The Choice

by Shayla Black

  “Brace yourself. She’ll set your damn taste buds on fire,” Seth growled.

  For an unguarded moment, jealousy knifed Beck. He forced himself to yank out the blade. No more putting this petty shit above her. It wasn’t a competition. There were no winners or losers. Time to exercise the same sage acceptance Seth had shown earlier so they could shower Heavenly with the passion and love she deserved.

  “Wait until you feel her pretty mouth wrapped around your cock,” he drawled without an ounce of malice.

  “Beck!” She gaped in embarrassment.

  “What?” He opened her wider and glided his palms up her thighs. “It’s the truth. You’ve got a sinful tongue.”

  “Yeah?” Seth grinned. “I want that. I want that now.”

  God, the million things they could show her… The epic pleasure they could give her… The many ways they could twist her body—and her mind…

  If she’d stay long enough to let them.

  Beck refused to let worry creep in. Heavenly might have turned his life upside down, stolen his heart—then given him zero hope for the future—but he had to believe after tonight that she would want more. The wonder and awe lighting up her face were too bright to be snuffed so quickly.

  Beck cleared his mind and focused on Heavenly spread out before him. Vaguely, he noticed Seth stacking pillows under her head before he aligned his cock against her mouth. She blinked up at him, uncertainty lining her face, before she bravely parted her lips.

  The memory of her mouth surged through Beck. His blood thundered. Demand roared.

  He focused on Heavenly’s pouty, glistening folds, feeling like a kid on Christmas morning opening the special present he’d pinned all his hopes and dreams on. Inhaling her deeply, he filled his lungs with her thick, heady scent. Then he gripped her hips and lifted her to his mouth.

  Beck trailed his tongue up the inside of her thigh, laving a shimmering path to her golden curls. Heavenly writhed, restless and seeking, as he parted her with his thumbs. Her juices seeped like warm syrup.

  He couldn’t wait. He swiped his tongue through her slit. Her tart essence made his taste buds sing. His body hummed. His cock wept. And his heart soared at the sheer perfection of his first taste of Heavenly.

  With a growl, he latched onto her mound and began tongue-fucking her narrow, satiny walls without mercy. Her muffled cries and her undulating hips urged him to drive her higher.

  “You look so fucking hot, angel,” Seth groaned. “And your mouth feels insane.”

  Beck’s cock pulsed impatiently against the sheet as he stared between her splayed thighs, watching Seth glide between her parted lips. The man fisted her hair as he shuttled in and out of her mouth. Heavenly looked beyond beautiful drinking in Seth’s benevolent approval.

  Determined to wring even more pleasure from her, he slid one finger inside her clutching walls and sucked her sensitive clit. When he pressed another finger inside her, she tensed, arched. The sounds of her muted suffering lit him up like a bonfire.

  Twisting his fingers inside her sweltering core, he dragged them over the sensitive patch of nerves behind her clit. She bucked against his mouth again as a fresh torrent of liquid flooded his tongue.

  Seth cursed and sucked in a hiss. “Angel. Christ…”

  “Oh, my gosh,” she panted in sweet desperation as she laved Seth’s thick crest. “I love tasting you but…Beck. H-he’s doing things, and I need…”

  “You want to come for us?” Seth taunted as he plucked her nipple.

  “Y-yes.”

  Her breathless reply was all the incentive Beck needed. He lashed her clit with his tongue while his fingertips toyed with the hyperaware spot inside her. Heavenly tensed. Her panting moans escalated into keening cries.

  Heavenly was seconds from breaking into a million pieces.

  “Give it to us,” Seth insisted. “Come now!”

  At his command, Heavenly’s body bucked. She bore down and screamed. Beck felt her spasm, her hips jerk as she tossed back her head and splintered. He took her higher, circling her clit with his tongue and sliding his fingers through her fluttering pussy.

  God, she was beautiful. Priceless. And right here, right now…she was theirs.

  When climax released its grip on her, Beck stared into her smoldering, unfocused eyes. A fine sheen of sweat made her flushed skin glow. She whimpered, struggled to catch her breath again…and left him spellbound.

  Seth dropped onto the bed next to her and stole her mouth in a long, passionate kiss.

  Beck watched as he eased from her pussy. “Amazing, little girl.”

  Heavenly ended the kiss and cupped Beck’s face with a sated smile. “That felt…incredible, way better than anything I can give myself.” She blushed. “Even stronger than the orgasm you gave me at Angelo’s.”

  “We can give you more, angel. First, we’ll have to prepare you to take us both.”

  “Y-you’re both going to be inside me…together? At the same time?”

  Seth picked up the tube of lube Beck had left on the nightstand. “We’ll take it as slow as you need. If, for any reason, you want us to stop, say the word.”

  Heavenly darted a glance between them, seeking, searching their faces. Then she nodded and lay back, exposing herself entirely to them. “Do whatever you need.”

  Her solemn show of trust undid him. Beck had to get inside her now.

  He stood and held out his hand toward Seth for the lube.

  Cooper shook his head and held out a condom instead. “I got this. You do the honors.”

  Beck stared at the little square foil in Seth’s palm, his heart revving, his mind racing. Sweat beaded his brow. Sure, he’d fantasized about this over and over, but…

  I don’t do virgins!

  Images of a different innocent girl from another lifetime assaulted his brain. The haunting apparition gripped his soul with icy fingers. He closed his eyes and tried to shove the memories away, focus on the moment. On Heavenly alone. If he wanted to make her his, this was the only way.

  He swallowed. His hand shook as he reached for the condom. “You’re sure?”

  “Yeah. Are you okay with that?” Seth’s brows furrowed in concern.

  Of course the PI was too observant not to have noticed his hesitation. He’d no doubt ask questions later. Fuck.

  Heavenly cupped his cheek, worry lining her face. “Beck, is everything—”

  “All right?” He dragged in a breath, wiring his shit tight again. “No, little girl. Everything is perfect.”

  Then he brushed his mouth over hers before sinking past her swollen lips and savoring her.

  He was going to take her virginity. Holy shit. The day he’d met her, he’d thought fleetingly that he’d break his rules to have her. He’d had no idea then that he’d be forced to shatter the one he’d held most sacred for two decades.

  She smiled up at him as she wrapped her arms around his neck. Beck clutched her tight as he rolled onto his side in a tangle of arms and legs, dragging her with him.

  The cap on the tube of lube opened with a pop. Seth wasn’t wasting any time.

  Beck didn’t, either. He deepened the kiss, their tongues tangling as he slid his fingers between her warm thighs. Her saturated curls coated his digits as he penetrated her and thumbed her clit. Beck swallowed her erotic mewls as Seth worked to thin the rigid rim of her backside.

  “Christ, she’s so damn tight,” Cooper growled.

  The moment Seth worked a finger inside their girl, Beck felt him behind her vaginal wall. He absorbed every gasp and shudder and play of pleasure across her face. He strummed her clit and teased her G-spot, revving her…but he never let her sail over the edge.

  Finally, Seth squeezed in a second finger. A tremor skittered through Heavenly. Her eyes grew unfocused. A wail rolled off her tongue. Beck smiled as Seth added more lube and quickly inserted a third finger.

  “Relax and let him in.” Beck held her quivering body and peppered her with kisses. “Once y
ou do, we’ll fill you with every burning, aching inch of our cocks. Then we’ll all go up in flames.”

  Heavenly gave him a little nod as she rocked her hips between them. Her brows knit and the lush bow of her lips pursed as she processed the sensations he and Seth heaped on her. Beck let her set the tempo, unwilling to jerk her from the euphoria consuming her as Seth started seesawing his fingers back and forth. She dug her nails into his arms. Her soft, kitten-like mewls became pitiful moans.

  She was going to come apart again.

  For Beck, watching Heavenly was like watching a butterfly break free of its chrysalis. She was emerging more gorgeous than he’d imagined.

  “Just one last finger to work inside you,” Seth cooed.

  “It burns.” Her breathy voice shook. “It’s so…”

  “Good?” Beck snarled.

  “Oh…” Her lashes fluttered shut. “So good.”

  “Can you imagine what it will feel like when we both squeeze our cocks inside you?”

  “N-no. But I want to… I need… Oh. Please…”

  “Ready to come again?” Seth asked, sweat dripping down his face.

  Heavenly lifted her heavy lids as if trying to focus. “Y-yes. The fire…it’s so hot. Overwhelming. I can’t stop…”

  Beck glanced Seth’s way. He nodded.

  The interminable wait was nearly over.

  As he eased his fingers from Heavenly’s pussy, she let out a frustrated howl.

  With his teeth, Beck tore open the condom and dragged the latex over his pulsing shaft. He refused to think about the fact that he was violating the one tenet he’d always thought sacrosanct and merely thought about hearing her screams of ecstasy thundering through his ears.

  The sound of ripping foil told him Seth was gloving up as well.

  Then within seconds, they were again on the same page without exchanging a word, both driving their fingers into her body once more. Through her thin membrane, he brushed knuckles with Seth. Together, they drove her to the edge. Heavenly’s high-pitched cries echoed off the walls and filled the air while she ground herself against their thrusting fingers.

  “That’s it, little girl,” Beck growled. “Come!”

  Heavenly screamed as rapture ripped through her. She clamped down, her walls fist tight and crushing his fingers. The sight of her squirming between them punched Beck in the chest.

  “We need to move now, man,” Seth barked, jerking his fingers from her virgin backside.

  Digits still locked in place, Beck rolled her to her back. Ecstasy made her eyes glassy. Bliss transformed her face.

  Beck had never seen any woman wear pleasure so absolutely and purely in all his life.

  Swallowing hard, he hovered above her and kneed her thighs apart, then eased his fingers from her body and aligned his crest to her sweltering, still-pulsing opening.

  It was time.

  A lump of emotion clogged his throat. Tears stung the backs of his eyes.

  He threaded his fingers through Heavenly’s and dragged her arms above her head. She lifted her heavy lids and met his stare. She knew what he was about to do. Beck saw no hesitation or fear, just trust glowing from her blue eyes as she lay her soul wide open, somehow wrapping her entire being around his heart.

  He loved her.

  Beck couldn’t explain or contain it. It just…was. And somehow he already knew that whatever happened next wouldn’t be like any sex he’d ever had. He’d had an inkling once that if he ever fucked this girl, it would wreck him. He’d been right. She was going to both destroy and rebuild him in ways he couldn’t fathom.

  Locking his gaze to hers, he pressed his wide crest against her narrow folds. Heat crawled up his body. He shuddered with sensation. Jesus, he hadn’t entered her yet, and she was already undoing him.

  Beck dug for patience. Sweat ran from his temples. His arms trembled as he held himself above and slowly began to inch in.

  Quickly, he reached her fragile barrier and paused, breath hot and harsh. As he gazed into her eyes, the gravity of the moment slammed him.

  “Please,” she begged with a beseeching stare.

  Then she surged up and pressed her mouth to his, imploring him with her breath and her lips and every fiber of her being. How could he refuse her?

  Clenching his jaw, Beck eased back, stared into her eyes, then plunged forward—and tore through her innocence.

  The air rushed from their lungs. She tensed and panted rapidly, squeezing her eyes shut. Slowly, he tunneled deeper, watching pleasure and pain tangle on her face.

  He was finally, completely inside her.

  Though his cock was strangling inside her gripping heat, he remained unmoving, letting her adjust. Torturous seconds ticked by like hours. “Talk to me. Please tell me you’re okay.”

  Academically, he knew he may have caused her something between discomfort and pain. But goddamn it, he needed her to be all right, to want him as deep inside her as he could get.

  Finally, she opened her eyes and met his stare. Her pink tongue swept across her parted lips. Then she sent him a blinding, lazy smile. “I’m…wonderful. More?”

  Seth released Heavenly and crawled onto the mattress beside her, breath held. Anticipation zipped up his spine as he watched the moment Beck rolled his hips and claimed her virginity. The air left Seth’s lungs in a rush. Pleasure-pain rippled across her flushed face as she trembled, trying to adjust to the thick cock stretching her tiny pussy.

  Fuck, he couldn’t take his eyes off her. Seeing her cross into womanhood left him speechless.

  Heavenly’s breathless, raspy groan seeped under his skin, scored his flesh. His cock was on fire. The urge to drive deep and bestow on her every delicious, dirty, deviant pleasure he could think of deluged him. Seth already knew that once he got inside her, he wouldn’t stop until she could feel him—feel them—all the way to her fucking soul.

  “Talk to me.” Beck’s low demand filled the room. “Please tell me you’re okay.”

  Her lashes fluttered lazily and opened. “I’m…wonderful. More?”

  “As much as you can take,” Seth rumbled.

  She sent him a come-hither smile that shocked the hell out of him—and killed his patience.

  “Get her in position. I can’t wait.” He grabbed the lube and slicked a layer over his cock.

  “You got it.” Beck rolled to his back, dragging Heavenly on top of him, his shaft still buried inside her as her slender legs straddled his hips.

  Surprise skittered over her glowing face at the new sensations. Her mouth fell open. Then she wriggled on the doctor’s dick with a gasp and a sigh, hands braced on his shoulders, as she sank impossibly deeper.

  Her body undulated. Her back bowed. Her pale hair spilled down, draping over Beck’s thighs. Even though he’d ten times rather be fucking her, too, Seth almost hated to stop watching.

  Heavenly shocked him again when she opened her eyes and sent him an unfocused stare. “I’m ready.”

  Shit, had there been a vixen sleeping inside their virgin?

  “Oh, angel… It’s so on.”

  Seth raced to the foot of the bed and knelt on the mattress between Beck’s legs. Wrapping an arm beneath her breasts, he pulled her against him, gratified when she melded herself to his chest.

  Impatience rode Seth as he nipped at her ear and notched his cock against her ass, sliding his hard length back and forth between her plump cheeks. Heavenly moaned and rolled her hips back at him.

  “You’re fucking turning me on,” he grunted as he gripped her and rubbed his skin—his scent—all over her.

  “Me, too,” Beck chimed in, his big hands engulfing her small waist. “Jesus… Hurry, Cooper.”

  Seth gave a sharp nod, but he was distracted by Heavenly swaying and surging against his dick. Goddamn it…

  He jerked her against him even tighter, dragging her over the aching head and sensitive column. He dug his fingers deeper, knowing he’d leave bruises. The worry didn’t stop him from straining fo
r more, tendons popping in his neck, face contorting as he found a deliberate, demanding rhythm.

  “She’s so fucking tight,” Beck bit out.

  Seth was desperate to feel her for himself.

  With an animal moan, he plowed his fist in her hair and tugged her face to his, gaze delving into her smoldering blue eyes. She panted, full of hunger, lips parting. The girl’s half-lidded stare was fixed on his mouth.

  Yeah, he wasn’t refusing that invitation.

  Seth devoured her lips, swallowing her raw cries. He cupped her breast, captured her beaded nipple, twisted and squeezed. She surged into his hand, into his kiss with a keening wail. He did the same to the other, torturing the bud until she whimpered and quivered and melted under his touch. He soaked in every one of her incoherent pleas. Oh, she was going to be a thrill to bend to his will.

  He could hardly wait.

  Peeling his mouth from hers, he scraped his teeth down her neck. “I’m going to fuck that pretty ass. While Beck is shoving his way up your cunt, I’m going to work every inch of my cock into your backside and plow you until you can’t breathe.”

  “Fuck, yes,” Beck moaned. “We’re going to stretch you, make you burn hot and fast until you come for us. You’ll still be bucking and shaking when we start all over. By the time we’re done wringing pleasure from you, you’ll be boneless and begging for mercy.”

  “And don’t expect much of that,” Seth added.

  He caught the flutter of her lashes, watched her red, swollen lips form a sinful O as she twisted and wrapped her arm around his neck, her body flowing and rolling between them. A little smile played at her lips. “That sounds…perfect.”

  He stared. She was serious.

  Seth swallowed hard, trying to contain his animal growl. “Head down. Ass up.”

  She gave him a little nod and began to lean onto Beck—but not fast enough. He propelled her against the man’s chest, holding her flat with a palm between her shoulder blades. The doctor took full advantage, claiming her lips as he fucked up and into her. Seth couldn’t stop staring, transfixed by the sight of Heavenly’s parted thighs and Beck’s thick stalk disappearing into her between. Her deep groan tangled with his panted breaths. The sounds were somehow muted yet magnified in the small room, spotlighting the intimacy of their passion.