Stalked lk-5

by Allison Brennan

Sean maneuvered through New York traffic like a native and merged onto a freeway.

  “It all connects here in New York,” Sean said. “I’m going to call Suzanne and find out where she is, fill her in on the news about Hans, and have her or her cop friend pull the files on Theissen.”

  “Be careful,” Lucy said.

  Sean took her hand. “You, too, princess.”

  *

  “What’s going on?” Suzanne demanded when she met Sean in front of the Webers’ narrow three-story town house on the Upper East Side. “You’re thirty minutes late, and you tell me to wait? Sunday is usually the only day off I get, and yet I was up at the butt crack of dawn to interview a suspect, then ordered to rush over here, only to be kept waiting by a friggin’ P.I.?”

  Sean smiled and handed her coffee. “Black and sweet, right?”

  She grabbed the coffee but didn’t return his smile. “Where’s Lucy?”

  “Headed back to Quantico.”

  “Why?”

  “It has to stay between you and me. Can’t even tell your boyfriend.”

  “DeLucca isn’t my boyfriend.”

  Sean coughed a laugh. “I was speaking metaphorically, but good to know.”

  She glared at him from under the brim of her Mets hat, all fire.

  “Hans Vigo had an accident yesterday. He’s in critical condition. Lucy was called back in, and my guess is that it wasn’t really an accident.”

  “Why are you still here?”

  “Hans asked me to find Peter McMahon. That’s what I’m doing.”

  “Back up-is this the Peter McMahon whose sister was murdered when he was a kid? The case Tony was so curious about?”

  “Four people involved in his sister’s investigation are dead under mysterious circumstances.”

  Her brow furrowed. “Four people? Who?”

  Sean ticked them off on his fingers. “Weber, Bob Stokes, Dominic Theissen, and Tony Presidio.” He explained the suspicious circumstances of Stokes’s and Theissen’s deaths and how they might not have been accidents, or natural.

  “McMahon has been completely off the grid for the last six years,” Sean said. “No death certificate, no Social Security number in use, nothing. FBI is going through their channels; I’m going through mine. I traced him to college at SU; then he seemed to just vanish.”

  “There has to be something else.”

  “Agent Presidio’s personal file on the McMahon investigation disappeared from his office the day he died. Something is going on, maybe it has nothing to do with Peter McMahon, but it’s not easy to go completely off the grid.”

  “So you’re thinking he’s targeting cops who worked his sister’s case because why?”

  “I don’t think anything at this point,” Sean said. “I’m just going to find him.”

  “And you think Bridget Weber knows something she didn’t tell me?” Suzanne sounded skeptical.

  “I think Rosemary Weber has a lot of files and information on the McMahon investigation that may shed light on these deaths.”

  “So you don’t think her murder has anything to do with the Cinderella Strangler case?”

  “We’re not going to know until the feds are done with their forensic investigation.” Sean walked up the steps to the front door. “Hopefully, there’ll be enough answers here to give us a clear direction.”

  Bridget Weber was five years younger than her sister, but judging by Rosemary’s author photo on her book, they had looked very much alike-blond hair, blue eyes, and deep dimples.

  “Thank you for agreeing to see us on such short notice,” Suzanne said.

  Bridget tried to smile but didn’t quite make it. “Do you have information about Rosie’s murder?”

  “We’re pursuing every possible lead,” Suzanne said. “We just have a few questions. Did your sister discuss her books or what she was working on with you?”

  “Sometimes. But I travel a lot for work, and when she’s in the middle of a project she’s very focused, doesn’t talk to anyone but her research assistant, if that.”

  Sean said, “Did you talk about her current project?”

  “The Cinderella Strangler? A little-she was excited about it. She said it had all the hallmarks of a bestseller.” Bridget paused, then said, a bit sheepishly, “Rosie’s first book was a big hit. None of her other books did as well as Sex, Lies, and Family Secrets. She was always looking for what she called a big, juicy story, and she thought this new one fit.”

  “Did she say why?” Sean asked.

  “Not specifically, but anyone could see that the case was alluring. Underground sex parties, drugs, prostitution-the backdrop was more interesting than the crimes themselves.”

  Sean was grateful Lucy wasn’t here. To Lucy, it was always the victims who mattered, not the trappings, and she would take issue with the sister’s description.

  Suzanne said, “When we were going over her calendar and notes, we noticed she had scheduled a meeting with a reporter, Rob Banker. Do you know him?”

  “Yes, he was one of Rosie’s closest friends.”

  “She canceled the meeting because she had a lead to follow. Did she tell you anything about it?”

  Bridget shook her head. “I didn’t see her before she left. I was out at dinner. I invited her to join me, but she thinks my friends are boring.” She smiled sadly. “She did mention she had a meeting, but I didn’t ask any details.”

  Sean said, “She dedicated her first book to a Newark police officer, Bob Stokes. Do you know him?”

  Bridget straightened in surprise. “Actually, I do. He was one of the officers she’d known when she was a reporter in Jersey. They were friendly. But she hadn’t talked to him in years until he came up here for the funeral of Dom Theissen. Dom was a friend of Rosie’s. They talked a lot. I thought there might be something romantic between them, but she never said anything. I know his accident hit her really hard.” Bridget began to look irritated. “I told all of this to the other FBI agent who came by.”

  “Who did you speak with?” Suzanne asked.

  “Agent Presidio. You brought him with you earlier. Don’t you remember?”

  “Yes, I just didn’t know he returned. What time did Agent Presidio visit you?”

  “Thursday, late afternoon. Nearly five. He was on his way to the airport, he said. Is something wrong?”

  “He died of a heart attack Thursday night,” Suzanne said. “We never got his report.”

  Bridget put her hand to her mouth. “Dear Lord. I’m sorry. He just had a couple questions, then asked to see the files in the attic again.”

  “Did he take anything with him?”

  “I don’t think so. If he did, he didn’t ask me.”

  “May we?” Suzanne gestured toward the stairs.

  Sean followed Suzanne up. “What time were you and Tony here?”

  “We left around three in the afternoon, went back to headquarters with Weber’s notes from the original McMahon investigation. They were in shorthand.”

  “What time did he leave?”

  “I don’t know. I left him with the analyst and worked on reports. I didn’t see him again.” Suzanne pulled out her phone. “I’ll find out.”

  Sean looked around the attic. Everything was well labeled. Suzanne walked over to a stack. “We only took the notepads that pertained to the missing files on the McMahon book. Tony had hoped an analyst could decipher Weber’s shorthand and it would give us an idea of what was in the stolen files.”

  “Why did he come back?” Sean walked slowly around. One of the boxes had a lid that was skewed. He looked at the label. It was from the year following the McMahon homicide, while Weber was still a reporter in Newark. “One of the notepads is missing,” he said. He opened the box and noticed that Weber had meticulous labels. The front of every pad was dated. She went through at least one notepad a week.

  “It’s the anniversary of Rachel McMahon’s murder that’s gone,” Sean said. “That’s three months after Kreig’s trial.�
��

  “Why didn’t he tell me?”

  “Maybe he planned to. We need to find out if he called anyone after he left here. And I’ll call Noah and find out if he had the missing notepad on him.”

  They went back downstairs and Sean remembered that Tony had asked Bridget Weber more questions.

  “Ms. Weber, when Agent Presidio returned, what did he ask you?”

  “He wanted to know if she thought someone was following her. Specifically, he asked me if she was being stalked. And one more thing-how far back she kept her fan mail.”

  “We took all her mail,” Suzanne said.

  “Yes, and I told him that. He wanted to know about when she was a reporter, before she wrote the McMahon book. I didn’t know, but I can’t imagine that she’d keep anything that long.”

  Suzanne and Sean thanked the sister for her time and walked out.

  Sean said, “Did you have any indication that Weber was being stalked?”

  Suzanne shook her head. “No police reports, no restraining orders, nothing in her e-mails or notes, but I have an analyst going through them in greater detail. But Tony said something earlier about her killer knowing everything about her. Her schedule, what she would do. He felt that her killer was confident she’d expose herself to him and not be scared.”

  “Did he say anything else to you when he left?”

  “Nothing. I left him with an analyst to go over the notes we found here. She just sent me a message that he left headquarters at four thirty, plenty of time to get back here by five.”

  “I’m going to pull the newspaper archives from that missing week and see what Weber wrote. Tony thought it was important enough to take her steno pad.”

  “He should have called me.” Suzanne was justifiably upset.

  “He didn’t know what he knew,” Sean mumbled. “It was a hunch. Suzanne, I need a favor.”

  She rubbed her temples. “I’m not going to like this, am I?”

  He grinned. “It’ll be easy. Really. I need the accident report and autopsy for Dominic Theissen.”

  “You think it wasn’t an accident.”

  “What I think and what I can prove are completely different, but yeah, I think it’s highly suspicious.”

  CHAPTER TWENTY-NINE

  Washington, D.C.

  Lucy was surprised to find Noah waiting for her when she exited the gate at Reagan National. “I was going to take a taxi,” she said.

  “I want to fill you in, and the best place is on the road.”

  Lucy had first met Special Agent Noah Armstrong eight months ago during one of his investigations. Though she’d disliked him at the beginning-considering he had questioned her as a suspect in a murder investigation-they’d ended up becoming friends and he’d taken her under his wing during her ten weeks as an analyst in the D.C. regional office. Surviving a plane crash in May had solidified their friendship.

  “How’s Hans? He’s going to be okay, right?”

  Noah put his hand on her shoulder. “Lucy, it’s serious. He’s been unconscious since Security found him early this morning.”

  Lucy nodded, but her chin trembled. She swallowed and asked, “What happened?”

  “We don’t know exactly. Can we walk and talk?”

  She nodded.

  He squeezed her arm and then walked briskly toward short-term parking.

  “Hans was working in Tony’s office late last night. He made arrangements to stay in one of the bungalows Quantico has for VIPs and temporary instructors. He signed out of the building just after midnight and crossed a construction area on his way to the house. A scaffold fell on him.”

  “It really was an accident?”

  “We’re supposed to believe it was an accident, and that’s what everyone will be told today. A scaffolding did collapse, but two things point to attempted murder. First, the structure of the scaffolding had been compromised. The lab is testing the metal, but it appears that an acid ate away at the base and all it would have taken was a light push to make the whole thing come down.”

  “And that’s not a construction mistake?”

  “It could have been, but the project manager has been working with Forensics all morning to account for the weakness, and he swears it wasn’t his team. We don’t know what the chemical is yet, but there are a lot of common products that could be mixed to eat through the metal. The second piece of evidence is that the security camera outside of the armory caught a shadow. No face, but there was definitely a person moving away from where Hans was attacked at approximately the same time. Where he was attacked is outside the camera’s range.”

  They arrived at Noah’s sedan and he opened the passenger door for Lucy, then closed it and walked around to the driver’s side and started the car. Lucy blinked back tears and looked out the window as Noah drove out of airport parking.

  “I’m sorry, Lucy. Hans is a good friend to both of us.”

  Lucy wished she hadn’t gotten so angry with Hans yesterday. He’d been such a loyal friend and mentor-his betrayal in pulling strings to get her in the Academy was done out of his belief in her. He did it for the right reasons; she should have forgiven him yesterday.

  “Lucy?”

  “I’m okay,” she said quickly.

  “I know this is hard on you.”

  “He has to wake up, Noah.”

  Noah glanced at her and Lucy thought he was going to say something, concern clouding his eyes. Then he didn’t and looked at the road. A minute later he said, “Hans talked to Assistant Director Stockton yesterday about looking into the death of Tony Presidio. The lab came in yesterday and collected potential evidence, including Agent Presidio’s bottle of Scotch.”

  “It had been on his desk when I found him. His BAC was elevated.”

  “There are some discrepancies in the autopsy and his body is being sent to our lab to be reautopsied, and an extensive toxicology panel has been ordered. There are some drug interactions that may have caused an elevated BAC. They’re also specifically checking for legal and illegal drugs that may cause cardiac arrest.”

  “You think Tony was murdered.” Lucy shifted in her seat and stared at Noah. “I told Hans on Friday that it seemed suspicious that Tony died and all the McMahon files were gone.”

  “Hans contacted the lab after he talked to you, then called Rick Stockton and opened a classified investigation into Tony’s death. You, me, and Chief O’Neal are the only three people at Quantico who know about this investigation. And Kate-Hans told her last night, but she’s not taking an active investigatory role. Everyone else will be told that Tony died of natural causes, case closed, and that Hans had an accident when he cut through a poorly marked construction site.”

  “Someone we know did this?”

  “If Tony was killed at Quantico and not poisoned earlier, and since Hans was attacked on campus, the person responsible is either staff or someone from your class. Chief O’Neal is investigating the staff.” He glanced at her. “You and I are investigating Class Twelve-Fourteen.”

  “My class? There are three new-agent classes here.”

  “Class Twelve-Thirteen spent the weekend with DEA trainees on joint border and jurisdictional situations, and Class Twelve-Twelve was on survival weekend.”

  “Survival weekend is still within Quantico boundaries.”

  “I have someone verifying that all class members were accounted for-it’s possible, though unlikely, that someone could have slipped away. Everyone is paired up and between the survival grounds and campus is an active Marine training zone. Off-limits, well marked, and extremely dangerous to traverse. In addition, someone had to be following Hans to know when he left the building, or waiting in the construction area knowing that was the path he would take to his temporary housing.”

  Noah paused to merge onto the highway, then continued, “I have a list of everyone who was signed in, but as you know, there are ways to get on campus without signing in, or signing in later than you arrive. I pulled all records from the
main gate. Those will be harder to fudge because they’re maintained by the Marine base. But we need to consider everyone a suspect.” He glanced at her. “Are you okay with this?”

  She nodded, but she didn’t feel okay.

  “Lucy, talk to me. Once we get on campus we’re not going to be having this conversation.”

  “Essentially, you’re telling me that someone I know and trust killed Tony and attempted to kill Hans.”

  “It’s not going to be easy, but I need you at the top of your game.”

  “I know.” She took a deep breath. “I’ll be okay.” Would she? Could she look at her friends in the same way, knowing that one of them was a killer? One of them had manipulated her? Lucy always felt she was a good judge of character-and one reason she had so few friends was because she had a hard time trusting people. But here she had felt a bond instantly with her fellow new agents, a kinship because they were all in the same place-physically, professionally. And she liked them.

  Noah said, “Fill me in on everything you know, and we’ll go from there. Start with Dominic Theissen. Hans told Stockton last night that he wanted to look at his accident.”

  The comfort in reciting facts calmed Lucy and turned her mind from Hans to the job.

  “Theissen got in the middle of a fight at a subway station in Queens and was pushed onto the tracks. The police ruled that it was involuntary manslaughter. Sean and Agent Suzanne Madeaux in the New York office are pulling the files on it.”

  “And Theissen was the media officer during the McMahon investigation.”

  “Correct. And he was friends with Rosemary Weber. Bob Stokes was a Newark cop when Rachel McMahon went missing, and Weber’s main contact for her book, in addition to Theissen.”

  “While you were flying, Sean said Stokes came to talk to Weber after Theissen’s funeral. He died of a heart attack the next day.”

  “Sean doesn’t think it’s a coincidence and neither do I. But to poison someone means that the victim trusted the killer, or the killer knew the victim’s routine well enough to slip poison into their food or drink.”

  Lucy continued, “We also don’t know whether Rosemary Weber’s murder was linked-it’s the odd crime. Theissen was ruled an accident, Stokes and Tony natural causes, why was Weber stabbed to death in an obvious homicide? In addition, poison is a predominantly female method of killing, while stabbing is male. There are exceptions, but few. Under any other circumstances I’d think they were unconnected, but the four individuals are linked by only one event.”