The Indigo Girl

by Natasha Boyd

  The insult rolled off me. “You are being paid to be here for a specific purpose, and I do not want another year to close out without you having a chance to show me your expertise in indigo-making. But alas, pestilence has forced me to be patient. Next season can’t come soon enough. And I’m sure a man with your considerable talent won’t let it fail again.” I was certainly counting on his pride.

  The next question was, how would I keep Cromwell busy until we could sow again? “Let us go and speak to Quash about the plans to build all the production facilities so we can be prepared for our next harvest.”

  “Lead on,” said Cromwell stiffly.

  Over the next few months, Cromwell began to take the boat into Charles Town. As winter came, he stayed away more and more frequently. Sometimes he took Ben, and on those days sleep eluded me almost entirely. And I’d be up hours before dawn, checking our oaks and walking the property.

  I knew Cromwell was probably losing his shirt in gambling dens or frequenting unmentionable houses. But what was Ben doing when he went with Cromwell? The same? My stomach clenched tightly at the slightest thought.

  I had taken to joining Ben and Quash every moment I could when he was at Wappoo and finding excuses to ask as many questions of Ben as I could creatively summon. I probably drove him crazier than I had as a girl. Luckily, he and Quash worked closely together, Ben making himself useful before the next indigo season, and they seemed to have become good friends. And so, it was easier to hide my inclination to spend time near him since there were always plantation matters to discuss with Quash.

  Of course, nothing fooled Mama.

  Somehow, even though Ben rarely spoke to me, it was obviously clear to my mother that when I was out in the fields, I revolved around Ben like the Earth around the sun. And worse, it obviously didn’t much concern me who cared to notice.

  Weeks where we went to town for business and social functions were distractedly endured by me as I counted the moments until we could return to Wappoo. Only staying at the Pinckneys’, where I experienced Mr. Pinckney’s enthusiasm for my ventures, could come close to the pure happiness I felt when I was about the land.

  Mother had obviously inked an extremely concerned letter to Papa, for I received a cautionary letter from him a month later. He reminded me of my duty “as his surrogate,” and how my brother George’s legacy “rested in my hands,” and lastly, but by no means least, that any impropriety would demolish any hopes we had of a social standing in Charles Town or of finding me a husband “when the time came.”

  Incensed upon receiving it, I hastily worded a strong letter back to him.

  To the Honorable Colonel Lucas,

  Father,

  You are so good to say you have too great an opinion of my prudence to think I would entertain an indiscreet passion for anyone, and I hope heaven will always direct me that I may never disappoint you.

  What indeed could induce me to make a secret of my inclination to my best friend? As I am well aware you would not disapprove it to make me a sacrifice to wealth, and I am as certain I would indulge no passion that had not your approbation.

  Your most dutiful and affectionate daughter,

  E. Lucas

  “Quashy?” I asked one morning the following spring as he and I headed to check on several projects I’d asked him to set into motion. Togo had just given us the bad news that our lucerne grass was not thriving. And my mood was melancholic which somehow managed to weaken my resolve not to think about Ben. “How is …” My voice cracked and I cleared it. “How is Ben settling in?”

  “Fine, Miz Lucas. Jus’ fine.”

  “Only …” We’d made our way past the dwellings and headed down the dirt path to the cattle fields. “Do you think … well, does Mr. Cromwell treat him well? And the others?” I added hastily. “I want to know what kind of master he is.”

  I mashed my lips together.

  “He’s fine, Miz Lucas. Jus’ fine.”

  Losing my nerve to ask more, I changed tack. “And how is Sarah doing? I haven’t seen her much at the house.” In fact, I’d thought about her a lot over the winter. Her being right next door to Ben.

  “Fine, Miz Lucas.”

  Sighing in exasperation, I put my hands on my hips and came to a stop. “Are you going to say that about everything?”

  Quash’s mouth twitched. “Yes, Miz Lucas.”

  “Well, Quash. That’s of no use to me, now is it?” I turned back to the path and strode on, deciding to leave the subject of Ben alone again. “Tell me,” I tossed over my shoulder, “did Cromwell show you the plans for finishing the production facilities?”

  Quash didn’t answer, and I paused to look back at him. He’d stopped and folded his arms over his chest. His light brown skin furrowed upon his brow. Scratching his chin, he looked around.

  “Well? Did he?”

  Quash nodded.

  “And?”

  Quash stayed silent.

  I walked back to him. “What is it, Quash? If you don’t understand the instructions, perhaps you can ask Ben. You two seem to get along. And of course he should know all about the facilities required.” In fact, as I spoke, it seemed odd that Quash had not sought Ben to fix whatever roadblock he’d run into. I frowned and waited for Quash to answer me.

  He bowed his head as if he struggled mightily with what he was about to say, then he looked up, his face a myriad of confusion, hurt, and also hopefulness. “How come Ben done able to read?” he asked.

  My sleep had become increasingly fitful since the day Quash had asked me why Ben knew how to read. My dreams were even more vivid than they had been in the past.

  One night, memories from childhood seemed to flitter in and amongst my imagination so that every time I awoke as the night wore on, I wondered what was true and what was not.

  We stand in the shadow of a lean-to, the fronds of jungle palms slapping against the wood, the sound of birds cawing.

  “Un mystère por un mystère,” Ben says, his wide mouth quirking with mischief. I’ve never heard Ben speak true French.

  Ben at eleven years of age is very tall. His features are angular, almost European except that his skin is dark as charred coffee.

  “It’s no mystery,” I say importantly. “They’re just letters.”

  Then Ben is older. More serious. We are outside though it is nighttime now. I feel nervous, my palms sweaty, and I glance back toward the still house almost invisible against the sky. I’m not supposed to be out here.

  “You are daylight, I am night,” Ben whispers.

  We are sitting side by side.

  “Your eyes are rivers,” I respond, joining him in our game. We have read poetry with a small flame as our light, and now we play with words to find different ways to say normal things.

  “Like mud?”

  I laugh nervously.

  “Yours are green stones,” he says.

  “Emeralds? My eyes can hardly be compared to fancy emeralds.”

  “It is true, I have no use for fancy stones,” Ben says, his voice low, confusing me with what he means by that. As if he had need for my eyes otherwise.

  “I am uncomfortable with your words,” I whisper.

  “We sit en secret.” He slips into the French nuance his grandmother uses when she speaks. “And the color of your eyes makes you uncomfortable?”

  I swallow. My heart flutters against my ribs. “Not the color of my eyes … The way you see my eyes.”

  Ben studies me intently. I can see the reflection of our small flame dancing in the dark of his irises. “I see the eyes of a woman no one will ever forget.”

  I suck in a breath. “I’m hardly a woman. I’m but a girl.”

  “It’s no matter. I see what I see.”

  “The future, you mean? Is that part of the gift of your eyes? That you can ‘see’ like your grandmot
her?”

  He shakes his head and after a long pause where conflicting thoughts seem to pass over his face like clouds, he finally opens his mouth. “Today is my day to say goodbye.”

  “Why?” I frown at his words.

  “You are going away. Far away. To the place they will never forget you.”

  “I am most certainly not.” I’d only come back from England recently. There were no plans to leave Antigua.

  He shakes his head patiently. “I will see you again.”

  “What are you talking about?”

  “One day you will need my help. And I will come.” He shrugs. Then he lifts two fingers and lays them against the small leather pouch at his chest.

  “Benoit Fortuné, you are the most peculiar boy. Of course, you’ll see me again. You’ll see me tomorrow.”

  I woke with a start, my heart pounding, my throat parched. Replaying my strange dream, I knew that beyond he and I reading a few poems together he’d found difficult to understand, the entire conversation in my dream was definitely not from a memory. Yet, I still held the nervousness within my belly and remembered the intense look in Ben’s eyes.

  Sitting up, I swung my legs over the bed. A glance to the window told me it was time to get up anyway. I was relieved.

  As soon as I was dressed, I went over my list of chores, writing in new ones and prioritizing others. Then I crept downstairs and out of the front door, into the dim breaking daylight. I breathed in the fresh salted air of Wappoo Creek that was mingled with sweet yellow jasmine and made my way toward the indigo fields. I checked the small green shoots incessantly to make sure they were pestilence-free.

  Movement at the dwellings caught my eye. Someone had already been up and stoked the large cooking fire. The smoke curled up, becoming invisible against the gray sky. I stopped and discerned the tall, proud form of Sarah quietly making her way into her cabin. She slipped inside without a sound.

  For a moment, I thought perhaps I’d imagined it. I mashed my lips together as I contemplated where she had been. And, I knew without a doubt where she had been. Next door.

  I hadn’t had breakfast, but my belly didn’t feel empty. It felt as though I’d partaken of a hearty helping of coarsely ground oyster shells.

  I headed toward Ben’s cabin before I could change my mind.

  The door opened, and the fleeting expression that crossed Ben’s face was one of minor surprise. As if he was expecting someone else and got me. Not as if he didn’t expect me at all. I took it as an encouraging sign, but I was so nervous my pulse pounded in my throat, making it hard to swallow. Or talk.

  Ben, bare-chested, held a wet rag in one hand. The bitter smell of lye soap perfumed with myrtle mixed with the salty smell of fresh sweat and musk.

  I’d interrupted his morning ablutions.

  Moments passed in silence. His face was so familiar, yet so much a stranger’s.

  A small pouch on a thread of leather rested against his breastbone, and I felt a jolt of recognition upon seeing it.

  He stepped back to allow me room to enter.

  The gesture, shocking, turned my feet to stone, heavy upon the earth.

  “I’ll be out,” he said when I didn’t move.

  The door closed in my face.

  I let out a breath and crunched over dead leaves and pine needles, settling on a fallen log.

  He came outside a few minutes later and took a seat at the other end of the branch. He rested his elbows on his knees, hands hanging between his legs.

  My cheeks felt warm, despite the cold morning air. The image of Sarah hurrying into her cabin assailed me again.

  I should leave well alone. Sarah deserved happiness. Ben deserved more even than that. “I saw her.” I wanted to bite my tongue off for bringing it up.

  He looked at me. I could tell he wanted to ask what I meant. The terrible part about his habit of not talking to me, combined with his propensity to only speak when answering a question, was it resulted in this silent torture. He was slave and I was master.

  “I saw her leaving here.” I swallowed. “Sarah.”

  Mortified that I’d brought attention to my confused reaction upon seeing her, I snapped my mouth closed before I said anything else inappropriate.

  It was none of my business. He ignored my statement, pulling his small knife and a piece of wood from his pocket.

  God above, there was so much I wanted to ask. Why are you angry with me? Do you miss our friendship, or am I the only one? How’s your grandmother? Except, I didn’t want to ask that. He didn’t know how his grandmother was. How could he know when he’d been sold to another island? Separated from her. Families were routinely separated and sold and they never saw each other again. It was something I wanted to avoid here at Wappoo. I’d made Sarah that promise.

  Sarah.

  Sarah who’d watched my movements around Ben with an eye that crawled over my skin.

  “Is that the same pouch your grandmother made for you?” I asked, indicating the talisman that hung from his neck. A brief flash of the day I began to teach him letters crossed my mind. Ben sprinkling a pinch of dirt from the ground upon which we’d stood into the little leather pouch at his neck.

  Ben nodded.

  “Did—did you know where Cromwell was bringing you?” I’d been unaware this question was something I needed answered until the moment it left my mouth.

  Ben glanced to the side. “Yes.” He nodded once and sighed.

  “I mean to me. Not just South Carolina.”

  “Yes,” he repeated. “He is here because of me.”

  “How?” I stuttered in surprise. “How did you know?”

  “You need my help,” he said and slid his blade against the wood in his left hand.

  The eerie similarity to what he’d told me in my dream sent a chill through me. I held my hand up in front of my face to make sure this too was not a dream.

  It looked and felt real.

  “I do need your help, but you won’t talk to me. And Cromwell is a pompous bully. And … and I want my friend back. I miss you.”

  Ben snorted with derision and the heat in my cheeks flared, my stomach feeling nauseous.

  “Why you not teach Quash to read?” he answered me with a question of his own, his chin tilting up in challenge. “Or the chil’ren?”

  His question took me by surprise. “I—”

  Quash’s question had been on my mind constantly though, which had probably been the instigation behind my strange dreams.

  I’d waited impatiently for Ben to come back from wherever it was he’d disappeared to with Cromwell the last few days. To ask his advice? To ask him to help Quash finish the indigo-processing facilities? To ask him why he’d told Quash he could read?

  I got to my feet, pacing back and forth. “I—it was different when it was you and I. It was different there. I was young. There are rules. And laws. I—”

  Ben stood and took a step toward me, bestowing more eye contact upon me in moments than he had collectively since he’d arrived. “Lâche.” He hissed. “You a coward.”

  Blood seemed to drain from my head, and I sucked in a sharp breath. “How dare you.”

  He raised an eyebrow. “Why you teach me? To anger your mother? Maybe it was a game? You change my life. You no do the same for Quash?”

  I couldn’t believe I was being spoken to this way.

  And yet I could.

  This was Ben.

  The lines of white and Negro, servant and master didn’t seem to exist here between us.

  “Do you want indigo?” he asked.

  “Yes,” I whispered.

  “Why?”

  “I—” I put my hand upon my throat as if I could control what came out of it. My pulse fluttered wildly beneath my fingertips. How could I explain my selfish need to succeed and yet ask him to h
elp me in the same moment?

  This wouldn’t make him rich. Or Quashy. I wondered if Cromwell would ever free him. What incentive did Ben have to succeed here with me?

  “Why—” He grabbed the pouch against his chest as if seeking strength from it. His eyes closed briefly, his nostrils flaring. “It is a gift. Why do you deserve it?”

  “Does Cromwell deserve it?” I shot back.

  “No,” he said firmly, a snarl to his full lips. “But Crom’all, he holds my future. My freedom.”

  I took a step closer. Closer than propriety should allow. And I had the bizarre urge to press my lips to his, to soothe the twisted anger I saw there.

  Ben’s eyes flared. Perhaps with alarm.

  The instinct to look around for observers was strong, yet I held his eyes and reached out a hand to rest on his forearm. My fingers landed on his warm skin and I inhaled involuntarily, shocked at myself. Yet determined. “Benoit Fortuné,” I said softly and watched his eyes flicker at my use of his childhood nickname. “Someone else may control your future.” My hand squeezed his sinewy forearm. “But you control mine. You just said you are here to help me. So help me. Please. I’ll do what I can for Quash and the children here. But please.”

  We stood that way for long moments. Then he shook my hand off his arm and stepped back. Chilled air moved between us and he swung around and went back into his cabin, closing the door on me for the second time. I would have been incensed or disappointed, but I’d seen the acceptance on his face. His barely perceptible nod.

  He’d agreed.

  Now how was I to keep my end of the bargain?

  “I need your counsel, Mr. Pinckney,” I said quietly, sitting on the very edge of a pink damask-covered club chair in the Pinckneys’ library at Belmont.

  Mama, Polly, and I had been graciously invited to their country estate for a summer house party that included several families from the surrounding area. I still got along famously with Miss Bartlett, the Pinckneys’ niece, on the occasions we saw each other. She’d turned out to be intrigued rather than horrified by my role on my father’s estates. It made a refreshing change from most of genteel society. My reputation had apparently preceded me, certainly made more newsworthy since the Laurens incident. It was valiant on the part of Mr. and Mrs. Pinckney to continue to include me among their social set.