Cassie's New Plan

by Breanna Hayse

  “Please…”Cassie begged,“Stop torturing me.”

  Rob chuckled, seeing Bryon wink. He made his final dive, sucking her clit between his tongue and the back of his front teeth and pressing his fingers deep inside her virgin hole. He could feel the plug against his knuckles adding to her pain and pleasure.

  Cassie screamed, arching off the bed in spectacular spasms. Her head swung back against Bryon’s broad chest, her neck pulsing as he sunk his teeth into it gently—catching that special, sweet spot that caused her to spasm once again.

  “And the vampire strikes,”Rob teased, watching Cass shiver from Bryon’s‘special skill’. He always seemed to know where to find that place and could reduce a woman to a puddle when he bit it. She fell back against him, exhausted. Slowly he unwrapped his ankles from around her legs, releasing her.

  She panted, trying to catch her breath and unable to move. Bryon rolled her onto the bed to sit himself up and stretch his back.

  “Well, that was fun. When’s dinner?”

  “You certainly know how to spoil a moment!”Rob laughed, also stretching.

  Cassie could barely open her eyes, let alone add a remark. Not one part of her body had been untouched and she still tingled from the multiple orgasms she had experienced. She started to purr happily. She bet no other woman had ever had the same first experience she just did!

  “Sounds like she’s content. Let’s go get some food,”Bryon urged. Rob leaned over to kiss Cassie’s lips.

  “Rest up. We’ll come get you when it’s ready.”

  “May I please take this thing out?”Cassie whispered.

  “I’ll do it. You aren’t being punished with it,”Rob flipped her onto her stomach and gently slid out the plug before following Bryan down to the kitchen. Cassie was surprised; she felt empty and wondered how it would feel to have Rob’s cock fill that space instead.

  * * *

  The thunder continued to rumble through the house as the three sat for the evening meal. Cassie had come downstairs dressed despite Rob’s request to see her naked while at home, and earned herself a playful spanking from both Robby and her new Daddy. After being sat in the corner for 15 minutes, she was released with permission to keep her pajamas on because she was chilly.

  The three sat in front of the TV, Cassie nestled between the brothers, as they watched Tough Love. Of course, both men had their own solution as to how the host, Steve, should deal with the obnoxious, overindulged women on the show, and they informed Cassie of their opinion that he needed to man up and redden each of those women’s bottoms.

  Cassie giggled, feeling content. In just two days, her life had turned around and now felt right. For the first time, she knew for certain that she was wanted, desired, loved and needed. Not by just one but by two men, in two completely different ways. She knew her love for Rob went deep and well beyond the play they had engaged in. He would be her absolute future. He owned her now and she truly felt like his possession as intimately as she had felt his lips make love to her earlier.

  As for Bryon, it was wonderfully special that he took the place of her Daddy. She desperately wanted to make them both happy.

  “What are you thinking about so deeply, Hot Pocket?”Bryon asked. She snuggled against his arm.

  “You make a good Daddy. I never really had one before, you know.”

  “Pop tried to be a father to you. You wouldn’t let him,”Bryan reminded her.

  She nodded. “I know. I’ll make things right when he gets home. But, I wouldn’t let him be the kind of Daddy you are,”she giggled.

  “Should I be jealous?”Rob asked in good-humor.

  Cassie turned to kiss him soundly on the lips. “I don’t do this to my Daddy,”Cassie whispered, her tongue deep in his mouth. Rob’s cock started to swell.

  “You could if you wanted too.”Rob caught his breath. “I just want your heart belonging only to me.”

  “You have it. I love you,”she whispered, climbing onto his lap.

  Rob wrapped his arms around her. “Good. I love you, too. Do you mind if we share you and let Bryon stay on as your Daddy until he finds himself an old lady?”

  “No. I think I might like it,”Cassie giggled. “But what if I want to keep him as my Daddy even after he finds an old lady?”

  “We could hook the two of you up…”Bryon started.

  “No!”both Rob and Cassie said.

  Bryon laughed. “Okay, no girl-on-girl. Gee, and I thought Iwas the conservative one!”

  Chapter Eight

  Cassie leaned back happily on the over-stuffed couch in the family living room, working on her homework and waiting until her‘men’got home. Dinner was in the oven and starting to smell really good. The one month winter break began next week and Bill was due home after New Years. Things were finally going well for her. The court issue was over with no ill-effects, she was doing better in school and, for once, there was no conflict at home.

  Until Judy walked in with Glenn at her side.

  “What are you doing here?”Cassie asked, glaring at Glenn.

  Judy smiled sweetly. “Hello to you, Cass. Glenn and I have been dating.”

  “What? You never told me!”

  “I knew you two didn’t get along very well so I thought it would be better to keep quiet until I knew where things were heading. Cass… Oh shit. Excuse me,”he said to Judy as he raced up the stairs behind Cassie.

  “Chili Pepper? Hey, don’t be mad. You’re never home to play with and well, Judy likes me.”

  “She likes you because she hates me. Glenn, don’t you see? She’s a slut! The whole campus knows it. If you fuck her then your dick will fall off from something she gave you.”

  “Judy is my girlfriend and you are not to say another nasty thing about her!”Glenn suddenly shouted in her face. “You, of all people have no right to judge who is a slut. You! Do you think I don’t know that you’ve been fucking both my brothers at the same time!”

  Cassie stared at him opened mouthed in shock, tears springing to her eyes.

  “I am not screwing either of them,”she whispered tearfully. “And I’m in love with Rob.”

  “Yeah, right. They think I’m stupid, but I know what sick shit they are into. Of course, I’m not good enough to be invited. Not even to the house, let alone to get a piece of you, too.”

  “Oh my God! Glenn…wait. Please.”

  The door slammed shut behind him. He was jealous. For all those years, he had been the closest to her, a playmate at only one year apart. They grew up together and he was what she really considered more a brother than just a friend. She had neglected him in the excitement of her new life with Rob and, subsequently, Bryon. Cassie felt terrible. She knew his words were spoken only out of hurt and years of pent up jealousy over his brothers’successes.

  Bryon came home early to find her curled up in bed, staring at the wall.

  “Hey, baby, what’s wrong?”he asked softly. She shook her head. He stretched out next to her. “You can tell Daddy. Talk to me.”

  Cassie broke out in tears, telling him everything that had happened.

  He paled slightly. “How did he find out about us?”

  “I don’t know. It wasn't me. You won’t get in trouble at your job, will you?”she suddenly sat up, grabbing his arm. He shook his head.

  “Nah, we’re all adults and in a very unique living situation. I’m more worried about Pop finding out.”

  “He thought I was fucking both of you. He called me a slut.”

  “Watch your mouth, young lady…He called you a what? I’ll kill him!”

  “I kind of provoked it. I told him Judy is a slut. She hates me and is going to hurt him to get to me.”

  “Glenn is an adult; granted, he’s very immature but he still needs to learn his own way, just like the rest of us. Please don’t let what he said bother you. He’s hurting right now. Come here and give your Daddy luvs…”Bryon said, pulling her up onto his lap and rocking her like an infant.

  He an
d Rob had decided that Bryon would use Cassie for his age-play fix. He had been excited because Rob was going away for another trip for three days and Bryon would be taking Cassie to the farm for a whole weekend to be his young lady. But now, with Glenn’s accusation…

  “Did he give you any idea of what he thinks he knows?”Bryon asked, kissing the girl’s cheek as he cradled her in his arms like a baby. He had threatened recently that he was going to find a bottle one day and maybe put her in diapers if she was particularly naughty. She had adamantly refused but also suspected that she might have to endure some such treatment during that upcoming weekend whether she liked it or not.

  “No, Daddy. He just yelled at me and was real mean,”she sniffed, letting her voice drop to sound like a child. Bryon liked when she regressed, and she liked to please him. She hated making Daddy upset; young lady spankings hurt as bad as big girl ones!

  “Rob and I will talk with him tonight. Now, tell me about this girl he’s with. Will she cause problems?”

  “Yes, Daddy. She’s a liar and a manipulative bitch.”

  “Must I wash your mouth out with soap for using bad words, young lady? Do you need to be told again?”Bryon scolded. Cassie put her hands over her mouth, eyes wide and shaking her head.

  He frowned. “No more of that, then. How can we keep her quiet? I’m sure she overheard Glenn’s comment to you.”

  “She’s probably already started spreading it. It will get back to Glenn and he’ll know who’s trying to hurt his family. I can’t see him letting anyone do that, no matter how mad he is at us.”

  “He’s jealous, love. He feels left out. We need to bring him to the farm with us this weekend.”

  “But our time together…”

  “He’s our brother. We need to do what’s right for him, okay? Be a good girl and I’ll get you something special. Maybe a new Teddy Bear?”

  Cassie’s eyes shone as she nodded. Her new daddy loved to buy her Teddy bears after he had discovered the story from the first one she had at eight years old. She had tossed that old one away and now had her very special bears given to her by a daddy who really loved her. She loved them almost as much as the crystal and glass fairies that Robby started collecting for her.

  Glenn still hadn’t come home by the time she, Bryon and Rob had sat down together for dinner. Cassie had made a cranberry apricot glazed lamb roll with seasoned cornbread stuffing and asparagus with béarnaise sauce.

  Rob groaned with delight. “You are a magician in the kitchen, my love. Thank you for dinner. So, what should we do about the little brother?”

  Bryon suggested a gentle talk and inviting him to the farm with him and Cassie while Rob was gone. Rob thought about it. “You could do that. I could also invite him to come to Las Vegas with me. I have some meetings, but plenty of time to go around with him. I could even take him to the Club.”

  “Are you sure you want to expose him to so much?”

  “We need to find out how much he knows first. If he really knows the scoop then it would be smarter to include him, not exclude him. If he’s interested, then at least we can guide him. If not, then he knows enough to make a different choice.”

  “If he comes to the farm, should we keep it straight?”

  “If he really knows, then it’s up to you and Cass. What do you think, honey?”

  “He misses me badly. I think he’d be even more jealous if he’s not part of what we do. He’ll know we don’t hang out at the farm to watch TV, either. I told him I wasn’t screwing both of you.”

  “It’s the truth. Although, I don’t know how much longer I can wait,”Rob whispered into her ear. She shivered with delight.

  Bryon patted her bottom. “What if he tells Pop?”he asked.

  Rob sighed. “Then we tell him the truth. He might hand us our heads on a platter, but he’s still our father. He wants us all to be happy.”

  “I was thinking about that…What would you say if I brought you home a mommy, Cass?”

  “Are you dating someone?”her eyes brightened. No wonder he wasn't as interested in sex! Bryon shrugged.

  “Not really. We’re just friends with benefits. Her name is Suzanne and she’s a teacher. I met her during one of our games.”

  “Why didn’t you say something to me? Rob? Did you know?”

  “We didn’t want you to get jealous. It’s not serious,”Bryon said softly.

  “Tell me about her. Will she let you share me with Rob?”

  “Well…she wants to be a mommy to an adult young lady. Unfortunately, she had no interest whatsoever in being cared for as an adult young lady. You know that’s what I really want. I told her about my young ladyand she is very eager to meet you. She’s interested in being either your mommy or an aunt.”

  “Does she have any kids of her own?”Cassie asked, her voice small. It was so easy for Bryon to put her into that role.

  He nodded his head. “Two daughters. They are both a little younger than you and live with their father in Orlando.”

  “Wow! She must be OLD! Like 40! You found your cougar, huh?”Cassie teased.

  She looked innocent, blinking her big eyes as Bryon beckoned to her and pointed to his lap. Sighing, she obeyed, placing herself with her bottom upturned and sit spot accessible. Cassie yelped loudly when five sharps smacks landed on her bottom. Bryon stood her back up, shaking his finger.

  “You best be nice. Suzanne is wicked with a hairbrush.”

  “I will, Daddy. I’m sorry I was bad.”

  “You weren’t bad. Kiss me and go love on Robby.”He smiled warmly. Cassie obeyed and climbed onto Rob’s lap for hugs and very grown-up caresses. They heard the front door open.

  “Glenn? We’re in the kitchen,”Rob called, sliding Cassie off his lap so she could warm some dinner up for the youngest brother. He walked in, looking dejected. Cassie put the plate down before him and wrapped her arms around his neck, kissing his cheek.

  “Glenn? I’m so sorry I hurt you. I didn’t realize how much you would miss me if I wasn't around so much.”

  “You guys leave me out of everything,”he pouted, stuffing the food into his mouth without really tasting it.

  Rob patted his arm. “I’m sorry, too, Glennster. None of us thought twice about how selfish we were being. Forgive us?”

  “Me, too, little brother. I never meant to hurt you. We want to be up front with you. You’re our brother and you’re an adult. We trust you and respect you.”

  “You do?”

  “We do.”Bryon kicked Rob under the table, and he nodded.

  “Let’s start from the beginning. You said you knew about us? What do you know and how did you find out?”Rob asked carefully.

  “You guys go to that gay bar in South Bay where the Leathermen hang. My friend saw you there a couple of times. I know you’re not gay, which means you are into leather. Simple deduction. Whips and chain stuff.”

  “What made you think Cassie was screwing us?”Rob frowned.

  Glen shrugged. “I was just being mean. Sorry Cass. I know you hate Judy, but she seems to really like me.”

  “Glenn, she might like you but we love you. She’s not a safe person for you to be around. She’s unscrupulous and will hurt the family if she gets a chance,”Cassie said softly, her eyes concerned.

  Glenn shook his head. “You know I wouldn’t let anyone hurt my family. Besides, there’s nothing wrong with being Leathermen and I know you and Rob have a thing going. I’m okay with that...”

  “We aren’t into leather, Glenn,”Rob said firmly.

  Bryon eyed his elder brother, who nodded. “And we aren’t gay. We have other interests,”Bryon said.

  “Like what? Cass? You too?”

  “Yes, but…”

  “Glenn, I want to invite you to either go with me to Las Vegas this weekend or spend the weekend on my farm with Cass and Bry. Either way, you’ll get a better understanding. You just have to swear not to ever tell Pop. He’d have a heart attack.”

  “If I go to Vegas,
will you pay?”Glenn asked slyly. Rob smiled, nodding.

  “We haven’t had a trip together in a long time. When we get back, I’ll take you over to the farm. Deal?”

  “Deal. When do we leave?”

  “I’ll get you a ticket right now. Can you be ready at 7?”

  “Hell yeah. Let me go pack,”Glenn said excitedly, rushing from the table. He kissed Cassie’s cheek, thanking her for dinner.

  “Well, that went better than I thought it would. Leathermen? We could have gotten away with letting him believe that, you know,”Bryon said, nibbling on a roll.

  Cassie frowned, hands on her hips. “It’s not nice to lie, Daddy. I’d be spanked hard for even thinking that,”she scolded quietly.

  “Yeah, Bad Daddy,”Rob teased.

  Bryon shot them both the bird.

  * * *

  Glenn sat quietly next to his older brother as they started the long trip to Vegas. Not much was said, both of them were tired from the early morning flight. He eyed Rob.

  “You’ve changed.”

  “Huh?”

  “You’re happier. Is it because of Cass?”

  “Most of it, yes.”

  “Do you swear to me that you’ll tell me the truth if I ask?”

  “I swear. It’s exhausting to keep secrets from the people you love.”

  “Okay, then tell me about your kicks. And where Cassie fits in.”

  Sighing, and keeping his voice low, Rob explained.

  Glenn’s eyes widened. “You share her? That’s gross.”

  “We aren’t sexually involved. At least she and I are not yet and Bryon won’t be. He’s got a lady friend who might be joining our little family.”

  “Is she bi-sexual?”

  “I’m not sure, I haven’t met her yet. They’re just friends with, uh, benefits. But she has the same interests as Bry with wanting to care for an adult child. You know how Bry’s always been the nurturer. This is natural for him, and Cassie being so tiny and always into mischief allows him to indulge his need.”