Babysitter's Club Alyssa

by Jordan Silver

  I climbed in behind her and put my arm around her waist with my eyes on her face. She stretched and smiled before her eyes came open slowly. “Hi!” Her voice was hesitant, almost fearful and I took a guess at what she was thinking.

  “Hi beautiful how do you feel?” I ran my hand down her thigh to her pussy and cupped it. “Any pain?” She blushes so prettily, my little virgin doll.

  “Just sore!”

  “Does this feel good?” I played around the outside of her cunt with my fingers, not letting them go in. She arched into my hand and cooed. “Yes!” I should take my hand away before I got something started that I had no intentions on finishing.

  She needs time to heal and though the wait might kill me, I’ll do it for her. She moved against my fingers, her clit getting fatter and longer with each stroke.

  She has a large clit and I love it. I love that I can hold it in my mouth and play to my heart’s content. Like now! I might not be able to fuck her for at least another day or two, but there was nothing stopping me from pleasuring her with my mouth.

  With that thought in mind, I pulled the sheet from around her and made my way down the bed, settling my shoulders between her legs. Her pussy was a mess.

  It was red, swollen, and beat to shit. I felt equal parts contrite and happy as fuck. This was mine, this beautiful cavern of pink lust was all mine. No one else had ever been there and as I breathe, no one else ever would.

  I licked ‘my’ pussy as my heart thundered in my chest. I lapped up her juices as they flowed and went back for more time and time again until she climaxed in my mouth, clutching my head to her cunt as she ground it into my face.

  I waited until she came down before getting to my knees between her spread thighs with my cock in hand. I stroked my cock as I looked into her eyes.

  “I’m going to teach you how to suck my cock the way I like.” Her eyes followed my hand and her nostrils flared. “Get on your knees!”

  She got to her knees in front of me. “Touch it.” I took her hand and led it to my cock. Keeping her hand under mine I showed her how to stroke my shaft until pre-cum coated her hand.

  “Now take me into your mouth, just the tip, that’s a good girl. Now lick the slit with your tongue until you taste me.” She followed my instructions and pretty soon her own natural instinct kicked in and she was chasing my pre-cum with her tongue.

  She licked me like an ice cream cone before sucking my swollen cockhead into her warm mouth. “Fuck that feels good.” I didn’t ask her if she’d done this before because it was obvious that she hadn’t.

  It was the look of wonder on her face each time my cock jumped on her tongue that convinced me of that. Or the way she tried getting too much cock in her mouth and was mortified when she choked. I played in her hair and soothed her ruffled feathers, telling her how proud I was of her.

  “You’re doing good baby, I love your mouth.” I caressed her cheek and chin with my thumb. “Now I’m going to fuck your mouth with my cock. Don’t use your hands to stop me. In fact, clasp your hands behind you.”

  She did as I said and her head tilted back a little. It was the perfect angle to fuck into her throat. I started out slow, getting her used to having her air passage blocked off.

  She choked, gagged and dribbled, all over my cock, but she didn’t stop. “Look up at me while you suck my cock. I want to see your eyes.” She did, and the look in them almost had me shooting.

  I reached over her back and down between her legs and she was soaking wet. She was getting off on sucking my cock. “Oh baby! we’re gonna have so much fun.” For the next sixty years at least is what I’m thinking.

  Once she got used to my slow fucking I picked up the pace. Before long I was face fucking her, my dick knocking against her tonsils and slipping into her throat.

  Each time she gagged I pulled back but went right back in again. She’s a fast learner I’ll give her that. Though I did enjoy her clumsiness, her innocence. I can’t wait to teach her more.

  Gage

  I took care of her for the rest of the day, never letting her leave the bed, not even when my kids got home from school. I told them she wasn’t feeling well and that’s why she was laying down in my bed.

  They were in and out ‘taking care’ of her for the rest of the evening until the dreaded time came. She had to go home, I didn’t want her to leave my sight.

  I know I was being unreasonable, but how can I get her to understand? What man in his right mind, when finding a gem, a precious something that no one else in the world could ever own, wouldn’t want to keep that thing for himself?

  “Tell your mom that you’re moving in here a little early. I want you in my bed tomorrow night no arguments.” I was only appeased when she got up on her toes and kissed me goodnight at the door.

  It was only after she left that I realized I still didn’t know why she’d been crying earlier. Shit! I’d spent the rest of the afternoon before the school bus pulled up, playing in her pussy. I didn’t give her my cock again, but I used my mouth and fingers to please her.

  We’d ended things off with a classic sixty-nine which she seemed to enjoy immensely. The girl loves sucking cock, my cock. So there hadn’t been much room for talking. One or the other of us had a mouthful all afternoon.

  I hope her mother doesn’t notice the marks I left on her body and freak. She’s old enough of course, but I’m older and in a position to take unfair advantage.

  So until I make my intentions known, I’d rather not have the wrath of a concerned mother coming down on my head.

  I smiled as I walked through the house turning off lights and making sure the place was locked down tight. I waited until she’d had enough time to get home before calling. I didn’t want her answering her phone in the car.

  “You’re home. I just remembered, you never told me why you were crying before.” There was a long silent pause on her end.

  “Can we talk about that tomorrow?” I got the feeling that she didn’t want her mom overhearing whatever it was she had to say. We stayed on the phone for about an hour and I was amazed at how time had flown by.

  I kept the conversation light so as not to make her uncomfortable, but I got to learn a little more about the girl that had made her way into my heart.

  “Come early tomorrow, and don’t forget, tell your mom you’re staying a few days early. I need you.” Her voice was breathy when she answered and we hung up a few minutes later.

  In the morning as I made breakfast, I thought of the best way to tell my kids about the change in our relationship. They knew she was moving in for the summer, but they didn’t know she’d be sleeping in daddy’s bed and that her time here will now be extended.

  “Kids, how do you feel about Alyssa moving in here with us, for good?” My little girl didn’t get it though she was excited to have one of her favorite people near, but my son seemed to read between the lines.

  He nodded his head as he took a bite of his sausage and I think I saw him relax. When I walked them to the door later I stopped him with a hand on his shoulder.

  “Are you sure you’re cool with this?”

  “Yeah dad, I like Alyssa, she’s cool and she’s never mean to Chels and me.” Which meant someone else had been.

  I fought back emotion and nodded my head, squeezing his shoulder before letting him leave and follow his sister who was calling for him to hurry up.

  I paced around the house getting nothing done and even considered going after her a time or two. About an hour after the kids left the phone rang. It was one of my buddies from the team.

  “Hey what’s up you miss me already? Practice is only a few weeks away.” I joked as soon as I heard his voice. I stopped laughing when I realized he wasn’t talking and there was no humor coming from his end.

  “What is it?” I thought he was going to tell me that one of our team mates had been hurt or something like that, but the words that came out of his mouth left me just as cold.

  “Dude, your ex has b
een up to some nasty shit.”

  “I’m not interested in anything that woman did in the past or…”

  “No-no-no, you’re gonna want to hear this. Do you know she went to the coach and told him that you were fucking your babysitter when she was still a kid?”

  “What the fuck did you just say?”

  “Yeah, and apparently the girl was questioned yesterday by some reporter outside her house. She denied everything of course, and you know coach, I think he told her to fuck off. Scorned woman and all that. I just thought you should know.”

  “Yeah, thanks for telling me.” I hung up the phone almost in a daze. Why hadn’t she told me that something as serious as this was going on?

  I was about to call her when I saw her pull up outside and had the door open before she made it down the walkway. She had a bright cheery smile on her face which disappeared when she got a look at my face.

  “Get in here. Why didn’t you tell me what happened to you yesterday? That you were questioned by a reporter in front of your house?” She looked troubled and a little scared I guess.

  “I didn’t know…I wasn’t sure how to tell you. I didn’t want you to be mad again and…” I took her hands in mine, some of my anger leaving me at the misery on her face.

  I reminded myself that she was still young in more ways than one. I’m gonna have to remember not to treat her with the same distrust as I did the lying hag I’d just divorced.

  “Okay come ‘ere, don’t cry. I’m gonna take care of it. Did you tell your mom?” She nodded her head against my chest.

  “I had to, they kept calling this morning.” Dammit.

  “And what did she say?”

  “I told her the truth, that we hadn’t done anything back then, but now…” She looked at me as if expecting me to be mad that she’d shared our secret.

  “I’m glad you were brave enough to be honest with your mom. I’ll have a talk with her later. Right now we have somewhere to go.” It was a spur of the moment decision but one that worked for me. I had no intentions on proving anything to anyone, but I wasn’t about to let her walk around this town with a target on her back.

  Those who knew me knows that I would never have broken my vows, and I damn sure wouldn’t have fucked a sixteen year old.

  I’m guessing the reason the cops hadn’t shown up at my house is because sixteen happens to be the age of consent in this state. Still it’s the principal of the matter.

  I didn’t worry about what people would think after I made this move. My only interest was in reassuring her, and her mom maybe, with the added bonus of sticking it to Tanya. Like I said, there isn’t shit she or anyone else can do to me.

  She balked when I pulled her into the luxury jeweler. “Stop it!” I tugged on her hand and pulled her over to the case I was looking for.

  Beneath the glass were the engagement rings with rocks the size of marbles. When I got married the first time I was still young and was careful with my first paycheck. I’d always planned to upgrade Tanya’s ring, but never got around to it. I know this shit would make her green as fuck.

  I chose the one I wanted, it was a simple cushion cut, four carats with another carat of pave diamonds around the center stone. It was huge on her little hand, in other words, just right.

  She stared at that thing and then at me for a solid five minutes, her mouth hanging open and not saying a word. Then she fell into my chest and burst into tears.

  From there I called up a reporter buddy of mine, who’s been following the team for a good few years. I gave him an exclusive which I knew would be going nationwide by the next day.

  It’s like I said, in the beginning I’d kept my head down and did what I had to-to protect my kids. But once all Tanya was had come to light, the gloves came off. One thing I will never be is a patsy for any fucking one on this earth.

  “Happy?” We were in the car on the way back to the house. I’d dragged her with me to the interview but refused to let them question her. I’m the one in the spotlight, not her. They don’t need to be in her shit.

  “Yes very. But are you sure…”

  “Don’t ask me that question again. After yesterday I’d already made up my mind to marry you, this thing just escalated my plans is all.”

  And I wasn’t even mad. My kids already knew and so did her mother apparently, and that’s all the fuck I care about. In fact I felt very relaxed and at peace with this turn of events.

  It was good that we’d gotten out of the house anyway, because I didn’t want her to think that all I wanted from her was sex. At least with my ring on her finger she should be a lot more at ease with what we were doing.

  I can’t imagine she’d given up her virginity lightly. I sure the hell don’t take it that way. And I plan to spend a lot of time showing her just how grateful I was that she’d chosen me as her mate.

  I started that shit as soon as we walked through the door. By the time we made it to the couch I had her stripped with my hand between her legs and two fingers shoved inside her pussy.

  Gage

  "Fuck Alyssa don't fuck back at me like that you'll make me cum too soon." I held still as my cock pulsed strongly in her clenching pussy and gritted my teeth against the oncoming explosion.

  We’d been at it for hours. I fucked her once on the couch, then again on the stairs leading up to our room. Once in the shower where I bent her over and ate her pussy because she said she was sore. But once I’d given her my mouth and her pink pussy winked at me from behind, I couldn’t help myself.

  I damn near killed her up against the shower wall as I pounded her tight little cunt without mercy. She was still having trouble taking me, but she seemed to get off on the pain.

  I can get behind that. I find I have this new kink in me. Her small stature, her age, everything about her made me feel controlling, something I warned her about when I was balls deep in her.

  “You ever cheat on me they’ll never find you. Do you hear me?”

  She nodded her head as she pushed her ass back for my dick. “Yes, yes sir.” She remembered. I’d finished fucking her in the shower and dragged her out and put her in my bed because I wasn’t done with her yet.

  I had two years of fucking to make up for and her little ass was gonna pay the price. She wanted to suck my dick so I laid with my head at her toes, so that I could eat her out while she polished my knob.

  She teased and sucked my cock and balls until my dick grew to its fullest. I put her on her hands and knees and slammed my cock into her tight pussy, making her cry out and tear at the sheets.

  And that’s where we are now. With me on my knees behind her, her hips in my hands as I fuck in and out of her doggy style. I think this might be her favorite position because her pussy is even juicier than usual.

  I watched my cock slice in and out of her pink gash. She arched her back deep, “That’s it, cock that ass in the air for me baby.” I knew that her pussy hurt moans weren’t a plea for me to stop, she loves it.

  I reached around and under her for her tit and squeezed as she clamped down on my dick. “I don’t want to cum yet.” It’s a fucking nuisance. Each time I tell myself that I’m gonna last longer than a half an hour she uses her pussy to prove me wrong.

  Usually after I’ve blasted once it can take me a while to shoot again. But not only does she make me cum too soon, she also gets my dick hard as fuck in less time than it usually takes in between fucks.

  “Cum in me Gage, I like to feel you cum inside me.” Well shit, there goes my plans to make this shit last this time. With her words she squeezed her pussy muscles and fucked her cunt back hard on my rod.

  “You want to get bred, is that what you’re saying?” I sped up my thrusts and plowed into her belly making her cry out. “Tell me you want me to breed you, beg me for my seed.”

  That made her cum all over my cock and the words were a jumbled mess but I understood them. I hadn’t discussed this with her and thought for sure that once the haze of lust cleared she’d
have something to say, but nope.

  After I came in her for about the fifth time we rolled away from each other barely breathing. I rolled over on my side and snagged her around her waist, looking down into her eyes until they cleared.

  “You know I’m serious right.” I lifted the hand with my ring and licked her knuckle. “I want you to have my baby, our baby. In fact, the way I fuck you, you might end up with one a year in you.”

  From the smile she gave me I don’t think she minded too much. “I want you to stay here in my bed, I’ve got some stuff to take care of.” I looked at my watch as I rolled out of bed.

  “I should be back by the time the kids get home. How about the four of us go out to dinner?” She smiled at me and relaxed back against my pillow. There was still a bit of shyness about her, which is cute.

  I take that back. As I watched her she let the sheet slide down her body and bent one knee in the bed, rocking it back and forth so that her sweet pussy winked at me. Of course my mouth started to water and my dick came to attention.

  “Dammit baby, I have somewhere to go.” That didn’t stop me from climbing back into bed and crawling between her thighs. Her pussy smelt like her juices and mine, but I didn’t care.

  I tasted myself when I dipped my tongue inside her to eat her out, but since it was mixed with her sweet nectar I decided I liked it just fine.

  We ended up fucking again and she kept me trapped in her pussy all day so I had to put off my errands for another day and dinner was pizza we ordered from a local chain.

  Oh well, at least I was pretty sure that I’d bred her one of the times I came deep inside her. If nothing else, the womb fuck I gave her at the end should’ve done the trick.

  By the time my very candid interview went live the next day the whole place was in an uproar. My manager and even the coach and my teammates were quick to vouch for me.