s natural reaction; full hip thrust into his mouth. He responded exactly like she did, open mouthed as I hit the back of his throat. I don’t know when Callie joined us, I was too lost in the pleasure he was giving me. I couldn’t help but thread my hands into his short dark hair as I thrust my hips, full on face fucking him. Not once did he stop, he opened his throat to take all of me repeatedly. I could feel Callie’s hands caressing down my back as I felt the tightening in my balls. Without verbal warning, I shot load after load down his throat and he swallowed every last drop. I stumbled to the side, collapsing onto the wooden sauna style bench where I desperately tried to get my breathing under control.