Triple Pass: An MFMM Reverse Harem Romance

by Sierra Sparks

  Grabbing the base of his cock, he lined up the head to my gushing pussy. He played with it against my labia, teasing. He rubbed it against my clit. I was quivering.

  “Fuck me,” I begged breathlessly. “Fuck me, Killian.”

  He pushed in and was suddenly balls deep. I could feel the walls of my vagina stretching. They had never been stretched so far! I gasped and moaned. My head went back and I tensed up, my pussy muscles grabbing his cock. It was like they were pulling him inside me. Then he backed out and went in and back out.

  “Aw, yeah, that’s it. That’s it, baby,” I moaned.

  “You like that? You like how I fuck you?” he said.

  “Yes! Yes! Fuck me like that. Just like that.”

  Killian pushed up from the bed, his muscular arms on either side of me. He was banging me steadily and increasing speed. The whole bed started to squeak and shake. I could feel his raw power as he thrusted in and out of me. The entire bed scraped across the floor of his room and rammed into the wall behind me. It was making a lot of noise, but I didn’t care. I was awash in absolute pleasure. I kept cumming all over his cock and my pussy juice made it slicker and slicker.

  “You’re so hot and wet,” he gasped. “Never been with someone this hot inside. You’re like, burning!”

  “Take me from behind!” I demanded.

  He pulled out and I immediately flipped over on all fours. He pulled me perpendicular to the bed and stood up. Standing on the floor, he started fucking me from behind. He was strong and even though he tried not to pound me too hard, I had to put out my hand to steady myself against the wall. The slap of his thighs against my ass was audible and at this angle, it was a whole new sensation. My twat was like a volcano constantly erupting.

  Killian grabbed the back of my hair and pulled my head back. I got into the rhythm with him as he pounded me. It was out of control! The hair pulling put me over the top again and I started cumming. I was just squealing with delight at this point. I couldn’t stop. I would literally keep doing this until I passed out. It was that good.

  Then suddenly, I heard the door open and Teagan was standing there.

  Chapter 10:

  Amy

  “Holy shit,” said Teagan. “Amy, you really are up here. The guys downstairs told me, but I didn’t believe it.”

  “God damn, Teag,” said Killian. “What are you doing here? We’re fucking, man!”

  “I was just licking her pussy not one hour ago.” said Teagan. “Amy? I thought I’d get to fuck you.”

  “You can both fuck me,” I heard myself saying. “Get your clothes off and shut the door. I want you both now.”

  Teagan and Killian looked at each other. They both shrugged.

  “Problem solved!” said Teagan.

  While I definitely wanted this sexual exploration, part of me wondered who I had become. Here I was, Amy Morrell, normally one of the most repressed people on the planet. Now, not only was I having sex with a man I barely knew, I was now going to try sex with two men at once? Who was this new Amy? Had I transformed or was this Amy always bubbling below the surface, ready to emerge?

  I liked this new Amy. She was brave, daring and desired by men. In the academic world, most of the men were timid. They’d compete with each other to see how less manly they could act. Not true with the O’Connor brothers. They were manly men: brash, confident and exciting. They knew exactly what they were doing and didn’t give a damn what anyone else thought!

  Just last week, all I could think about was homework and getting into my master’s program. Now here I was about to get railed by two guys at once! What was the etiquette here? A small part of me expected them to argue over me and thinking about that, I knew that could turn dark. Thankfully, we live in more enlightened times. The O’Connors were sexually liberated already, I was merely catching up to them!

  As Teagan got his clothes off, I helped him. Killian took advantage of the break to grab a Gatorade from his mini-fridge and chug it down. After getting Teagan’s pants off, he offered me a swig and I gladly took it. We were going to need our electrolytes if we were going to keep this up.

  I decided I had to get Teagan caught up, so I immediately started kissing him. He tasted like hamburger, as he had just come from the dining hall. I kissed down the front of his chest, which was also cut. Killian was broad and built like a fridge, but Teagan was more compact and defined.

  Kneeling down in front of Teagan, I took his already growing cock into my mouth. His dick had a curve to the right. It was a little thinner than his brother’s and possibly slightly longer. It tasted the same though: manly, a little salty and a little sweaty. I licked the length of his shaft and I could see the wide eyed expression on his face. He couldn’t reach his brother, but if he could they would’ve been high-fiving, I’m sure.

  “Holy shit, Amy,” said Teagan, surprised. “You’re a wild woman!”

  Lifting his dick, I put my face in his balls and started licking them. He kind of lost his words at that point and just start moaning, “Oh! Oh! Holy shit! Oh!” I was really liking the taste of his balls. The manly smell spurred me on to do more. I put them in my mouth and rolled them around with my tongue. Teagan was now rock hard, ready to give me a good fucking.

  “I want you both inside me,” I commanded. “Fuck me, Teagan! Do me!”

  I got on all fours on the bed where Killian was sitting and went down on him with my mouth. Teagan got behind me and pushed in. I moaned on Killian’s cock and the vibration of the sound made him grunt in surprise.

  “Jesus Christ!” said Teagan. “Your pussy is like a furnace. God damn! I’m going to get third degree burns in here. Shit!”

  The extra curve in Teagan’s cock gave me pleasure in a whole new area deep inside. My pussy walls were quivering as I slobbered up and down on Killian’s shaft. He grabbed the base of his cock and started playing with it. He bounced it against my face and lips and smiled at me. Then I went in further and started to play with his balls in my mouth.

  “Awwww,” he moaned. “That’s fuckin’ rad!”

  I was kind of wondering who still says “rad” anymore, but I let it go. When you’re in the throws of ecstasy, people say strange things. Hell, I barely realized what I was saying half the time, or I may have been mumbling nonsense while hearing the words in my head. It didn’t seem to matter. All that mattered was that I was getting a pounding of a lifetime. Riley was right. This was a day I would never forget!

  Teagan pulled out for a minute to keep himself from cumming too soon. Killian stepped up to continue the fucking. I obliged by turning around and facing my ass toward him. He pushed in and I welcomed the return of his pulsating cock. Like his brother, he knew how to use his dick. I made out with Teagan while Killian fucked me.

  After a few solid minutes of my pussy being pounded, Killian pulled out and started rubbing his dick up and down my crack. He put a finger in my ass and twirled it around. I gasped in pleasure.

  “Oh,” I gasped. “I like that. That’s so dirty!”

  “It’s time to go for both your holes, baby,” said Killian in my ear. “Are you ready?”

  “Yeah,” I said, energized. “Fuck my tight little ass!”

  Killian bent over and lubed up my ass with his tongue.

  “We need things nice and wet down here,” he said. “You ready?”

  “Yes, please!” I cooed.

  He slowly pushed his cock in and my ass tightened on it. As he pressed inside me, I saw stars. I had never been stretched like that ever. I was an anal virgin up to that point. I had seen it on videos, but never imagined I would try it. I always thought it would hurt, but I loved it!

  “Oh, God! Yes!” I shouted. “Fuck me in the ass! Fuck my dirty asshole!”

  I sat back all the way on his cock and all my muscles tensed on it.

  “Ahhh!” he moaned. “Holy shit! That’s so tight!”

  “You ready for more?” offered Teagan.

  “Yes!” I heard myself saying.


  Who was this wild woman I had become?

  “Both of you. I need both of you inside me.” I begged.

  Teagan positioned himself at my pussy and slowly pushed in. I could feel both cocks pressing against the walls of my pussy and ass. I had never felt so full and stretched so physically. The deep feeling inside me was like nothing else. They both fucked me in concert and it was a rhythm that made for the most amazing and unique orgasms.

  I could feel myself cumming all over Teagan’s cock. Each time, I would tense up and grip both cocks, which would cause them both to moan. I had both of these incredible, sexy, handsome men in my power. The power of my own body was unchallenged and unstoppable!

  It was like I was living--- Really living for the first time! The world of this sexuality was new to me, but it felt right. It felt freeing and liberating. The world was suddenly in my grasp! I felt like I could do anything in that moment and I never wanted that feeling to end.

  I became overwhelmed with the orgasms. I was squealing and trying to catch my breath at the same time. I’m sure the entire frat house could hear us, but I didn’t care. Let the world know that this was who Amy Morrell was now. Unbridled! Passionate! Sexy!

  Killian and Teagan both started cumming inside me. I could feel their condoms filling up with hot cum. The heat, deep inside, cause me to orgasm for the umpteenth time, but this time was harder. I felt like I was going to black out. I lost control of my motor functions for a few moments, but pinned between the two brothers, I had nowhere else to fall but on top of either one of them.

  The boys pulled out slowly, which was another orgasmic experience. It was totally unexpected and it left me on Killian’s bed shaking from all the after-quake orgasms. The sex was so damned satisfying. Never before had I experienced sex like this. Not only was it fantastic and not to be feared, it was something that needed to keep happening in my life. In those moments, I was truly happy.

  We collapsed in the bed exhausted and we went to sleep together happy. I had a smile on my face that felt like it was going to be there for the rest of my life.

  Chapter 11:

  James

  After everything that happened with the Dean, I returned Jen’s car and then had a big meeting with the coach just to smooth things out. He was pretty worried my brothers and I might miss a game or even get expelled, but I put his mind at ease. By the time I calmed him down and the rest of the coaching staff, it was late. One of the other players had a dorm room nearer to the practice field and since his roommate was away, he offered to let me crash. Normally, I would’ve turned him down, but I thought if I stayed away from the frat house for a night, maybe the Dean would give me some credit for not getting into trouble. Plus I really didn’t want to know if Teagan and Killian were out causing mayhem. Better that I just find out later. It was easier to fix the disaster that way.

  When I got back to the frat house, my brothers were at class. I went into the kitchen to fix myself a bowl of cereal. Sitting at the table was Tyler, who had just joined the frat. He sometimes tried a little too hard to be “fraternity guy”, but he was a good dude, deep down.

  “Brother Tyler,” I greeted.

  “Brother James!” he smiled. “You obviously weren’t here last night.”

  “Don’t tell me you guys had another kegger,” I said. “Man, Tuesday keggers are a little much.”

  “Nah, bro, nothing like that,” he assured. “Your brothers are crazy.”

  “Oh, no,” I said. “Please tell me they didn’t do something stupid.”

  “I don’t know about stupid,” he laughed. “But this chick came by and they both ended up doing her. And let me tell you something, the entire house could hear them going at it!”

  Guess that wasn’t too bad. At least by Teagan and Killian standards. I mean, this was a containable disaster if anything. I figured some football groupie came over and things got hot and heavy. It happened before, although usually with two girls. It was a little odd that there was only one. She must’ve been amazing.

  “They both did the same girl?” I said, a little amazed.

  “She was pretty hot,” said Tyler. “But the weird thing was, she was kind of bookish, ya know? She looked more like an academic. Not your typical sorority sister. I mean, I don’t even think she was a sorority sister.”

  “Wait,” I said, growing increasingly worried. “Did this chick have glasses and blonde hair?”

  “Yeah, I think her name was Amy or something.”

  My heart sank. I literally felt like I was going to pass out. Of all the stupid things my brothers have done over the years, double banging the tutor that the Dean sent had to be the stupidest. Don’t get me wrong, I think Amy was really hot. I mean, there was definitely something about her, but for us to endanger our scholarship over her? That was just plain stupid. We didn’t even know her. She comes to a frat house and gets done by two guys, who knows what she’s going to tell people outside the frat. And with all the bad press fraternities get, I had to go see her. I needed to make sure this wasn’t going to blow up in our faces.

  “I gotta go,” I suddenly announced, having not even taken a bite of my cereal. “You want my cereal?”

  “Sure bro,” he said immediately.

  I pushed the bowl toward him and rushed out of the kitchen. If Amy suddenly woke up regretting last night, we’d be screwed. One phone call to the Dean and he’d hit the roof. Having sex with one of us would be bad enough in his eyes, but two of us at the same time? Add the fact that she regrets it? My brothers would be lucky not to go to jail, not to mention losing everything.

  As I walked across campus, I went over the scenario in my head. I had to remain positive about the situation. Sure, they had a threesome, but it was most likely Amy’s idea. I mean, it wasn’t something Teagan and Killian actively looked for. And both of them seemed genuinely interested in Amy, so it’s not like they’d want to risk giving her up to the other.

  Maybe that was it. Maybe they couldn’t decide who would get her and they both ended up with her. I just hope they didn’t talk Amy into something she’d regret later.

  Then I thought, who else knows? Oh, God. The fraternity can’t keep a secret! If everyone heard it, then half the campus must know. Of course, the guys were always talking about sexual conquests, so as long as it was part of their standard bragging, it probably wouldn’t raise any red flags, right?

  All this ran through my mind as I rushed toward Amy’s dorm. Stupid Killian and Teagan. This chick now had us completely at her mercy. If she wanted to destroy us, it wouldn’t take much. I just had to pray that she really, really liked sex. Unfortunately, she was a mousey bookworm. What were the odds?

  I knocked on Amy’s door and prepared myself.

  “Come in,” she beckoned.

  When I walked through the door, I expected the prudish, mousey chick I met at the Dean’s office. The person who greeted me was smoking hot! Her hair done up, make up, fingernails--- The whole shebang! Now instead of wearing clothes to hid her body, she was wearing clothes to show it off. Her curvy figure was displayed perfectly in tight black jeans and a fitted button up shirt, and her glorious blonde hair fell in soft waves around her face. Underneath that librarian exterior, there was a smoking hot chick and now it was obvious.

  “Hey, James,” Amy greeted warmly. “Come on in.”

  Amy also seemed really relaxed, which was a good sign. She flopped down on her bed and offered me a seat at her desk.

  “Where are you books?” she asked. “I need to tutor you, remember?”

  “Oh, right,” I said, finally remembering. “Sorry, before that, I just wanted to talk to you.”

  “Sure,” she said casually. “And come to think of it, I could probably teach you a think or two without books.”

  Did she just make a pass at me? That sounded a little suggestive. Well, screw that. If I make that call wrong, they’ll nail me to the wall. I’ll just let it go.

  “Not that it’s any of my business or that it bother
s me, but were you with my brothers last night in the frat house?” I asked directly.

  “Yes,” she smiled. “We had a great time.”

  “Oh,” I said, very relieved. “Great. I’m just--- I was just worried you might wake up the next morning and regret it, so…”

  “Regret it? It was one of the best nights of my life!” said Amy. “It was the kind of night I’ll remember when I’m an old woman.”

  “So you’re happy and you’re not going to tell the Dean?” I checked.

  “Why would I tell him and yes, I’m very happy. Your brothers opened up a whole new world of sexuality for me. It’s just great.”

  “Oh, well, I’m very happy for you all, I guess,” I said, feeling a bit like a third wheel. “Well, that’s all I wanted, so I’ll go.”

  As I walked to the dorm room door to let myself out, she said something I didn’t expect.

  “Wait,” she asked. “Don’t you want some?”

  “Some what?”

  I turned around and looked back at her. She moved closer to me. Amy was confident and commanding the room. It was a little intimidating. She took my hand and placed it on her breast.

  “Some of this,” she said.

  She put my second hand in her crotch.

  “And some of this,” she said.

  I couldn’t believe this was happening. I had been asked out by women before, but I never been so boldly propositioned by a member of the opposite sex. Amy was like an unstoppable force. Looking into her eyes, you felt like you’d better fuck her or she’d come back later and fuck you anyway.

  Touching either side of her face, I brought it up to look me in the eye. This was real and she was sincere in her offer. You can just tell sometimes. I started kissing her deeply. The Dean wasn’t going to like this, but who cares about the Dean, right? If you have a chance to have sex with a beautiful woman, why wouldn’t you take it?