City (S.F. MASTERWORKS)

by Clifford D. Simak

Still alien by all other standards, the second tale strikes a more familiar note than did the first. Here, for the first time, the reader gains an impression that this tale might have been born about a Doggish campfire, a situation unthinkable so far as the first tale is concerned.

  Here is voiced some of the high moral and ethical concepts which the Dogs have come to value. Here, too, is a struggle which a Dog can understand, even though the struggle does reveal the mental and moral deterioration of its central character.

  For the first time, too, a character emerges which has a familiar ring – the robot. In the robot Jenkins, first introduced in this story, one comes to know a character which for thousands of years has been a puppish favourite. Jenkins is regarded by Tige as the real hero of the legend. In him he sees an extension of Man’s influence beyond the day of Man’s disappearance, a mechanical device by which human thought continued to guide the Dogs long after Man himself was gone.

  We still have our robots, valuable and lovable little contraptions that exist for one purpose only – to furnish us with hands. Throughout the years, however, a Dog’s robot has become so much a part of him that no Dog now regards his robot as a thing apart.

  Tige’s insistence that the robot is an invention of Man, a heritage that our race carries forward from Man, has been sturdily attacked by most other students of the legend.

  The idea that the robot may have been fashioned and given to the Dogs as an aid to the development of their culture, Bounce believes, is an idea which must be summarily ruled out by the very virtue of its romanticism. It is, he contends, a story device on the face of it and as such must necessarily be suspect from the first.

  There is no way now of knowing how the Dogs evolved a robot. Those few scholars who have given some time to a study of the development of robotry, point out that the highly specialized use to which the robot is put does indeed argue that it was invented by a Dog. To be so specialized, they argue, the robot must necessarily have been invented and developed by the race for whose particular use it is so singularly fitted. No one other than a Dog, they contend, could have done so good a job on so intricate a tool.

  To say that no Dog to-day could build a robot is begging the question. No Dog to-day could build a robot because there is no need to build one, since the robots build themselves. When there was a need, it is quite evident that a Dog did build a robot and, by building a robot endowed with the reproductive urge which resulted in his building others like himself, solved the problem in a typically Doggish manner.

  In this story likewise is introduced an idea which runs through the rest of the legend and which for long has puzzled all students and most readers. That is the idea that one may move physically off this world, out into space, crossing it to reach other worlds. While the idea in most part has been regarded as pure fantasy which, of course, has its proper place in any legend, a good deal of study has been devoted to it. Most studies have confirmed the belief that such a thing is impossible. Such a belief would argue that the stars which we see at night are mighty worlds at great distances from our worlds. Everyone knows, of course, that they are only lights hanging in the sky and that most of them are very near to us.

  Bounce advances what may be the best explanation for the origin of the across-space world idea. It is, he says, no more than an ancient story-teller’s twist on the cobbly worlds, the existence of which the Dogs have known since dim antiquity.

  II

  Huddling Place

  The drizzle sifted from the leaden skies, like smoke drifting through the bare-branched trees. It softened the hedges and hazed the outlines of the buildings and blotted out the distance. It glinted on the metallic skins of the silent robots and silvered the shoulders of the three humans listening to the intonations of the black-garbed man, who read from the book cupped between his hands.

  ‘For I am the Resurrection and the Life—’

  The moss-mellowed graven figure that reared above the door of the crypt seemed straining upwards, every crystal of its yearning body reaching towards something that no one else could see. Straining as it had strained since that day of long ago when men had chipped it from the granite to adorn the family tomb with a symbolism that had pleased the first John J. Webster in the last years he held of life.

  ‘And whosoever liveth and believeth in Me—’

  Jerome A. Webster felt his son’s fingers tighten on his arm, heard the muffled sobbing of his mother, saw the lines of robots standing rigid, heads bowed in respect to the master they had served. The master who now was going home – to the final home of all.

  Numbly, Jerome A. Webster wondered if they understood – if they understood life and death – if they understood what it meant that Nelson F. Webster lay there in the casket, that a man with a book intoned words above him.

  Nelson F. Webster, fourth of the line of Websters who had lived on these acres, had lived and died here, scarcely leaving, and now was going to his final rest in that place the first of them had prepared for the rest of them – for that long line of shadowy descendants who would live here and cherish the things and the ways and the life that the first John J. Webster had established.

  Jerome A. Webster felt his jaw muscles tighten, felt a little tremor run across his body. For a moment his eyes burned and the casket blurred in his sight and the words the man in black was saying were one with the wind that whispered in the pines standing sentinel for the dead. Within his brain remembrance marched – remembrance of a grey-haired man stalking the hills and fields, sniffing the breeze of an early morning, standing, legs braced, before the flaring fireplace with a glass of brandy in his hand.

  Pride – the pride of land and life, and the humility and greatness that quiet living breeds within a man. Contentment of casual leisure and surety of purpose. Independence of assured security, comfort of familiar surroundings, freedom of broad acres.

  Thomas Webster was joggling his elbow. ‘Father,’ he was whispering. ‘Father.’

  The service was over. The black-garbed man had closed his book. Six robots stepped forward, lifted the casket.

  Slowly the three followed the casket into the crypt, stood silently as the robots slid it into its receptacle, closed the tiny door and affixed the plate that read:

  NELSON F. WEBSTER

  2034–2117

  That was all. Just the name and dates. And that, Jerome A. Webster found himself thinking, was enough. There was nothing else that needed to be there. That was all those others had. The ones that called the family roll – starting with William Stevens, 1920–1999. Gramp Stevens, they had called him, Webster remembered. Father of the wife of that first John J. Webster, who was here himself – 1951–2020. And after him his son, Charles F. Webster, 1980–2060. And his son, John J. II, 2004–2086. Webster could remember John J. II – a grandfather who had slept beside the fire with his pipe hanging from his mouth, eternally threatening to set his whiskers aflame.

  Webster’s eyes strayed to another plate, Mary Webster, the mother of the boy here at his side. And yet not a boy. He kept forgetting that Thomas was twenty now, in a week or so would be leaving for Mars, even as in his younger days he, too, had gone to Mars.

  All here together, he told himself. The Websters and their wives and children. Here in death together as they had lived together, sleeping in the pride and security of bronze and marble with the pines outside and the symbolic figure above the age-greened door.

  The robots were waiting, standing silently, their task fulfilled.

  His mother looked at him.

  ‘You’re head of the family now, my son,’ she told him.

  He reached out and hugged her close against his side. Head of the family – what was left of it. Just the three of them now. His mother and his son. And his son would be leaving soon, going out to Mars. But he would come back. Come back with a wife, perhaps, and the family would go on. The family wouldn’t stay at three. Most of the big house wouldn’t stay closed off, as it now was closed off. There had been a ti
me when it had rung with the life of a dozen units of the family, living in their separate apartments under one big roof. That time, he knew, would come again.

  The three of them turned and left the crypt, took the path back to the house, looming like a huge grey shadow in the mist.

  A fire blazed in the hearth and the book lay upon his desk. Jerome A. Webster reached out and picked it up, read the title once again:

  Martian Physiology, With Especial Reference to the Brain, by Jerome A. Webster, M.D.

  Thick and authoritative – the work of a lifetime. Standing almost alone in its field. Based upon the data gathered during those five plague years on Mars – years when he had laboured almost day and night with his fellow colleagues of the World Committee’s medical commission, dispatched on an errand of mercy to the neighbouring planet.

  A tap sounded on the door.

  ‘Come in,’ he called.

  The door opened and a robot glided in.

  ‘Your whisky, sir.’

  ‘Thank you, Jenkins,’ Webster said.

  ‘The minister, sir,’ said Jenkins, ‘has left.’

  ‘Oh, yes. I presume that you took care of him.’

  ‘I did, sir. Gave him the usual fee and offered him a drink. He refused the drink.’

  ‘That was a social error,’ Webster told him. ‘Ministers don’t drink.’

  ‘I’m sorry, sir. I didn’t know. He asked me to ask you to come to church sometime.’

  ‘Eh?’

  ‘I told him, sir, that you never went anywhere.’

  ‘That was quite right, Jenkins,’ said Webster. ‘None of us ever go anywhere.’

  Jenkins headed for the door, stopped before he got there, turned around. ‘If I may say so, sir, that was a touching service at the crypt. Your father was a fine human, the finest ever was. The robots were saying the service was very fitting. Dignified like, sir. He would have liked it had he known.’

  ‘My father,’ said Webster, ‘would be even more pleased to hear you say that, Jenkins.’

  ‘Thank you, sir,’ said Jenkins, and went out.

  Webster sat with the whisky and the book and the fire – felt the comfort of the well-known room close in about him, felt the refuge that was in it.

  This was home. It had been home for the Websters since that day when the first John J. had come here and built the first unit of the sprawling house. John J. had chosen it because it had a trout stream, or so he always said. But it was something more than that It must have been, Webster told himself, something more than that.

  Or perhaps, at first, it had only been the trout stream. The trout stream and the trees and meadows, the rocky ridge where the mist drifted in each morning from the river. Maybe the rest of it had grown, grown gradually through the years, through years of family association until the very soil was soaked with something that approached, but wasn’t quite, tradition. Something that made each tree, each rock, each foot of soil a Webster tree or rock or clod of soil. It all belonged.

  John J., the first John J., had come after the break-up of the cities, after men had forsaken, once and for all, the twentieth century huddling places, had broken free of the tribal instinct to stick together in one cave or in one clearing against a common foe or a common fear. An instinct that had become outmoded, for there were no fears or foes. Man revolting against the herd instinct economic and social conditions had impressed upon him in ages past. A new security and a new sufficiency had made it possible to break away.

  The trend had started back in the twentieth century, more than two hundred years before, when men moved to country homes to get fresh air and elbow room and a graciousness in life that communal existence, in its strictest sense, never had given them.

  And here was the end result. A quiet living. A peace that could only come with good things. The sort of life that men had yearned for years to have. A manorial existence, based on old family homes and leisurely acres, with atomics supplying power and robots in place of serfs.

  Webster smiled at the fireplace with its blazing wood. That was an anachronism, but a good one – something that Man had brought forward from the caves. Useless, because atomic heating was better – but more pleasant. One couldn’t sit and watch atomics and dream and build castles in the flames.

  Even the crypt out there, where they had put his father that afternoon. That was family, too. All of a piece with the rest of it. The sombre pride and leisured life and peace. In the old days the dead were buried in vast plots all together, stranger cheek by jowl with stranger—

  He never goes anywhere.

  That is what Jenkins had told the minister.

  And that was right. For what need was there to go anywhere? It all was here. By simply twirling a dial one could talk face to face with anyone one wished, could go, by sense, if not in body, anywhere one wished. Could attend the theatre or hear a concert or browse in a library half-way around the world. Could transact any business one might need to transact without rising from one’s chair.

  Webster drank the whisky, then swung to the dialled machine beside his desk.

  He spun dials from memory without resorting to the log. He knew where he was going.

  His finger flipped a toggle and the room melted away – or seemed to melt. There was left the chair within which he sat, part of the desk, part of the machine itself and that was all.

  The chair was on a hillside swept with golden grass and dotted with scraggly, wind-twisted trees, a hillside that straggled down to a lake nestling in the grip of purple mountain spurs. The spurs, darkened in long streaks with the bluishgreen of distant pine, climbed in staggering stairs, melting into the blue-tinged snow-capped peaks that reared beyond and above them in jagged saw-toothed outline.

  The wind talked harshly in the crouching trees and ripped the long grass in sudden gusts. The last rays of the sun struck fire from the distant peaks.

  Solitude and grandeur, the long sweep of tumbled land, the cuddled lake, the knife-like shadows on the far-off ranges.

  Webster sat easily in his chair, eyes squinting at the peaks. A voice said almost at his shoulder: ‘May I come in?’

  A soft, sibilant voice, wholly unhuman. But one that Webster knew.

  He nodded his head. ‘By all means, Juwain.’

  He turned slightly and saw the elaborate crouching pedestal, the furry, soft-eyed figure of the Martian squatting on it. Other alien furniture loomed indistinctly beyond the pedestal, half guessed furniture from that dwelling out on Mars.

  The Martian flipped a furry hand towards the mountain range.

  ‘You love this,’ he said. ‘You can understand it. And I can understand how you understand it, but to me there is more terror than beauty in it. It is something we could never have on Mars.’

  Webster reached out a hand, but the Martian stopped him.

  ‘Leave it on,’ he said. ‘I know why you came here. I would not have come at a time like this except I thought perhaps an old friend—’

  ‘It is kind of you,’ said Webster. ‘I am glad that you have come.’

  ‘Your father,’ said Juwain, ‘was a great man. I remember how you used to talk to me of him, those years you spent on Mars. You said then you would come back sometime. Why is it you’ve never come?’

  ‘Why,’ said Webster, ‘I just never—’

  ‘Do not tell me,’ said the Martian. ‘I already know.’

  ‘My son,’ said Webster, ‘is going to Mars in a few days. I shall have him call on you.’

  ‘That would be a pleasure,’ said Juwain. ‘I shall be expecting him.’

  He stirred uneasily on the crouching pedestal. ‘Perhaps he carries on tradition.’

  ‘No,’ said Webster. ‘He is studying engineering. He never cared for surgery.’

  ‘He has a right,’ observed the Martian, ‘to follow the life that he has chosen. Still, one might be permitted to wish.’

  ‘One could,’ Webster agreed. ‘But that is over and done with. Perhaps he will be a great engineer.
Space structure. Talks of ships out to the stars.’

  ‘Perhaps,’ suggested Juwain, ‘your family has done enough for medical science. You and your father—’

  ‘And his father,’ said Webster, ‘before him.’

  ‘Your book,’ declared Juwain, ‘has put Mars in debt to you. It may focus more attention on Martian specialization. My people do not make good doctors. They have no background for it. Queer how the minds of races run. Queer that Mars never thought of medicine – literally never thought of it. Supplied the need with a cult of fatalism. While even in your early history, when men still lived in caves—’

  ‘There are many things,’ said Webster, ‘that you thought of and we didn’t. Things we wonder now how we ever missed. Abilities that you developed and we do not have. Take your own speciality, philosophy. But different than ours. A science, while ours never was more than ordered fumbling. Yours an orderly, logical development of philosophy, workable, practical, applicable, an actual tool.’

  Juwain started to speak, hesitated, then went ahead. ‘I am near to something, something that may be new and startling. Something that will be a tool for you humans as well as for the Martians. I’ve worked on it for years, starting with certain mental concepts that first were suggested to me with the arrival of the Earthmen. I have said nothing, for I could not be sure.’

  ‘And now,’ suggested Webster, ‘you are sure.’

  ‘Not quite,’ said Juwain. ‘Not positive. But almost.’

  They sat in silence, watching the mountains and the lake. A bird came and sat in one of the scraggly trees and sang. Dark clouds piled up behind the mountain ranges and the snowtipped peaks stood out like graven stone. The sun sank in a lake of crimson, hushed finally to the glow of a fire burned low.

  A tap sounded from a door and Webster stirred in his chair, suddenly brought back to the reality of the study, of the chair beneath him.

  Juwain was gone. The old philosopher had come and sat an hour of contemplation with his friend and then had quietly slipped away.

  The rap came again.