Crying Wolf, Shoot for the Moon, Thrown to the Wolves

by Rochelle Paige

  I hadn’t ever thought about it that way. Was it possible? Spencer had done everything in his power over the last six months to show me he wasn’t going anywhere. He hadn’t run when he hadn’t known what was stopping me from accepting his mark, and he hadn’t balked when I’d told him about my dreams of him.

  “So I’m guessing by the look on your face you hadn’t ever considered it?” Grace asked me, pulling me out of my thoughts.

  “Not until just now. No,” I admitted.

  Her eyes lit with joy. “Then my job here is done! Let’s go get me married to that gorgeous man of mine.”

  I was dazed as Parker came for Grace so he could walk her down the aisle. He gave me a strange look, and Grace just shook her head as a warning to leave me alone for now. Once she was ready to go, Parker offered me his other arm and walked us both to the sliding glass door off the kitchen.

  When the music changed, I stepped outside and my eyes immediately locked with Spencer’s. My step almost faltered when I saw his love for me shining bright for everyone to see. Then I made my way down the aisle to stand under the arch on the bride’s side, waiting for Grace to join me.

  I knew I should have been watching her as she walked towards us, but my gaze kept straying to Spencer. And each time I did, I found his eyes on me. I couldn’t help but think that, if I let go of my fears, this could be us. We could be the couple everyone else looked at with tears in their eyes because of how perfect we were together. We could be fully mated with a claiming this next full moon if I truly believed that Spencer loved me with all of his heart and would never willingly leave me until his death.

  And then Grace reached us and Parker took her hand and placed it in Hunter’s, giving away the bride to his brother. I saw Hunter lean down to kiss Grace’s cheek, and then his head jerked up so he could look into her eyes. When Grace whispered to him, his eyes widened before he turned his head to look back at Parker. Then as he swiveled back to his bride, his eyes locked with mine for a brief moment.

  I couldn’t help the grin that spread across my face at the vision of the two of them under the arch of flowers as our alpha learned he would be a father. It was exactly as I had dreamed it two nights ago.

  As I stood beside Grace and Hunter while they exchanged their vows, I finally accepted the possibility that Grace was right. That I was the one causing the harm in our relationship by holding on to my dreams. Her words had given me a speck of hope—one I clung to all night long as we celebrated Hunter and Grace’s marriage.

  I noticed Spencer shooting me curious looks several times through the night. My best guess was that I wasn’t doing a very good job of pretending that something wasn’t on my mind. I was quieter than usual and barely touched my food as I pondered our situation. By the time we made it to the dance floor, I just wanted to be alone for a little while so I could get some real thinking done. Apparently, Spencer had other ideas about how our night should go from here—ones that included an explanation of what was wrong with me.

  “You’ve barely paid any attention to me tonight,” he grumbled. “And I didn’t even get to stay with you last night because you had Grace over.”

  “It was my responsibility as her bridesmaid to make this day special for her, and part of that was honoring the traditions surrounding weddings,” I explained.

  “Fine,” he sighed. “I get last night, although I still don’t know why you didn’t call me for help with the flowers if you were here in the middle of the night putting them up.”

  “If I’d done that, then I wouldn’t have been able to keep the secret about Grace’s pregnancy and I wanted her to be able to surprise him during the ceremony,” I explained.

  Spencer pulled my body closer to his and held me tight in his arms as we stopped in the middle of the dance floor. His dark gaze was serious as he looked down at me.

  “Everything went perfectly and your duties as a bridesmaid are all done. But you still aren’t really here with me right now. What’s going on in that pretty head of yours, dream girl?”

  I felt like everyone was watching us as we stood still. Glancing around the room, I found several pairs of eyes on us. Some were happy, like his brother’s. Some were exasperated, like the other dancers who were trying to avoid us. And then, out of the corner of my eye, I caught the flash of jealousy and anger that was quickly masked by another she-wolf before she looked away. Having Spencer in my arms was certainly worthy of envy in the single women here tonight.

  “Not here,” I whispered. “I haven’t really slept in days. Let me get some rest tonight and I promise we’ll talk tomorrow.”

  Disappointment spread across his face. “One of us is running away from the other in this relationship, Eliza. But it isn’t me.”

  I knew he was right, but I needed one quiet night to think about what Grace had said earlier. “But not to get away from you. Never that,” I swore.

  His eyes filled with determination. “Then let me mark you, Eliza. Soon.”

  “We’ll talk about it tomorrow,” I promised again before stepping out of his arms. “After I’ve had a good night’s sleep and can make a rational decision about this.”

  Five

  Spencer

  Eliza didn’t need to make a rational decision about my marking her. She needed to trust her heart and our feelings for each other, but her head was so messed up because of those damn dreams that she had convinced herself that I didn’t really want her. Not that I’d helped the situation much with how we’d started. I’d created this mess by feeding into her insecurities, and now, it was my job to convince her that I was in this for the long haul.

  For the last month, I’d tried to balance Grace and Hunter’s advice without coming across too strongly, but I was done with that now. It was time to “man the fuck up,” as Hunter had put it. It had worked to get her to tell me about her dreams, so maybe it would work to get her to finally believe that I would be her mate forever.

  When we had stood at the altar with my brother and Grace for their wedding, the sense of wrongness had overwhelmed me. Six months had passed since the night I’d whispered the mating words to her, and enough was fucking enough. Come hell or high water, by the end of tonight, Eliza would have no question who she belonged to—me.

  Letting myself into her home while she was asleep was probably frowned upon by most people, but did I give a fuck about what anyone else thought? Desperate times called for desperate measures. Damn woman was almost as stubborn as I was, but not quite. Whoever said that all was fair in love and war had it right. As the pack enforcer, I was more comfortable with war than love, so it was about time I used those skills to tie Eliza to me.

  As quietly as possible, I crept into her bedroom and prepared for my mission. Then I settled in to wait until she stirred. But as the minutes ticked by, I began to get restless—visions of what was to come once Eliza woke up burning in my brain. Determination to tear down her walls brick by brick fueled me. Had she been awake already, my smirk would have warned her that I was up to no good. If that didn’t do it when she did wake up, then the boner from hell pressed against my pants would give my intentions away.

  Standing at the foot of her bed, I waited for her eyelids to flutter open. When dreams weren’t plaguing her, she was a sound sleeper, which I’d used to my advantage well tonight. Finally, she stirred in the bed, and her eyelids popped open when she realized she couldn’t move her arms or legs.

  “Hey, dream girl,” I whispered.

  “What the hell, Spencer?” she spit out, the sleepiness quickly leaving her eyes as they lit with anger.

  A dark chuckle escaped my lips as I walked closer. Eliza struggled against the cuffs until she finally understood that she wasn’t going to break free from them. The sheet slipped off her body and revealed her naked flesh to my starving eyes.

  “Get me out of these. Now!” she barked at me, her eyes gleaming in the dark.

  “No,” I hissed out.

  “What the fuck, Spencer? I know I passed o
ut from exhaustion, but I’m not so tired that I can believe I fell asleep naked. And I sure as hell didn’t put these handcuffs on myself. Why are you doing this to me?” she wailed.

  I stared into her eyes as I pulled my bow tie from my collar and dropped it on the floor. Then I slowly unbuttoned my crisp, white dress shirt and tossed it onto the chair where I’d flung my tuxedo jacket earlier. Kneeling on the end of the bed, I ran my hands up her legs until I almost reached her glistening pussy lips. I could hear Eliza’s breathing as it quickened with desire, but I wasn’t ready to give in to our need for each other yet. I needed to get some things straight with her first.

  “Six months,” I growled. “It’s been six pain-fucking-stakingly long months since I mated you, my dream girl.”

  “Spencer!” Eliza gasped out with sorrow in her eyes.

  “No!” I barked out, placing my finger over her mouth to stop her words. “I know the dreams have made you terrified. I know you don’t mean to hurt me, but I need you to tell me what I can do to make you see I will never turn away from you. Never!”

  “I can’t explain what it’s like to see the man I love look at me the way you do in the dreams. Every time it happens, it kills me to see it. I can’t imagine what I would do if it were real,” I tried to explain.

  “Don’t you see, Eliza? That’s exactly how I feel. It doesn’t seem to matter what I do or say. You just won’t let that final wall between us come tumbling down. I know I fucked up badly when we met. I was a stupid motherfucker when I told you we would never be more than casual lovers. But I mated you knowing you weren’t ready to accept my mark. I gave you months of space when you needed it. I’ve wooed you with dates and presents. Haven’t I paid enough already?”

  Eliza shook her head wildly. “No, that’s not what it is at all. I’m not trying to punish you for what happened between us.”

  “I made a commitment to you six months ago, Eliza. I did it knowing I was taking a huge risk because you weren’t ready yet. But that didn’t stop the way I felt about you. You’re my mate. Forever. I will never denounce you for another woman because there will never be another woman for me. And it’s killing me to know that, even though I tied myself to you so many months ago, you’re still not willing to let me mark you.”

  “But what if you change your mind later?” she whispered.

  “You know me better than that. Look me in the eyes and think about it. Don’t let your fear ruin this for us. You know your visions are only one possible version of the future. Do you really think I will ever willingly walk away from you?” I asked.

  She tilted her head as she stared at me, and slowly, the fear in her eyes gave way to hope. “I think Grace may have been right,” she whispered almost to herself.

  “Right about what?”

  “I’m the one in control of my future. Not my dreams. I helped change Grace’s fate by telling Hunter about my dream of her. And if I continue to push you away, then I might just be the one who’s responsible for making my dreams about us come true,” she answered.

  My heart began to beat wildly in my chest at her response. “Does that mean what I think it means? Because I need you to actually say the words.”

  “No, I don’t really think you will change your mind about being my mate and leave me. You love me,” she finally admitted.

  “And?” I bit out.

  “I want to be yours forever, too,” she sighed. “Mark me.”

  “Finally,” I groaned before bending down and shoving my face in her pussy. Then I licked each of her lips, tasting the wetness that had been for me. She jerked when I flicked my tongue over her clit, and I moved farther down to plunge it inside her pussy.

  Eliza was panting beneath me, squirming against the cuffs. I held her hips in place and fucked her with my tongue until I felt the fluttering of her walls that signaled how close she was to an orgasm. I pulled away and waited until she settled a little and then gently blew against her damp skin.

  “Spencer, please. I need to come,” she begged.

  “Not yet,” I told her before thrusting two fingers inside her drenched pussy.

  Swirling them around, I twisted my hand until I was touching that spongy spot deep inside her. Then I slowly rubbed until she was soaking my hand before pulling away again. Reaching into my pocket, I found the cock ring I’d brought with me to help in my torture of her. When I turned the motor on, Eliza stilled and looked up at me with shocked eyes.

  “What are you going to do with that?” she gasped.

  “I’m gonna make sure you know you’re mine,” I growled. “By the time I’m done, you’ll have no doubts remaining about how much I want you. How much I need you. And love you.”

  “Spencer,” she sighed, “I already know that.”

  “Maybe that’s true,” I agreed. “But I need this. And my wolf needs it even more. Tonight, I’m going to possess you like I’ve never done before, dominate you, and then I’m going to mark you. Come morning, you’ll feel my devotion to the depth of your soul. You’ll never need to hold yourself away from me. If that’s not what you want, you need to tell me now. Last chance. Do you want to be mine?”

  The sensual haze cleared from her eyes before she answered, and I could see her wolf gazing at me as she spoke. “Yes! More than anything in this world, I want to be your mate. Do it!”

  A howl of triumph crept up my throat and broke free. After tonight, Eliza really would be mine. She’d carry my mark, leaving all other wolves with no doubt that she was my mate.

  I slid the cock ring over two fingers before moving my hand back to her pussy. Centering the vibrating ring over her clit, I cupped her mound with my palm and waited. Her hips pulsed against me as liquid heat gushed from her body.

  “Please,” she begged, pulling on the cuffs and writhing with need.

  “Not until you can’t think of anything but me,” I growled. “I want to be the only thing in your mind. The only thing you can see while you feel my body wrapped around yours, filling you as deep as I can go. Only then will I let you come. Right before I sink my teeth into your shoulder and leave my mark there for everyone to see.”

  “Don’t you get it yet, Spencer? You are the only thing I’ve been able to see ever since I arrived in Wolf’s Point. My days and nights have been filled with thoughts of you. Yours is the only face I want to see before I fall asleep and the only thing I want to see when I open my eyes in the morning. It’s you for me. It’s always been you. So take me now and make it official. Mark me.”

  The utter acceptance in her words sent the blood roaring like fire through my veins. The urge to mate, the need to dominate her as we fucked, became impossible to ignore. I pulled away from her body and stood so I could slide my pants down my legs, my boxer briefs along with them. After yanking the vibrating ring from my hand, I slid it over my cock and hardened even more. Then I crawled between her legs and reached under her body so I could grab her butt cheeks for leverage.

  “Tell me again,” I urged. “Who do you belong to?”

  “You,” she whispered back.

  “Louder!” I yelled as I lifted her higher, her body arching as I slapped her ass.

  “You!” she yelled. “I belong to you. Only you!”

  “That’s right, my dream girl. It’s about damn time you realized it, too.”

  I entered her with one swift thrust of my hips, filling her as much as I could at this angle. She screamed my name as I pounded into her with all the desperation I’d been feeling since I’d mated her. The cock ring bumped against her clit each time I rammed home, and I swiveled my hips to make sure the vibrations rolled through her body. When the tingling began in the base of my spine, I quickened my pace, determined to force her over the edge before I allowed myself the orgasm I needed so much.

  Eliza trembled beneath me, her walls starting to clench more tightly against me with each punishing thrust. I knew she was getting closer and closer to coming for me.

  “Are you ready to be mine forever?” I grow
led, my teeth lengthening in preparation of the bite I’d been waiting to give her ever since I’d spoken the mating words so many months before.

  “Yes,” she hissed, a brief flash of clarity sweeping across her lust-filled eyes as she gazed up at me.

  As I released my hold on her body, she sank into the bed. Then I gave one final thrust before bending her head to the side and biting into her shoulder, right where it met her neck. Light burst behind my eyes as my climax hit me. Her body spasmed under mine, her eyes rolling back into her head while her pussy squeezed me. I jerked my hips in short, hard jabs as I fucked her through both of our orgasms.

  My arms gave out and I dropped down onto Eliza’s panting, sweat-slickened body. Not wanting to crush her, I flipped onto my side as my chest heaved while I tried to regain my breath.

  When she moved her arms, I heard the cuffs knock against the bedposts and was reminded that they were there. Once I could breathe again, I released her wrists and then her ankles. Rolling onto her side, she locked her gaze with mine, and I saw the same contentment I felt in my heart there in her eyes.

  We were finally mated and marked—only the claiming lay between us and forever.

  Six

  Eliza

  I’d heard stories growing up about that moment when you accept your mate’s mark—all she-wolves did. My mom hadn’t gone into too many details because of the level of intimacy involved—no one wanted to hear those types of things about their own parents. But nothing I had ever been told compared to what had just happened between Spencer and me. There was a moment of pain and then the pleasure was so overwhelming that I almost couldn’t stand it.

  Waves of mind-numbing bliss racked my body as an orgasm stronger than any I’d ever experienced before crashed down upon me. The moment when Spencer’s cock was buried deep inside my pussy while his teeth were under my flesh was one I would never forget for the rest of my life. It was the first time my heart had felt full of love and acceptance. The first time my wolf and human sides had felt like they were in utter harmony.