The Fallen Man jlajc-12

by Tony Hillerman

  Rosebrough shook his head. “It took teams of good climbers years to find the way you can get from the bottom to the top. Even that’s no cinch. It involves doing a lot of exposed climbing, with a rope to save you if you slip. Then you have to climb down a declivity to reach the face where you can go up again. That’s the way everybody who’s ever got to the top of Ship Rock got there.

  And as far as I know, that’s the way everybody always got down.”

  “So there isn’t any ‘fast way down’?”

  Rosebrough gave that some thought. “There has been some speculation of a shortcut. But it would involve a lot of rappelling, and I never heard of anyone actually trying it. I think it’s way too dangerous.” They were moving away from Ship Rock now, making the long slide down toward the Farmington Airport. Leaphorn was feeling better. He was thinking that whatever Breedlove had meant by the fast way down, he had certainly done something dangerous.

  “I’m thinking about that rappel route,” Rosebrough said. “If he tried that by himself, that would help explain where they found the skeleton.” He was looking at Leaphorn quizzically. “You’re awfully quiet, Joe. Are you okay? You’re looking pale.”

  “I’m feeling pale,” Leaphorn said, “but I’m quiet because I’m thinking about the other two people who made the climb with him that day. Didn’t they get all the way up? Or what?”

  “Who were they?” Rosebrough asked. “I know most of the serious rock climbers in this part of the world.”

  “We don’t know,” Leaphorn said. “All we have are the notes of an old mountain watcher. Sort of shorthand, too. He just jotted down nine slash eighteen slash eighty-five and said three men had parked at the jump-off site and were climbing the—”

  “Wait a minute,” Rosebrough said. “You said nine eighteen eighty-five? That’s not the date Breedlove wrote. He put down nine thirty eighty-five.”

  Leaphorn digested that. No thought of nausea now. “You’re sure?” he asked. “Breedlove dated his climb September thirty. Not September eighteen.”

  “I’m dead certain,” Rosebrough said. “That’s what the photo is going to show. Was I confused or something?”

  “No,” Leaphorn said. “I was the one who was confused.”

  67 of 102

  15/03/2008 19:57

  TheFallenMan

  file:///C:/Documents%20and%20Settings/Floop/Local%20Settings/Te...

  “You sure you feel all right?”

  “I feel fine,” Leaphorn said. Actually he was feeling embarrassed. He had been conned, and it had taken him eleven years to get his first solid inkling of how they had fooled him.

  23

  CHEE HAD DECIDED THE GREASE

  in the frying pan was hot enough and was pulling the easy-open lid off the can of Vienna sausages when the headlight beam flashed across his window. He flicked off his house trailer’s overhead light—something he wouldn’t have considered doing a few days ago.

  But his cracked ribs still ached, and the person who had caused that was still out there somewhere. Possibly in the car that was now rolling to a stop under the cottonwood outside.

  Whoever had driven it got out and walked into the headlights where Chee could see him. It was Joe Leaphorn, the Legendary Lieutenant, again. Chee groaned, said, “Oh, shit!” and switched on the light.

  Leaphorn entered hat in hand. “It’s getting cold,” he said. “The TV forecaster said there’s a snow warning out for the Four Corners.

  Livestock warning. All that.”

  “It’s just about time for that first bad one,” Chee said. “Can I take your hat?” Which got Leaphorn’s mind off the weather. “No. No,” he said, looking apologetic. He regretted the intrusion, the lateness of the hour, the interruption of Chee’s supper. He would only take a moment. He wanted Chee to see what they’d found in the ammunition box on top of Ship Rock. He extracted a sheaf of photographs from the big folder he’d been carrying and handed them to Chee.

  Chee spread them on the table.

  “Note the date of the signature,” Leaphorn said. “It’s the week after Breedlove disappeared from Canyon de Chelly.” Chee considered that. “Wow,” he said. And considered it again. He studied the photograph. “Is this it? No one else signed the book that day?”

  “Only Breedlove,” Leaphorn said. “And I’m told that it’s traditional for everyone in the climbing party to sign if they get to the top.”

  “Well, now,” Chee said. He tapped the inscription. “It looks like Latin. Do you know what it means?” Leaphorn told him the translation. “But what did he mean by it? Your guess is as good as mine.” He explained to Chee what Rosebrough had told him about the ‘fast way down’ remark—that if Hal had tried this dangerous rappelling route it might explain how his body came to be on the ledge where it was found.

  They stood at the table, Chee staring at the photograph and Leaphorn watching Chee. The aroma of extremely hot grease forced itself into Leaphorn’s consciousness, along with the haze of blue smoke that accompanied it. He cleared his throat.

  “Jim,” he said. “I think I interrupted your cooking.”

  “Oh,” Chee said. He dropped the photograph, snatched the smoking pan off the propane burner, and deposited it outside on the doorstep. “I was going to scramble some eggs and mix in these sausages,” he said. “If you haven’t eaten I can dump in a few more.”

  “Fine,” said Leaphorn, who had deposited his breakfast in the barf bag, had been suffering too much residual queasiness for lunch, and had been too busy since to stop for dinner. In his current condition, even the smell of burning grease aroused his hunger.

  They replaced the photos with plates, retrieved the frying pan, replenished the incinerated grease with a chunk of margarine, put on the coffeepot, performed those other duties required to prepare dinner in a very restricted space, and dined. Leaphorn had always tried to avoid Vienna sausages even as emergency rations but now he found the mixture remarkably palatable. While he attacked his second helping, Chee picked up the crucial photograph and resumed his study.

  “I hesitate to mention it,” Chee said, “but what do you think of the date?”

  “You mean being a date when the keen eye of Hosteen Sam saw no one climbing Ship Rock?”

  “Exactly,” Chee said.

  “I’ve reached no precise conclusion,” Leaphorn said. “What do you think?”

  “About the same,” Chee said. “And how about nobody at all signing the book twelve days earlier? What do you think about that?

  I’m thinking that the three people who old man Sam saw climbing up there must not have made it to the top. Either that, or they were too modest to take credit for it. Or, if his ledger hadn’t told me how exactly precise Sam was, I’d think he got his dates wrong.” Leaphorn was studying him. “You think there’s no chance of that, then?”

  “I’d say none. Zero. You should see the way he kept that ledger. That’s not the explanation. Forget it.” 68 of 102

  15/03/2008 19:57

  TheFallenMan

  file:///C:/Documents%20and%20Settings/Floop/Local%20Settings/Te...

  Leaphorn nodded. “Okay, I will.”

  The entry signed by Breedlove was near the center of the page. Above it the register had been signed by four men, none with names familiar to Chee, and dated April 4, 1983. Below it, a three-climber party—two with Japanese names—had registered their conquest of the Rock with Wings on April 28, 1988.

  “Skip back to September eighteenth,” Leaphorn said. “Let’s say that Hal was one of the three Hosteen Sam saw climbing. It sounds like the car they climbed out of was that silly British recreation vehicle he drove. And then let’s say they didn’t make it to the top because Hal screwed up. So Hal broods about it. He gets the call at Canyon de Chelly from one of his climbing buddies. He decides to go back and try again.”

  “All right,” Chee said. “Then we’ll suppose the climbing buddy went with him, they tried the dangerous way down. This time the climbing buddy—and le
t’s call him George Shaw—well, George screws up and drops Hal down the cliff. He feels guilty and he figures Hal’s dead anyway, so slips away and tells no one.”

  “Yeah,” Leaphorn said. “I thought about that. Trouble is, why hadn’t the climbing buddy signed the register before they started down?”

  Chee shook his head, dealt Leaphorn some more of the Vienna-and-eggs mixture, and put down the pan.

  “Modesty, you think?” Leaphorn said. “He didn’t want to take the credit?”

  “The only reason I can think of involves first-degree murder,” Chee said. “The premeditated kind.”

  “Right,” Leaphorn said. “Now, how about a motive?”

  “Easy,” Chee said. “It would have something to do with the ranch, and with that moly mine deal.” Leaphorn nodded.

  “Now Hal has inherited. It’s his. So let’s say George Shaw figures Hal’s going to keep his threat and do his own deal on the mineral lease, cutting out Shaw and the rest of the family. So Shaw drops him.”

  “Maybe,” Leaphorn said. “One problem with that, though.”

  “Or maybe Demott’s the climbing buddy. He knows Hal’s going for the open strip mine, so he knocks him off to save his ranch. But what’s the problem with the first idea?”

  “Elisa inherits from Hal. Shaw would have to deal with her.”

  “Maybe he thought he could?”

  “He says he couldn’t. He told me this afternoon that Elisa was just as fanatical about the ranch as her brother. Said she told him there wouldn’t be any strip-mining on it as long as she was alive.”

  “You saw Shaw today?” Chee sounded as much shocked as surprised.

  “Sure,” Leaphorn said. “I showed him the photographs. After all, I spent his money getting them.”

  “What’d he think?”

  “He acted disappointed. Probably was. He’d like to be able to prove that Hal was dead about a week or so before he signed that register.”

  Chee nodded.

  “There’s a problem with your second theory, too.”

  “What?”

  “I was talking with Demott on the telephone September twenty-fourth. Twice, in fact.”

  “You remember that? After eleven years?”

  “No. I keep a case diary. I looked it up.”

  “Mobile phone, maybe?”

  “No. I called him at the ranch. Elisa didn’t remember the license number on the Land-Rover. I called him about the middle of the morning and he gave me the number. Then I called him again in the afternoon to make sure Breedlove hadn’t checked in. And to find out if he’d had any other calls. Anything worthwhile.”

  69 of 102

  15/03/2008 19:57

  TheFallenMan

  file:///C:/Documents%20and%20Settings/Floop/Local%20Settings/Te...

  “Well, hell,” Chee said. “Then I guess we’re left with Breedlove climbing up there alone, or with Shaw, and then taking the suicidal shortcut down.”

  Leaphorn’s expression suggested he didn’t agree with that conclusion, but he didn’t comment on it directly.

  “It also means I’m going to have to run down all these people who climbed up there in the next ten years and find out if any of them got off with a long piece of that climbing rope.”

  “Not necessarily,” Leaphorn said. “You’re forgetting our Fallen Man business is still not a crime. It’s a missing person case solved by the discovery of an accidental death.”

  “Yeah,” Chee said, doubtful.

  “It makes me glad I’m a civilian these days.”

  The wind gusted, rattling sand against the aluminum side of Chee’s home, whistling around its aluminum cracks and corners.

  “So does the weather,” Leaphorn said. “Everybody in uniform is going to be working overtime and getting frostbite this week.” Chee pointed to Leaphorn’s plate. “Want some more?”

  “I’m full. Probably ate too much. And I took too much of your time.” He got up, retrieved his hat.

  “I’m going to leave you these pictures,” he said. “Rosebrough has the negatives. He’s a lawyer. An agent of the court. They’ll stand up as evidence if it comes to that.”

  “You mean if anyone gets up there and steals the ledger?”

  “It’s a thought,” Leaphorn said. “What are you going to do tomorrow?” Chee had worked for Leaphorn long enough for this question to produce a familiar uneasy feeling. “Why?”

  “If I go up to the ranch tomorrow and show Demott and Elisa these pictures and ask her what she thinks about them, and ask her who was trying to climb that mountain on that September eighteenth date, then I think I could be accused of tampering with a witness.”

  “Witness to what? Officially there’s no crime yet,” Chee reminded him.

  “Don’t you think there will be one? Presuming we’re smart enough to get this sorted out.”

  “You mean not counting Maryboy and me? Yeah. I guess so. But you could probably get away with talking to Elisa until the official connection is made. Now you’re just a representative of the family lawyer. Perfectly legit.”

  “But why would Demott or the widow want to talk to a representative of the family’s lawyer?” Chee nodded, conceding the point.

  “And I think there’s something else I should be doing.”

  Chee let his stare ask the question.

  “Old Amos Nez trusts me,” Leaphorn said, and paused to consider it. “Well, more or less. I want to show him this evidence that Hal climbed Ship Rock just one week after he left the canyon and tell him about Maryboy being murdered, and ask him if Hal said anything about trying to climb Ship Rock just before he came to the canyon. Things like that.”

  “That could wait,” Chee said, thinking of his aching ribs and the long painful drive up into Colorado.

  “Maybe it could wait,” Leaphorn said. “But you know the other afternoon you decided Hosteen Maryboy couldn’t wait and you rushed right out there to see if he could identify those climbers for you. And you were right. Turned out it couldn’t wait.”

  “Ah,” Chee said. “But I’m not clear on what makes Amos Nez so important. You think Breedlove might have told him something?”

  “Let’s try another theory,” Leaphorn said. “Let’s say that Hal Breedlove didn’t live until his thirtieth birthday. Let’s say those people Hosteen Sam saw climbing on September eighteenth got to the top, or at least two of them did. One of the two was Hal. The other one—or maybe two—push him off. Or, more likely he just falls. Now he’s dead and he’s dead two days too soon. He’s still twenty-nine years old. So the climber’s register is falsified to show he was alive after his birthday.” Chee held up his hand, grinning. “Huge hole in that one,” he said. “Remember Hal was prowling around the canyon with his wife and Amos Nez until the twenty-third of . . . “ Chee’s voice trailed off into silence. And then he said, “Oh!” and stared at Leaphorn.

  Leaphorn was making a wry face, shaking his head. “It sure took me long enough to see that possibility,” he said. “I never could have if you hadn’t got into old man Sam’s register.”

  70 of 102

  15/03/2008 19:57

  TheFallenMan

  file:///C:/Documents%20and%20Settings/Floop/Local%20Settings/Te...

  “My God,” Chee said. “If that’s the way it worked, I can see why they have to kill Nez. And if they’re smart, the sooner the better.”

  “I’m going to ask you to call the Lazy B and find out if Demott and the widow are there and then arrange to drive up tomorrow and talk to them about what we found on top of the mountain.”

  “What if they’re not at home?”

  “Then I think we ought to be doing a little more to keep Amos Nez safe,” Leaphorn said. And he opened the door and stepped out into the icy wind.

  24

  ELISA BREEDLOVE HAD ANSWERED

  the telephone. And, yes, Eldon was home and they’d be glad to talk to him. How about sometime tomorrow afternoon?

  So Acting Lieutenant Chee show
ed up at his office in Shiprock early to get his desk cleared and make the needed arrangements. He arrived with tape plastered over the stitches around his left eye and a noticeable shiner visible behind them. He lowered himself carefully into the chair behind the desk to avoid jarring his ribs and gave Officers Teddy Begayaye, Deejay Hondo, Edison Bai, and Bernadette Manuelito a few moments to inspect the damage. In Begayaye and Bai it seemed to provoke a mixture of admiration and amusement, well suppressed. Hondo didn’t seem interested and Officer Bernie Manuelito’s face reflected a sort of shocked sympathy.

  With that out of the way, he satisfied their curiosity with a personal briefing of what actually happened at the Maryboy place, supplementing the official one they would have already received. Then down to business.

  He instructed Bai to try to find out where a .38-caliber pistol confiscated from a Shiprock High School boy had come from. He suggested to Officer Manuelito that she continue her efforts to locate a fellow named Adolph Deer, who had jumped bond after a robbery conviction but was reportedly “frequently being seen around the Two Gray Hills trading post.” He told Hondo to finish the paperwork on a burglary case that was about to go to the grand jury. Then it was Teddy Begayaye’s turn.

  “I hate to tell you, Teddy, but you’re going to have to be taxi driver today,” Chee said. “I have to go up to the Lazy B ranch on this Maryboy shooting thing. I thought I could handle it myself, but”—he lifted his left arm, flinched, and grimaced—“the old ribs aren’t quite as good as I thought they were.”

  “You shouldn’t be riding around in a car,” Officer Manuelito said. “You should be in bed, healing up. They shouldn’t have let you out of the hospital.”

  “Hospitals are dangerous,” Chee said. “People die in them.”

  Edison Bai grinned at that, but Officer Manuelito didn’t think it was funny.

  “Something goes wrong with broken ribs and you have a punctured lung,” she said.

  “They’re just cracked,” Chee said. “Just a bruise.” With that subject closed, he kept Bai behind for a fill-in about the pistol-carrying student. Typically, Bai provided far more details than Chee needed. The boy had been involved in a joyride car theft during the summer. He was born to the Streams Come Together people, his mother’s clan, and for the Salt clan, for his paternal people, but his father was also part Hopi. He was believed to be involved in the smaller and rougher of Shiprock’s juvenile gangs. He was meanness on the hoof. People weren’t raising their kids the way they used to. Chee agreed, put on his hat and hurried stiffly out the door into the parking lot. It had been chilly and clouding up when he came to work. Now there was solid overcast and an icy northwest wind swept dust and leaves past his ankles.