Eureka: The Unfinished Revolution

by Peter Fitzsimons

  Nevertheless, Labor Senator Gavin Marshall criticised the Prime Minister individually, and the Coalition generally, for their overall attitude.

  ‘Howard is an arch monarchist,’ he told the Sun-Herald, ‘and clearly they are running from what the Eureka flag represents; independence and people determined to fight for their rights.’39 John Howard did release a short statement, noting that ‘the events at Eureka 150 years ago were central to the development of Australia as an independent democratic country’, but that was it. At the same time, however, the Victorian Premier Steve Bracks could find a great deal of inspiration when, in his own 150th anniversary address, he observed, ‘I believe Eureka was a catalyst for the rapid evolution of democratic government in this country - and it remains a national symbol of the right of people to have a say in how they are governed. I am not saying there would be no democracy without Eureka. However, I doubt our democracy would have come as quickly - and I suspect our democracy would not be as egalitarian - without Eureka.’ 40

  As Geoffrey Blainey noted in 1963, ‘Eureka became a legend, a battlecry for nationalists, republicans, liberals, radicals, or communists, each creed finding in the rebellion the lessons they liked to see.’ 41 The surprising thing, however, is that the Liberals specifically and the Conservative side of politics in general, at least in the modern era, has not embraced Eureka strongly - given that one could look at the whole uprising as a collection of small businessmen/entrepreneurs rising against iniquitous taxes and over-regulation that was stifling their creation of wealth. Right up the Libs’ alley!

  A devotee of the above view is the conservative columnist Gerard Henderson. In a Sydney Morning Herald column in 2004, he decried the lack of John Howard’s involvement in the sesquicentenary, and finished, ‘Let’s hope that, by 2054, the federal Liberal leadership recognises that the battle for the Eureka legend requires more than a brief written message. After all, culture wars can be fun - and they are important.’42 To be fair, even some senior Labor figures can downplay the significance of Eureka. Early in the course of my writing this book, one famous identity of the ALP - let’s call him Bob Carr - waved a dismissive hand, and said, “Eureka? Local tax revolt …”’

  I passionately believe it was a lot more than that.

  Personally, from the perspective of 2012, I think there is enormous inspiration to be found in Eureka for Australians of all political persuasions, pursuits and backgrounds.

  Firstly, and most obviously, it is a great story of democracy, of a group of brave people fighting for, and winning, their democratic rights. Yes, it is right that we honour those men who fell at Gallipoli and elsewhere, but surely at least an equal debt is owed to those who died fighting for the ‘liberties’ we all enjoy today?

  Obviously, those of us who believe that it is archaic that Australia should, in the 21st century, still be politically aligned with the British monarchy, even to the extent of having the British flag on our flag, can and do find great inspiration in Eureka, and I also agree with former ALP leader Mark Latham that it was one of the first great moments of multiculturalism in this country. (Notwithstanding the widespread mistreatment of Aborigines and Chinese in other parts of the goldfields.)

  Let’s hear from you, Raffaello Carboni, as you reflect on a gathering of native-born Australians, Irish, Swedes, Germans, black and white Americans, Canadians, Italians, French and Jamaicans, all acting as one for the greater good: ‘We were of all nations and colours.’43 The diggers had come together, ‘irrespective of nationality, religion or colour to salute the Southern Cross as a refuge of all the oppressed from all countries on Earth’.44

  Witness Peter Lalor, as he mounts the stump beneath the Southern Cross and focuses on the vast sea of his fellow rebels, not unified by a common race but by something else entirely: ‘I looked around me. I saw brave and honest men, who had come thousands of miles to labour for independence. I knew that hundreds were in great poverty, who would possess wealth and happiness if allowed to cultivate the wilderness that surrounded us. The grievances under which we had long suffered, and the brutal attack of the day, flashed across my mind; and with the burning feelings of an injured man, I mounted the stump and proclaimed “Liberty”.’45

  All put together, I entirely concur with the words written by Macgregor Duncan, Andrew Leigh, David Madden and Peter Tynan for their book Imagining Australia: Ideas for Our Future, which appeared in The Sydney Morning Herald for the 150th Anniversary of Eureka, in a piece entitled ‘Time to reclaim this legend as our driving force’.

  They wrote: ‘Australia should re-elevate Eureka to its previous position as a central legend of Australian nationalism, standing for those distinctly Australian values - egalitarianism, mateship, fairness - together with democracy, freedom, republicanism and multiculturalism …

  ‘Obviously, Australian nationalism can never be reduced to just one legend, but Eureka offers great potential to a nation floundering for a national story.’46

  And their idea that I love most of all: ‘Our rather limp citizenship oath could be revitalised with a fragment of the bold Eureka oath: “We swear by the Southern Cross to stand truly by each other and to defend our rights and liberties.” And when we become a republic - as we surely some day must - what better flag to choose than the Eureka flag?’47

  Say it loud. Say it proud. Exactly!

  At the beginning of writing this book, as I mentioned in my introduction, I fancied that the image of the Eureka flag was too associated on the one hand with a certain right-wing, redneck, racist element - those who ludicrously brandish it as a symbol of white Australia - and on the other hand with the hard left of the trade union movement for it ever to be embraced by Australia as a whole.

  But no more. Now that I get it, I understand that the Eureka story really is the great Australian story; that we can take enormous inspiration from what occurred and that the Eureka flag more truly represents what is great about Australia than our current flag, which states to the world that we are still Great Britain in the South Seas. (Cue Jerry Seinfeld on his visit here in 2000: ‘I love your flag - Great Britain, at night!’)

  The reason I added ‘the unfinished revolution’ to the title is because, though those who fought at Eureka accomplished a great deal for this country, the last part of the job that Lalor enunciated as his goal on the eve of the battle - ‘Independence’ - has still not occurred.

  But it will come. And when it does so, I believe that the story of Peter Lalor and the valiant men and women of the Eureka Stockade will rightly take their place at the very forefront of Australian history.

  They were good and brave people, fighting for a great cause, laying the very foundation stones on which modern Australia has been built.

  I salute them. And their flag.

  Our flag.

  BIBLIOGRAPHY

  Acronyms used:

  AJCP

  Australian Joint Copying Project

  ML

  The Mitchell Library, Sydney

  NLA

  National Library of Australia

  SLV

  The State Library of Victoria

  VPRS

  Public Record Office Victoria

  Published Sources

  Books

  Abbott, Edward, The English and Australian Cookery Book: Cookery for the many, as well as for the upper ten thousand by an Australian aristologist, Sampson Low, Son, and Marston, London, 1864

  Bate, Weston, Lucky City: The First Generation at Ballarat 1851-1901, Melbourne University Press, 1979

  Billot, C. P. (ed.), Melbourne’s Missing Chronicles by John Pascoe Fawkner, Globe Press Limited, Melbourne, 1982

  Billot, C. P., John Batman: the Story of John Batman and the Founding of Melbourne, Hyland House, Melbourne, 1979

  Blainey, Geoffrey, The Rush That Never Ended, Melbourne University Press, Melbourne, 1963

  Blake, Gregory, To Pierce the Tyrant’s Heart, Australian Military History Publications, Loftus, 2009

  Blei
ssbarth, E. (ed.), Charles Joseph La Trobe, Australian Notes 1839-1854, Tarcoola Press, State Library of Victoria and Boz Publishing, Melbourne, 2006

  Bohn, H. G., The Standard Library Cyclopaedia: Political, Constitutional, Statistical and Forensic Knowledge, Vol. IV, Harrison and Sons, St Martin’s Lane, 1855

  Bonwick, J., Notes of a Gold Digger and Gold Digger’s Guide, The Hawthorn Press, Melbourne, 1942

  Bowden, Keith Macrae, Goldrush Doctors at Ballarat, Magenta Press, Victoria, 1977

  Stoney, Henry B., Victoria: With a Description of its Principal Cities, Melbourne and Geelong, Smith, Elder & Co., London, 1856

  Canon, Michael (ed.), Historical Records of Victoria, Victorian Government Printing Office, Melbourne, 1981-2002

  Capper, John, The Emigrant’s Guide to Australia: Containing the Fullest Particulars Relating to the Recently Discovered Gold Fields, the Government Regulations for Gold Seeking, George Philip and Son, Liverpool, 1852

  Carboni, Raffaello, The Eureka Stockade: The Consequence of Some Pirates on Quarter-Deck Wanting a Rebellion, J. P. Atkinson and Co., Melbourne, 1855

  Historical Studies: Eureka Centenary Supplement, Melbourne University Press, Melbourne, 1964

  Clacy, Ellen, A Lady’s Visit to the Gold Digging of Australia in 1852-53, Lansdowne Press, Melbourne, 1963

  Clark, Charles Manning Hope, A History of Australia, Vol. 4: The Earth Abideth Forever, 1851-1888, Melbourne University Press, Melbourne, 1991

  Clarke, William B., ‘Araminta’ Emigrant Ship, 1852, W. B. Clarke, Bicheno, Tasmania, 2003

  Cochrane, Peter, Remarkable Occurrences: The National Library of Australia’s First 100 Years, 1901-2001, National Library of Australia, Canberra, 2001

  Corfield, Justin; Wickham, Dorothy and Gervasoni, Clare, Eureka Encyclopaedia, Ballarat Heritage Services, Ballarat, 2004

  Cox, Leonard B., The National Gallery of Victoria, 1861 to 1968: A Search for a Collection, National Gallery of Victoria, Melbourne, 1970

  Craig, William, My Adventures on the Australian Goldfields, Cassell and Company, London, Melbourne, 1903

  Davison, Simpson, The Discovery and Geognosy of Gold Deposits in Australia with Comparisons and Accounts of the Gold Regions of California, Russia, India, Brazil, &c., Longman, Green, Longman and Roberts, London, 1860

  Dewes, John, China, Australia, and the Pacific Islands, in the Years 1853-56, R. Bentley, London, 1857

  Dickens, Charles, The Personal History and Experience of David Copperfield, A. L. Burt Company Publishers, New York, (Undated)

  Earp, George B., The Gold Colonies of Australia and Gold Seeker’s Manual, George Routledge & Co., London, 1852

  Elliott, A. F., (ed.), The Woodbury Papers: letters and documents held by the Royal Photographic Society, A. F. Elliot, South Melbourne, 1996

  Farwell, Byron, Queen Victoria’s Little Wars, W. W. Norton & Company, New York, 1985

  Fauchery, Antoine, Letters from a Miner in Australia, Georgian House, Melbourne, 1965

  Ferguson, Charles D., The Experiences of a Forty-niner During Thirty-four Years’ Residence in California and Australia, The Williams Publishing Company, Cleveland, 1888

  Flannery, Tim (ed.), The Birth of Melbourne, Text Publishing, Melbourne, 2002

  Fogarty, L., James Fintan Lalor: Patriot and Political Essayist, Talbot Press Ltd, Dublin, 1919

  Foster, John F. Leslie, Three Letters to Hon. James Frederick Palmer, James J. Blundell & Co., Melbourne, 1855

  Fox, L., The Eureka Flag, Southwood Press, Marrickville, 1992

  Gold, Geoffrey M. (ed.), Eureka: Rebellion Beneath the Southern Cross, Bigby Limited, Adelaide, 1977

  Goodman, David, Gold Seeking: Victoria and California in the 1850s, Stanford University Press, Stanford, 1994

  Serle, Grant, The Melbourne Scene 1803-1956, Melbourne University Press, Melbourne, 1957

  Hall, William H., Practical Experiences at the Diggings of the Goldfields of Victoria, Effingham Wilson, London, 1852

  Hargraves, Edward Hammond, Australia and Its Gold Fields: A Historical Sketch of the Australian Colonies from the Earliest Times to the Present Day with a Particular Account of the Recent Gold Discoveries, Ingram and Co, London, 1855

  Hill, David, The Gold Rush: The Fever that Forever Changed Australia, William Heinemann Australia, Sydney, 2010

  Hirst, John B., Freedom on the Fatal Shore: Australia’s First Colony, Black Ink, Melbourne, 2008

  Hocking, Geoff, Eureka Stockade: The Events Leading to the Attack in the Pre-dawn of 3 December 1854, The Five Mile Press, Rowville, Victoria, 2004

  Horne, Donald, The Story of the Australian People, Reader’s Digest, Sydney, 2010

  Horne, Richard H., Australian Facts and Prospects, Smith, Elder & Co., London, 1859

  Housman, A. E., A Shropshire Lad, International Pocket Library, Boston, 1989

  Howitt, William, Land, Labour, and Gold, or Two Years in Victoria with Visits to Sydney and Van Diemen’s Land, Longman, Brown, Green and Longman, London, 1855

  Hugill, Stan, Shanties from the Seven Sea Shipboard Work Songs and Songs Used as Work Songs from the Great Days of Sail, Routledge and Kegan Paul, London, 1984

  Jenks, Edward, The Government of Victoria (Australia), MacMillan and Co., London, 1891

  Johnson, Laurel, Women of Eureka, Brown Door Productions, Ballarat, 1995

  Kelly, William, Life in Victoria, or, Victoria in 1853 and Victoria in 1858, Vol. I, Chapman and Hall, London, 1859

  King, John, F. A., Edward Hammond Hargraves Esq: An Exuberant Biography of the ‘Discoverer’ of Payable Gold in Australia, Summit Books/Paul Hamlyn, Sydney, 1977

  Lang, J. D., An Historical and Statistical Account of New South Wales, Vol. II, Longman, Brown, Green and Longmans, London, 1852

  Lang, J. D., The Australian Emigrant’s Manual, or A Guide to the Gold Colonies of New South Wales and Port Phillip, Partridge and Oakey, London, 1852

  Lawson, Henry, Selected Poems of Henry Lawson, Angus and Robertson, Sydney, 1918

  Lawson, Henry, Cronin, Leonard (ed.), A Camp-Fire Yarn: Henry Lawson Complete Works 1885-1900, Lansdowne, 1984

  Lovett, William, Life and Struggles of William Lovett in His Pursuit of Bread, Knowledge and Freedom, Vol. II, G. Bell and Sons Ltd, London, 1920

  Lovett, William, The People’s Charter: With the Address to the Radical Reformers of Great Britain and Ireland, and a Brief Sketch of Its Origin, Working Men’s Association, C. H. Elt, C. Fox, Islington, 1848

  Lynch, John, The Story of the Eureka Stockade: Epic Days of the Early Fifties at Ballarat, Australian Catholic Truth Society, Melbourne, (undated)

  Macdougall, Anthony K., Australia: An Illustrated History: From Dreamtime to the New Millennium, The Five Mile Press, Rowville, Victoria, 2004

  MacFarlane, Ian, (ed.), Eureka: From the Official Records, Public Record Office of Victoria, Melbourne, 1995

  Marx, Karl and Engels, Friedrich, The Communist Manifesto, Echo Library, Middlesex, 2009

  Marx, Karl and Engels, Friedrich, Werke, Vol. 19, Dietz-Verlag, Berlin, 1962

  Mayer, Henry (ed.), Marx, Engels, and Australia, University of Sydney, Department of Government and Public Administration, Sydney, 1964

  McCombie, Thomas, The History of the Colony of Victoria: From its Settlement to the Death of Sir Charles Hotham, Sands and Kenny, Melbourne, 1858

  McCrae, Georgiana Huntly Gordon, Georgiana’s Journal: Melbourne 1841-1865, Angus and Robertson, Sydney, 1966

  Molony, John, Eureka, Melbourne University Press, Carlton South, 2001

  Morgan, John, The Life and Adventures of William Buckley, Archibald Macdougall, Hobart, 1852

  Mundy, Godfrey Charles, Our Antipodes; or, Residence and Rambles in the Australian Colonies: With a Glimpse of the Gold Fields, Richard Bentley, London, 1852

  Napier, Sir William F. P., The Life and Opinions of General Sir Charles James Napier, Vol. II, John Murray, London, 1857

  Newton, L. M., The Story of the Twelfth, a Record of the 12th Battalion, AIF, During the Great War of
1914-1918, J. Walch and Sons, Hobart, 1925

  O’Brien, Bob, Massacre at Eureka: The Untold Story, Sovereign Hill Museums Association, Ballarat, 1973

  Peach, Bill, Bill Peach’s Gold, Macmillan for Australian Broadcasting Commission, Melbourne, 1983

  Potts, Eli D. and Potts, Annette, Young America and Australian Gold: Americans and the Gold Rush of the 1850s, University of Queensland Press, St Lucia, 1974

  Quaife, Geoffrey Robert, Gold and Colonial Society, 1851-1870, Cassell Australia, Stanmore, 1975

  Read, C. Rudson, What I heard, saw and did at the Australian Goldfileds, T. & W. Boone, London, 1853

  Roberts, Shirley, Charles Hotham: a Biography, Melbourne University Press, Melbourne, 1985

  Rusden, George W., History of Australia, Vol. I, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 2011

  Scott, Ernest (ed.), Australia, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 1988

  Serle, Geoffrey, The Golden Age: A History of the Colony of Victoria, 1851-1861, Melbourne University Press, Melbourne, 1963

  Sharkey, Lawrence L., Australia Marches On, New South Wales Legal Rights Committee, Sydney, 1942

  Shaw, Alan G. L. (ed.), Gipps-La Trobe Correspondence 1839-1846, Melbourne University Press at the Miegunyah Press, Melbourne, 1989

  Sherer, John, The Gold-Finder of Australia: How He Went, How He Fared, and How He Made his Fortune, Clarke, Beeton & Co., London, 1853

  Shillinglaw, John J., Historical Records of Port Phillip, the First Annals of the Colony of Victoria, Heinemann, Melbourne, 1972

  Sidney, Samuel, The Three Colonies of Australia, Ingram, Cooke and Co., London, 1853

  Smith, F.B. (Preface), Historical Studies: Eureka Centenary Supplement, Melbourne University Press, Carlton, 1965

  Smyth, Robert B., The Goldfields and Mineral Districts of Victoria, John Ferres, Government Printer, Melbourne, 1869