Hearts on Fire

by Sabrina Wagner

  He finally cracked a smile, “This I know,” he said and tapped the tip of my nose.

  We hopped in the car and slowly pulled out of the driveway, making our way to Chris’s house. When we were a safe distance from the house, Tyler finally cracked, “That was intense. Your dad scares me a little bit.”

  “You handled it like a pro,” I assured him. “I’m the one who had to admit to my parents that we’re having sex,” I groaned.

  “Kyla, they already knew.”

  “Yeah, but they kind of made me say it. No girl wants to tell her dad she’s having sex. It’s just awkward.” I made a face and shivered. “It’s just kind of…gross. You know?”

  Tyler reached his hand across the console and grabbed me knee, “Oh, so having sex with me is gross. Huh?”

  “Oh, totally!” I teased him back. “Lucky for you, I’m really into gross.”

  He laughed hard and glanced over at me, “Okay. Now you’re giving me complex.”

  I leaned over and kissed his cheek. “You know I love you. And I really love having sex with you. And… I’m really looking forward to this week, so I can have my wicked way with you,” I laughed. “No interruptions. No late night curfews. Just us, snuggled together under the sheets.”

  He turned his head and caught me with a quick kiss, “Me too.”

  Chapter 28

  Tyler

  We pulled up at Chris’s a few minutes later. I popped the trunk and checked the side pocket of my duffle. The small box was still there. I had to double check.

  Once everyone was loaded up, Chris and Tori pulled out in his pick-up behind us. We headed toward I-75. We had about a four-hour drive north to Traverse City, where we would stop and get groceries, then another half hour to the house on Lake Michigan.

  Once we got on the expressway, Kyla turned up the radio, leaned back in her seat, and put her pretty painted feet on the dashboard. She wiggled her toes in time with the music. It was cute as fuck. Her legs were so short, that she could stretch them out completely.

  “You know I hate that, don’t you?” I lied.

  “What?” she questioned.

  I motioned to her legs. I loved teasing her. “Your feet on the dashboard. Where’s the respect?”

  “Really? I don’t have my shoes on,” she pulled her legs back, a worried look on her face.

  “No. Not really,” I admitted. “It’s actually really cute. You have sexy feet. And sexy legs.” I reached my hand over and rubbed up and down her thigh.

  She breathed a sigh of relief, put her feet back up on the dashboard, leaned back and closed her eyes. We drove in silence, not needing to fill the space with words. We were just content together in each other’s company. I could tell when she fell asleep, because her toes stopped tapping and her head lolled to the side. I loved watching her sleep. She was so beautiful.

  I didn’t tell Kyla, but my dad had had the sex talk with me the night before. He was a little more forward about it.

  I was sitting in my room and had just put a large box of condoms in my duffle bag, when my dad walked in. I tried to zip the bag quickly, but I knew he had seen.

  “I already know you and Kyla are having sex,” he said. “You don’t have to hide that shit from me.”

  I huffed out a breath, “Yeah, we are.”

  He sat down on the bed next to me. “You’re eighteen and the two of you have been together a while now. How long? How long have you two been active?” he questioned.

  “About two months.”

  My dad rubbed his hand over his chin, “Huh. I thought it had been longer than that. Were you her first?”

  I grabbed at the back of neck. This conversation was awkward. “Yeah. And she was mine.”

  He raised his eyebrows, “Really?”

  I nodded my head. “I love her, dad.”

  “I trust you, but you two are going to be alone all week. Keep your head. You’ve set yourself some pretty big goals. Babies can change things. I don’t want to see everything you’ve worked for to go down the drain. I don’t know what her plans are, but I’m sure they don’t include a baby.”

  “We’re careful. Neither one of us wants kids right now. Trust me.”

  “What happens when you go away to school? There’s going to be lots of girls there. Some of them would like nothing more than to get pregnant if you end up making a name for yourself.”

  I was taken aback. “I’m not going to cheat on Kyla.”

  “I didn’t say you would, but temptation will be there.”

  “Unless she’s a cute little blond with green eyes, I’m not interested.”

  “Just be careful. That’s all I’m saying.” He stood and walked towards the door, then stopped to face me again. “By the way, I like her. She seems to make you happy. It’s your job to keep her safe. Treat her right.” Then he walked away.

  “I will,” I said to myself. Always.

  I drove with the radio turned low, lost in my own thoughts. I wanted to make this week special for her. I knew she was worried about us being apart. Although she would never tell me, I knew she wished I wasn’t leaving. She was good at hiding her true feelings, but I could see right through her. I could see her insecurities. I would try to take them all away this week. I would assure her that we would be okay. We had to be. Anything else was not an option, because she was my “forever”.

  When we got closer to Traverse City, I gently shook her leg. “Time to wake up, Sleeping Beauty.”

  Her eyes fluttered open as she stretched her arms up over her head, pushing her tits out. “Oh, my god. What time is it?” she said trying to acclimate herself.

  “It’s almost one.”

  “I didn’t mean to fall asleep. Why didn’t you wake me up?” she questioned.

  “I like watching you sleep. Besides you’re going to need all your energy for later,” I waggled my eyebrows at her.

  She flipped down the mirror, rubbing underneath her eyes to fix her smudged make-up. “Is that so?”

  “Yep. The only sleep we’re getting will be while lying on the beach,” I promised.

  She rested her head on my shoulder and sighed, “I can’t wait.”

  After stopping to get groceries, we drove the final stretch to the beach house. We pulled in the driveway, and you could see the lake just past the house. It was a great house, with a wraparound porch in front and a massive deck in the back that led right out to the water.

  We unpacked the groceries and carried them inside. “Tori, I’ve really missed this place!” Kyla exclaimed as she unloaded the bags onto the kitchen counter. She turned to me, “Tori’s family used to bring me here every summer, since we were like sisters and inseparable.”

  Tori threw her arm around Kyla’s shoulders and pulled her into a side hug. “I swear we were attached at the hip when we were kids.”

  Chris snuck up behind Tori, and grabbed her around the waist, “This week those hips are going to be attached to mine and my dick is going to attached to your…” Tori quickly threw her hand up over his mouth. We all broke out into laughter.

  “You’re so crass, man,” I said shaking my head at him.

  Tori and Kyla finished putting everything away in the kitchen, while Chris and I brought in everything else from the car. Tori and Chris took her room. Kyla and I took the guest room. I carried everything in, and set it on the bed. I went over to the sliding glass door, pushed it open, and stepped out onto the balcony.

  Kyla came up behind me and wrapped her arms around my waist, leaning her head against my back. “It’s beautiful isn’t it?” The lake stretched out for miles in front of us, the water blue and sparkling. “If you look over there,” she said pointing to the right, “you can see the Sleeping Bear Dunes. And if you look straight out into the water, you can just see her cubs, The Manitou Islands.”

  I knew the legend. We had all learned it in school during Michigan history, but seeing it was different than reading about it.

  I reached back and brought her around to m
y front and wrapped my arms around her small shoulders, tucking her under my chin. I could stay like this forever, feeling her warmth as she snuggled into my chest. “I wanna be inside you,” I whispered as I buried my face in her hair.

  She looked up at me with those brilliant green eyes, “Then make love to me.”

  I captured her lips with mine, and carried her to the bed. We pushed our bags to the floor and started to undress each other. The cool breeze from the lake swept across our naked bodies. I pulled a condom from my bag and gently pushed her back against the mattress. She opened her legs for me and I slowly slid in. Her blond hair cascaded across the pillow. She was all mine. I hovered above her and she wrapped her legs around me. There was nothing more perfect than this right here. I started to move, slowly rocking in and out of her. She pushed her hips up into mine, looking for the friction she needed. I kissed her lips and down her neck, as I continued to slide in and out. She leaned her head back and moaned, “Oh my god, baby. That’s so good. I’m so close.”

  I picked up the pace and pushed into her hard, burying myself to the hilt. I ground into her, trying to give her what she needed. She began pulsing around me, clenching down on me, and we both lost it. I rode her through her orgasm as I chased mine with one final thrust. I collapsed and rolled on my back next to her. I threaded my fingers with hers, “I love you, Kyla.”

  She looked deep in my eyes, “I love you, too. You’re my everything.”

  Just as I leaned into kiss her, a loud knock scared the crap out of us.

  “Stop fucking! We’re going down to the beach,” Chris yelled through the door.

  I rolled my eyes, “Yeah! We’re coming!”

  “I don’t need to know that shit. Just get your suits on and meet us on the deck.”

  Kyla giggled, “I guess we better get dressed.”

  Chapter 29

  Kyla

  It was late afternoon before we made it to the beach. And although I wanted nothing more than to spend time walking along the shoreline, my stomach had other ideas. “I’m hungry and you guys must be starving. How about I go back up to the house and get dinner started?”

  Tori piped in, “I’ll come with you. How about just burgers tonight, since I don’t have the energy for much more?”

  “Sounds good to me. Want us to come up and start the grill?” Tyler said.

  “That would be perfect,” I said.

  We all made our way back up to house. Tori and I got started on making the hamburger patties and a salad, while the guys got the grill ready.

  Tori pulled out the lettuce and cucumber from the fridge, “So you guys were already at it, huh?” She had a smug look on her face as she started to slice the cucumber.

  “Hey, don’t judge. This is our last week to really get some alone time together,” I said pointing a knife at her.

  Tori held her hands up in surrender, “I’m not judging. Just making an observation.”

  “Well don’t. I promise to pretend I don’t hear you and Chris, if you pretend not to hear us. Deal?” I continued to cut the lettuce and put it in a bowl.

  “Deal,” Tori giggled. “But seriously, what’s going to happen after this week?”

  I looked out to the deck to make sure the guys we’re still occupied. Then I turned to Tori and whispered, “I plan on fucking him so many times that he won’t even be able to think of anyone else when he goes to school. I’m up for anything creative. Any advice?”

  “Oh girl, you’ve come to the right place.” She started ticking off her ideas on her fingers, “Shower sex, reverse cowgirl, doggie style…oh and don’t forget sex on the beach. It’s more than just a drink you know.”

  I started giggling, “You are so bad! Speaking of drinks, was Chris’s brother able to hook us up?”

  “Of course. Would I leave you hanging like that?”

  “Well, let’s break them out. I could go for something right about now.”

  Tori reached up into the cabinet above the refrigerator and started pulling out bottles. “Pick your poison- Absolute, Captain Morgan’s, plus there are beer and wine coolers in the drawer of the fridge.”

  “I’m gonna have a Captain and diet. Can you grab a beer for Tyler?”

  “Sure thing, girlie,” Tori reached in and pulled out two bottles.

  “Thanks.” I grabbed the drinks and the platter of hamburger patties and headed out towards the deck.

  After dinner and a few more drinks, we decided to head down to the beach and make a bonfire. The four of us sat around the fire, listened to music, and rehashed some of the best moments from the last year. As the sun began to set over the lake, I snuggled up between Tyler’s legs, while he held me tight. I rested my head back on his shoulder and sighed. “I love it here with you. I wish this could last forever.”

  “Me too, Ky. We have the next five days together. Let’s make them count.” He leaned his head into mine and kissed me.

  “I think we’re going to head back to the house. See you guys in a bit? “Tori asked.

  “Sure thing. Just remember our deal, okay?” I gave her a knowing look.

  “Wouldn’t forget, girlfriend,” she waved over her shoulder and made the trek back up the beach with Chris.

  Tyler looked at me in confusion, “What deal would that be?”

  “Oh nothing. Just girl talk.” I feigned innocence.

  “Girl talk, huh?”

  “Yep.” I said definitively. I turned in his arms, sitting between his legs, and threw my arms around his neck. I pressed my lips to his and bit gently at his bottom lip. He reached up and turned his hat backwards, devouring my mouth with his. The sun dipped below the horizon, leaving us with only the light from the fire. I gently pushed him back on the sand, and laid on his chest. Our kisses became more desperate. He reached his hand up under my shirt and palmed my breast. I moaned, as I ran my hands over his hard chest. “You wanna move this inside?”

  “Yeah, but we are having sex on this beach before we go home,” he groaned.

  “Definitely, but not tonight. I have other plans for you,” I beckoned him with my finger. I grabbed his hand and pulled him to his feet. We kicked sand over the fire, and I led him back to the house. Dragging him behind me, I made my way to our bedroom, which just happened to have an en suite bathroom. After shutting the door, I made sure it was locked. I walked towards the bathroom, stripping my shirt off along the way. “Shower with me?”

  Tyler’s eyes went wide, “Yes. Please.”

  I wiggled my finger at him, motioning for him to follow. “You said this was on your ‘To Do’ list, so figured we might as well.” I turned the water on and slid my shorts off. I stood there and let him take me in before I reached for the hem of his shirt. I slid it up his chest and over his head, then went to work on his shorts. His hands were all over me, caressing every curve of my body.

  I stepped in, pulling him with me. We let the water wash over our bodies, as we melted into each other. I ran my hands down his chest, past his sexy “V” and down to his hardness. I gripped it firmly in my hand and started to stroke him up and down.

  “God baby, that feels incredible,” he growled.

  I sank to my knees. I licked the pre-cum from his head and wrapped my lips around his length. I sank down on him deep, and felt him against the back of my throat. I wrapped my tongue around his hardness, and swirled it up under his tip, caressing the soft skin. Then sank back down again. I continued bobbing my head up and down, stroking him with my hand. I looked up at him, from under my lashes and saw the ecstasy on his face. It encouraged me to suck harder and deeper, taking him to the back of my throat over and over again.

  “You gotta stop Ky. I’m gonna come,” he groaned out, trying to pull me to my feet.

  I pushed his hands away and continued my assault. Going deeper and faster, stroking him harder and tighter. I felt him tense up, twitch, and then hot streams ran down my throat. I swallowed and stroked him through his orgasm, taking in every last drop.

  I stood
and faced him. “Good?”

  “Fucking awesome, baby. But you didn’t have to…“

  I put a finger to his lips. “I want to make you feel good. I don’t want you to forget about me when you’re gone.”

  “Not gonna happen. Ever.” He rubbed his hands over my shoulders, down my back, and cupped my ass, pulling me closer. He quickly turned me, pushed me against the wall and ran his hands down my back. His hands lingered at the small of my back as I arched into his touch.

  I braced my hands against the wall and looked at him over my shoulder. He was ready and waiting. “Again? Already?”

  “Kyla, this is only the beginning. I could go all night with you. Remember, no sleep except on the beach?”

  “I remember,” I said breathlessly. I pushed my hips back and spread my legs. He grabbed my hips and slid into my slick heat. No condom. No barriers. The skin on skin sensation was amazing. He held my hips tight, bruising the delicate skin, pulling himself into me harder and harder. “Oh my… that’s so fucking good. Harder, baby!” Pain melted into pleasure, as he picked up the pace and slammed into me over and over again, pushing my breasts against the wall. And then the fullness was gone. I felt him come against my back, as it dripped down my ass. His hands went to the wall above my head. He leaned over me panting and out of breath.

  “I’m so sorry. I shouldn’t have done that. I got carried away.” He hung his head in regret and looked down at me.

  “It was amazing. I loved feeling you—and just you—inside me,” I assured him.

  “It was amazing.” He closed his eyes. “But we can’t be irresponsible. I need to think with the right head.”

  I turned and took him in my arms. “You didn’t decide that on your own. I could have stopped you. I didn’t. And I don’t regret it.”

  “I know, but from here on out—we don’t do that shit.”

  I threw some shorts and a tank top on and started to crawl under the covers. Tyler came out of the bathroom with a towel wrapped low on his hips. He looked at me and let out a low laugh. “What are you doing?”