Four Cowboys & a Witch

by Cheryl Dragon

  Trey laughed. “I watched you grow up. You can eat anything and never gain an ounce. You’re the girl who fainted all the time. Everyone said you were delicate.”

  “Yeah, sounds better than she’s psychic. Her brain becomes overwhelmed with too much information.” Dani added syrup.

  “If we start to bombard you, just yell.” Ben sat next to her.

  “I can handle you guys. It’s mostly sex stuff.” She stopped and bit her lip. “Sorry. I’m truly better at handling this stuff now.”

  “Why hide with us? We know what we want.” Sam grabbed a piece of bacon.

  When Dani stayed quiet too long, Trey jumped in. “I want to show you the ranch. Sam and Rodney are going to check up on a current case this morning. Ben has to go into town for more supplies. So I’ll be your guide.”

  She smiled. “Sounds good. I miss the open spaces and clearing your mind with a long walk or horseback ride.”

  After breakfast, they all went their separate ways. Trey led Dani out the back door. They walked toward the barn.

  “Sorry if the group is a little pushy. Ben gets overly excited.” Trey led the way.

  “I remember. It’s fine. Back then I had my own group of friends who protected me. Oddly enough, I thought all you guys were gay. Your interest in joining us is flattering, but you can’t do that sort of magic based on lust.” Dani walked into the barn and inhaled.

  “We’re all bisexual. Magic is Rodney and Ben’s area. I don’t know about that stuff. I love to ranch, and I don’t like creatures disturbing our way of life. You are a twist for us. A blast from the past. Of course, I couldn’t have a thing for my best friend’s little sister. He’d have kicked my ass.”

  “You were sleeping with Ben anyway.” Dani twirled and fell back on a pile of hay. “I do miss it.”

  “I know you had a crush on me.” He flopped down next to her.

  “Duh. Everyone knew. I was in middle school. First loves are frequently foolish and innocent. I’m glad you’re still with Ben.” She held his hand.

  Trey rolled to her. “It’s not just lust, Dani.”

  “It’s complicated. That’s life.” She stared at him. “You four are good together.”

  “We are -- but we could be better.” He almost leaned in for a kiss, but she stood and dusted off her rear before he could.

  Trey got up and led the walk out the back to the horses. She headed calmly to the horses. They came to her like she had treats. All her life, Dani’d had a way with animals, the sort of talent locals passed off as just being a good rancher. Trey knew she liked animals because they didn’t hide their feelings or manipulate people. They were honest creatures. It was part of why he loved them too.

  He walked up behind her and patted the big bay. “When I was a kid, doubting myself, I could always ride. The horses didn’t care if I liked girls or boys -- or both.”

  Dani smiled. “Pure love and trust, if you earn it… plus no judgment from a horse. So, you were confused back then? You’re really into both?”

  Trey nodded. “Only fight that almost busted up me and Ben. We both thought the other one was cheating. It turned out we were attracted to the same woman. We tried, but it was complicated.”

  “Rodney and Sam too?” Dani looked unconvinced.

  “Yeah, those two went to college and did a lot of experimenting. They badly miss having a woman. The group came together when they graduated and were looking for a place to land. It works. I know it’s crazy, but it’d work even better with a woman in the mix.” Trey leaned on the fence. “I know it sounds like too much. Four men?”

  She looked out at the horizon. He could see the wheels turning as she processed all the information. “You okay?” he asked.

  “Sure. So you guys sell the horses? Looks like a breeding operation. No cattle.” She took in the stock.

  “Good eye. Sam’s got a relation in the breeding biz who gave him a deal on stock. They needed to sell off some. Too much inbreeding is bad. He picked up some others to make new lines. He and I pretty much run the ranch side of things. Rodney does the books. Ben likes to play cook.”

  “Cook and lord of the manor.” She smiled. “You four haven’t changed a bit.”

  “Neither have you.” Trey studied her. “Not the real you.”

  * * *

  After lunch, Dani called to reschedule her appointment with the lawyer. Then she retreated to her bedroom for a nap. The men needed her. It was a fantasy come true. After seeing the world they lived in and hearing from Trey how things had unfolded, she couldn’t shut down her feelings. Her desire for multiple men hadn’t eased at all.

  The men shared one bedroom and a lot of passion. It’d haunted her dreams the night before, but in the light of day, Dani knew how crazy it sounded. Who else could she be crazy with? Four men running a ranch, fine… But sharing one woman?

  Dani had loved Texas growing up. The barbeques, horses, and boots were hard to give up, but it was more difficult to hide her powers when everyone was in everyone else’s business. She could help people and be anonymous out east.

  Whispers that she was a witch or a demon had started when she was in middle school. Her parents ignored it, downplayed it, and kept her inside as much as possible. They didn’t know how to handle it. She couldn’t blame them.

  She wouldn’t go back to hiding and not using what God and the Goddess had given her. Aunt Millie said there was room for both. Dani was no longer a child. If someone was embarrassed by her, they could go away.

  Dani set the small box of ashes on the vanity. Aunt Millie had lived alone, never married and never complained. The plan had been for Dani to do the same. She didn’t want to pass the gift down to anyone or drag someone into her stress. The men here had plans of their own. She sensed their intentions in every move they made. She’d have to be strong to resist.

  Looking in the mirror, she knew she didn’t want to resist, though. The sexual fantasy of a lifetime was here, but the feelings she had for them hadn’t disappeared, either. She loved them all, and somehow she was meant to be here with them now. Destiny had made a believer out of her back in high school. In her vision, Sam had mounted the horse in the chute, and she’d seen him fall, trapped with one leg under the horse.

  If only she’d seen it sooner. The others had run in after him and stopped the round. He might’ve been killed if they’d delayed the rescue, but his leg had still ended up badly busted. Yet he didn’t hold a grudge against animals. They were all amazing men. How could she resist the short term temptation?

  She headed downstairs and found all four of them in their man cave. They were intentionally giving her space. Right now all she wanted was to be close to them. Dating was difficult for a psychic. If the man had no clue of her gifts, she couldn’t resist picking his brain for big warning signs. If the man knew about her, he wanted to test her or play games.

  These four men had never used her or called her a liar. The relationship was special, whatever form it took. She couldn’t see her own future, the one block to her impressive powers, so she trusted her instincts and tried not to second guess them. Aunt Millie had drawn her back here for a reason. Despite all the meditation Dani had done before returning to Texas, she’d yet to see Aunt Millie’s spirit near her.

  She slid onto Ben’s lap and took off her boots and socks. Her bare feet found Sam’s leg and soaked up the energy of his nagging ache.

  “You okay? Look like you’ve seen a ghost.” Trey smiled.

  “No, I’m not a good medium, but I thought I would see Aunt Millie -- or at least feel her -- but nothing yet. Am I in the way?” she asked.

  “Never.” Rodney put the computer aside. “I would like to pick your brain at some point on this case.”

  “Sure, but I don’t feel like that’s on your mind now.” She ran her hand over his chest. The soft cotton T-shirt did nothing to keep the heat from her palm. He was always so contained on the outside, but Rodney felt deeply.

  “Are you sure about this?” Sam
asked.

  She slid to his lap and smiled. “Maybe my powers are misreading everyone. I don’t want to cause any trouble. You four have a great thing going here.”

  “This isn’t about your powers, Dani. It’s about you. What you want.” Ben kicked off his boots and tugged at Trey’s.

  Dani pressed to Sam and kissed him slowly. The fire took hold. She deepened the kiss as his arms held her. Rodney’s lips found her shoulder and then the back of her neck. When his tongue teased behind her ear, Dani pulled Rod toward Sam into a three-way kiss. Awkward at first, she found the men loved kissing each other as much as her. It wasn’t too much. In fact, she wanted more.

  After Sam tugged off Rod’s shirt, Rod did the same to Sam. Dani let her hands trail over their muscles. She sucked a flat nipple on each man and groans rewarded her. She ran her hands boldly over their flies. The heat of their sexual energy nearly knocked her back.

  “Easy. You don’t want to faint. We’re not going to overload your psychic powers.” Ben slid up behind her and held her.

  Trey nodded. “We were worried about that.”

  Dani shook her head. “I’ve had sex, but it’s different with four. I can block out your feelings, though, now that I’m used to it.”

  Ben pulled her shirt over her head.

  Kissing him, she focused on her needs while keeping her mind out of theirs. It worked so well that her arousal took center stage. Taking off Trey’s shirt, she saw the scars. He’d been a rodeo rider for a bit too. He’d stopped when he’d earned a bunch of stitches. She leaned in and kissed them as Ben unhooked her bra.

  Once the scrap of cotton was gone, too many hands to count slid over her body. Trey kissed her breast then reached behind her to strip Ben’s shirt off. Dani pulled Trey up. She kissed his mouth then turned and kissed Ben.

  “Does it always take this long to get everyone naked?” she asked.

  Ben laughed. “No, but men tend to go right for the naked action.”

  “Not that we’re not romantic. We’re very affectionate. We are. Hit the sex button, though, then things work faster.” Trey nipped her neck.

  She smiled. “You’re going slow so I don’t feel rushed.”

  “No rush. No overloading you. We’ve got all the time in the world.” Rodney opened Sam’s fly and pulled out his cock.

  Dani moaned as she stared at the pulsing shaft. There were four men all around her. Dani’s pussy grew wetter at the idea. Her fingers grazed Sam’s balls as Rodney pushed the jeans down. Sam unbuttoned Rodney’s fly while Dani did the same to Trey. The men coordinated expertly. Dani found Ben stripping her jeans off as the other three shed their clothing. Everyone was naked in seconds. Then Trey turned his attention to taking Ben’s clothes off.

  Sitting on the couch, she took in the view of all four of them, hard and sexy. She wanted every one of them. When Ben went into a bathroom, she wondered if the moment had passed. Then he returned with two big handfuls of familiar packets.

  She grabbed some. There were condoms and lube. They were definitely prepared. “You guys must go through a lot of these.”

  “Safety first.” Ben kissed her as he set the piles on the end table.

  Dani pulled Trey into the kiss then eased back to watch the men get into each other. She looked over to Sam and Rodney. They’d taken it to the next level. Sam sucked Rodney’s cock as Rodney stroked Sam’s.

  She kneeled on the couch, and stared up at Trey and Ben kissing. Leaning forward, she licked their erections. It was real. The amazing view of them pressed together so their cocks nearly touched made it even better. She sucked the tips and tongued down the length of each. Groping their balls, she let herself get lost in the sensations.

  Sam’s hand slid between her legs. Dani moaned as his fingers worked magic on her slit. She couldn’t deny what she wanted and grabbed a condom. Dani tossed the packet on Sam’s stomach. He took the hint. As she kissed him, she straddled his hips. Once the protection was in place, she slid down on his cock until she had it all.

  “We knew you’d fit right in.” Rodney kissed her then Sam.

  Dani rode her cowboy. She kissed him until he took over, gripping her hips. Both of their mouths turned to Rodney and sucked his cock. One man wasn’t enough. Dani had to admit she’d never been fully satisfied with previous boyfriends.

  “Ever tried two?” Rod asked her.

  “No. Can you handle it?” she asked.

  Smiling, Sam slid his ass toward the end of the couch. Dani shivered at the new angle and rode his cock harder. She’d tried anal sex before, but it sounded much better with her pussy filled as well.

  The men chuckled. Rod moved behind her. Ben stood on the couch and offered her his cock. Dani couldn’t hide her smile as she kissed him playfully. The sex took over as Rod rubbed the lube into her ass.

  “Relax. Don’t try to take too much too fast,” Rod whispered in her ear.

  Dani nodded, squeezing Sam’s cock in her pussy. More pleasure filled her as Rod’s cock entered. She tensed for a second. Sam rubbed around her clit until she gave in.

  Riding two cocks, Dani couldn’t juggle sucking a third, as well. She squeezed Ben’s balls as she rocked on the cocks inside of her. Sam lifted harder and faster. The orgasm built in her. When Trey appeared on her other side, he sucked her breasts, biting and pulling at them. She gave in. Her climax hit. She tightened on Sam as he came.

  “That’s it. Take what you want, Dani.” Sam’s head fell back on the sofa.

  Rodney leaned over and kissed Sam as his arms wrapped around her waist. Her hands clung to Sam, but Rodney lifted her up. He moved her to Trey, who was sitting there already hard.

  The control these men had impressed her. Rodney settled her onto Trey. He guided her hips so she could take his cock. The stretching and pressure of two cocks made her tremble. She kissed Trey, letting the men do the work for a bit as her body grew accustomed to having her fantasy fulfilled.

  Sam knelt, facing her on the couch. He kissed her breasts then Trey’s mouth. Sam groaned, leaning on Trey. She held Trey and looked up to see Ben rubbing lube into Sam’s ass. Fascinated, she knew the four shared openly, but seeing men screwing each other up close was a new turn on.

  Watching Ben’s thick cock fill Sam’s ass sent flashes of need mixed with pleasure through her body. It wasn’t all about her, yet she knew they all wanted her. Dani felt their passionate love, but they had it for each other as well. The pressure wasn’t all on her. They could all find satisfaction with one another. The lust was etched on Ben’s face as he fucked Sam’s ass.

  She kissed Sam as he groaned and rocked back. Trust plus love made it work. Giving in, she fucked her men as their love took her. Rodney stayed deep in her ass as he grunted in release. Trey’s thrusts came faster, rubbing against sensitive spots made even more tender with Rodney stretching her ass. Arching her back, she screamed as her orgasm hit deep.

  Trey held her hips down on him. She ground for more until he shouted her name. Sam gripped her hair and kissed her as Ben changed to short, hard strokes. The men drove rougher on each other. Dani let their darker needs flood her senses. Sam shuddered in release as Ben buried himself deep, grunting like an animal.

  It almost felt like Dani was floating as they recovered. Rod eased from her as Ben did the same from Sam. Ben kissed her hard as Trey held her tight. When she looked over her shoulder, Sam was kissing Rod on the floor. No jealousy or judgment.

  “I want to fuck all of you,” she said.

  “We want that too, but you don’t rush amazing stuff like this.” Ben bit her lower lip.

  Trey squeezed her ass cheeks. “Besides, you don’t think we like fucking each other? We’re just settling for that while waiting for you to come home?”

  “No! Obviously you guys are very hot together. I’m impressed at how open it all is. Group sex… I thought it’d be complicated.” She shrugged.

  “The key is love. If you love each other then it’s all good. That’s the online coven guidelines too
. If you try to use sex to enhance spells or powers, it has to come from love. If you just use lust then you get bad results. We had the good stuff before we even joined the coven, but adding you made it stronger,” Rodney said.

  “Did you try a spell? I didn’t sense it.” Dani slid off Trey to sit on the couch between him and Ben.

  “No, not this time. We don’t need to have great sex for the sake of magic. It was for us. Want more?” Rodney sucked Sam’s cock.

  Her body tingled. That had been round one. She nodded. “Maybe we should try the bed?”

  Chapter Three

  As the group cleaned up after breakfast the next day, Rodney watched Dani carefully. She didn’t seem to regret the encounter. He’d felt her power. The energy she possessed had knocked him back. If she channeled all of her energy into a spell, they could have real protection.

  “Stop staring, Rodney,” she said.

  “Sorry. You’re gorgeous.” He kissed her.

  She shook her head. “You’re thinking about work.”

  “Protecting the guys isn’t really work. It’ll help the mission regardless of the case. I don’t have your natural gifts, but I’m studying.” He added soap to the dishwasher before closing it. “I would like to pick your brain on the current case. We’re out of plausible ideas.”

  Trey wrapped his arms around her from behind. “Come on. Cattle are being killed. You can’t say no to innocent animals being slaughtered, their meat left to rot. There are no clues.”

  “Yeah, we could use a fresh brain. People are talking crazy.” Sam shook his head.

  “I’ll do what I can. I’m no expert in the supernatural.” She shrugged.

  Rodney watched Sam shift his weight on the messed up leg. It was really bothering him today, and Rodney hurt for him. “Not to change the subject, Dani, but if you need a good reason to try a sex spell, we could try to heal Sam’s leg.”

  Dani’s expression turned serious. “I haven’t done many spells. I’m not a natural healer. I’m a psychic, with a tiny slice of a medium’s gifts. Sam’s injury is pretty old.”