My Best Friend's Dad

by Bella Winters

  I was about to reply as I felt my phone buzzing in my pocket. “Oh my gosh,” I said. “I hope it’s Alex!”

  Dan rolled his eyes. “You’re hopeless, Molly.”

  My stomach churned and twisted when I saw Rebecca’s name flashing on the caller ID.

  “It’s my roommate,” I hissed. “We got in this huge fight last week and we still haven’t talked!”

  “You should answer it,” Dan said. “Maybe she wants to apologize for being such a meddling bitch.”

  I blushed. The phone kept buzzing and buzzing. Finally, after what felt like an eternity of agony, I swiped the call open and held it to my ear.

  “Hello?”

  “I know you know it’s me,” Rebecca said. She sounded miserable. “Molly, I’m really sorry. This is just hard for me. Neither of us has ever dated before – we’ve both always spent so much time together.”

  “I know.”

  “Can you come out and meet me? I’ll buy you dinner.”

  I looked down at the mostly empty pizza box. “Sorry, I just ate. I’m on campus – Dan and I ordered a pizza.”

  “Oh, okay. Drinks then? We could go to a bar and I’ll buy you a few beers.”

  I swallowed. Part of me wanted to say no, to yell at her for being such a bitch. But the other part of me desperately missed my friend. This had been one of the loneliest weeks of my life and I was looking forward to making up and getting over it.

  “Okay,” I said. “Where do you want to meet?”

  Rebecca gave me the address of a bar close to campus and I hung up, slipping the phone into my pocket.

  “We’re going to get drinks together,” I said, getting to my feet and picking up my things. “Sorry, I felt sort of like I had to say yes.”

  Dan waved his hand in the air. “Hey, don’t worry about it,” he said. He rolled his eyes. “You think you have a dramatic life? Try being a gay man.”

  I laughed. “Thanks for not minding,” I said. Dan pecked me on the cheek and I set out for the bar.

  When I got there, it was so crowded I could barely squeeze past the bar. Rebecca was at a small table in the back, nursing a glass of white wine.

  “Hey,” Rebecca said. She gave me a hopeful smile. “Thanks for coming out on such short notice. I know I could’ve waited for you at home…but I don’t know, this is probably better.”

  I nodded. “Yeah,” I said. “Um, thanks for apologizing. That means a lot.”

  “I was just such a jerk,” Rebecca said. “I’m jealous of your time, Molly, and I realize that’s totally not healthy. We’ve just always been so close, you know?”

  I nodded. “I know,” I said. “Trust me, I get it.”

  Rebecca sighed. “I’m just sorry I acted like that. It’s kind of…hard to imagine you with my brother, and I just don’t want you getting hurt.”

  “Well, probably nothing will happen with Alex,” I said, sighing moodily. “So, it’s not like you have much to worry about.”

  “Have you seen him this week?”

  “Seen who?”

  The sound of Alex’s voice made both Rebecca and I jump. He grinned, then lowered his muscular body down into a chair next to me. His face was red and sweaty, and I could smell beer on his breath.

  “Alex!” I said. “What are you doing here?”

  Alex smirked. “Having a drink. God, Molly, you would be the only person in a bar without a beer in front of you.”

  Rebecca rolled her eyes. “She obviously just got here,” she said. “If you care so much, go get her something.”

  Alex cocked his head to the side and stared at me. “Only if she promises to thank me for it,” he said, raising an eyebrow.

  I blushed hotly, grateful for the dark cover of the bar. “Of course,” I said. My voice was barely above a whisper.

  Alex grinned and vaulted out of his chair.

  “I can’t believe he just showed up!” Rebecca said. She shook her head. “I should go.”

  “No,” I said. “Don’t.”

  “Really? You don’t want to be alone with him?”

  I did want to be alone with him – more than anything else in the world. But being in a bar wasn’t really like being alone, and I felt like the nature of my friendship with Rebecca was still slightly more precarious than it should be.

  “No,” I said. “I mean, stay, you should really stay.”

  Rebecca nodded. She took a sip of her wine. “If he gets mean, I’m leaving,” she said. “But don’t feel like you have to come.” She yawned. “I’m exhausted.”

  “Me, too.”

  Alex set a frothy mug of beer down in front of me. He smirked. “All yours,” he said.

  “Thanks,” I said shyly. “How much do I owe you?”

  Alex waved his hand dismissively through the air. “Don’t worry about it,” he said. “I’m sure you can think of a way to pay me back later.”

  My blush darkened to a crimson red and I nodded. Alex sat down, scooting his chair close to mine. When I felt his hot hand on my leg under the table, I shrieked.

  “Molly? Are you okay?” Rebecca asked, her voice tinged with concern. “What’s wrong?”

  “Molly’s just feeling a little jumpy tonight,” Alex said. He moved his fingers higher up my thigh, pushing the skirt of my sundress into my lap. I bit my lip and resisted the urge to squirm.

  “Yeah,” I said. “Don’t worry. I’m fine.”

  “So, sis, Rob was talking about you today,” Alex said. His fingers moved higher and higher, until they were practically in my crotch. I shifted, spreading my legs slightly to allow him greater access. He pinched me and I squeaked, covering my hand with my mouth.

  “Wow, Molly, you’re so jumpy tonight,” Alex said smoothly. “You okay?”

  I nodded just as his fingers strayed to the crotch of my panties. They were soaked with sweat and the juice from my pussy. Just being around Alex again was making me feel sexy and horny. I wanted him to kiss me. I wanted him to pull me into the grimy bar bathroom and fuck me against the wall. I wanted to lick my own juices off his cock, just like I’d done with his fingers.

  “I’m fine,” I squeaked.

  “Rob?” Rebecca asked. “Your weird friend?”

  Alex’s fingers brushed the spot of wet fabric right over my clit and a delicious wave of pleasure shot through my body. I spread my legs even further and rolled my hips forward, desperate for more pleasure. Alex stroked me harder, circling his fingertip around my clit until I thought I would moan.

  “Yeah, Rob,” Alex said. “He said something about a double date. You game?”

  Rebecca bit her lip. “You mean….” She trailed off, gesturing to the three of us.

  Alex nodded. “Yeah. I was thinking dinner or something. You like steak, right Molly?”

  As he said it, his fingers pulled the crotch of my panties to the side. Cool air hit my hot, wet pussy in the most delicious way possible and I swallowed another loud moan.

  “Yeah,” was all I managed to say.

  Alex’s finger slipped inside my wet cave and I shivered. He kept his thumb against my clit as his fingers slid in and out of my soaked hole. Fire was building in my lower belly and I kept my hands clenched in fists under the table so I wouldn’t move.

  “Good girl,” Alex murmured under his breath, too low for Rebecca to hear. “Don’t move or I’ll stop.”

  “I like steak,” Rebecca said. She frowned. “But I don’t know if I like Rob. He’s kind of a pig, isn’t he?”

  Alex shrugged. With his unoccupied hand, he lifted his beer to his lips and drank. “It’s just a date, sis. It’s not like you’re signing away your life to him or anything like that.”

  “I don’t know,” Rebecca said. She bit her lip.

  Alex’s fingers moved faster and faster, his thumb stroking my clit like a vibrator. It felt so good that I could hardly breathe, and I could feel a powerful orgasm building in my lower belly. My nipples had stiffened into little pebbles of flesh and they brushed against the cott
on of my dress, only furthering the delightful torment that Alex was inflicting on me.

  I spread my legs even further, until the fabric of my underwear was cutting into the sides of my body. I didn’t care. The pleasure growing between my legs was becoming too powerful to ignore. When my orgasm hit, I gasped and held my breath. The delicious, by-now-familiar sensations brought a torrent of orgasmic pleasure to my body and I clutched the table as I trembled and shook.

  Alex pulled his hand away just as the waves were starting to fade. He licked his lips and smirked at me.

  “So, double date with Rob some time next week,” Alex said, getting to his feet. He lifted his fingers to his nose and sniffed, keeping his eyes locked with mine the whole time. “When are you free, Molly?”

  “Hey,” Rebecca said. “We have totally different schedules you know!”

  “Yeah, but Molly’s more important,” Alex said with a snicker. “You’re just an afterthought, sis.”

  “I hate you,” Rebecca muttered under her breath.

  “I’m free Wednesday and Thursday,” I said. “Do either of those work?”

  Alex looked at Rebecca and raised his eyebrows. “Either of those work for you, Miss Spoiled and Demanding?”

  Rebecca gave him a dark look. “Either,” she said. “And tell Rob to behave himself.”

  Alex laughed. “Got it,” he said. “Although I have to warn you, he might not listen.” He chugged the rest of his beer and set the glass down on the table. “Well, it was nice, ladies. But I had some fish and chips for lunch, and I need to go wash my hands and then go home.” He smirked at me as he said ‘fish.’

  I blushed hotly. The delicious sensations were still echoing around in my body and I nodded.

  “Nice to see you,” I said, smiling. “Have a good night, Alex.”

  “Yeah, what she said, only not as nice,” Rebecca said. She rolled her eyes. “Molly, you wanna go home? Or go out for froyo?”

  “Let’s get froyo,” I said, getting to my feet. “I have a feeling I just worked up an appetite.”

  Chapter Fifteen

  Alex

  I didn’t wash the scent of Molly’s sweet, musky cunt off my fingers. Instead, I drove home with my hand under my nose, smelling her pussy and dreaming of the day I could plow her into oblivion.

  You need to knock it off, I thought. This is moving too fast.

  As much as I’d screwed my way through life, I’d never really been interested in dating. I’d had one girlfriend, back in high school, for about a week. I cheated on her three times in one weekend, and she found out and spent the next six months bursting into tears whenever she saw me in the hall. That experience had been a long time ago – over ten years – but it had frightened me into behaving, or at least keeping myself emotionally unavailable from women. They were too much drama. Besides, I really only liked having sex with them. I’d never enjoyed having dinner with girls, or getting drinks with them. The thrill of the chase had only been fun in my younger years, and then it got old.

  But somehow, I liked the idea of having dinner with Molly. Even if my stupid, annoying brat of a sister would be there, too.

  I just hoped Rob would behave himself and not act like a total and complete ass.

  That night, I barely slept. I kept dreaming of Molly. Her pussy, her tits, her amazing smile. What was it about her that made me feel so horny all the time? And why did I want to think about her even when I wasn’t in the mood to fuck?

  Was I in danger of getting too close?

  I didn’t want any messy drama. Molly seemed like the dramatic type. She was immature, inexperienced, and I knew she’d never been in a relationship. Hell, getting ice cream with me was her first real date. I had to keep distance between us, or I knew I’d really wind up hurting her. I didn’t want to do that.

  But the problem was, I had no idea what it was that I did want to do.

  The problem plagued me for days. By the time Wednesday rolled around, I was feeling hornier for Molly than ever before. But now my lust was mixed with confusion. It was clear I didn’t just like fucking her. I liked her. But what was going to happen?

  At the end of the day, I took a long shower and put on my best cologne with a clean shirt and a pair of dark jeans. I didn’t normally spend this much time on my appearance, and it was borderline embarrassing, almost like I was a girl or some stupid fag. The plan was for Rob to meet us at the restaurant, and I’d drive Molly and Rebecca over. That way, Rob could take Rebecca home…and I could take Molly back to my place and fuck her senseless. I wanted to do everything with her. I wanted to bury my face between her fat thighs and lick her cunt until she howled with pleasure. I wanted her to suck my cock until my balls ached. I wanted to fuck her in the pussy, in the ass, between the tits – everything.

  I didn’t fuck girls in the ass very often. Most girls wouldn’t let me do that on a one-night stand, and I rarely got to fuck someone enough times before I could ask. But I had a feeling Molly would love it, and I wanted to fuck her virgin asshole until she couldn’t sit down for days. I smirked as I got into my Mustang and roared away from my apartment.

  Tonight’s going to be awesome, I thought. Some steak, getting laid, and then what? Would Molly spend the night with me? I’d never let a chick sleep over before – I didn’t like the ideas it put in their heads.

  But somehow, I had a feeling that with Molly, I was playing another game entirely.

  When I got to my sister’s apartment, I knocked on the door until Rebecca answered. Half of her face didn’t have makeup and she looked stressed.

  “I’m not finished getting ready,” she said. “Molly’s not home yet, she’s coming right from campus.”

  “Rob’s going to meet us there,” I said. “So, we can’t be late.”

  Rebecca put her hands on her hips and rolled her eyes. “Yeah, because I’m sure Rob is the picture of punctuality,” she said with a groan. “I’ve got to finish getting ready.”

  She disappeared in the bathroom and I took one of Molly’s beers from the fridge and cracked it open. I thought of kicking back on the couch and flipping through the channels on their huge TV, but instead I wandered down the hall. Molly’s door was closed, but I pushed it open and glanced around. I snickered – it was a mess. She’s really a slob, I thought as I stepped inside and looked around. There were dirty clothes and books all over the floor, and the covers of the bed weren’t mad. The air of her room had that sweet smell of her body and I inhaled deeply as my cock stiffened in my pants. Part of me was tempted to lock the door and hump her mattress, smelling the scent of her sweat and pretending it was her.

  “Alex?” Rebecca was standing in the door. “What are you doing in here? I told you, she’s not home yet.”

  “Yeah, I know.” I smirked. “Just thought I’d take a look and see where the magic happens.”

  Rebecca rolled her eyes. "Well, come on, it’s creepy that you’re in there when she’s not home,” she said. “Are you ready to go?”

  “We have to wait for Molly,” I said, raising an eyebrow. “At least, that’s what I thought, right?”

  Rebecca sighed. “Look, Alex…what are you doing with her? Are you going to keep stringing her along and then never talk to her again? What am I supposed to say when she’s totally heartbroken?”

  I narrowed my eyes. “I haven’t thought of that,” I said, shaking my head. “Besides, how do you know that’s going to happen? What are you, some kind of genius psychic wizard?”

  Rebecca crossed her arms over her chest. “Very funny,” she said. “But I know you, Alex, you’re my brother. I’ve spent practically my whole life with you, and I know how you work.” She glanced at the ceiling and sighed. “Look, I thought it would be a good idea for you and Molly to have sex so she could lose her virginity – I wasn’t actually expecting it to happen! And if it did happen, I didn’t think it would be more than once!”

  “What’s your point?” I stepped closer, drawing myself to my full height and looking down at m
y little sister. “You thought I wouldn’t actually fuck her?”

  Rebecca exhaled loudly. “I don’t know what I thought,” she said. “But…this is too much. The attention, the dates. She’s starting to think you really like her.”

  Before I could think and reply, the front door opened and slammed shut.

  “I’m home!” Molly yelled. “Rebecca? Alex?”

  I exchanged a glance with my sister.

  “Yeah!” Rebecca called loudly, pulling me into the hall before Molly could discover us in her bedroom. “We’re here!” She shot me a dirty look. “Whatever you do,” Rebecca hissed under her breath. “Just don’t say anything. You got that?”

  I looked at her and shrugged. “Whatever.”

  Chapter Sixteen

  Molly

  The prospect of being around with Alex and his friend, Rob, made me incredibly nervous, even though I didn’t want to admit it. I didn’t know what kind of Alex he’d be – the sweet, lovable Alex that I was used to, or the mean Alex who poked fun of my weight while drinking my beer.

  “I’m nervous,” I said, biting my lip and shifting in the passenger seat of Alex’s car. Looking down at my outfit, I felt even worse. I’d taken extra care of my looks today – I’d even gone to my favorite plus-size store and bought a new dress, along with getting a makeover from Sephora. I’d felt confident and happy before getting home, but now I wondered if I’d gone overboard. Rebecca was simply dressed in the peasant blouse and denim skirt she wore whenever there was a “function” at school. She wasn’t even wearing heels.