Lost Girls

by Andrew Pyper

  In the years since, I’ve come to see the two of them held together in a kind of orbit. Each connected to and moving about the other according to some superior, intricate power. And somewhere on the periphery there was me, passing them at a distance, related but secondary as a moon.

  Darkling I listen; and, for many a time

  I have been half in love with easeful Death,

  Call’d him soft names in many a mused rhyme,

  To take into the air my quiet breath;

  We were a family of three. But when they died together in a car accident at the end of my fourteenth summer, the family part was gone. I required farming out. It was my wish to be sent to boarding school and the sympathetic but preoccupied circle of uncles and aunts in charge of my care were more than happy to oblige. Somewhere along the line there were friends, books and a handful of clever, scandalous pranks, all now difficult to recall. It wouldn’t be an exaggeration to say that the better part of my remembered adolescence was spent staring out the window of a third-floor dorm room at Upper Canada College. The smell of burnt margarine hanging in the stairwells, the salt of lights-off ejaculations buried in every mold-speckled mattress. And this: on my seventeenth birthday I was given a mint-condition yellow MG convertible. It remained in the parking lot until the following year when I put a classified ad in The Globe and sold it to a recently divorced Lawrence Park orthodontist. Nobody asked what I did with the money.

  There’s more—there must be more—but from the first two decades of my life there are few details I can call on. A stuffed zebra with button eyes plucked from its head. Charlie’s Angels. The wrought-ironed, duplexed streets of the city leaning down to the lake. A broken collarbone from running into the goalposts looking skyward for a long-bomb pass. It seems to me now that my childhood was more a prolonged setting of mood than a sequence of actual events, like the music the orchestra plays in a darkened theater before the curtain is raised and you’re required to start paying real attention.

  Although I was alone I don’t remember being lonely. Never popular but respected from a distance in the way that derisive, slightly feared young men can be. And so when I went to university when the trust fund finally kicked in after I turned nineteen there wasn’t the usual cast of mentors to advise me on what course of study to take, and I had no strong inclinations of my own. It must have been some kind of subconscious tribute to the old man when I signed up to major in English when it came time to register. Four years of British verse, French theory, American novels and all around me girls morphed into talking panthers I dared not speak to. Then law school, for all the usual reasons: legitimacy, money, a safe reservoir for undistinguished intelligence. But it turned out to be far more compatible than I imagined, my passion for words finally married to an indifference to truth. For me, law school was the discovery of religion, albeit a godless one, with its Latin prayers and shifting, manufactured convictions. Belief the weight of the air in your lungs.

  Of course not all of my classmates experienced their legal education the same way I did. Many even arrived with declared intentions of “doing some good out there” or “making changes from within the system,” but there was much less of that kind of talk by the time graduation rolled around. And it was a good thing too, the rest of us having found the spectacle of diminished moral ambitions rather embarrassing and sad, like watching a man with a wooden leg take dance lessons.

  Then the purchase of suits and all of my classmates drifting away into marriage or property or the pursuit of expensive, rarely indulged hobbies. Whether due to my suspicious bachelorhood or success in releasing unpredictably violent offenders back into the world, I am no longer asked to their late-bloomer weddings, house warmings or—if such things still go on—cocktail parties. Although occasionally curious, I miss none of them. I assume all of us are happy in our ways.

  Adieu! adieu! thy plaintive anthem fades

  Past the near meadows, over the still stream,

  Up the hill-side; and now ’tis buried deep

  In the next valley-glades:

  Was it a vision, or a waking dream?

  Fled is that music:—Do I wake or sleep?

  EIGHT

  After I’ve shaved and thrown on a shirt I sit on the edge of the bed for a minute, the heat of my skin escaping out into the chill of the room which lingers despite the sunlight that slices in through the windows. Pull out my leather agenda and study the series of empty days leading up to the trial. The pre-trial conference for disclosure of any remaining Crown evidence is scheduled for tomorrow morning, but today’s still wide open. I riffle through the loose-leaf appendices of the police report and pull up the already wrinkle-worn map of the county, spread it over the bed. There, in a meandering line of radioactive yellow highlighter, is the course of the accused’s drive from Georgian Lakes High School to the side of Fireweed Road where his 1990 green Volvo station wagon was parked and the victims allegedly removed to be taken down to the water.

  It’s not a short drive. Judging from the map, five miles as the crow flies but probably closer to eight when you consider the snaking private road Tripp would have had to take through the woods and around part of the lake’s coiled shoreline. And then, once he’d parked, to somehow pull the two girls down to the water—that must have taken a while, too. How did he manage it? If he’d sedated them somehow, it was too far to lug them over his back. (Tripp isn’t small, but he’s no hulking woodsman either.) And if he hadn’t knocked them out one way or another, they must have followed him either willingly or under threat. But couldn’t at least one of them have pulled free and ripped off into the woods when his attention was on the other for a moment? If it’s as long a walk as it appears on the map, the implication of an unused opportunity for easy escape may be of assistance to the defense’s cause. And seeing as Tripp is unlikely to be of any help in providing topographical descriptions himself, there’s nothing for it but to follow his tracks on my own.

  I fire up the Lincoln, pull a U-turn and head back up toward the courthouse. A left at the second of the three sets of lights and into the blocks of staunch brick homes with paint peeling off the eaves and trees planted too close to the front windows. An Ontario town. Whether clustered at the meeting of concession roads on the flat land nosed into the Great Lakes or blasted through the pitching rock of the Canadian Shield, all of them built on the shared assumption that one must always start with straight lines. Grid patterns. County borders designated by surveyors’ measurements instead of the creeping accidents of lakeshore, escarpment or creek. And all but a few people meant to live on the even blocks set inside phantom town limits, residential streets finally melting into endless gravel roads or weedy culs-de-sac at the edge of bullfrog swamps. Order thrown down on the land like an unmet challenge, fenced backyards and rectangular playgrounds plotted out in the hope that dignity and history might follow. Imaginary city walls standing where the used car lots and scrap metal yards have rusted away and yielded to whatever came before.

  And Murdoch no different from the rest. In fact something classical about it, the humility that comes with all failed experiments. Shingles flapping off the roofs to be replaced with smearings of tar. Towering, nettled weeds allowed to grow in place of the cleared first-generation jack pines and poplars. Uncertain-looking houses with nylon curtains permanently drawn in the upstairs windows and a single porch light packed tight with moth wings. Above the main street storefronts the by-the-week apartments where the whiskey bachelors peer down with faces you can never clearly see, as though a ghost or a minor character in a complicated dream. Below them, the good citizens of Murdoch scuffing by. Hard-working if there’s work to be done, honest if asked directly, skeptical of good fortune. People not so much friendly as prepared to help if called upon.

  At the end of the street there’s the high school, the brick a dirty yellow instead of the houses’ dirty red. Nobody outside except a couple guys in Guns ‘n’ Roses T-shirts, energetically smoking as though it might make them
warm. At one of the classroom windows a teacher points at a map of Europe, the heads of her students hung low from note-taking or sleep.

  I check my watch. 9:37.

  Left at the lights and right at the courthouse and then out of town on the main highway north which follows the shore of Georgian Bay, although now, even with most of the leaves off the trees, it’s still too far off to be seen. I keep an eye out for signs but still come to the turn almost too late to make it: LAKE ST. CHRISTOPHER, RIGHT 50 YARDS. The Lincoln leans off onto the crunch and bump of the single lane that quickly disappears, behind and ahead, into the trees.

  The map calls it Lake St. Christopher, but it used to go by Fireweed Lake. At least that’s what the couple of hand-painted direction signs nailed onto roadside pines still call it, erected in the days before some poet at the Chamber of Commerce changed its name. From what I can tell Fireweed Lake is more appropriate though, for instead of the dramatic rock formations or clear, sandy beaches which dignify many of the other settled lakes an hour or so to the south, this one could claim only a slow and soggy decline into the reed-ridden muck. It’s a big lake with limited road access and plenty of cheap land surrounding it, but the same could be said of a hundred other lakes up here that don’t suffer the blight of duckweed, quack grass and floating green algae as this one does. And then, after forty or fifty brake-pumping turns, it’s there before me, a glimpse of reflected cloud between an entanglement of brown trunks.

  The road rises, falls and jerks, occasionally exposing the entrance to a cottage driveway marked by some cutesie name burned into a hunk of driftwood. Mayonnaise Manor, Monarch Point, Bucky’s Palace. But there aren’t many of these, and the spaces between them are dotted with realty signs crippled from the rot setting in at their bases. The map is spread out beside me on the passenger seat and I pull over to trace the final part of Tripp’s path. A red dot to mark the place where he supposedly stopped, halfway around the circumference of the water. If the lake runs about three miles from end to end and three-quarters of a mile across at its midsection, and judging from how far I must have gone already, I’ve got to be pretty close. But it seems I have to continue on another quarter of an hour before, with the cresting of a final steep incline, the woods on the right are set off by the yellow plastic of a police line fluttering over the road from the wind sweeping up from the water.

  Roll down the window and suddenly my ears are filled with a high-voltage hum. An orchestrated layering of clicks and gulps and tweets that together is louder than the car’s engine. Over here. All society of nature calling out to each other, to itself. I’m over here.

  It’s beautiful. Even I can recognize the beauty of it. But as it goes on it becomes increasingly mechanical in my ears. A primitive, poorly lubricated machine producing some hard and common product, and soon all I can hear is noise.

  I turn off the car and step out onto the road, look down into the woods in the direction I know the lake to be but it’s not visible from here. The map showed that at this point the road wandered from the lake and left a wide margin of land between them, maybe a quarter-mile of exposed rock of a size only retreating glaciers could move. All things considered it would seem an impractical place for Tripp to stop: no cottages nearby to give rise to the concern of potential witnesses (even if anyone was up here at this time of year, which they apparently aren’t) and from this starting point the walk down to the water would be an unnecessarily prolonged pain in the ass. Why here? Did he come this far out of nervousness, choosing caution over convenience? Or was the nature hike part of the fun?

  Step onto the pulpy bed of pine needles and leaves which gives off the damp odor of living fibre turning into something else. Clouds of flying things enter at collar and sleeve only to explode from their own gluttony, leave dark smears over the backs of swatting hands. The going is slow. But despite the absence of any clear markings, the path is obvious. The gray rock faces shift to one side as I pass, the thorny branches arch high enough to let me through.

  When it finally comes the water takes me by surprise, a sudden leveling out that laps up to the rim of the rock I stand on. A foot below on either side is the marshy beach, which is less a beach than the meeting of earth, weeds and runoff the color of mustard left too long out of the fridge. There’s no way you could jump in without getting covered in it, without legs sinking into the softness of whatever collection of half-dissolved things it was that settled on the bottom. How could Tripp have deposited the girls here without having them float in the exact spot he’d left them? There wasn’t enough current in this place to shift a fallen branch six inches, let alone take two loads of 120-pound human being out to the middle. Did he get in there up to his armpits himself, swim out a bit to where it got deep? That would explain the first one maybe, but not the second waiting patiently on the rock for Tripp to paddle back and send her off the same way. And what if he had to carry them down—

  My thoughts are cut off by the idea of a sound just behind me. Turn, but there’s nothing there. A rush of blood past the eardrum. A lick of wind sounding as a whispered name.

  I jump off the rock and land funny on the pebbles below, the bolt of pain from a twisted ankle shooting up to my crotch. Then I’m rolling to the ground with both hands gripped around my sock while some woodland rodent chatters down at me from the network of trees overhead. Wait there on the poking stones for the throbbing to pass to the point that I can get to my feet. But there’s the voice again. Blown thin through the clacking branches. Not a name at all but the first call of alarm, startled and high.

  Lift myself as much with arms as legs and hop back up to the path. Wishing I could move a little faster but both the hill and my useless ankle hold me back. Although I know there’s nothing but the water cut off by the trees behind me I don’t turn around, keep my eyes on my feet stubbing over roots and stone, the wind now a distant laughter in the remaining leaves. By the time I reach the Lincoln and scrabble for the keys in my pocket I’m surprised by the choking tightness of my lungs.

  The road is too narrow to turn around so I’m forced to reverse to the first cottage driveway and on the way I scrape the passenger side past a fence-post that, with a sound like clicked fingers, neatly lops the mirror clean off the door. Watch it scuttle down into the ditch, sending back a glimpse of my own blanched face. Consider stopping to pick it up but my foot doesn’t move from the pedal. Add it to Mr. Tripp’s disbursements.

  It’s only on the main highway back into town that I check my watch. 11:42. Nearly two hours from start to finish.

  When I get back to the honeymoon suite I pull out a blank legal pad with the intention of taking down a physical description of the crime scene to help with cross-examination somewhere down the line. But nothing comes, and instead I find myself writing the heading SPECULATIVE HYPOTHESES at the top of the page and beneath it the following three theories:

  The first would suggest that Tripp is in fact a man possessing remarkable (however hidden) physical strengths as well as extraordinary patience in carrying out the transport and disposal of his victims.

  The second theory admits some degree of voluntariness on the part of the girls, who perhaps up until the final moments were under the impression that they were on a field trip out for an inspirational gazing over still waters.

  The third theory is that he had some help.

  NINE

  After a breakfast of toasted bagel discovered deep inside the pocket of my overcoat I head back up to the courthouse for my conference with a Mr. Goodwin, the Crown Attorney assigned to the trial. I’m feeling a little sluggish, having limited myself to only a single line of wake-up coke, but the fatigue seems to come from a different source. Since arriving in Murdoch my sleep has been degraded to a series of five-hour toss and turn marathons. Waking lacquered in sweat or balled-up in shivers, eyes opening at the imagined scrape of the window lifting open. A rattling breath joining my own in the dark room.

  I make a mental note to buy pills.

 
When I find Goodwin’s office I take a second before entering to finish a heaving yawn and guess at what sort of opponent I’m about to meet. “Never heard of him,” Graham had e-mailed back when I’d asked if Goodwin was a known quantity. “They assign the weird ones up there.”

  And he is weird, if being startlingly fat satisfies the definition. A peony-faced water retainer jammed behind a desk occupied by neatly arranged columns of documents. He’s still straightening them carefully from top to bottom when I come in, fingers rolling down their sides as if sculpting pottery on a wheel.

  “Hay-lo, you must be Bartholomew Crane. Pete Goodwin,” he says, his mouth sounding as though there’s something in it but there’s not, just his thick tongue banging up against the inside of his teeth.

  “Good morning, Mr. Goodwin,” I say, and try at a brisk smile. There’s a moment when a handshake is mutually considered, but because it would be a stretch for me to reach him across the broad desk and because his position there appears more or less permanent, I simply take a seat.

  “So, this is it?” I nod toward the fondled papers.

  “That’s right. Of course, you’ll have to review all the materials in whatever detail you deem fit, but I thought in the meantime I might provide you with a summary. The main highlights, as it were. By way of courtesy.”

  “Sure, yes. Courtesy. Give me your best shots.”

  Goodwin pushes his chair back and stands, revealing his full immensity. Panting a little, he takes a black marker from his jacket pocket and begins to make point notes on the white presentation board on the wall behind him. His mouth a puncture flapping out from the top of a hot air balloon.