Renee's High School Reunion

by Cheryl Dragon

  Maturity did wonders to the confusion of high school relationships.

  “He’s here. Right now, we want to hear about you.” Jesse held the elevator door as Renee exited and AJ carried her bag.

  Renee fumbled the key. “Not much to tell. Not married, no kids or anything. I’m a pilot for a commercial airline.” Finally, the door cooperated and they were in.

  “You always wanted to travel.” AJ put her suitcase down in the corner.

  “Yeah.” Renee marveled that AJ remembered the details. The jock she remembered was hot, sweet, but a bit self-involved. His family put pressure on him to achieve as much as possible so she couldn’t blame him on that score. “What about you?”

  “I own a mechanic shop. Cars and motorcycles were always my thing. Not much of a change. I restore some classics for fun.” AJ shrugged.

  “That’s wonderful. You loved getting dirty. And you?” Renee nodded to Jesse.

  “Professional photographer. Told you I’d make it. A lot of advertising for Vegas stuff, but it’s going good. I do my artistic stuff on the side.” Jesse smiled more then than Renee had seen him smile in all of high school.

  “That’s great. I always knew you’d succeed.” Renee put her purse on the dresser.

  “You were the only one who did.” Jesse gave her another hug, and it felt different this time. Sensual. Renee knew it’d been awhile, but Jesse wasn’t playing for her side.

  “I knew the minute I saw the pictures you took of Renee. Why do you think I freaked out and punched you at prom?” AJ moved closer to them, taking up his space and changing the feel.

  “You had naked pictures of my girlfriend.”

  “Not my face.” Renee got between them. “I wasn’t dating you when they were taken. I thought you two would be over this by now.”

  “We are. AJ just wants to get things worked up. We’re all friends here.” Jesse gave AJ’s arm a squeeze.

  She detected some sexual tension, but maybe, she was projecting her own fantasy. Linda and her fling suggestions didn’t help either. That girl really needed a man! Renee decided a subject change was in order. “Where do you both live now?”

  “Vegas,” they replied in unison.

  “Oh, okay. What are you two doing here so early? The reunion isn’t until tonight. It’s only ten-thirty in the morning.” Renee checked the clock to be sure. Her flight had been early, but her frequent flyer miles and pull with the hotels gave her flexibility. She’d left plenty of time to shower and change before the dinner and dance that evening.

  “We came here to see you. Put all the prom crap behind us and make nice.” AJ put an arm around her shoulders.

  Renee nearly melted as if she were seventeen again. AJ had muscle and testosterone to spare. Being a pilot sucked for relationships. It’d been so long since Renee had let her guard down and given into pleasure that was more than a random hook-up, but deep down she wanted that special connection. Someone who knew what she liked to eat and drink and what she loved in bed. It felt odd that the guys from high school were the closest she’d had to a serious relationship, but she still enjoyed the sparks with them.

  “I’m glad you two are friends after all that.” Renee was truly shocked AJ made friends with Jesse. He’d been so uneasy around the gay guys. High school rules and expectations no doubt, defending his masculinity at all costs.

  “Actually, we’re more than friends now.” Jesse gave her a sly smile.

  She laughed then stopped when they didn’t. They had to be playing a trick on her. “Good one, guys! Joke’s on me.” Renee looked up at AJ, and there was no laughter in his eyes.

  “Really?”

  “Really.” AJ released Renee and moved to Jesse, wrapping both arms around the slighter man and kissing his neck.

  They looked like a cute gay couple from the ads her airline did to promote gay-friendly resorts. It looked so natural. So hot! But it was AJ!

  “When? How?” Renee folded her arms and took a minute. She was excited and curious but shock won the emotional battle.

  “Prom night after you dumped me,” AJ answered.

  “What’s wrong? You supported me in high school.” Jesse wagged a finger at her.

  “I’m supportive of your lifestyle. I just didn’t know AJ was gay.” They were together.

  The two men she’d loved most now loved each other.

  “Relax, Renee. He likes women, too.” Jesse sat on the bed. “You dumped him. High school was almost over. AJ had college freedom, not high school judgment to look forward to.

  Exploration happens.”

  “You two have been together for ten years?” she asked.

  AJ grinned and gave a slight shrug, his way of saying yes. “Now, we know why I never fit in fully on the football team but enjoyed it.” She kicked off her sandals. Part of her envied their long term love. Most of Renee’s friends and sisters were married. Renee secretly wanted it, but she’d seen so many marriages go bad she kept her distance. “And they say no one stays together anymore. How exactly did this happen? When I left that night, AJ had been dragged off by the football guys and Jesse had a bloody nose.”

  She’d felt a little guilty stalking off, but her staying would have only antagonized AJ

  more. Once the team had pulled AJ back, Jesse had been safe. No one had wanted to miss graduation over a fight.

  “You’re sure you want the details?” Jesse asked.

  “Did you molest AJ or something? I knew you were horny for football players but seriously, Jesse.” Renee moved to sit in the desk chair and grabbed a bottle of water.

  AJ sat on the bed next to Jesse. “It was nothing like that. Coach was chaperoning the dance, and he’s an old-school type. Wanted us to be men and shake hands after the fight.”

  “He thought we were fighting over you.” Jesse grinned.

  “Shocking. So you shook hands and grabbed cocks by mistake?” she chuckled.

  He loved how Renee fell back into teasing them. It felt as if no time had passed at all. AJ

  looked over at Jesse. One night could change a life, and he wasn’t about to give up on another life-changing night because Renee seemed stuck in shock. “Coach left us in the parking lot and told us to go home. Banned from prom with two hours left.” Renee’s eyebrow arched. “So you went to an after-party, got drunk and got laid?”

  “Do you want to hear it or not?” AJ shot back.

  Renee held up her hands in defeat and took another sip of her drink. “Can’t wait. Sorry I missed it.”

  “I wanted to see all the pictures of you so we went to Jesse’s. His parents were out so we were alone. Seeing some of those pictures of you naked annoyed me again.”

  “And aroused him,” Jesse added.

  “So he did you like a substitute?” Renee asked Jesse. “Cock is addictive.”

  “Hell yeah. But it wasn’t a substitute.” AJ leaned over and kissed Jesse on the mouth. It felt like yesterday—that first time—but they’d had ten years together. Only one thing had been missing.

  “Do you two want the room? I can get another free. I’ve got plenty of flier miles.” She waved her glass, but her eyes stayed on them with interest.

  “No, you stay. I don’t remember you being such a prude.” Jesse leaned back in the bed.

  “I’m not a prude! Naked but very attractive pictures, remember. Sex in the football players’ locker room. Not a prude. I just don’t want to intrude when you don’t need me.” She pointed to them.

  AJ studied the beauty. Slim and sleek, her breasts and hips giving away her subtle curves.

  Her pixie face and angled bob of dark blonde hair still made him hard. “We want you here.” Renee set her drink down. “It’s getting a little weird in here, but two men having sex is hot. Finish the story.”

  “I got annoyed and turned on seeing the pictures. Basically, I accused Jesse of wanting you for himself and just playing the gay best friend thing to get close.” AJ gave Jesse a playful nudge.

  “So, I had to
show AJ that I was really after football meat that night.” Jesse grabbed AJ’s jeans and massaged his cock.

  AJ watched Renee’s eyes grow wider as his erection tented his pants.

  “Apparently, I’m getting the instant replay.” Renee squirmed in her chair.

  “Hit pause now or enjoy the show,” AJ said.

  When she didn’t say a word, Jesse continued unzipping AJ’s fly and removed his thick cock.

  AJ thrust up needing more of Jesse’s touch. Yet, AJ watched Renee, her pink lips hanging open in stunned silence. As Jesse licked the tip, AJ fucked up, the familiar jolt of heat increased by their audience. They’d waited for this, hoping she’d show up at the reunion.

  At least now, AJ knew why trying to track her down had been tricky. She never sat still, but between the two of them, they would manage to pin her down. It had taken some years to figure it all, out but they were a good team.

  Fisting a hand in Jesse’s dark hair, AJ thrust up until Jesse moaned. Jesse released AJ’s cock and stroked it for a bit. “Tell her how many times you sucked me off that night. If only his football buddies had seen him then.”

  AJ groaned, fucking harder. Jesse knew how to get him off with verbal play and a firm hand. The fact that Renee was still there looking flushed only pushed AJ to the edge faster. “I can’t take it.” He grabbed Jesse’s neck.

  “Just like that night, high school guys come if you flash them. He’s developed a lot of endurance, but with you watching him…” Jesse winked at Renee and leaned down to suck AJ’s cock back into his mouth.

  The tip of AJ’s cock rubbed the back of Jesse’s throat, triggering his release. He came hard, feeling just like that first time on prom night in high school without the jealously or immaturity.

  Pulling Jesse up, AJ kissed him hard. “Still good,” he mumbled against Jesse’s mouth.

  “This is really hot, but I’m still confused.” Renee tucked her hair behind her ears. “Is this some sort of sexual revenge because I left when you two fought? A ‘look what we’ve got?’

  Because it’s working. I’m horny and a little jealous but not sure where it’s going.” AJ sat up. “Renee, we’re not in high school anymore. I know it’s weird. Tonight, will be very wild. But we didn’t come here early to perform a sex act in your hotel room and rub it in your face.” Though the idea of rubbing her face places did get AJ’s juices flowing again.

  “So you just have oral sex in front of everyone?” Renee shrugged.

  “Sorry. This is hard to just blurt out.” AJ understood her frustration. They’d kept her in the dark long enough. He hoped she was turned on as well. Either she’d be into it or not, but dragging out the suspense wouldn’t help. The blush on her cheeks was unmistakable, and he took it as a good sign.

  “No blurting out news, but you’ll whip your cock out. Come on AJ! Blurt out with the info,” Renee urged.

  She sat there primly, legs crossed with a black skirt and a halter top in paisley green. The black heels had had AJ’s attention since the lobby.

  “It’s easier for men to solve issues with sex, so yeah, whipping it out is easier than explaining stuff. Makes being with a guy fun. But we’ve both had experiences with women that were great.” AJ tried to be subtle. While he’d found a whole new level of sexual satisfaction and intimacy with Jesse, he’d had amazing sex with Renee, too.

  Renee glanced to Jesse, staying quiet.

  “Bisexual isn’t a bad thing.” Jesse leaned in her direction.

  “I never said it was bad. It can be very hot. Wait, I’m not doing it with a girl, though.

  That doesn’t do it for me. Men are hot. Men together is a super turn on, I’ve always wanted to see it up close. I’m not sure how open you two are.”

  “You’re our turn on. We’re inviting you in.” AJ held out a hand.

  Renee uncrossed her legs, shifting her weight forward, but her face was scrunched with uncertainty. “The three of us. You two are both bisexual?”

  “That’s the idea. It’s not complicated.” AJ grinned. “I heard you’re staying over the weekend. We can make it memorable.”

  “We ruined your prom night. Thought this might be a fun way to make it up to you. That bad music and lousy food we can’t recreate.” Jesse tugged up AJ’s shirt to reveal killer abs.

  “You’re not going to the reunion? I want to see everyone’s faces when they find out AJ

  went for Jesse. Shocking people can be fun.” Renee eased from the chair and moved to the edge of the bed.

  AJ pulled her between him and Jesse. “That’s still on. Why not enjoy the down time?

  You can have anything you want this weekend. You’re the only woman we’ve both wanted. That hasn’t gone away in ten years.” He untied the knot at the back of her neck and let the halter top fall.

  The strapless bra underneath teased AJ, and the way Jesse’s cock strained in his jeans, he wanted more as well. Jesse undid the bottom part of the halter-top and tossed it aside.

  “This is crazy,” she said.

  AJ eased up her black skirt and found a thong teasing him. “What’s crazy is you dressed for sex and you didn’t even know.”

  “Maybe she knew she’d get lucky. Had plans for some of your football buddies?” Jesse suggested.

  “You think there was any way I ever expected this? I dressed for Vegas heat. But this is way hotter than the desert. Someone pinch me.” She stretched out on her side.

  AJ nodded to Jesse, and in unison, they gave her exactly what she asked for…a good pinch on each of her lush cheeks.

  Chapter Three

  “Ouch! It’s like a kinky, tag-team wrestling match. Are you guys serious?” she asked.

  “Think of it as make-up sex that’s very late.” AJ kissed her cheek.

  “Sounds good but I don’t want to mess things up between you. You’re my best high school memories. Guess it can’t hurt.” Renee pushed up Jesse’s shirt and yanked it over his head.

  “We’d never hurt you again. It was an immature mess, but we’re much older and more talented now.” Jesse unbuttoned her skirt and worked the zipper down. Looking at AJ, Jesse knew this was the right thing for both of them. AJ fell quickly into the bisexual category, while Jesse had struggled with admitting his lust for both men and women. The gay label had been safe in high school—at least, it had felt right. Then he was with AJ. But AJ sensed more to it and, every few years, brought up the girl thing.

  “Do you two do this a lot?” Renee leaned over to kiss AJ then back to kiss Jesse.

  Her soft lips sent him back to high school. He’d only ever been with one woman, and while it’d been great, Jesse had needed to deal with his need for men first. Liking girls didn’t disturb anyone. He took his time and kissed her thoroughly. She pressed to him and didn’t try to speed things along. Just a fling sounded good, but the feelings he had for Renee weren’t going to go away.

  “You’re the first.” AJ unhooked her bra and tossed it aside. His large hand covered one breast completely.

  Jesse ignored his pulsing erection and pushed Renee down to the bed on her back. Her breasts weren’t huge, but they were by no means small. What he remembered most was the roundness. They’d held up great. This was his fantasy, Renee between him and AJ.

  Sucking her breast, Jesse tugged her g-string down, and AJ grabbed it, taking it off completely. Then Jesse saw AJ’s hand on his belt. His boyfriend was right. If Jesse didn’t get out of those pants, he’d come like a freshman.

  “You two have never done a three-way before?” Renee gasped at their attention to her breasts. “How do you know you’ll like it?”

  Jesse climbed off the bed and stripped, his erection strained for more of AJ and Renee.

  “That’s how,” he said.

  As he returned, two hands reached for his cock, one male and one so female and soft Jesse bit his lip. AJ had been right. Without Renee, things were incomplete. At least now, they could figure out if they had a future.

  “Sure it’s n
ot just a fantasy?” Renee asked.

  “If it is?” AJ released Jesse’s cock and rubbed her bare pussy. “A weekend of fantasy sex isn’t such a terrible thing with old friends.”

  “I’m not complaining, but I don’t want it to be weird either. You and I used to date. The feelings were real, and we never really wrapped up our relationship. It was intense.” She stroked AJ’s growing cock but turned to face Jesse. “And you were my best friend who I wanted a lot. I don’t want to ruin friendships that could be rekindled, but you are very tempting.” She rubbed Jesse’s sac.

  “How many three-ways have you done?” AJ nipped at the side of her breast.

  Renee’s cheeks flared pink. “A few. But not with men I knew really well. Or who were in a relationship and would have sex with each other. I was the only one getting two lovers. This feels very different.”

  “We haven’t done much to you yet.” Jesse rubbed his cock against her hip. “Don’t worry.

  AJ has enough three-way porn. If we didn’t want this, we’d know it by now.” AJ’s hand gripped her hips. “But if it’s too weird with us, Renee, it’s okay. I can keep Jesse busy until the reunion.”

  “Oh no!” Renee rolled onto AJ and kissed him. “You’re not getting out of it now. You two got me all hot and ready. If it’s not weird for you, then I need to live out this fantasy. Just don’t be shy about going after each other. I’m used to being the main attraction and watching could be really hot.”

  “You are the main attraction this time.” Jesse moved in closer. Renee and AJ had dated for a year. He’d heard all about the sex, and it was good—high school good, but they’d learned a lot since then. In high school, Jesse had always felt a little jealous. Now, he couldn’t tell if it was jealousy of Renee or AJ.

  “Good. But that doesn’t mean I don’t want to watch. I thought I had experience, but I’ve never been with two guys who are bisexual.” She leaned toward Jesse, licking his cock and guiding him to AJ with her mouth.

  Giving in to the feel, Jesse let AJ lead him in. Jesse straddled AJ’s head, facing Renee.

  The second AJ’s touch connected with Jesse’s balls, all thought went away.