The First Victim

by JB Lynn

  The First Victim

  By JB Lynn

  She was like all the other victims. Naked, flawed, helpless…

  Fifteen years ago, Emily Wright barely escaped from a serial killer dubbed the Baby Doll Strangler. She wants nothing to do with the small town where she was abducted, but when her father is hospitalized she reluctantly returns home to care for her teenage sister.

  When her sister’s friend is killed and left in front of Emily’s house, Emily begins to relive the nightmare she endured long ago. Soon she realizes that her sister, too, is in danger from the killer—and the only person who can help is the man Emily left behind: Deputy Bailey O’Neil. Together, Emily and Bailey must discover the killer’s identity before he claims his next victim…

  72,000 words

  Dear Reader,

  I feel as though it was just last week I was attending 2010 conferences and telling authors and readers who were wondering what was next for Carina Press, “we’ve only been publishing books for four months, give us time” and now, here it is, a year later. Carina Press has been bringing you quality romance, mystery, science fiction, fantasy and more for over twelve months. This just boggles my mind.

  But though we’re celebrating our one-year anniversary (with champagne and chocolate, of course) we’re not slowing down. Every week brings something new for us, and we continue to look for ways to grow, expand and improve. This summer, we’ll continue to bring you new genres, new authors and new niches—and we plan to publish the unexpected for years to come.

  So whether you’re reading this in the middle of a summer heat wave, looking to escape from the hot summer nights and sultry afternoons, or whether you’re reading this in the dead of winter, searching for a respite from the cold, months after I’ve written it, you can be assured that our promise to take you on new adventures, bring you great stories and discover new talent remains the same.

  We love to hear from readers, and you can email us your thoughts, comments and questions to generalinquiries@carinapress.com. You can also interact with Carina Press staff and authors on our blog, Twitter stream and Facebook fan page.

  Happy reading!

  ~Angela James

  Executive Editor, Carina Press

  www.carinapress.com

  www.twitter.com/carinapress

  www.facebook.com/carinapress

  Acknowledgments

  While I may get the credit for writing this book (and take the blame for any inaccuracies or inconsistencies within) it wouldn’t have been possible without the support of the following people:

  My parents, for getting me hooked on suspense novels from an early age.

  My dear friends, many of whom generously offered to be readers of the manuscript, who provided unflagging support.

  Pamelia S. Stratton, former Special Agent of the FBI, for answering a myriad of questions.

  My patient and insightful critique partners, Cynthia Valero and Jennifer Colgan, for sticking with me through multiple versions of this story.

  My personal cheerleader Laura, who initiated our friendship many years ago by coming up to me and saying, “I love the way you write!”

  The entire Carina Press team, but especially, Charlotte Herscher, my editor who provided priceless guidance with wit and humor.

  And Doug, whose support, enthusiasm and love makes everything possible…

  Contents

  Copyright

  Chapter 1

  Chapter 2

  Chapter 3

  Chapter 4

  Chapter 5

  Chapter 6

  Chapter 7

  Chapter 8

  Chapter 9

  Chapter 10

  Chapter 11

  Chapter 12

  Chapter 13

  Chapter 14

  Chapter 15

  Chapter 16

  Chapter 17

  Chapter 18

  Chapter 19

  Chapter 20

  Chapter 21

  Chapter 22

  Chapter 23

  Chapter 24

  Chapter 25

  Chapter 26

  Chapter 27

  Chapter 28

  Chapter 29

  Chapter 30

  Chapter 31

  Chapter 32

  Chapter 33

  About the Author

  Chapter 1

  She was like all the other teenage girls. All of them were disappointing once he got them like this.

  Naked.

  Helpless.

  Flawed.

  She huddled on the floor in a puddle of her own piss and shit, trembling and whining like a beaten dog.

  She hadn’t been hurt.

  Much.

  Yet.

  He really wished she hadn’t made such a mess of herself. He liked them clean. He wanted them to be unspoiled, not caked in their own filth. He needed them to smell sweet, like candy.

  She balled herself tighter as though that offered some protection.

  He laughed, the sound bouncing off the concrete walls, the echoes magnifying his mockery of her. She couldn’t stop him. He’d take what he wanted from her. He owned her. She was his plaything now.

  He didn’t tell her again to get up; he just turned the hose on her. She yelped when the first blast struck her. Instinctively, she rolled away from the icy water, but she couldn’t escape. She cried out as he kept the stream aimed at her tender flesh. She held out her hands to ward off the stinging assault, but he kept changing his angle of attack.

  “Stop! Please stop!” She scrambled to her feet, trying to put some distance between herself and the harsh spray, but he pursued her relentlessly.

  “It hurts!”

  He smiled. It had been a stroke of genius to use a power washer instead of a lowly garden hose to clean off the dirty girl.

  She backed all the way into the corner. “Please stop. Please. Please!”

  He paused, and she sobbed her relief. “Thank you!”

  She looked so pathetic, so unlike the perfect doll he wanted her to be. Pink welts rose on her skin where the water had lashed her. He wondered if they’d be warm to the touch.

  He moved closer and she pressed back against the wall. He lunged to the right. She threw herself in the opposite direction, leaving a smear of water against the wall where she’d leaned. As he followed her, she moved farther away. Normally, he loved this part. The part where they danced this bizarre, macabre tango, but today he just wasn’t in the mood.

  She froze as he raised the handle. He smiled as he saw her hope of escape get extinguished.

  Except for her shivering, she stood still, waiting for him, knowing that she had no other choice. Her eyes drifted closed, signaling her surrender.

  He used the nozzle to push away the arm that was covering her young breasts. Obediently she let it fall, offering no resistance. With his free hand he traced a line of water beads from her throat down to an exposed nipple. Her skin was cold, but at least she was clean.

  Grabbing her hand, he pressed her palm to his dick. She curled her fingers into a fist, not wanting to hold him, so he jammed the hose between her legs, reminding her of his power. Her almost blue lips parted on a pained gasp as her hand unclenched.

  Submissively she wrapped her fingers around him. Even though her hand was icy, the discomfort was still a pleasure.

  “That’s a girl. Up and down. Up and down.”

  As she tentatively stroked him he leaned in and licked a welt on her shoulder, tasting her. What flavor was she? Orange? Grape? Cherry?

  Every time she rubbed him, he ran his tongue over her skin. The hose nozzle fell to the floor with a clatter as he pushed her back against the wall, pinning her there, so that he had both hands free to squeeze her tits.

  “Don’t stop
,” he ordered when she hesitated.

  She began to stroke him again in earnest. Not that it would do any good. He never, ever came this way, not even when he used his own hand in the shower, but it still felt good.

  “That’s it, Emily. That feels so good.”

  Not that this girl was Emily. This was Dianne, a poor substitute. But if he closed his eyes, and concentrated really, really hard, he could imagine that it was Emily he was touching and tasting. Emily he was about to fuck. Emily he was going to kill.

  “Does your palm itch? Emily?”

  Engrossed in paperwork, it took Emily Wright a moment to realize that her assistant, Ruth, was talking to her. She looked up at the older woman as Ruth placed a cup of coffee beside Emily’s telephone. It was only then she realized that she’d been rubbing her left thumb across her right hand.

  “Does your palm itch?”

  Emily nodded. “Thanks for the coffee.”

  Ruth beamed. “That’s good news. It means you’re going to come into money.” Her unspoken message was that it boded well for the presentation Marisol, Emily’s business partner, was probably making at this very moment. All nine of the advertising firm’s employees were eagerly waiting to hear whether they’d landed their biggest client ever.

  “Do you really believe in those old superstitions, Ruth?”

  “They can’t hurt. Can I get you anything else?”

  “No. This is great. Thanks.” Watching her newest employee, a woman old enough to be her mother, leave her office, Emily secretly hoped she was right.

  She looked down at her palm. The scar that stretched across it had faded over time and was now nothing more than a thin raised line. No doubt there were a hundred doctors in Manhattan who could remove the physical reminder of what she’d suffered, but to her the scar tissue was a talisman of sorts, proof that hope could triumph over evil.

  She’d learned an invaluable lesson the day she’d earned this scar. She’d learned that she was capable of more than she’d ever imagined, that help came from the most unexpected places and to never give up. Those lessons had served her well, which was how she found herself a co-owner of a Manhattan ad agency, waiting to hear whether they’d landed their first national account.

  Feeling the distant rumblings of a tension headache, she rubbed at her temples, and then made a grab for her coffee cup. She needed caffeine!

  Her cell phone buzzed. Hoping that it was Marisol calling with good news, she snatched it out of her purse. An icy tingle of fear ran down her spine when she recognized the area code. Home.

  It rang three more times before she took a deep breath and answered.

  “Hello?”

  “You’ve got to come home, Em.” Bailey O’Neil, her childhood friend and teenage crush who still made semi-regular appearances in her dreams, didn’t offer a greeting, ask how she was or even identify himself. Not that he needed to. Even though it had been close to fifteen years since they’d had regular conversations, she’d recognized Bailey’s voice immediately.

  It transported her from behind her desk to a dock on a lake’s shore. In that instant it was easier to believe she was a confused fourteen-year-old girl rather than a driven, thirty-one-year-old businesswoman.

  “There’s been an accident.”

  He’d called and said the same exact thing two years earlier, but that had been a lie. Her mother had overdosed, and no one would ever convince Emily it had been an accident.

  With Marisol, who was not only her business partner but her best friend, in tow for moral support, Emily had returned to Lakeside Acres, Pennsylvania for the funeral, choosing to stay at The Garden Gate Bed & Breakfast rather than the house she’d called home as a child. She hadn’t been back since, not even to see Laurie.

  “Em?” Bailey still used the shortened version of her name, just like he had when they were kids. It almost sounded too familiar, since it suggested that they knew each other well. That was another lie. “Em? Did you hear me? I said you’ve got to come home.”

  “I heard you. How’d you get this number?”

  Ignoring her question, Bailey told her, “There’s been an accident. Your father’s been hurt. It’s pretty bad. They’re not sure he’s going to make it.”

  “So?”

  She heard Bailey’s sharp intake of breath. He probably thought she was a stone-cold bitch. So be it. She’d decided long ago that she didn’t have to explain or justify her relationship, or lack of relationship, with her dear old dad. If Bailey O’Neil didn’t approve of her reaction, that was his problem.

  Bailey, though, didn’t miss a beat. “Laurie needs you.”

  Try as she might, Emily didn’t hear any judgment or condemnation in his tone, only a genuine concern for her younger sister. Doing her best to ignore the twinge of guilt she felt for not immediately inquiring about her only sibling, Emily asked, “Is she hurt? What happened?”

  “Your father was out on his boat. I don’t have the details yet. Laurie wasn’t involved, but she’s scared, Em. She needs someone. She needs you.”

  Emily’s gaze settled on two tiny framed photographs perched on the corner of her desk. They’d been taken more than two years earlier when Laurie was thirteen. She and her sister had crammed into one of those tiny booths at a mall, made a bunch of silly faces and ended up with a strip of four, slightly grainy, black-and-white photographs. They’d torn the strip in half, each taking two of the pictures. Besides the funeral, it was the last time she’d seen her sister. Their father had seen to that.

  “Em?”

  “Okay. I’ll be there in a few hours.”

  “Swear?”

  An image of Bailey solemnly staring at her popped into her mind, not this adult version of Bailey who was just doing his job, but the boy she’d played freeze tag with.

  “Em? Swear?”

  “I swear.” She severed the connection.

  Chapter 2

  Emily whizzed past the sign that said Welcome to Pike County. She was getting closer. Her gut churned like the water at Bushkill Falls, “the Niagara of Pennsylvania,” which she’d passed earlier. She was almost home.

  The sun was setting as she approached the outskirts of her hometown. The winding, narrow roads that she’d once known so well were now unfamiliar. An impending sense of doom weighed heavier on her with each mile marker she passed, making it impossible to concentrate on driving.

  Only her love for her sister could make her return to this place that frightened her so. Otherwise she’d happily live the rest of her life without ever setting foot in this town again. Every bend in the road taunted her with a history she’d rather forget.

  She was so consumed by thoughts of the past that she barely registered the flashing eyes right in front of her. At the last possible instant, she stomped on the brakes, jerking the steering wheel hard in order to avoid hitting the deer frozen in the middle of the road.

  Not for the first time that day, her stomach lurched and everything seemed to be happening in slow motion. The brakes and tires of her hybrid compact car struggled to halt her inevitable slide off the road. Tires squealing in protest, the car careened wildly onto the gravel shoulder, bounced through a shallow drainage ditch and crashed through a bank of trees, ultimately smashing into the sturdy trunk of an oak. The airbag deployed, smacking her in the face, knocking the breath out of her.

  It took her a moment to realize that the vehicle had stopped moving. As soon as she did, Emily batted away the airbag and groped for the door latch, desperate to get out. Opening the door was not enough to free her. She was still pinned in place.

  Panicked, she imagined it was his hands holding her down, trapping her. She could hear his voice whispering, “Shhh, Baby Doll.” She could smell his breath, laden with the sickeningly sweet scent of a cherry lollipop. It made her retch.

  The action jerked her forward, and she realized that it was her seat belt that held her in place, not him. He wasn’t here. It was just her mind playing a twisted trick on her.

&n
bsp; She fumbled to release the seat belt, and then tumbled out of the car.

  Her legs, rubbery from shock, refused to support her and she fell to her knees. She scrambled on all fours over a bed of hard acorns and crackling fallen leaves, out of the menacing shadows of the trees. Distancing herself from the car, she climbed back toward the street she’d skidded off.

  “You should have just hit the damn deer,” she berated herself. When she reached the roadside, she saw the cause of her predicament blithely nibbling on grass. “Next time, Bambi.”

  Still too shaky to stand, she sat on the shoulder glaring at the skid marks her tires had left. “I shouldn’t be here. This is all Bailey’s fault.” Pulling her legs up to her chest, she grabbed her ankles and buried her head into her knees, curling up like a timid turtle on the side of the road.

  For Laurie’s sake, despite her reservations about returning to Lakeside Acres, she had done her best to keep her promise to Bailey.

  It had taken Emily ninety minutes to get everything organized and to hold an impromptu meeting with the staff, outlining their duties while she was gone. An hour after that she had packed her bag, gotten her car from the lot and was headed home.

  Then the damn deer appeared.

  Darkness was falling fast now. Having regained a semblance of equilibrium, Emily slowly got to her feet. Nerves jangling and thoughts scattered, she stood at the side of the deserted road, unsure of what to do. Pursing her lips, she exhaled slowly, emptying her lungs, before taking a deep breath. The trick a therapist had taught her long ago helped to regulate her breathing. She immediately felt calmer. As her body settled down, her thoughts followed suit, and logic returned.

  She’d call for a tow truck and wouldn’t have to wait long for help to arrive. Fishing into the front pocket of her jeans, she pulled out her cell phone. The light that flickered from it as she turned it on made the woods seem less dark.

  The comfort was short-lived as a low battery warning flashed once and the phone went dark and dead in her hand. “Dammit!”