Sole Survivor

by Holly Dunn

  Sole Survivor

  The Inspiring True Story of Coming Face to Face with the Infamous Railroad Killer

  Holly K. Dunn

  with Heather Ebert

  Copyright

  Diversion Books

  A Division of Diversion Publishing Corp.

  443 Park Avenue South, Suite 1008

  New York, NY 10016

  www.DiversionBooks.com

  Copyright © 2017 by Holly K. Dunn

  All rights reserved, including the right to reproduce this book or portions thereof in any form whatsoever.

  Except where otherwise noted, all photos courtesy of the author.

  Scripture quotation is from The ESV® Bible (The Holy Bible, English Standard Version®), copyright © 2001 by Crossway, a publishing ministry of Good News Publishers. Used by permission. All rights reserved.

  For more information, email info@diversionbooks.com

  First Diversion Books edition November 2017

  ISBN: 978-1-68230-813-4

  For the loves of my life,

  Jacob, William, and Warren

  In memory of

  Christopher Thomas Maier

  (1976 – 1997)

  Introduction

  As for you, you meant evil against me, but God meant it for good, to bring it about that many people should be kept alive, as they are today.

  —Genesis 50:20 (ESV)

  My name is Holly Dunn Pendleton, and I have the unusual distinction of having survived a serial killer. This is not an identity I would have ever chosen, but in the years since I was attacked, the incident has formed and shaped my very purpose and passion.

  When I was a little girl, I dreamed of becoming the first woman in the Oval Office. When I got older, I decided to follow my father into the family hotel business instead. My young son, William, wants to build houses when he grows up, so he can be like his dad too. When we’re little, our futures are a vast expanse of possibility. We make plans for school, for a career, for a family. We don’t plan on tragedy—or horrific violence. The impact of unforeseen forces can alter our path forever, for better or worse. As the cartoonist Allen Saunders once said, “Life is what happens to you while you’re busy making other plans.”

  On the night of August 28, 1997, my new boyfriend, Chris Maier, and I were making plans for the next day, for the weekend, for a new school year at the University of Kentucky in Lexington. We hadn’t anticipated coming face to face with a serial killer or making headlines in newspapers across the country. That night, a savage and vicious man bludgeoned Chris as I lay helpless next to him. The attacker then stabbed me in the neck, raped me, and beat me until he was convinced I was dead. What the killer hadn’t planned on was my surviving. For the next two years, I wouldn’t know who had attacked us. But then there came a day when I faced him in a Texas courtroom to help ensure he would face the ultimate reckoning allowed by law.

  You may remember this serial killer. His name was Angel Maturino Resendiz, also known by his most common alias, Rafael Resendez-Ramirez. He was an illegal immigrant from Mexico who spent decades furtively riding the rails and running up a rap sheet all over the United States. The media nicknamed him the Railroad Killer because his victims were usually located within a short distance of train tracks. After he was apprehended, Resendiz was connected to an estimated twenty murders in the US in at least four different states. I am the only known survivor of his attacks.

  Surviving sexual assault and near death at the hands of a serial killer was only the very beginning of a long journey back to physical and emotional health. It can be nearly impossible at times to make sense of violence and tragedy, but in my case, I believe God saved my life for a reason. I was given a second chance. Chris wasn’t given that chance, and neither were Resendiz’s other victims. I wanted to live well and with meaning—to make them all proud. I wanted this horror to be used for good.

  In the twenty years since Chris and I were attacked, I have dedicated my life to educating communities on how to best combat violence and to supporting other survivors of sexual assault. My efforts have been aimed at empowering people against violence while also offering hope that healing is possible even when violence or tragedy occurs. In partnership with the Evansville Police Department, I spent several years helping establish a non-residential advocacy center for victims of domestic violence, sexual assault, and child abuse. The nonprofit, called Holly’s House, is based in my hometown, Evansville, Indiana, and offers a safe and nurturing space for forensic interviews, services and support for victims, and community outreach and education.

  My story has been featured on countless media outlets including Glamour and People magazines, the UK’s online newspaper The Guardian, America’s Most Wanted, CBS News’s 48 Hours: Live to Tell, The Montel Williams Show, A&E/Bio’s I Survived, and many more. I’ve shared my experience at schools and universities, conferences and symposiums, and training events for law enforcement. Along the way, I have received numerous requests for a book-length version that details the ordeal and the long journey of recovery that followed. What I hope to convey is that I was transformed—not just by horrific violence—but even more so by the outpouring of love and support that came in its wake.

  The good news is that no matter what happens—even one’s worst nightmare come true—you can survive, heal, and even thrive. I may never stop having to heal from this darkest night in 1997, but pouring out my life in service to others has helped me continue to grow. My experience with Chris Maier initiated many deep, intimate friendships that have been sustained and continue to blossom even decades after our ordeal. My story offers evidence that life doesn’t just go on after bad things happen—life can still be beautiful, meaningful, and joyous.

  In the days before he died, Chris’s last words to his big sister were, “Life is good.” On the night we were attacked, his last words to me were, “Everything is going to be okay.” He didn’t just speak these words one time—he lived them daily as an example to everyone who knew him. He was vibrantly alive, and he remains that way in our hearts and memories. In the end, you could say my life’s purpose is to continue spreading his message to those who face their own dark hour:

  Life is good, and everything really will be okay.

  PART 1:

  The Monster Attacks

  CHAPTER 1.

  Chris

  For all the color Christopher Thomas Maier brought into the world—his blue eyes, the jade stone that hung from his neck, the gold Isuzu Trooper he drove, his expressive artwork—it was the silver on his toenails that first drew us together.

  It was a warm night in late June of 1997. I was a rising junior at the University of Kentucky, a school with more than twenty thousand undergraduates on a sprawling campus at the center of Lexington. On a map, Lexington looks like a wheel with spokes. New Circle Road encompasses the heart of the city, and state roads extend outward in all directions toward the horse farms. This is, after all, the Horse Capital of the World, where champion thoroughbreds are raised on rolling bluegrass pastures, and long stretches of white-plank and dry-stone fences delineate the farmland from the city’s urban core. Lexington felt very much like a big, modern city to me. I had moved there from Evansville, a small city on the southwestern tip of Indiana that had about half of Lexington’s quarter-million population and was a sixth its geographic size.

  I first arrived at the University of Kentucky in the fall of 1995 to study accounting so I could join my father in our family’s hotel business back home. Throughout my childhood, my dad had demonstrated how to have a highly successful career and still be fully present and engaged with our family. I wanted to emulate him and create a life like that for myself. But, as it turned out, accounting wasn’t quite my strong suit. I ended up switching my m
ajor to finance, and then right after my sophomore year, I enrolled in summer session to catch up on a few prerequisites.

  That summer, my friends Annie, Jessica, and I rented an off-campus apartment on the second floor of a dark red brick house on Aylesford Place near East Maxwell Street. Like most of the former family homes in the neighborhood, this house had been converted into multiple units for college students. Ours had three bedrooms and a bathroom with the most disgusting shower ever—tiny and gross with chipped ceramic and peeling walls caked in mildew that we couldn’t get clean if we tried. Our kitchen sink was perpetually full of dirty dishes. The living room was stark and neutral, and the only décor was whatever could be hung using sticky tack. Without central air conditioning, a valiant window unit fought off the Kentucky heat and humidity.

  The whole apartment was as crappy as a college student’s apartment might be, but this was my first ever apartment, and I was having a blast.

  The evening I met Chris started out with a simple quest: My best friend Annie turned twenty-one at midnight, and the girls and I wanted to take her out for her first legal drink. It was the start of a celebration that would culminate with a birthday party at our apartment the following evening. I was only twenty at the time and had been using my older sister’s ID at the local bars. That night, at a nearby TGI Friday’s, my sister’s ID didn’t work so well. The bartender turned me down and then refused Annie, too.

  We drove back toward our apartment feeling frustrated. I wouldn’t be twenty-one until the next January, but I didn’t want my being underage to keep us from toasting Annie. On the way home, we turned from South Limestone onto East Maxwell Street and passed a sports bar and restaurant on the corner called Buffalo Wild Wings and Weck, nicknamed BW3’s or B-Dubs by the locals. The bar was dark and a bit of a dive and also oddly affiliated with the next-door laundromat, Sudsy’s. The two establishments had separate entrances, but if one of us needed to use the restroom, we had to go next door to the laundromat. Such are the gems housed in a college town, but all we cared about was that it was still open.

  “This is perfect,” I said, as we walked inside. “Happy birthday, Annie!”

  The area around the university was much quieter in the summer than when school was in session. The only other people in the restaurant that night were five or six guys from school whom we’d never met before. The girls took seats at a high-top table in the lounge, and somehow I ended up in conversation with the guys around the bar. I’ve always been rather loud and gregarious, so chatting up strangers—especially cute boys—wasn’t anything particularly unusual for me. The guys were apparently B-Dubs regulars because they all lived close by. While I was talking to a guy named Brian, the conversation turned to the silver polish on my toenails, a color I wore all the time back then. This very tall and extremely cute guy was listening to our banter. He stuck out his foot and said, “I have on silver toenail polish, too!”

  And that’s how I met the one and only Christopher Maier.

  Chris and I started talking, and I learned that he was from North Canton, Ohio, and was majoring in lighting design in UK’s theater department. Chris had started school the same year I did, but he’d already turned twenty-one earlier that June.

  We all left the bar at the same time and parted ways, but not before the girls and I invited them to our place for Annie’s birthday party the next night.

  On the way home, I kept thinking, Man, that guy is cute. I’d felt an undeniable connection to him. But before I could voice the words, my friends were saying the same thing: “Did you see that tall guy? He was so cute.”

  Dang, I thought. Everyone is into him. I have no chance! But at least I’d get to see him again soon.

  • • •

  The night of Annie’s birthday party, our apartment filled with Annie’s friends from home and classmates who were still in town for the summer, along with Chris and a couple of the guys we met the night before. Chris and I gravitated toward each other and ended up not leaving each other’s side the entire evening. We completely monopolized each other’s time. When things started to wind down, we left the party and walked a few blocks down to Woodland Park. As lively and sociable as Chris was, he was happiest outdoors. The park stretched across nineteen acres between two city blocks and was dotted with picnic tables, sports fields, an aquatic center, a skate park, and a playground.

  The park was dark and still. We meandered to the playground and sat on a swing set, our silver toes grazing the sand back and forth beneath us.

  “How have I not encountered you before?” he asked.

  Despite the tens of thousands of students at UK, Chris’s fraternity and my sorority were fairly close and hosted a number of mixers during the years we’d been on campus. My freshman year, I joined Kappa Kappa Gamma, called Kappa for short. From sophomore year onward, I lived in the sorority house during the school year. Chris was a brother in Phi Kappa Psi—or Phi Psi. Beyond our campus affiliations, a strong part of what drew us together was how we had been raised. We both came from tight-knit families and had had a Catholic upbringing. We both had older sisters back home whom we adored, and he was also close with an older female cousin. He had a great rapport with women. He even had two girl roommates, Adrienne and Kelly. I had met Adrienne during freshman orientation, and we had two classes together—algebra and economics—our first semester. She and Chris were both from Ohio and close friends from the start of our time at UK.

  “Ha! That explains the silver nail polish. It’s like Three’s Company.”

  “It’s exactly like Three’s Company,” he said. “We even sing the show’s theme song on our answering machine.”

  Being with Chris was a new, exciting experience and yet so comfortable. We could talk for hours. He was unlike any guy I had ever hung out with before, a modern hippie of sorts. He wore necklaces he made by hand himself. One was a braided hemp necklace double-looped around his neck with a tear-shaped jade stone at the base of his throat. He loved being outdoors and often hiked in the Red River Gorge, a canyon system about an hour and a half from Lexington. He was a bicycle enthusiast and worked at the Tenth Gear Bicycle Shop on Southland Drive. He loved to walk everywhere and anywhere with absolutely no shoes on.

  Chris told me about his high school years at the Western Reserve Academy boarding school in northern Ohio, and how he spent summers living and working in Maine with his good friend Justin, whose family had a farm in Cherryfield.

  “I go back as often as I can,” he said. “Maine is magical, there’s nothing like it. I’m headed there in August to see Phish—they’re playing a huge festival in Limestone.”

  Phish, a jam-rock band from Vermont with a following that rivaled the Grateful Dead, was one of Chris’s favorite bands. It wasn’t a group I knew much about at the time, and I’d never listened to their music before. Though Chris introduced me to so many new things, not just jam bands, but biking and outdoor treks, in the end there wasn’t enough time for us to pursue these interests together. His passions ended up being legacies he left behind for me to explore long after he was gone.

  It had grown extremely late and Annie’s birthday party was likely long over. Chris walked me back to Aylesford Place. We had this undeniable connection, and after that evening, we both wanted to see where it might lead.

  • • •

  Our summer nights after work and classes were filled with friends, picnics, games, and any excuse to be outside. We often stopped for a scoop of ice cream at the Baskin-Robbins where his roommate Adrienne worked before heading over to meet friends at Woodland Park or UK’s Arboretum to play Ultimate Frisbee. Chris was exceptionally good at Ultimate because he was so tall—nearly six foot five inches with shoes on. One afternoon we were due to meet up for a game at the Arboretum, a hundred-acre botanical garden on the south side of campus. One of my sorority sisters and I drove down earlier and went for a walk in one of the gardens. When I came out to my car, Chris had left a note on the windshield to say they changed venues.
His note was simple, handwritten in blue ink.

  “Holly—We went over to the soccer complex to play. There’s less wind—less dog shit. You can see us from here. Look to the far right corner.”

  The soccer complex was just north of the Arboretum. Bad weather had turned the fields to mud, and after our game, Chris’s cleats were so dirty I wouldn’t let him in my car. I found a stick in the bushes near the parking lot.

  “Turn around, let me help you with this mess,” I said.

  I dug the clumps of mud out of Chris’s cleats like a farmer dislodging rocks from a horseshoe. We were both laughing at what we must look like—Chris leaning over with one leg bent behind him, completely at my mercy.

  We were silent for a moment. Then Chris turned around and looked at me, while I held his ankle in one hand and the stick in the other.

  “I want to be more than friends,” he said.

  “Well, okay then.”

  It had only been a matter of time.

  I could tell from the start that Chris was going to have a unique influence on my life, but I couldn’t have imagined to what degree at the time. I was simply enamored by this tall, handsome, kind, and generous soul who made me laugh and who inspired me with his passion for the outdoors, music, and even art. In the tiny apartment on Latrobe Court that he shared with Kelly and Adrienne, the stark living room walls held little more décor than ours did, but there was no doubt an artist lived there. Chris’s room overflowed with artwork he had created.

  One evening when I was hanging out at their place, Chris pulled out drawing paper, crayons, and chalk. The brilliant hues and soft pastels of his art supplies were intensely brighter than the ugly, 1960s brown plaid couch beneath us.