His Twisted Choice

by Amelia James

  I forgot about the knot and finally managed to kick him. “Don’t ever do that again!”

  He shoved my foot away. “Don’t you ever do it. I know how.”

  Talia sat up and put her hand on my knee. “He does. We’re safe.”

  The color returned to her face, and her breathing evened out. She’s all right. “It looked like you were gonna kill her.”

  Alex shook his head. “I know when to stop.”

  “She’s got fingerprints on her neck!”

  Talia rubbed her throat. “They’ll fade by tomorrow.” She knelt between my legs. “Thank you for being so concerned.” She stroked my leg and his. “I like having a protector.”

  Her boyfriend grinned. “He’s your hero. I’m your bad boy. That works.”

  I’d rescue her all day long if I had to.

  She leaned back and looked up at him. “May I give him a blow job?”

  Alex grinned and played with her nipple. “Do you think he deserves it?”

  “I think he needs to relax.”

  “That’s true.” He laughed. “Chill out, man. You’re gonna blow a gasket.”

  The hand still tied to the chair was balled into a fist, and my fingernails left half-circles in my palm as I unclenched. I remembered to breathe, but tension still held my body in its rigid grip.

  Talia massaged my thigh. “Trust us.”

  Is that what Alex had on his agenda? He’d allowed Talia to sit beside me at the restaurant, watched me kiss her without interfering. They’d permitted me to watch them fuck without touching—the ropes just heightened the experience. They let me see the proof I needed to trust them.

  I leaned back and let Talia caress my legs. “I do.”

  She looked over her shoulder at Alex.

  “Give it to him.”

  My cock sprang upright as she pulled my zipper down—still hard even after watching Alex nearly strangle her. Hmm, maybe they were onto something.

  “Mmm… yummy.” Talia wrapped her fingers around my erection and licked her lips. She stroked me, easing the neglected ache while stoking the embers burning for her.

  Alex pulled his pants on and sat on the couch, drinking his beer and watching.

  She tugged my jeans down to my knees and brushed her breasts on my thighs as she bent over and circled my hard-on with her tongue. Her hard nipples tickled my skin, and her soft moan buzzed my cock.

  I closed my eyes and let my body go limp. My senses took over as her warm, wet mouth pulled me in. Soft slurps reached my ears as flickering licks assaulted my shaft. I grabbed her hair and held her while she sucked.

  Fucking hell, I love this woman. Should I tell her? I peeked at her golden brown hair spilling across my thighs and down her back toward her heart-shaped ass. She probably knew how I felt about her, but I couldn’t risk saying the words.

  Should I tell him? I shifted my gaze toward Alex without turning my head. He held a bottle in one hand and stroked his crotch with the other, a dazed smile on his face. I knew that look well. I’d worn it every time I watched him fuck the woman I loved, happy to let him do it as long as it was just sex. Then he’d gotten attached and everything went to hell.

  Don’t tell. We’d agreed on no secrets, but I had to keep this one to protect myself. To protect all of us. Just sex.

  Talia cupped my balls, reinforcing that idea as she dragged her tongue along my cock. No emotions, no one gets hurt. She sucked my dick all the way down.Just—holy hell—mind-blowing sex.

  She moaned and I watched her toes curl as they peeked out from under her butt. Those embers sparked, and her tongue fanned the flames into a fucking bonfire.

  I clutched the armrests while her mouth and her hands rocked me. My knees trembled and my balls tightened as the pressure mounted. Her relentless tongue whipped up a firestorm, and my dick erupted before I could warn her. “Ahh… shit!”

  But she handled it well, sucking and swallowing as I pumped her mouth. Before I came to my senses, and before Alex could tell her not to, she’d crawled onto my lap and kissed me, her tempting pussy hovering one small shift above my quivering dick.

  I tasted sex on her tongue. Nothing more. I pulled back and touched my mouth to hers, lips closed, heart sealed off. “Thank you. I needed that.”

  “Want more?” She planted her bare ass on my naked thighs.

  Yes! “Not tonight.”

  “Soon?”

  I glanced over her shoulder at Alex and he nodded. “We’ll see.”

  “Okay.” She kissed my cheek and untied my arm.

  “Holy fucking hell.” Alex rubbed his hand over his red face and through his hair. “Now I know why you love to watch, man. Doesn’t get much hotter than that.”

  I pulled up my pants. “Yeah, it’s pretty… damn, my brain isn’t working.” I stood and slipped my arm around Talia’s waist, leaning in to kiss her cheek. “What did you do to me?”

  Alex got up and moved behind her, fondling her ass as he nestled her between us. “How come we never knew she liked to perform?”

  “We never told her she had an audience.”

  He leaned down and kissed the top of her head. “Lesson learned. From now on we need to tell each other about all our kinks.”

  She snuggled back against him. “And then we can show how they’re done.” She giggled and he grinned.

  They’re so happy. What’s wrong with me?

  Alex patted my shoulder. “Want another beer?”

  I shook my head. “I should go.” If I stayed any longer, I’d end up in bed with them. Not a bad idea, but not yet.

  Talia pouted. “Will you go out with us again?”

  “Yeah. Check the Rockies’ schedule. I’ll pay for the good seats.”

  Alex shot back. “Hey, you were unemployed. I was doing you a favor.”

  “Whatever.” I searched my pockets for my keys.

  Talia pulled Alex’s shirt over her head and walked me to the door. “Call me. Or Alex. Either one.” A devious smile lit her eyes as she groped my crotch. “Or both.”

  “You beautiful slut.” I kissed her naughty lips and smacked her ass. “Sweet dreams, darlin’.”

  “Mm-hmm.”

  I nodded good night to Alex and closed the door behind me. The cool mountain air refreshed my lungs and replenished my body, but my heart still felt like lead. Could I be as happy as the woman I loved and her boyfriend? With them? Without them?

  Alex’s security light switched on as I climbed in my truck, flooding the cab with a blinding truth. Talia came with Alex. If I wanted her, I had to take him, too.

  Can I take that risk again? The truck started on the first try, roaring to life with strength I hadn’t known it possessed.

  I glanced toward the house and watched Alex’s t-shirt ride up Talia’s thighs as she raised her arm to wave goodbye. Right then I chose to do anything to make her happy—no matter the risk.

  Now what the hell am I going to do about Claire?

  Perfect

  “So what are you going to do about Claire?” Alex had told me not to ask Will about her, and I’d managed to do it for a couple of days, but the question finally burst out of me.

  Will shook his head and signaled to turn left into the parking garage. “Right now, I’m just hoping we don’t run into her leaving Alex’s office.”

  “She knows we’re friends, right?” I glanced at my watch. Claire usually went home at five, but sometimes Alex asked her to work late. He wouldn’t do that tonight.

  “I told her we went out, but I didn’t go into detail.” He pulled into a parking space and searched the groups of employees leaving the building. “How close are you with her?”

  “I didn’t know her well when I first came here. We could be friends. I like her. I’m starting over here, too, and I need a female friend. I’d hate to have you come between us.” But if she got between me and Will….

  He gritted his teeth. “Let’s go.”

  I opened the door and jumped out. “Don’t worry, I’m sure she
wouldn’t be surprised to see us together.”

  He locked the truck. “I know, but I feel bad for leaving her hanging while trying to figure out what the hell to do with my life.”

  He hasn’t decided? We hadn’t seen Will since I’d tied him up and gave him that amazing blow job, but I hoped he’d gotten over Claire. Apparently not.

  We scurried across the parking garage to the elevators and waited for one to empty, then we hopped on. The doors closed, leaving us alone. I stepped close to Will and fondled his firm ass.

  “Hey!” He scooted away from my wandering hand. “Does Alex know you’re accosting me?”

  “I’ll tell him.” I backed him into a corner and slid my fingers along his stiff crotch. “He likes that.”

  He slipped his hand under my shirt. “Bastard picked up my bad habits.”

  I wiggled my fingers into his pants and touched his hard cock. “I never imagined you could corrupt him.”

  Will laughed and shoved my bra cups down to pinch my nipples. “See? I’m not always the nice guy.” He yanked my shirt up and licked a hard bud. “Why are you wearing a bra?”

  “Take it off.” But the elevator stopped at Alex’s floor. We adjusted our clothes and walked down the hall. “Did you get good seats?”

  “Lower deck right behind home plate.”

  “Sounds nice.” As if I cared. I’d rather spend the time formatting spreadsheets than watching a bunch of guys spit tobacco and cop a feel, but if I got to sit between my two favorite men, I’d endure it.

  We walked into Alex’s suite. Claire’s empty chair sat beside her dark computer monitor. I glanced at Will and he shrugged.

  He needs to commit.

  To what? To me? Me and Alex?

  Well, yeah.

  Alex leaned back, holding the phone to his ear as he waved us in. Will settled in the chair in front of his desk, and I perched on the credenza behind Alex. He stroked my thigh while he listened and nodded.

  “Right. I’ll have the motion ready by noon tomorrow.” He hung up the phone and glared straight at Will. “Found her yet?”

  “I’m close. I know it.”

  “Close isn’t good enough. I need her.”

  I kicked Alex’s chair. “Who?” Are they sharing another woman?

  He grabbed my ankle and nibbled my knee. “A witness, or a suspect.”

  Will kicked his feet up on Alex’s desk. “Most likely a victim.”

  They’re working on a case, idiot! “Oh, never mind.”

  “Get those boots off my files.”

  Will grinned and ignored him. He winked at me. “Are you gonna tell him?”

  “Tell him…?” Oh, the dirty details. I ran my hand through Alex’s hair. “He groped me in the elevator.”

  Will snorted. “She started it.”

  My boyfriend, yeah that works, rolled his eyes. “And I’m sure you tried to stop her.”

  My lover, mmm nice, shrugged. “Um… no.”

  I slid my hand down Alex’s chest, tugging at his buttons. “He pulled my shirt up, and licked my nipples.”

  “And?”

  Will scowled. “And she’s wearing a bra.”

  Alex yanked my shirt up. “What the hell?”

  I pulled it back in place. “I always wear a bra in public.”

  “Lame excuse. Take it off before we go.”

  “But if I get cold–or aroused—you’ll see my nipples through my t-shirt.”

  “Guys like that.”

  Will shifted in his chair. “Hell yeah.”

  I sat up straight to get a better look at the wood in my lover’s jeans, then I circled my boyfriend’s nipple with my fingertip and watched his crotch get stiff. Well, damn. I can’t let this opportunity go to waste. “What if I take it off and we don’t go?”

  Alex rubbed my leg. “I thought you wanted to go out.”

  “Baseball is boring. I’d rather stay here and play with your balls.” I braced a hand on Alex’s shoulder and reached down to stroke his cock. Then I got up and knocked Will’s feet to the floor so I could sit on the desk. “And yours.”

  He spread his legs as if expecting and encouraging my hand on his hard-on.

  Alex moaned behind me as I fondled his friend.

  “I’m sure we won’t miss much if we’re a couple hours late.” I turned around and sat on Will’s lap, leaning back against him as his arms slid around my waist.

  Alex raised an eyebrow. “You think we’ll last for a couple hours?”

  “That’s why I have two of you. You’ll last as long as I want.” I loved having two—loved it—and I’d do everything I could to keep them.

  “Are you okay with this, Will?”

  My lover groaned as I squirmed in his lap. “I don’t care about the tickets.”

  “I know that.” Alex threw a pen at him. “Last time you told me you didn’t want to get in too deep until you got your life in order.”

  I sat still, remembering how he’d resisted the idea. Damn it! It would be so easy to rub my ass on his dick or flash my tits and render him thoughtless, but I scooted to his knees and folded my hands in my lap. “I don’t want to push you.”

  Will smiled and swept my hair across my shoulder, his warm fingers grazing my neck. “If I waited till my life was perfect, I’d never get to touch you.”

  “It’s never perfect. We learned that the hard way.”

  “Yep.” He slid his hand under the back of my shirt and unhooked my bra.

  I moved in. “I promise I won’t tie you down this time.”

  “Mmm… good girl”

  “No.” I stood and pulled my shirt over my head. “Bad girl.” I bent forward over Alex’s desk and let my bra fall off my shoulders while Will slipped his fingers under my shorts.

  Alex caressed my naked breasts. “Lock my door.”

  Will got up and crossed the room in two steps, closed the door, moved behind me again and swatted my ass. “Feeding time.”

  Huh?

  Alex laughed and stood in front of my face. “Are you hungry, baby?”

  I unzipped his pants and released his erection. “Always.” While my lover pulled my shorts and panties off, I sucked my boyfriend’s cock.

  Will pulled the chair close and sat down to tease my pussy, fingering me first, then nipping at my thighs and tasting me with long, slow licks.

  Alex shoved his hands between me and his desk, knocking files on the floor while he stroked my nipples. He fucked my mouth while Will mouth-fucked my pussy.

  Oh my God, I missed them so much! I wiggled back against my lover’s face, but maintained a firm grip on my boyfriend’s cock. My elbow smacked the keyboard as I shifted to stroke his balls. “Ow.”

  “Uncomfortable?” Alex massaged my back.

  “Yeah.” I turned over and sat up. Will scooted back to give me room to kick my shoes off and slide my shorts to the floor. Then I lay back on the desk, stretching my arms above my head and spreading my legs, offering my body to the only two men I wanted—the two men I loved. “Play with me.”

  Will sucked his breath in and Alex grunted. I slid my fingers between my legs and touched my clit, shivering while I waited for them to take action.

  “Mmm….” Alex leaned over and kissed me, slipping his tongue into my mouth and twisting it with mine. Will kissed my thighs, flicking his tongue on my quivering skin. Hot showering sparks danced on my flesh as they planted kisses all over my body: sucking a nipple, sipping my clit, nipping, biting, and licking me into a quivering glob of Jell-O.

  “I’m gonna make her come first,” Will said to Alex as they each licked a nipple.

  “You can try.” Alex reached down and tugged on my clit while Will slid two fingers into my wet pussy.

  “Oh my God!” Endless waves of bliss surged over my body, carrying me along on a rushing ride between the two men.

  They rubbed and stroked, still sucking my nipples while I slapped my hands on the desk, searching for something to hold on to. I managed to grab Will’s hair and Al
ex’s leg and then the wave crested and broke, crashing down over us and sweeping me away.

  Will sat back, still fingering me. “Call that a draw?”

  Alex shrugged and pulled a quarter from his pocket. “Heads, I get to fuck her first. Tails, you do.”

  I slapped his hand from underneath, knocking the coin to the floor. “What am I? A contest?”

  Will grinned. “No, sweetheart, you’re the prize.”

  I can live with that. “Will gets to fuck me first.”

  My lover’s gaze shifted to his friend.

  Alex nodded and sat down. “That’s cool. I’ll watch.”

  Will unzipped his jeans and shoved them to the floor. His cock stood straight up, begging for my pussy.

  “Ooo….” I sat up and wrapped my hands around that beautiful thing. “Let me play.”

  He grunted and wobbled, then braced his hands on the desk while I stroked.

  I leaned back a space and smiled into his dazed eyes. “Hi.”

  “Hi.” He kissed me, soft and gentle, then with deepening urgency, plunging his tongue into my mouth as I pulled on his erection.

  Will pressed me down on the desk and stepped between my thighs, thrusting his cock into my pussy and gasping in my ear. I caught my breath and sank my fingers into his long, thick hair. Only a few weeks had passed since we’d fucked, but this thrust, that kiss, reunited us with meaning and passion. He rocked my body, holding me close as I wrapped my legs around him.

  Don’t let go.

  “Welcome home,” Alex said from behind me.

  Will grunted and stood up, still fucking me. “Want some?” he said to Alex as he groped one of my breasts.

  “Yes, I do.” Alex stroked my nipples as I reached for his cock and pulled it into my mouth.

  Will’s momentum drove me into Alex, and I sucked him while my lover fucked me. As much as I loved having two cocks, it had to be these two. And these hands roaming my body—Alex’s fingers playing my clit, Will’s thumb brushing my nipple. Both or neither at all.

  My eyes stung and a lump stuck in my throat. I pulled my boyfriend’s cock out and gasped for breath.

  “Are you okay?” Alex caressed my hair. I nodded and he leaned over to kiss me, drawing my tongue into his mouth and loving it.

  “I need you,” I gasped on his lips. “I can’t ever be without you.”