The Story of Us: A heart-wrenching story that will make you believe in true love

by Tara Sivec

  “Don’t worry about what happens tomorrow, or next week, or months from now. All I care is being with you, right here, right now, just like this,” I told you as you wrapped your arms around my shoulders and smiled.

  “You make it sound so easy.”

  I returned your smile, tightening my arms around your waist.

  “Because it is easy. Especially now that you’ve stopped trying to pretend like you hate me,” I joked, which earned me a smack on the chest. “The only thing that’s hard is knowing you’re having a fancy dinner tonight with some schmuck your mother adores who could give you everything I can’t.”

  I wanted to kick myself in the ass for saying something a little too honest and deep when I watched the smile fall from your face. I opened my mouth to apologize, but you quickly leaned forward and kissed me, sliding your hands through my hair and making me forget what I’d just been thinking when you slid closer and pressed your body right up against mine.

  You pulled your mouth away before I was ready and gave me that smile again.

  “Fine, I won’t worry about tomorrow as long as you won’t worry about tonight,” you told me with a shrug. “Since you avoided my first question, now you get three. Favorite color, favorite movie, and favorite food?”

  You quickly moved your hand between our mouths when I tried to lean in for another kiss.

  “You’re killing me,” I muttered against your hand, groaning when you tortured me even further by sliding one of your legs over my hip.

  “First you answer the questions, then we get to the good stuff,” you laughed, letting out a surprised squeal when I quickly rolled us until you were beneath me.

  “Green, Shawshank Redemption, Peanut Butter Captain Crunch,” I spoke rapidly, your laughter immediately dying with a soft moan when I pushed between your thighs and kissed you before you could ask me anything else.

  You made it easy to forget about my worries and insecurities, and I could only hope as I slid my hand under your shirt, that I did the same thing for you.

  Fuck, I miss the sound of your voice. I miss the smell of your skin. I miss your smile. I miss your laugh, I miss your kiss.

  —Eli

  There’s a knock on my bedroom door, and I look up from the letter I just finished reading when Meredith opens the door and peeks her head in.

  She gives me a sad smile when she sees the letters strewn all over my bed, and I feel a moment of remorse that I’ve completely ignored her in the last week by either locking myself in this room to read the words Eli wrote to me all those years ago, or to race off to meet him.

  “I know you’re still mad at me and that’s okay,” Meredith tells me as she opens the door wide and moves farther into the room. “I did something really shitty, thinking I was protecting you, and I’m sorry. I just want you to be happy, Shelby.”

  I open my mouth to tell her that I am happy, but she holds up her hand to stop me.

  “I know he can do that for you. I see it on your face every time you come back from being with him, but just be careful. He’s been through a lot, and so have you. You guys can’t stay locked up in that barn forever. You’re going to have to come out and face the world someday, and you can’t do that if you don’t talk to each other.”

  I’m still hurt and angry by what she did, but it’s hard to stay mad at her. If the shoe were on the other foot, I might have done the exact same thing. I’d do anything to protect Meredith and keep her safe, and as misguided as her attempt was, I know she didn’t do it to intentionally hurt me.

  “I forgive you,” I whisper.

  Her chin quivers with emotion and her eyes fill with tears. She quickly clears her throat and smiles at me as she moves to the side of the bed, leaning down and giving me a quick hug before pulling back and straightening her shirt.

  “Enough of this emotional shit. My car is waiting out front to take me to the airport. I’ll call you later when I land?”

  I nod my head and return her smile, knowing we’re going to be okay as I watch her walk out of my bedroom and hear the front door close. I close my eyes and rest my head back against the headboard with a smile, knowing that no matter what, Meredith always have my back and be there for me.

  * * *

  I took a few deep breaths to calm my nerves as I walked up the steps to Eli’s new place, but it didn’t work. We’d spend the last week doing nothing but ripping each other’s clothes off almost as soon as we saw each other, and even though each time was more amazing than the last and it’s all I wanted and all I thought about when we weren’t together, I knew we couldn’t keep going like this. We couldn’t close ourselves off in the tack room night after night, staying in our safe little cocoon and avoiding the world around us.

  As easy as it was to fall back together, as natural as it was just to be together, Meredith was right, there were things we needed to talk about that I’d been avoiding. I kept convincing myself to keep it easy and keep it light because he didn’t need anything hard in his life right now. I told myself he’d been through too much and shouldn’t have to deal with the added pressure of my drama and bullshit on top of that, but I couldn’t do it anymore. Not after reading his letters and not after seeing just how strong he was after the years of hell he’d lived through. The more time I spent with him, the more amazed I was at how easily he’d been able to come home and adjust back into his life. He’d mentioned a few times that he’d been talking to a therapist since he came home, but a part of me couldn’t believe that’s all it took to make him forget and move on and remember how to live again. Especially after the nightmare I witnessed him having in the stables and the scars those people left behind.

  I shouldn’t have been so surprised. He used to always tell me I was the strongest person he ever knew, but he had no idea just how strong he was. After the horrors he’d seen and been forced to endure, he still put my needs first. He still worried more about me than he did himself and I refused to take that for granted or let him down. I stopped being the weak and pathetic woman who wouldn’t stand up for herself because of him and he needed to know that. I saw the look on his face the few times I got a text from Landry when we were together and I tried to pretend like it wasn’t anything important, and it kills me that I wasn’t honest with him right in that moment. He’s here, he’s alive, he’s fighting for me, and I need him to know that I’m fighting right back, even if it might take some time.

  When he called and invited me over for dinner tonight, saying he wanted to show me his place and that we needed to talk, it felt good to know we were thinking the same thing. Until I got in my car and headed over here and thought about everything we needed to discuss. Like why he lied to me in that first note when he left for deployment, if he really is doing okay, if he’s told his sister about us, if he’s sure I’m still what he wants, and if so, what exactly does he want. Not to mention the elephant in the room who keeps texting and calling, the one I used to try and move on from Eli, the one I’d hoped would help me forget him. I have to tell Eli that I let another man touch me and try to take his place, even though it’s obvious now that no man could ever replace him, could ever be more than him or better than him. I have to tell him I allowed another man into my bed and into my life while he was being tortured and abused and clinging to thoughts of me and my love for him just to keep him alive. I have to tell him the other man is still in my life because I’ve been too much of a coward to break it off and too distracted being with Eli again to even care, and I’m scared to death Eli’s going to hate me for it.

  My mother is another story. Even though she’s been strangely absent lately and she hasn’t made any more threats since she reminded me of how she could still have Eli investigated for treason if I didn’t hold up my end of the deal by staying away from him, I know when she finds out about all of this, there will be hell to pay, and Eli needs to be prepared. I need to be the strong woman Eli came home for, stand on my own two feet, make my own decisions, and take back my life. I won’t risk his s
ecurity or that of his family by telling him everything she’s done and everything she’s threatened until I talk to her first, but don’t want him to spend one more day thinking I gave up or that I chose this life. I just want him to be safe. I just want him to be happy, and I just want to find a way to make him understand without putting him at risk.

  As I lift my hand to knock, the door is flung open before my fist can even make contact with the wood. Just like every time I see him again, it feels like the first time. Butterflies flap around in my stomach and my heart beats faster when I see Eli standing in the doorway with a smile on his face, wearing a T-shirt and jeans and his hair still damp from a shower.

  Before I can say anything, his arm is around my waist and he’s pulling me against him and into the house, slamming the door behind me and pushing me up against it. His body presses into mine and his hand goes to the back of my head, his mouth slamming into mine before I can even take a breath or look around the foyer. I lose myself in his kiss and his taste and his touch, and the pep talk I gave myself while I was standing out front completely flies from my mind.

  I can’t think about anything else when he’s this close and I don’t care about anything else when he’s kissing me. His tongue swirls around mine and his leg pushes between my thighs and all I care about is never wanting this feeling to end. Never wanting him to stop touching me or kissing me or wanting me. I’ve had too many days, months, and years of feeling so empty and feeling nothing that I don’t know how to stop craving it or how to stop needing it like I need air to breathe.

  I know I should pull back, slow this down, and do all the talking I convinced myself on the way over needed to happen, but it’s physically impossible when the heat from his body warms everything cold inside me and the smell of his skin surrounds me.

  Eli suddenly stops the kiss and pulls his head back, both of us breathing heavily and staring at each other.

  “I invited you here because I thought it would be less distracting than the stables, so we could talk,” he pants.

  “Yes…talk,” I mumble distractedly as my eyes move down to stare at his lips.

  He presses his thigh up between my legs and I whimper, my hands fisting into the material of his T-shirt by his chest as his head dips down to the side of my neck.

  “Fuck, you taste so good,” he whispers, biting down gently and then tracing the tip of his tongue over the same spot.

  I groan as he continues kissing my neck until my head thumps back against the door behind me, the sound bringing me somewhat back to my senses.

  Moving my hands to the back of his head, I clutch on to his short hair and pull him away from my neck so I can see his face.

  “Talking is important,” I remind him, my eyes fluttering closed when he starts sliding his thigh back and forth between my legs.

  “Very important,” he confirms in a low voice, his hands moving slowly over my breasts and down my sides until he gets to my hips and clutches the material of my skirt in his fists.

  As he leans in to kiss me again, I press my hand to his mouth to stop him and he growls against my palm. Dropping my hand down to flatten it against his chest so I can feel his heart beating against my skin, I raise one eyebrow and wait.

  “Fine,” he sighs loudly. “You’re right. Favorite smell, favorite time of day, favorite memory?”

  He fires off the questions rapidly and all I can think about is the letter I just read this morning, how some things never change no matter how much time we spend apart, and how I suddenly don’t want to do anything else right now than let him distract me.

  “Whatever soap you use, whatever time it is now, this one right here,” I tell him quickly, cutting off his satisfied chuckle by yanking him back to me and attacking his lips.

  I stand on my tiptoes, pushing away from the door to mold my body to the front of him and wrap my arms around his shoulders. I think about all the time we lost and how many times I wished for just one more moment with him. I’ve been given that second chance to touch him whenever I want, and I don’t want to waste it.

  When his hands slide up my thighs and under my skirt to grab my ass and lift me up against him, I immediately wrap my legs around his hips and tell myself, Just a few more seconds and then I’ll make us stop.

  When one of his hands moves from my ass, slides under my tank top and up my rib cage, moving my bra aside as he goes, I think, I just need a little bit more, then I’ll make us stop.

  When his rough palm cups my breast and his thumb slides over my nipple as he walks us through his new house that I’m not even seeing, I tell myself, I deserve a few more minutes of feeling like this.

  When he sits us down on the edge of the bed with my legs straddling his thighs, rolling my nipple between his thumb and his finger, my hands scramble between us, unzipping his jeans and pulling his cock out. When he moans into my mouth as I squeeze him and run my palm up and down his thick, hard length, I think, He deserves a few more minutes of feeling like this, too.

  When his hands fly to my hips and he lifts my body just enough for me to slide my lacy underwear to the side and guide him where I need him, when he doesn’t hesitate to thrust himself inside me hard and deep, I stop thinking about putting a halt to this.

  When his fingers dig into the skin of my ass as I grind myself against him and when he sucks my tongue into his mouth, I stop thinking about anything else we should be doing right now.

  When his hands clutching my ass help move me, slamming me down on his cock over and over, when he pulls his mouth away from mine and begs me to fuck him harder, fuck him faster, when he tells me how I good I feel, when he tells me he still can’t believe I’m real, when he tells me he can’t live without this, can’t live without me, I stop thinking about anything but how good it feels to be so consumed and so filled by this man that I’ve never stopped loving.

  When I come so quickly it takes my breath away, when I ride him harder and faster until he shouts my name, when I can feel his cock pulsing with his release, when he reaches between us and his fingers find my clit, I stop thinking about all the things I need to say.

  When he holds himself still inside me as his orgasm subsides, when his fingertips circle and slide and move faster, when he makes me come again and I moan his name with a sigh, when he tells me he loves me, tells me nothing else matters, begs me to stay…I stop thinking altogether.

  Chapter 23

  Eli

  So much for talking.

  Staring down at Shelby’s hair spread out on my pillow with her face soft and relaxed in sleep, I forget what was so important that we needed to talk about last night. I forget everything but how good it feels to open my eyes and see her lying next to me, feel her body curled up against mine, and listen to her breathe. Nothing is more important than this moment, right here. Being happy and content and not having any worries other than what I’m going to feed her for breakfast when she wakes up.

  After I opened the door to her last night and saw her standing there in a casual white tank top and blue and white patterned short skirt with her long, gorgeous legs on display, I forgot all about my concerns and just wanted to kiss her, hold her in my arms, and finally believe she’s here with me and it wasn’t all a dream. Every time she leaves me, I have moments of panic that none of this is real. So many minutes wasted during each day where I have to stop and remember how to breathe and push back the images of filth and pain, and screaming and death, that flash through my mind. I never feel like myself again until she walks back into the room and I can touch her, feel the heat from her skin, the silk of her hair, and listen to the sound of her voice, erasing all my doubts and fears.

  Shelby sighs in her sleep and the ping of her phone goes off on the nightstand next to her. I watch her eyes flutter open at the sound and she turns her body away from me, grabbing the phone and bringing it close to her. I stay silent as she quickly presses a button to blacken the screen, setting the phone back on the nightstand before rolling back to me.

&nbs
p; Her face lights up with a smile and she lifts one hand up and presses it to the side of my face.

  “Good morning.”

  Her voice is raspy and still full of sleep and I’m instantly hard for her, but I don’t move to pull her close. The peaceful moment from just a few seconds ago has been interrupted, and no matter how much I want to ignore it and lose myself in her, I can’t do that now.

  “It’s okay if you need to take that,” I tell her, nodding in the direction of her phone.

  She rubs her thumb back and forth over my cheek and shakes her head.

  “Nope, it can wait.”

  Her body starts to slide closer and I press my hand against her chest to stop her, hating the look of confusion on her face.

  “Shelby, it’s fine. I’ll go take a shower and give you some privacy,” I reassure her, even though all I want to do is slide between her thighs and push inside her, reminding her she’s mine.

  I move to roll away and get out of bed, but her hand grabs my arm and tugs me back to her.

  “Please, don’t go,” she begs softly as I flop down onto my back and stare at the ceiling.

  “I get it, okay? I understand and I’m not mad. I hurt you and I was dead for five years. It’s selfish of me to think you would have been alone all that time.”

  She sighs, closing the distance between us to rest her arms on my chest and slide one of her legs between mine. Both of her hands grab my face and gently turn it toward her.

  “It’s not what you think, Eli. It isn’t…he isn’t—”

  “I told you, it’s okay,” I remind her, cutting her off as she flounders for the right words. “You don’t have to explain. I thought I needed you to, but I don’t. I’m not mad, I just don’t want to know. I don’t want to have this image in my head of you with someone else. I just…don’t want to know. You let go and you moved on and that’s okay. I get it. Just let me get out of the room so you can handle whatever it is.”