Secret Confessions: Backstage – Theo

by Zaide Bishop

  Theo could see everything and she met his gaze. Even as Rei reached around to cup her breasts—looking more curious than aroused—Theo felt as if this display was for him. However his view was blocked by Sawyer’s bare back as he knelt in front of her. He kissed her on the mouth, hot and intense, then moved down her neck to her breasts. He kissed Rei’s fingers, sucked one, and Theo saw Rei’s eyes roll back a little. Andi sighed as Sawyer’s tongue scoured across her nipples, leaning back against Rei who kissed her neck.

  Sawyer worked downward, kissing his way across Andi’s belly until his head was between her thighs. Theo couldn’t see anything but his messy blonde hair, but Andi gasped and arched suddenly, cheeks flush with colour. Rei’s fingers tightened around her breasts, the flesh moulding between them and she locked her eyes on Theo’s, lips parted, breath catching as Sawyer bobbed in a steady rhythm. He brought up one hand and Andi arched again, letting out a groan as his elbow started to work in tandem with his head.

  Theo could hear the slick, wet sound of penetration, even over Andi’s mounting gasps and whimpers. Over her shoulder, Rei was flushed with colour, eyes a little glassy with want. His hands were moving on Andi’s breasts, squeezing, cupping, then pinching her nipples, tugging at them and rolling them in a way that left Theo unable to tear his gaze away.

  His own cock was throbbing with need. Trapped against the fabric of his jeans, it was moving from aroused to painful and he unbuttoned his fly, wriggling out of his jeans completely. His cock seemed to find the hole in the front of his boxers on its own, thrusting out of its own volition, trembling eagerly.

  He ignored it, attention still locked on his friends and Andi, as they drew her closer and closer to orgasm. Her whole body was shaking, her mouth open and gasping, hips jerking, but her eyes were locked on his. He wanted those lips around his cock. He wanted to taste her. To fill her.

  She cried out, body buckling and Rei had to hold her steady as Sawyer milked climax after climax from between her thighs. Theo was starting to think she might break, but when Sawyer finally pulled back, she righted herself, flushed and grinning.

  Sawyer scrambled quickly to his feet, unbuttoning his fly with a fierce urgency. His erection bounced out, just as turgid as Theo’s.

  “I need some attention here,” he announced.

  Andi laughed. “Not me.”

  She rolled off Rei, which left him suddenly exposed, fully clothed still and face to face with Sawyer’s cock. Rei and Sawyer looked as surprised as each other. Then Sawyer turned almost inexplicably shy.

  “Oh.”

  “Is this okay?” Rei asked, uncertain.

  Sawyer studied him a moment, then stepped closer, cupping Rei’s face in both his hands and leaning down to kiss him soundly on the lips. Rei seemed to throw everything into that kiss. Every hope, every ounce of passion. Theo felt a little faint just watching.

  When Sawyer broke away, he seemed a little unsteady on his feet. Rei didn’t give him any time to recover though. Staying Sawyer’s hips with one hand, he grasped his shaft in the other and took it in his mouth. Sawyer’s eyes went wide and he stiffened. Theo could see every centimetre of Sawyer’s cock vanishing as it slid past Rei’s lips, all the way to the hilt. He’d had no idea Rei could deep throat so well.

  Clearly Sawyer didn’t either, paralysed with want, one hand on the back of Rei’s head. Rei took his time, pulling back slowly, cheeks hollow, tongue working.

  “Fuck,” Sawyer groaned.

  Andi, perched on the bed behind Rei, catching her breath, giggled.

  Rei slowly increased his speed, caressing Sawyer’s balls, using his hand and mouth in tandem. Sawyer was gasping, head back, hips arched forward. Theo didn’t think the blond would be able to hold it in much longer, but then abruptly he pulled back—ceasing Rei’s ministrations.

  “I want to see you fuck a girl,” he said to Rei.

  Rei blinked. “W-what?”

  “I want to watch you fuck Andi,” Sawyer clarified.

  Rei opened and closed his mouth, dumbfounded. “I don’t know if I—”

  Sawyer leaned down and kissed him again, hard. “I’ll be right here.”

  Rei turned to Andi and she grinned. “It’s okay, vaginas aren’t bear traps.”

  He swallowed, then glanced at Sawyer’s still raging erection and nodded. Sawyer grinned and grabbed Rei’s shirt, wrestling him out of it while Andi crawled up behind him and undid his pants. He still looked a little stunned, so she kissed him on the cheek, then wriggled up the bed to lie down with her head on the pillows while Sawyer removed Rei’s pants and boxers, dumping those on the mounting pile on the floor.

  Rei crawled up Andi’s body, unsure. However, despite that, his cock was hard—clearly visible to Theo between his legs.

  “Is this your first time with a girl?” she asked.

  Rei nodded.

  She grinned. “You don’t have to. Just tell him to fuck off. We don’t need him, we can order pizza.”

  Rei smiled back. “No, I want to.”

  “Pizza,” she offered again with wide eyes. He shook his head, amused, and kissed her. She kissed him back, her arms sliding around his neck. Theo watched in fascination as Rei’s cock drew closer and closer to the join in Andi’s legs. His own erection was throbbing, desperate for release, but he was still ignoring it.

  Sawyer too, seemed fascinated with Rei’s heterosexual deflowering and was on his knees beside them, his own hard-on equally as abandoned as Theo’s. He slid his hand across Rei’s ass and stroked his balls, causing Rei to pull back from his embrace with Andi with a gasp.

  “In,” Sawyer coaxed, guiding the head of Rei’s penis into position. Rei groaned, rolling his hips forward as Andi arched under him, wrapping her legs around his butt and pulling him into her. He was in, all the way in. Heterosexual virgin no longer. Theo’s hand came to rest on his own cock as Rei began to thrust. Andi gasped, controlling his movement with her legs.

  Suddenly Sawyer was up on his feet, though Rei didn’t seem to notice, too engrossed on Andi.

  “Lube,” Sawyer said to Theo, his gaze flicking briefly to Theo’s cock, then away. “I need lube.”

  “Uh, try Rei’s toiletry bag?” Theo suggested, voice thick. He swallowed, watching Rei’s cock slide in and out of Andi. For a moment, they seemed to have forgotten anyone else. Theo couldn’t ignore his own need anymore. He felt like his balls were about to explode. He started to stroke himself, his body ready to quicken and release almost instantly, but Andi caught his gaze.

  She flashed him that wicked smile and motioned for him to come closer. It was like she had a cord running through his spine and out through his cock, drawing him in. There was no power in him to resist. He crossed the room, pulling off his shirt and kicking off his boxers as he went, then joined them on the bed.

  “Stay on your knees, come here,” she said, still gasping with every thrust. He made his way over to her, careful to avoid the masses of black curls, spilling across the sheets. She leaned toward him, eager and he thrust his hips forward, so his cock was between Andi and Rei’s faces. Using a free hand she drew it to her mouth, sucking him in deep—hot and very wet.

  Rei’s eyes were closed, his teeth bared as he pumped—the bed rocking with his exertions. Theo put one hand on his friend’s shoulder to steady himself as Andi drew his cock into the back of her throat, licking and sucking, her hand sliding up and down the shaft to make up for the length she’d couldn’t handle.

  Sawyer reappeared from the bathroom, eyes cloudy with want, lube in his hand. He scrambled onto the mattress, fitting in behind Rei, one hand on his ass to let him know he was there. Rei slowed, but didn’t entirely stop as Sawyer spread the lube—a little more than was necessary—across Rei’s asshole. His fingers probed, pressed and then slid inside and Rei gasped, his whole body going rigid. For a moment, he didn’t seem to be able to move—every nerve and brain-cell keyed into Sawyer and how he was touching him. Andi whined in frustration, sucking Theo harder as if th
at would somehow kick-start the movement again. He gasped, shuddered, and almost came.

  Sawyer seemed to decide that three fingers all the way in was enough and withdrew, replacing them with the fatter, much more solid head of his cock.

  “Rei,” he breathed.

  “Fuck me,” Rei said, with a hot urgent sort of need.

  Sawyer didn’t wait for further instructions. Rei gave a cry as Sawyer slid forward, deep into his asshole and he was pinned between them, Sawyer and Andi, fucking and being fucked at the same time.

  Sawyer began to thrust, the motion moving Rei against Andi and she moaned and rocked her hips, working Rei from underneath as Sawyer worked him from above. They were moving in perfect tandem, and between them Rei’s cries were becoming more and more animal, his arms and shoulders slick with sweat as Sawyer bent over him to kiss along his spine.

  Andi released Theo’s cock to say: “Get him up, Sawyer.”

  Theo was baffled, focused only on the sudden lack of lips around his dick, but Sawyer seemed to understand, putting one arm around Rei’s middle and helping him up so they were both on their knees, Rei’s back to Sawyer’s chest, Sawyer’s cock still buried deep in Rei’s ass.

  Rei’s cock stood stiff and glistening with Andi’s wetness, so hard it almost looked painful. He was panting, beyond words now. He tried to reach for himself, but Sawyer pinned his arms.

  “Suck him, Theo,” Andi said with a smile.

  “Me?” As if there was another Theo somewhere in the tangle of limbs.

  She nodded. “I want you inside me, but someone needs to finish Rei off first.”

  Theo hesitated. His cock and balls felt like they were going to explode, but he’d never been with a man before. Never had any interest at all. It wasn’t that it grossed him out, he just… wasn’t attracted to men. He liked women. He liked Andi. However it wasn’t like he was going to have a problem getting hard. He was already as hard as he could get without doing some sort of permanent damage. And it wasn’t like Rei was going to take long either.

  He dropped to all fours, Rei’s cock bouncing in his face, brushing against his chin and smearing it with slick moisture. He could smell Andi—that musky, spicy scent of a woman. That decided him.

  He took Rei in his mouth—tasting of Andi, smelling of Andi. Rei’s cock felt a lot bigger in his mouth than it had looked a moment earlier and Theo had not developed the same tolerant gag reflex as Andi or Rei. Still, he knew how he liked his own dick touched and swirled his tongue around the head, flicking, sucking as best he could. He felt Rei’s hand on his head and then he almost gagged as Sawyer started to thrust again. Hard. Harder, Theo was sure, than he had been when Rei had still been inside Andi.

  Rei cried out. Again. Again. Theo was breathing through his nose, trying to focus. No teeth, lots of tongue, don’t gag. Then Rei spasmed. Hot and salty, his cum sprayed down Theo’s throat, across his tongue. He couldn’t pull away, Rei’s hand was holding him in place as he pumped, jet after jet of semen, right into Theo’s mouth.

  Theo protested, but with his mouth full it was just a gagged moaning. He swallowed, several times. Then Rei seemed to come back to his senses and let Theo go.

  “Sorry,” he gasped.

  Theo scrambled back, wiping his mouth and shooting Rei a sour look. Sawyer and Andi both laughed.

  “Come here, you,” Theo growled. He snagged Andi around the waist and dragged her close. She playfully fought back, but he kissed her anyway—letting her taste herself and Rei in his mouth. She gave up trying to get away, kissing him back, her body moulding against his, hot and urgent.

  Rei dropped to his hands and knees, trying to catch his breath. Behind him, Sawyer rolled his hips slowly. “I’m not done yet,” he said.

  “Shut up and finish then,” Rei said.

  Theo flipped Andi onto her back. Sawyer wasn’t the only one who wasn’t finished yet. She looked up at Rei and grinned.

  “Hi.”

  He chuckled. “Hi. How you going down there?”

  “Oh, well, you know. Still disappointed you didn’t choose pizza.”

  Theo lifted her hips and guided his cock inside her, thrusting hard. She was tight and hot and her body arched off the bed with a cry that was half pleasure, half surprise.

  “Still want pizza?” Theo asked.

  “Will you all shut up?” Sawyer demanded, eyes closed, finding his rhythm again.

  Rei lowered his head enough to kiss Andi and she caught a hold of the back of his neck. Inside her, Theo could feel her body gripping his shaft and with every thrust she pushed back against him. Harder, deeper. He could feel the spasms building inside her and she let Rei go—needing to gasp, to cry out, voice rising as her body clenched around him. Her insides were like a fist, clamping around him and he couldn’t take any more, coming hard. Harder than he’d ever come in his life, every thrust jetting another squirt of seed inside her.

  Sawyer peaked too, his whole body arching, every muscle straining as he finished, buried deep in Rei, out of control as he fell.

  Theo collapsed beside Andi, pulling her into his arms and Sawyer curled around Rei like a python. For a few minutes, there was only heavy breathing. Theo could feel his pulse in his skin. He could feel Andi’s heart beating through her ribs—pressed to his chest. He could taste her, and Rei, and he could not remember once in his life being as completely satisfied as he felt in that moment.

  Andi poked him.

  “Shower.”

  “What?”

  “Come and shower with me.”

  “Now? Give me ten minutes. My legs don’t work yet.”

  She grinned at him. “Now.”

  “Okay, okay.”

  Saying it didn’t make it easier, and it took him a few goes to propel himself to his feet. He held out his hand to her and pulled her up too. Together, they hunted through the tangle of fabric on the floor for their clothes and slipped into the bathroom.

  “Do you always have to hose off the moment you finish having sex?” Theo asked as she turned on the water.

  She chuckled. “No, I just wanted to give them time alone. Together. They need that right now. If we stayed with them, it would give Sawyer an excuse to laugh it all off.”

  Theo shook his head in wonder. “You really do know us scary well.”

  “Don’t say it like it’s a bad thing,” she scolded.

  After Theo and Andi’s shower, once they were dressed and out of the bathroom, they found Rei and Sawyer still lying on the bed in a tangle of limbs, heads together and deep in conversation. Theo opened the door to the balcony, ushering Andi out into the cool evening air.

  The muted sounds of the Chicago night rolled over them. Clouds were low, reflecting the city lights in foggy orange and it smelled like rain. Theo glanced back in through the glass sliding door to the bed, watching Sawyer’s foot slid across Rei’s ankle affectionately.

  “I can’t believe I’m saying this, but… it might have worked,” Theo said.

  “Ye of so little faith,” Andi grinned.

  “So was that your plan?” he shifted closer to her, snaking one hand around her waist to pull her closer. She obliged and the front of her hips pressed against his. “Show up and solve all our problems. From socks to snacks to love?”

  “Maybe,” she teased quietly.

  He slid his hand into her back pocket. “I’m not complaining, I just—”

  He froze. There was stone lump between his fingers. A leather cord. The smooth surface was intimately familiar to him. He withdrew his hand, and the necklace that had been stuffed into her back pocket. The bottle green stone flashed dully in the light. He met her gaze, surprise slowly turning into a cold, hard anger.

  “This is mine.”

  “Theo—”

  He stepped back, pulling away from her. He felt sick, all twisted up inside. She’d been the one who’d stolen his necklace. She’d been the one who was selling it. He’d let her in, kissed her, participated in her twisted little game and all the time
she…

  “Stay the fuck away from me,” he said, voice low and cold. “I don’t ever want to see you again.”

  “Wait, Theo,” she tried to grab his wrist and he snatched his hand back. He went for the door and she blocked his exit, pressing her back against the glass. “Please listen.”

  He growled. If it had been one of the boys he would have shoved them out of the way, but he couldn’t do that to a woman. Even one who stole from him and was now holding him hostage on a balcony.

  “Move. Right now. Or I will have security throw your lying ass out onto the street!” he snarled, right in her face.

  Her eyes went wide and she flinched aside. He yanked the door open, storming across the room and out into the corridor. He thumped the elevator button over and over until the doors opened.

  As it descended, he clenched the stone tight in his hand, the leather cord cutting off the circulation in his fingers. That huge act about being on their side, having their best interests at heart. He’d actually thought…

  The elevator doors opened and he walked out of the hotel lobby onto the street. Then he realised he didn’t even have shoes on. No wallet. Bare feet. No phone. He couldn’t just storm off like this. He didn’t want to go back upstairs either.

  “Theo!” Andi jogged out the hotel doors, looking faintly panicked. She gave a sigh of relief when she saw him, then made her way quickly to his side. “Will you listen, please?”

  “Why would I ever listen to anything you had to say, ever again?” he demanded.

  “Because I didn’t steal the necklace. I won the necklace.”

  “What?” he froze, thinking it over. That story didn’t make sense. “No you didn’t. The auction only ended a few hours ago.”

  “I did. I picked it up already. I was about to give it to you, but you stuck your hand in my pocket right before I…” she gave him a crooked grin.