Craving More

by Scarlett Avery

  Allison wiggles her ass impatiently, stealing his attention away from me.

  “Did you enjoy my tongue up your ass when we were all in the hot pool?” Jake squirts the gel in his hands.

  “Uh-huh. I did.”

  “Good. You’re going to like this even more.”

  Allison sucks in a breath as a heavily lubed finger slides against her tight asshole. “Oh,” she gasps. My best friend presses his finger past the ring of muscle and she hisses while gyrating as he slides it in deeper.

  The pressure builds at the base of my balls, tightening them, and the sensation mounting is overpowering. I’m trying to ward off the inevitable, but watching her in this position with Jake dominating her like this is intense. I won’t lie, it’s intoxicating to watch another man finger a tight, virgin asshole before he fucks her.

  Jake’s husky voice breaks my trance. It’s as if he can tell I’m close. “Hunter, save your climax for Ali and get your cock over here so she can keep busy while I work her from behind.”

  There’s no doubt we’re both dominant alpha males, but there’s something so unapologetic and so unrepentant about Jake when we take a woman together. The way he uses my tongue, my fingers and my cock as extensions of his own with each one of his commands is extraordinarily dirty.

  I climb onto the bed in front of Allison and slide under her until I cup her huge hanging tits. When I look up, all I can see are her heavenly breasts, nearly suffocating me. When I shift my eyes behind me, I see my friend working her ass and I can’t help but smile. Damn, this is going to be mind-blowing.

  I cup her left tit and suck her right nipple into my eager mouth. Fuck. She moans when I wrap my lips around her peak and she pants when I nibble and lap at her large areola. From this vantage point the weight of her tits sits nicely on my face and I swear I could stroke my cock and come while biting down on her erect nipples.

  Behind her, Jake withdraws his fingers. The loud sucking sound that follows causes her to sob, but suddenly her wailing turns into gasps. Jake must have inserted two fingers. I take that as my cue and I bite gently on her peak and she rewards me with another squeal.

  “How is it, Ali?”

  “Jesus, Jake,” she hisses.

  Although I’m still lapping at Allison’s tits and pinching her nipples, I notice when Jake withdraws his fingers again. He waits a few seconds before penetrating her again and her entire body contracts, expecting more.

  “Fuck, three fingers?” she screams, outraged, when Jake slides deeper inside her tightness. The slurp of the lube follows, but this time her knees wobble as Jake invades her ass once again. “Oh, Christ.” Her raspy voice arouses my already rock-hard cock and I slip my hand down her stomach until I reach her pussy. She moans and widens her legs, inviting me to stroke her clit.

  “I can’t take this any longer.”

  Jake takes a step back and the condom crinkles. I slide from under Allison and get up on my knees. I pat around the bed in search of my own shield and when I find it, I bring the packet to my mouth to rip it open. With our cocks sheathed, we nod at each other.

  “Are you ready for us, Ali?”

  “Uh-huh.” She folds her lower lip into her mouth.

  “No, baby, I want to hear you say the words.”

  “I want both of you to take me. Now.”

  Jake and I lock eyes and we share a silent understanding that transcends words.

  “Hunter, our little virgin is ready to discover her wild side. Get inside her so I can do the same.” Jake’s order is precise and I sit back down and glide to the edge of the bed with my dick spearing into the air, grazing Allison’s stomach. I hold out my arms to her and she smiles at me as if she can’t wait to mount me.

  “Slowly,” I say, holding her hands as she scrambles to position herself.

  I grab her hips as she climbs over me. When my dick’s head nudges at her pussy, I struggle not to thrust into her in one quick movement. “Come on, sit on my cock and lean into me.”

  She obeys and with every inch of me she swallows with her pussy, I grunt at the pressure. Within a few seconds, I’m fully impaling her.

  “Oh, fuck,” she purrs when I’m all the way in. I groan in response as her pussy grips my dick and her muscles clamp around me. I brush her damp hair from her face and lose myself in her gaze. Her eyes are already glazed over and we’ve barely begun to rock her world.

  “Fucking shit,” I say when she begins to gyrate against my shaft.

  “You’re so deep inside me,” she marvels.

  “You like being on top?” I tease.

  “Do I get to control things?”

  “In your dreams, but you do get an A for effort. I’m the one who has the cock, so I’m the one controlling things,” I say, playfully sticking my tongue out at her.

  She folds her body towards me and giggles into the crook of my neck, but Jake’s voice puts an end to her lightheartedness.

  “Spread your thighs for me, Ali.” Jake’s command is strangled and urgent.

  Allison shifts her body against mine and she widens her legs.

  “Damn, this is a magnificent view. It’s too bad you’ll miss it, Hunter,” Jake mocks.

  “Don’t worry about me. Enjoy it while you can because it’ll be my turn soon enough.” I wink at her.

  The next thing I hear are two slaps followed by Allison’s muffled cry.

  “I’m going to enter you now, Ali, nice and slow.”

  “Okay.” She casts me a worried look as she bites down on her lower lip.

  “Hold on to me,” I say, tightening my grip around her waist. “You’re going to be fine.”

  “Oh.” Her body jerks forward. She reaches for me and I lift my head high enough to take her mouth to calm her down.

  “Easy, baby. It’ll be good once I’m all in.” Jake’s words reassure her and she rewards me with a weary smile. “Spread yourself further. I’m going to use more lube because you’re an untouched little one,” he chuckles.

  “It’s okay, Allison. Breathe, baby,” I whisper, nipping at her neck.

  “Jesus, Hunter, she’s so insanely tight.”

  “I bet she is.”

  “Argh,” she yelps, biting my shoulder to keep from crying out.

  “Where do you think you’re going, Ali?” She tries to escape him but Jake will have none of it. He grabs the blonde’s hips and pulls her back towards him. “I’m entering you slowly—inch by inch.”

  “Once Jake is fully in, you’re going to lose your mind. You’ll have two lovers filling you up.”

  She closes her eyes and tilts her head back. “Holy hell,” she yells out. He’s inside her. And just like that, the tension leaves her body and she submits herself fully to both of us.

  Damn, it’s about to get dirty.

  CHAPTER FIVE

  JAKE

  I’ve been waiting for this moment since I first laid eyes on Allison’s delicious body. She’s riding my best friend’s dick and I’ve just entered her very tight asshole.

  “Oh, fuck, buddy, she’s clenching her pussy around me hard. I’m going to shoot my load in no time,” Hunter shouts through gritted teeth.

  I have no intention of rushing things. I want to savor every inch of her ass as she swallows me. I pull out slightly before pushing in slowly, stretching her while allowing her to become accustomed to having me fill her ass. When I’m nearly all in, I withdraw again and thrust into her with more determination.

  “Is it good, baby?”

  “Mmmmm.”

  “Are you ready? I’m going to go faster now.” I brush her hair to the side and kiss the back of her shoulder.

  “Yes,” she hisses through clenched teeth.

  “If it doesn’t feel good, what should you say?”

  She hesitates for a moment and then remembers the safe word I gave her when I took her inside the barn. “Lemon.”

  “Good girl.”

  I slide my free hand to her tits, pinching her tightening nipple, and she bucks wi
ldly against me. I push my dick further into her ass, groaning loudly, bringing both hands back to her hips and holding her in place. Both Hunter and I move rhythmically. We pull out and slam back into her in unison. Christ. She can’t do a thing but hold tightly to my best friend’s shoulders and take us.

  I’ve barely started moving, but already a wave of pleasure rushes over me. “Holy shit, Ali.”

  “Fucking Lord,” Hunter grunts in response to my plea.

  “Oh, God,” she exhales.

  “Ali, I can’t even begin to describe how amazing your ass feels around my dick,” I whisper in her ear, reaching around her and palming her tits again, pinching her nipples, painfully hard.

  “Argh.”

  “You like that, don’t you?”

  “This is so raw, so primal and so untamed, I fear I’m tumbling over the edge.” Her body convulses and she cries out but neither Hunter or I slow down. In fact her wailing makes us fuck her harder, faster—relentlessly. We’re pumping in and out, increasing our speed, pushing her close to the climax she craves.

  “I’m so close, baby,” Hunter groans. “Make me come.”

  “I don’t know if I can. It’s so hard with Jake slamming into my ass.”

  “Of course you can. Clench your pussy around my dick and milk me for everything I have.”

  “Ahhh.”

  “That’s it. Focus and let go.”

  “Jesus, the two of you are going to rip me apart,” she grunts, but neither Hunter or I slow down our cadence. “I’m going to die. This is too good.”

  “Yeah, but what a way to go—with two guys fucking you.” Hunter fists her hair and pulls her mouth down to his, kissing her almost violently.

  Witnessing both of them unleashed like this only brings out my feral nature. I thrust harder, faster, slamming her into Hunter.

  “Damn, Ali.”

  She moans, jerking her head back, sending her cascade of hair flying in the air. She keens as my thrusts increase in speed, pushing into her and dominating her like no man has ever done before. “Oh, yes, yes, yes.”

  “Fuck, Ali, you’re a naughty vixen.” Her ass greedily hugs my dick.

  The room is filled with our moans, grunts and groans and slowly the sound of skin slapping against skin takes over. This is sweet debauchery at its best.

  “Ah, Jake, you feel so good,” she says, turning her head.

  “Oh, baby, you want me deeper inside your ass?”

  “I want more. Hunter, keep fucking me, please.” She bounces her attention between Hunter and me, unable to decide which one of us is giving her the most pleasure.

  “Don’t worry, baby. I’ll give you what you want.”

  “I’m going out of my mind here.” Suddenly she clenches against Hunter’s cock, her hips swing forward and her ass squeezes hard around me. With every buck of my hips, I press her harder against Hunter, forcing her clit to rub against his body.

  “Oh, God, oh, God, oh, God,” Allison cries out. “Jake, please come in my ass.”

  “I will, Ali.”

  “Hunter, fill my pussy.”

  “Shit, Allison, you’re going to get it.”

  I slide my hands down her stomach and pinch her clit between my fingers, pushing her over the edge.

  “Mother of God.” Allison clenches her ass so tight it nearly cuts my breathing off. Shit. My balls tighten and I know I’m done. I’m no longer in control of any of this.

  Her climax hits her hard and she’s too exhausted to even scream. Her bottom lip is trembling, tears are in her eyes and she’s clinging on to Hunter like he’s a life jacket to avoid drowning in the sea of her own euphoric rapture. Her body convulses again and she digs her nails into Hunter’s shoulders, leaving long scratches as I slam into her a final time. I explode. I’m lost in this moment of sheer ecstasy and I come with a deep growl I’ve never heard before. I pull out of her ass and quickly remove the condom before choking my dick, spewing my milk all over her back. Fuck. Instinctively, I spread the warmth of my orgasm all over her silky skin—I’ve branded her.

  “Argh,” I exhale.

  My heart is beating so fast, I fear it will stop, unable to withstand the fact that all the blood in my body has travelled to my dick.

  I’m still breathing heavily when my best friend screams out his own release. “Jesus fucking Christ.” Hunter’s cry comes from deep down. I’ve never seen him undone like this.

  Ali collapses on Hunter, panting hard, but with a wide smile on her face despite the teary eyes.

  “Are you still alive?” I tease.

  “Barely.”

  “Seriously, how do you feel?” Hunter asks with his eyes still closed shut. “Did we work you too hard for your first time?”

  “Maybe a little. I’m exhausted and a bit sore.”

  “Hopefully not too sore.” Hunter opens one eye and Ali looks at him in disbelief.

  “You can’t be… Already?”

  Slap.

  “What?” she protests, turning her body to face me.

  I gently spank her gorgeous ass and stroke the sting away. “Knowing my best friend, he’s very serious. This is only the first round, baby. We’re not nearly done with you yet.” I grin devilishly.

  Fuck, this was even more mind-blowing than I ever thought possible.

  CHAPTER SIX

  ALLISON

  I wake up cuddled snugly against Hunter, my head resting on his shoulder and my leg draped over his as his arm wraps around my shoulders. Oh, God, my body aches all over. I try to move, but I’m quickly reminded of our endless binge of sexual depravity and abandonment.

  After Jake claimed me, Hunter did the same and my hunks took turns ravishing me until I couldn’t take it anymore. Although I doubt I’ll be able to walk without a limp for the next few days, if not the next week, I wouldn’t change a thing. I’ve gone from having the worst luck in men to being worshiped by two extraordinarily handsome studs—it doesn’t get better than that.

  Both my boys are still sound asleep and I take a minute to admire each one. Although taller, Hunter isn’t as broad as Jake. That said, his muscles are incredibly lean and sculpted. His high cheekbones are more pronounced and his jaw is elongated whereas Jake’s is strong, well defined and square. I turn my head slightly to glance over at Jake, who is sleeping on his back naked with his arms spread over his head, sporting a semi-erection. How in the world did I ever get to be this lucky?

  There’s no two ways about it, both men are outrageously sexy in their own way and I guess that’s why this experience is even more surreal. I know I’m blessed beyond belief and I’m pretty sure Gwyn will remind me I’m the luckiest woman in the world, but my eyes linger on the blue-eyed man who took my virginity last night.

  What is it about Jake that makes him so irresistible to me? Perhaps it’s the fact that Jake’s intense presence makes me feel safe in a way I’ve never felt before with any other man. It’s strange I don’t feel the same way with Hunter considering both men are extremely caring. Maybe it's because I've had sex with Jake twice now and I’ve bonded with him enough to let my guard down before having sex with Hunter.

  I know if I stay in bed, my mind will start playing tricks on me and the internal chatter will take over. It would be selfish to rock the boat because things are really good between the three of us. Why ruin things by questioning them? I look up at Hunter, wondering how in the world I’ll be able to move without waking him up, when he lets go of me and turns onto his other side. I take this as my cue to slide out of bed and find an activity that will occupy my thoughts.

  Ouch. Every muscle screams in protest as I sneak out of bed and try to stand up on my shaky legs. Before leaving the room, I glance down one last time at the two men who made me come so many times last night, I thought I was going to forget my own name. I know for sure they won’t spare me when their appetite for me reignites. I need to replenish if tonight will be a mirror image of last night’s wantonness.

  I tiptoe my way out of the room in searc
h of a bathroom where I can take a quick shower and find something to wear. I’m very aware I’m no model, but I’ve never felt more comfortable with my own reflection than I have in the last few days thanks to the way Jake and Hunter praise my curves. On the other hand, I can’t cook a hearty breakfast with my boobs flying all over the place.

  Hunter’s bathroom is as luxurious as Jake’s. It’s more modern and edgier. I don’t linger under the water and once I braid my hair and twist it in a tight bun at the base of my neck, I borrow one of Hunter’s oversized t-shirts from a small table in the corner of the bathroom and I run downstairs to the kitchen.

  This is truly my favorite place in a home. I immediately swing open the fridge and start my inventory to determine which ingredients to use to prepare a breakfast to refill our energy after a night of forbidden passion. Since Isadora stocked up our refrigerators before she left, I already have a few great recipes in the back of my mind that I can whip up quickly.

  My head is still stuck inside the fridge when a pair of strong hands caress my naked ass. I squeal, surprised. I quickly pull my head out of the fridge and turn around to meet a pair of mischievous brown eyes staring down at me. “Hunter! When did you get up?”

  “Well, good morning to you too, princess. After our intimate night, I was hoping for a warmer greeting, but I guess I’ll have to take whatever it is you’re dishing out,” he mocks.

  “I’m sorry. Good morning. I didn't expect you to be up already since you were still sound asleep when I left the room.”

  “You’re right, but the shower woke me up. My first instinct was to roll out of bed and come join you under the water, but you worked us so hard last night my brain couldn’t convince my body to move.”

  “Are you seriously going to walk around naked like this?” It’s taken me a minute to notice Hunter is standing in front of me unbothered by the fact he isn’t wearing any clothing.

  “What? This is my house after all and I usually walk around in the morning in the buff.” He grins from ear to ear.