The Scoundrel's Honor

by Christi Caldwell

  OTHER TITLES BY CHRISTI CALDWELL

  Sinful Brides

  The Rogue’s Wager

  The Scoundrel’s Honor

  The Theodosia Sword

  Only for His Lady

  Only for Her Honor

  Heart of a Duke

  In Need of a Duke

  For Love of the Duke

  More Than a Duke

  The Love of a Rogue

  Loved by a Duke

  To Love a Lord

  The Heart of a Scoundrel

  To Wed His Christmas Lady

  To Trust a Rogue

  The Lure of a Rake

  To Woo a Widow

  To Redeem a Rake

  Lords of Honor

  Seduced by a Lady’s Heart

  Captivated by a Lady’s Charm

  Rescued by a Lady’s Love

  Tempted by a Lady’s Smile

  Scandalous Seasons

  Forever Betrothed, Never the Bride

  Never Courted, Suddenly Wed

  Always Proper, Suddenly Scandalous

  Always a Rogue, Forever Her Love

  A Marquess for Christmas

  Once a Wallflower, at Last His Love

  Danby

  A Season of Hope

  Winning a Lady’s Heart

  Brethren of the Lords

  My Lady of Deception

  Nonfiction

  Uninterrupted Joy

  This is a work of fiction. Names, characters, organizations, places, events, and incidents are either products of the author’s imagination or are used fictitiously. Any resemblance to actual persons, living or dead, or actual events is purely coincidental.

  Text copyright © 2017 by Christi Caldwell

  All rights reserved.

  No part of this book may be reproduced, or stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording, or otherwise, without express written permission of the publisher.

  Published by Montlake Romance, Seattle

  www.apub.com

  Amazon, the Amazon logo, and Montlake Romance are trademarks of Amazon.com, Inc., or its affiliates.

  ISBN-13: 9781503943438

  ISBN-10: 1503943437

  Cover design by Michael Rehder

  For the Ladies in My Corner—every day I lose myself in a story. Writing is and always has been a cathartic experience. Writing can also be a solitary endeavor—but not for me. You ladies are always there to talk about my heroes and heroines, and all my books, past and present. From the bottom of my heart, I thank you for all your support. Penny and Ryker’s story is for you!

  Contents

  London, England — Spring 1823

  Chapter 1

  Chapter 2

  Chapter 3

  Chapter 4

  Chapter 5

  Chapter 6

  Chapter 7

  Chapter 8

  Chapter 9

  Chapter 10

  Chapter 11

  Chapter 12

  Chapter 13

  Chapter 14

  Chapter 15

  Chapter 16

  Chapter 17

  Chapter 18

  Chapter 19

  Chapter 20

  Chapter 21

  Chapter 22

  Chapter 23

  Chapter 24

  Fortnight Later — St. Giles

  Chapter 25

  Chapter 26

  Acknowledgments

  About the Author

  London, England

  Spring 1823

  Chapter 1

  Dear Fezzimore,

  Mrs. Dundlebottom insists we remain silent through her lessons on propriety and decorum. I tried, Fezzi. I truly did. Alas, propriety and decorum are highly overrated.

  Penny

  Age 11

  It was coming.

  The mantra. Or litany. Or lecture. Or whichever one chose to call it.

  It was coming, as it invariably did when a Tidemore girl made her Come Out.

  Seated on the ivory sofa with her hands clasped primly on her lap, Lady Penelope Tidemore stared at the pair across from her.

  Her mother, the Dowager Countess of Sinclair, and her brother, Jonathan, the Earl of Sinclair, stared back.

  “Penny . . .” Jonathan began.

  “Penelope,” she swiftly corrected. She gave him a pointed look.

  “Penelope, then,” he acquiesced. “As you make your entrance into Society, there are certain expectations . . .” He grimaced.

  Yes, well, at least he, a reformed rogue who’d earned a scandalous reputation, saw the irony in giving any manner of lecture on societal expectations.

  “Expectations,” Penelope prodded. Annoyance stirred. This meeting was more befitting a girl of eight than a woman of eighteen, nearly nineteen, years. Granted, with the early death of her father, Jonathan had been more father than brother, but this high-handedness set her teeth on edge.

  Jonathan tossed his hands up. “Mother?” he entreated.

  The Dowager Countess of Sinclair cleared her throat. “Yes, as your brother tried to say, there are societal expectations.”

  Expectations that not a single Tidemore had fulfilled . . . Penelope steeled her jaw. Until her. “I made my debut,” she reminded them. Since then, they’d attended the theatre and dinner parties, but never anything more. No balls. No soirees. Nothing that young ladies new to the London Marriage Mart longed to attend.

  She’d demonstrated her resolve to rise above gossip and prove to Society that scandal need not follow her family. After all, it was possible to have love . . . and be properly behaved and respected. She was sure of it. In a world where women had control over so very little, her reputation was something within her grasp, and she would not relinquish her hold. Even if her elder sisters and brother had proved deplorable models before her.

  “Society will not be kind,” Jonathan said, and that frank warning brought her gaze back to him.

  “Beg pardon?” Well, this was not the lecture she’d been expecting.

  Her brother settled his ankle across his knee. “Given our family’s . . . ?” He swiped a hand down the side of his face.

  “Scandals?” Penelope supplied.

  “Scandals,” he confirmed with a nod. “Polite Society will not demonstrate any real kindness.” Yes, well, when one’s sister eloped with one man, only to marry another, and then one’s brother married the governess, and one’s other sister was wedded after a public scandal to a fortune hunter, gossip did follow.

  Their mother leapt into the discussion. “Which is why it is so very essential, Penny—”

  “Penelope.”

  “That you remember”—her mother carried on over Penelope’s interruption—“to be everything and all things proper. All the time.” And there it was—the mantra. “The gossips are always watching. Always waiting for one to falter.” Her voice shook with the same force of emotion as if she were speaking of great battle plans to conquer the Continent.

  Smoothing her palms along the front of her gown, Penelope looked between her mother and brother. “I am well aware of the stringent expectations. I also assure you I’m entirely practical and logical.” Even if she did dream of love, a lady could still be practical.

  At the skeptical looks that passed between them, she frowned.

  Penelope had not always been proper. Given that, a stern sit-down with her mother and brother was certainly not unmerited. Nonetheless, this inability to see her as a young woman grown, and above those childish antics she’d once been famous for, chafed. “I am no longer the child you see me as,” she said in even, modulated tones that only deepened the wariness in her skeptical kin’s eyes.

  Also, not undeserved.
As a girl, she’d actually been quite mischievous and always troublesome. Or, as her mother had long lamented, “the bane of my motherly existence.” Well, one of the banes. The title of bane had been applied to all the Tidemore daughters in equal measure.

  “It is not my intention to cause a scandal.”

  “That is my point exactly,” Jonathan said with his usual frankness. He uncrossed his legs and set both booted feet on the floor. Had he made a point? She really hadn’t remembered it. “I worry—”

  “We worry,” their mother said in a show of unity with her son, “with your . . .” Penelope narrowed her gaze, as Jonathan searched for his next words.

  “Romantic spirit,” he settled for.

  My romantic spirit? “That you’re unprepared for the extent of Society’s viciousness,” Mother said in the same calming tones she’d used when Penelope had scraped her knees as a girl.

  In short, they believed her a daft, empty-headed ninny.

  “As such,” Mother supplied for her son, “you may not deliberately seek out scandal . . .”

  “Why would anyone deliberately seek out scandal?” Penelope asked dryly.

  Mother blinked wildly. “Well, they wouldn’t.”

  “We wish you to be careful, Penny,” Jonathan said bluntly. “We wish you to know despite your expectations there are those who would like nothing better than to see a lady fall, and I’d not have you become that woman.”

  She widened her eyes. “Is this why we’ve avoided the ton events?”

  Her mother’s cheeks flamed a guilty red.

  “We haven’t avoided the ton events,” Jonathan mumbled, shifting in his seat like a boy who’d just been caught with his hand on the dessert platter.

  Penelope proceeded to tick off on her fingers. “First, we were a month late arriving for the London Season.”

  “It was cold?” their mother put in, her voice weak.

  “Then, I had to be fitted for a wardrobe,” she carried on, wiggling her index finger.

  “Which is customary,” Jonathan pointed out, tugging at his cravat.

  “For it to take more than a month to receive my wardrobe?” A wardrobe of frilly, white monstrosities. But one matter of discontent at a time.

  It was Jonathan’s turn to flush. Good. He should feel guilty. The miserable bugger.

  Penelope warmed to her argument. “Following my debut, I’ve been to the theatre.” Twice. “Lord and Lady Drake’s formal dinner. Lord and Lady Drake’s informal dinner. Lord and Lady Waxham’s recital. But never a ball.”

  Silence met her damning list. Then, what could they say? The traitors.

  “You left your . . . diary in the parlor.”

  Her mother’s words held Penelope frozen—suspended. Surely she’d misheard? “You read my diary?” she choked out. Humiliated shame and shock rolled through her, setting her body afire with heat. All the intimate, poignant, hopeful words she’d set to page read by her mother. Groaning, Penelope buried her face in her hands. “How could you?” She’d misplaced that precious book when they’d arrived in London for the Season. She’d turned the townhouse upside down, eventually finding it in her chambers. Only to now find the blasted thing had been found, read, and then properly planted. She dropped her hands to her lap and glared.

  Jonathan coughed into his hand. “It was merely the first two entries.”

  She singed him with a look. “They are”—were—“my thoughts.”

  “And they were enough for us to know to worry after your romantic hopes for the Season.”

  Her body jerked. She’d fashioned herself into a proper lady, abandoning her hoydenish ways. Only onto the pages of her diary had she poured her deepest hopes and dreams as a woman, and her brother had read them.

  Two entries—may as well have been page two hundred twenty-two for the words she’d inked there. She curled her toes into the soles of her slippers. “Is that all?” she seethed.

  The pair seated across from her exchanged glances.

  “I am no longer a child. I . . .” resent. Be calm, Penelope. Do not feed their perceptions. “Appreciate your concern, but do not require any lectures. I intend to be all things proper and polite. As such, you needn’t keep me from all the balls and soirees.” Events she desperately longed to attend. After all, how was a lady to otherwise find love and an honorable husband? She brought her shoulders back. “I am not Poppy,” Poppy who’d long been the most troublesome of all the four Tidemore girls.

  A loud growl sounded from the hallway and Penelope looked to the panel. No doubt, Poppy was at the keyhole even now.

  “We know you are not Poppy,” Mother said, placating her, earning another distant growl. She wrung her hands together and cast a worried look at Jonathan.

  Penelope had tired of their cryptic looks and gestures. Could they not say precisely what it was they thought?

  Jonathan spoke with an unexpected solemnity. “We are attending the Duke and Duchess of Somerset’s ball this coming Friday.”

  And all ladylike decorum went out the proverbial window. Penelope rushed to the edge of her seat. A ball. Not the miserable stuffy event at Almack’s or her own modest come-out affair. Excitement stirred.

  Excitement that her brother promptly quashed.

  “I do not want to see you hurt, Penelope.” The way Patrina and Prudence had been. The reminder hung in the air.

  Yes, her two elder sisters had eventually found love . . . but their path to happiness had been fraught with heartbreak. Penelope had witnessed enough of it to know she could do without the heartbreak part. Fortunately, she was the logical Tidemore.

  “My judgment is sound. As I said, I’ve no intention of bringing scandal to the family. I’ll not run off with a scoundrel. I’ll not be trapped by a fortune hunter. Have I missed anything?”

  Additional looks were exchanged. Jonathan shook his head. “That is all.”

  With aplomb, Penelope rose. Her skirts settled in a noisy taffeta rustle about her ankles. Then, with a grace and decorum her mother had long lamented that Penelope would never be in possession of, she marched out of the room, closed the door behind her, and started down the hall.

  Annoyance warred with an eager anticipation for the coming event she would attend.

  They would question her judgment. They would worry after her like she was a child because that is precisely the light in which they still saw her. What they failed to realize was that Penelope’s path to proper reform had been set after her eldest sister Patrina’s scandal. And then after her brother’s scandal. And her path was determined only further by the latest scandal a year earlier, of her elder sister Prudence. After all, it was one thing to be an always-laughing child, delighting in mischief, but it was quite another to be sobered by the reality of the world around you. The real truth, long lectured by Mama, and confirmed by life—there are consequences to your actions.

  A harsh whisper filled the corridor. “What rubbish was that?”

  Penelope shrieked. Her youngest sister Poppy, of seventeen years, stepped directly into her path. Poppy brandished a newspaper.

  “You startled me,” Penelope scolded, stepping around her and resuming her forward march.

  Poppy fell quickly into step. “‘Not Poppy,’ you said,” her sister muttered, waving about the paper in her hands. “You sound like a stodgy bore when you talk.”

  “I sound practical and logical,” she said instantly. From the corner of her eye she glared at her sister. “And I am not boring.”

  “You weren’t boring. You are now.”

  That sharp retort raised another frown. She’d not debate the merits of her character with Poppy—Poppy who still traipsed over country estates in breeches and swam in lakes. “When you make your Come Out, you’ll understand the need for decorum.”

  Her sister snorted. “If you think I’d marry a man who wanted me to be proper and logical,” she said in a high-pitched tenor, mimicking Penelope’s earlier words, “then you’re far less sensible than you credit yoursel
f.”

  They reached Penelope’s chambers, and she pressed the door handle. Her sister spilled in ahead of her. With a sigh, she followed behind and closed the door.

  “It is hardly fair you get to attend the Duke and Duchess of Somerset’s ball,” said Poppy, still waving about the paper. “It is the singularly most interesting event of the Season. They are calling it the Event.” The younger lady dropped her voice to a conspiratorial whisper. “The papers say the duchess’s brother, Mr. Black, the notorious gaming-hell owner, will attend. The bastard son of the Duke of Wilkinson.” She dropped her voice even further. “They say he has killed men.”

  A chill skittered along Penelope’s spine, and she tamped down the irrational response. “Do not be silly. I’m certain he hasn’t killed men.”

  “He does own a gaming hell,” Poppy pointed out.

  Of course, with her tendency to listen at closed doors, she’d have gleaned long before Penelope details of the duke’s ball. Then the girl’s words registered. How many years had she spent dreaming of infiltrating those clubs visited by her brother? “A gaming hell?” she breathed, unable to keep her intrigue buried. Penelope’s cheeks turned hot. You do not care about gaming hells. You are a lady. You are polite . . .

  Penelope gave a toss of her curls. “He is a duke’s son,” she corrected Poppy.

  “Yes, and he has a title, but he refuses to be addressed as Lord Chatham or any variation of his title.” Poppy dropped her voice to a hushed whisper. “They say he kills men and women who call him anything other than Mr. B—hey,” Poppy cried out, as Penelope plucked the paper from her fingers. Ignoring her sister’s sharp protest, she proceeded to skim for only the relevant details on the page. It could have been a ball in a barroom and she would have been thrilled to attend. Granted, a barroom ball would be interesting for any number of reasons. She gave her head a shake. If I were one of those hoydenish ladies. Which she decidedly was not.

  “There,” Poppy said; leaning over her shoulder, she jabbed her finger at the middle of the page. “It promises to be the most attended ball, and you are going, while I remain here.” In her normal dramatic fashion, she flung herself upon the bed and collapsed on the feather mattress.

  While her sister bemoaned the unfairness of being born last, Penelope gazed over the article.