Three Times the Fun: A Reverse Harem Thanksgiving Love Story

by Blythe Reid

  “I’m never getting tied down, sweetheart,” Julian replied. “I’d rather catch an illness than catch feelings, you know what I mean?”

  “You’d rather get crippling herpes than date a nice girl like Morrigan?” Theo asked him.

  “Okay, no,” conceded Julian. “But, you know what I mean.”

  The bartender finally came over; it was a woman this time.

  “What’ll it be, hun?” she asked me.

  “Shot of tequila, please,” I told her.

  Both guys shot each other a look.

  “So, we going to talk about the elephant in the room?” Julian asked me.

  “Which is?” I asked coyly.

  “We both want to fuck you pretty bad,” Theo replied.

  Hearing their words gave me the chills that I was becoming accustomed to after coming through Deplicious’ doors.

  “Usually I don’t fuck the same woman twice,” interjected Julian. “But you, baby, yours is so good and so tasty, I’m willing to break all my rules to have it again.”

  “I don’t have any rules,” said Theo. “I just want to pick up where we left off.”

  “Oh wow,” I muttered.

  “So, here’s your dilemma, milady,” said Julian. “You need to pick which one of us you want.”

  “Aw- I have to pick?” I went. “I like both of you.” I offered a pout. Was I really trying to get two men to take ownership of my body at once? Fuck yeah, I was.

  “It wouldn’t be called a dilemma if it had an easy solution,” said Julian.

  I looked at both of them, feeling slightly uncomfortable at the position I was being put in.

  Then, I thought about how much fun it would be if they both had me in different positions together.

  “We could have a threesome,” I suggested.

  This proposition seemed to surprise both of them. They looked at each other, exchanging looks that only they understood.

  Before either could respond to me with words, their friend Skylar joined us, carrying a round of drinks.

  “Who wants shots?” Skylar asked the group.

  “Ah, you’re the best, chief!” said Julian, smacking Skylar’s shoulder.

  Skylar looked a few years younger than Julian and Theo, but he wasn’t as built. He was thin and lanky, but I could tell that he was toned. Once he noticed me looking him over, he began to flaunt his physique in any way that he could. It definitely helped him- along with his nice auburn hair and hazel eyes he was definitely attractive.

  “Who might you be?” Skylar asked me.

  “I’m Morrigan,” I answered.

  “Good to meet you,” he said handing me a shot.

  We all took our shots- it was a nice whiskey that went down smoothly.

  “So, what did I miss?” asked Skylar.

  I waited for one of the guys to answer, but they both looked over at me.

  “Well,” I answered. “I just offered to have a threesome with your friends here. But, they’re taking their time with an answer. So, I guess it’s a no, which is a shame. I’m not going to choose between you two. Either I’m going to have both of you, or neither of you.”

  I looked over at Skylar, wondering what he looked like without his clothes on. “Unless you want to fuck me instead?” I asked him in a sexy voice.

  “Uh, sure?” said Skylar. “Who wouldn’t want to fuck you?”

  “That’s what I was wondering,” I said while shooting a look at Julian and Theo.

  “You know,” began Skylar. “We could have a gang-bang.”

  Julian and Theo exchanged another look. It was almost humorous to be in the middle of such depravity. My heart sped up. Three men? Three cocks buried inside my body? My pussy wept at the idea of it.

  “What’s the issue?” asked Skylar. “We all know each other, right? We’re all hot and horny, we only have one life! Why don’t we live a little?”

  Theo grinned, giving Julian a weak shrug, who in return gave Skylar an odd glare.

  “The only ass you’re going to be fucking with is Morrigan’s, deal?” Julian narrowed his eyes at Skylar a little. “Exit only, man.”

  “You’re straight. I get it,” said Skylar rolling his eyes. “By the way Morrigan, I’m more of a beta than an alpha, but I’ll fuck you until you’re numb if that’s what you need, pretty girl.”

  Before I gave any of them a chance to make me numb, I decided to milk them. We got into the room, got undressed, and skipped any preliminaries.

  I gave them all blowjobs, sucking on each cock as if I were starving. While I had one in my mouth, I would take care of the other two with my hands. I had hands and mouths all over my body, taking care of my breasts and pussy whenever possible. Skylar came in my hand, which both startled and pleased me. His dick wasn’t quite as long as his friends’, but it was still nice and thick.

  I wanted Theo’s cock in my mouth last, because I wanted to feel it touch my throat again. I got on all fours, bending my ass up and opening my mouth wide. While Theo was riding my face with a force that I would require from then on, Julian was fucking my pussy hard and fast, while Skylar began to lick my ass.

  I was moaning louder than I ever had before. I was cumming so often that I began to lose track of how many orgasms I was actually having. I was becoming more anxious; because I knew once Skylar had filled back up, he would be filling my ass with his plump shaft. I hadn’t let anyone in my ass before, but I wanted it. Bad.

  I felt him enter my ass, and the scream that I emitted against Theo’s flesh was enough to get him to shoot his hot load down my throat. I had no time to enjoy his flavor, because most of my focus was on what Skylar was doing. He was gentle at first, but once he was able to fit all the way inside, he was ramming his thin body against me, shoving his dick far up into my ass.

  Julian pulled out from my pussy, ripping off his condom in order to put his dick back into my mouth. It was odd to taste him after having consumed Theo’s cum, but I was pleased to see that he was attempting to mimic the kind of force that his friend used. While he slammed his dick down my throat, Theo was busy playing with my pussy, inserting his fingers deep inside me while his tongue tickled my clit.

  I couldn’t tell whether Skylar had actually finished in my ass, but he had pulled out, moaning and crying with intense ecstasy. Theo then moved from my pussy over to my ass, sliding another condom down his shaft as he was preparing to enter my ass himself.

  Theo had barely penetrated my asshole and I could tell that I was cumming yet again. His impressive size was stretching my ass to such an extent that I had never felt before. The pain was almost too much, but I didn’t want it to stop. I couldn’t tell how much of him was inside my ass- I was afraid to look. I wanted him to go balls deep. I wanted to know that his hot load was filling up my willing ass.

  Theo smacked my ass, and then came inside it. Julian pulled his dick from my mouth so that he could spray his cum all over my face. Skylar was jerking off over me, watching all of us.

  After we all recovered, we returned to where we had paused. All of my orifices were being filled and my hands were always full.

  Once it was all over, the room was a mess. There was cum and condoms strewn all over the floor. Sweat had coated all of the couches. The music had grown slightly quieter, but that was because the club was close to closing.

  While all three of my lovers lay there, exhausted and utterly spent, I dressed as quickly as possible and readied to take my leave. None of them could dictate a word, and I could barely stand.

  I didn’t care how my hair looked; I just wanted to get back into my bed and let my body recuperate after the extremities.

  “A friend of mine told me that this place is going to be open on Thanksgiving,” I told them all. “Supposedly, they’re going to have some good drink specials, could be fun.”

  It looked like they all wanted to reply, but simply couldn’t form the words.

  I blew them all a kiss and took my leave. I knew that after the day that lay ahead of me
on Thursday that I was going to want some fun afterward. I hoped that they would take my not-so-subtle hint and show up.

  Preferably all three of them.

  7

  Family was starting to arrive from all over. The family from Sacramento had gotten in early that morning, and the family that I was dreading seeing was expected to show up that night.

  My parents and I had been working together to get the house as organized and situated as possible. We were tasked with cleaning and certain baking duties. Since the meal was going to be large for a big gathering, we had to prepare a lot of the food the day before the holiday. Fortunately, people were also bringing some dishes of their own to contribute to the feast.

  I was becoming stressed, and my temper was short. Because I had gotten in so late from my night of debauchery, my sleep had been limited. I was making lots of mistakes that needed correcting.

  Luckily, Dani had arrived around lunchtime to help me deal with the chaos. It was easy for her to fit into the assembly line of work because she had come by so often over the years; she knew where everything belonged and how long to cook and bake certain things.

  I could tell that she was curious about my tired state, but she’d held off on asking me about it for nearly an hour. Once she knew that we were out of earshot of any of my family members, she approached me.

  “Had a rough night?” she asked me.

  I chuckled. “You could definitely say that.”

  “Tell me about it, player,” she goaded.

  I told her all about my orgy, and how it all came to happen. I went silent whenever my mom would walk by to get something, but I was able to finish my story in quick time.

  “That is fucking insane,” whispered Dani. “That is, so unlike you!”

  “Right?”

  “You’re bullshitting me. No way you had three guys all at once.”

  “What? You had a threesome before,” I reminded her quietly.

  “Yeah, but not an orgy,” she said. “I gotta admit, that sounds really hot. I may or may not have had that fantasy before.”

  “It was hot as fuck,” I assured her. “God, I hope I can do it again.”

  “Yeah, no shit,” she laughed. “You better do it again. Then, tell me about it again. Let me live vicariously through your orgies.”

  “Or you could tag along,” I said half-jokingly.

  “I don’t know. I’ve heard you having sex before, and it sounded too twisted for me,” she laughed.

  “Uh, when did you ever hear me having sex?”

  “It was your birthday, remember? We had all been drinking, we were chilling by the pool, then you and Brad went and-”

  Feeling as though she had somehow offended me, she decided to stop her train of thought.

  “And what?” I asked.

  “Sorry, I just… I felt bad bringing up Brad after, you know, the other night,” said Dani guiltily.

  “Oh,” I went. “Yeah, that was weird seeing him again like that.”

  “You been okay since you saw him?” she wondered.

  “Oh yeah, I’m more than fine,” I said absentmindedly. “I mean, it was weird seeing him again. It was more awkward than anything. It’s a little hard just having Thanksgiving again, what with our marriage ending over last Thanksgiving.”

  “Right,” she remembered.

  “But, I’m managing just fine,” I promised. “I’ll be fine. After all, I just keep finding guys that want to appreciate me. What more could I ask for?”

  “You could ask the boys to bring some extra lube if they want to keep playing with your backdoor,” said Dani. “You’re probably too tired to notice, but you’re walking really weird. You’re clearly in pain.”

  The weird thing was, even though I was definitely in pain, it didn’t bother me in the slightest. I liked the pain, it was a constant reminder of the adventures that I was getting myself into.

  8

  The burning reminder remained all throughout the day. I had hoped that relaxing in bed would alleviate the pain slightly, but it seemed to only intensify it. As it intensified, the images in my head continued to replay over and over. I couldn’t get my orgy out of my mind.

  I had been thinking about it constantly since it had happened. When I wasn’t thinking of that night, I was imagining what future nights with those men might be like. I hoped more than anything that it would happen again, and soon. I didn’t know what their Thanksgiving plans were, but I selfishly hoped that they might include me.

  I hoped I didn’t scare them off. I should have been utterly wrecked after what I was put through, but I could have kept on going for much longer had the club not closed. I also didn’t want them to think that I was a whore for suggesting a threesome and then being so open and willing to an orgy. I knew that we had all gone in to that sex club with similar ideas, but that didn’t stop me from worrying.

  I decided to take a hot, steamy shower; not just for a kind of ailment, but so that I could do something about my daylong arousal.

  The showerhead in my bathroom was movable and had seen a fair amount of my body in every sense of the meaning. I hadn’t used it in a while, but I was desperate for another orgasm. I played with it, moving it in just the right way so as to give my clit the proper stimulation that it needed. I imagined it was Julian that was taking care of me, I applied pressure and imagined Theo rubbing his strong hand firmly where the showerhead was resting. I wondered how good Skylar was at eating pussy.

  It felt good to pleasure myself in the shower, and I temporarily forgot about the good pains that the boys had left me with, but I was still not satisfied.

  I got out of the shower and lay in bed, still wet all over and naked. I looked over at my drawer where I had a variety of sex toys.

  I glanced over at my phone and noticed that I had a Facebook message waiting for me. My heart skipped a beat when I saw the name of the sender: Theo Lavern.

  His message read, “Hey. I hope you don’t think I’m weird or creepy or something. I just wanted to reach out and see how you were doing. It got pretty heavy the other night and I wanted to know how you were doing. Talk to you later.”

  I went onto Facebook, hoping that I would get to see a peek of his profile. Of course, his page was private, and so I was unable to see anything noteworthy or that could give me a glimpse into his life.

  I liked how he’d reached out; he was showing that he was an alpha with a soft side. I decided to reply back: “Hi Theo, I’m good, thanks for asking. I had a lot of fun with you guys the other night. I’m still a little sore, but I’m alive. ;) How are you?”

  He responded quickly, “I’m splendid. How’s your ass holding up? lol ;)”

  I giggled to myself before replying. “Sore, but it misses your dicks ;) I hope you had fun like I did. I hope we can do it again soon,”

  “Well, I did hear that Deplicious was having some drink deals tomorrow night.”

  “You’re correct, Sir. So, how the hell did you find me? No one ever knows how to spell my name!”

  “I eventually looked up where you worked. Not many people in Vegas work for Vicki Verelli. Process of elimination.”

  “Ah, good job.”

  “Thank you. What are you doing?”

  “I was actually about to masturbate, you?”

  “Well, it doesn’t matter I guess now I’m masturbating too. Let me call you.”

  “Yes. We can help each other out.” I reached for my phone and put it on speaker as it rang. “I want to hear your voice.”

  “Sounds good. I like the sound of yours in my ear. Make sure you moan for me, baby, okay?”

  I opened my drawer and pulled out my largest rubber dildo that I owned. I began to slowly rub it against my clit.

  “Absolutely, but just so you know, this doesn’t mean I’m playing favorites.”

  “That’s all right. I was fine with sharing you before, right?”

  “Good point. Random question, were any of you guys married before?”

  “Nop
e. Julian was engaged once but it didn’t work out. I’ve been in love a couple of times before, that didn’t work either.”

  “Aww, I’m sorry.” I bit my bottom lips as pleasure worked through me.

  “Don’t be. I’m glad I’m not with them anymore wasting my time.”

  “I understand that.” I moaned as I dipped the dildo into my pussy and rolled it around.

  “I’m not really looking for commitment right now.”

  “Me either.”

  “But I’m open to new things.”

  “I like the sound of that.”

  “I might be naked right now stroking my cock. Thinking about that perfect ass and pussy of yours.”

  “Good. I might be dreaming about the taste of your cum on my tongue.” I moaned again. Shit. I was turning myself on.

  “Such a good girl.”

  “One more random question.”

  “Yes?”

  “That night we met. The first time we hooked up, did you know who I was? Julian said something about how he’d mentioned hooking up with me. I thought maybe you knew after I saw you two together.”

  “Julian has hooked up with a lot of women at Deplicious.”

  “So, did you know I hooked up with him after I told you my name?”

  “I thought it was unlikely that you were the woman he told me about, but not totally improbable.”

  “Cool.”

  “Enough questions, Kitten. Tell me what you’re doing.”

  “I’m rubbing my clit with the thickest longest dildo I’ve got.”

  “Put it in your mouth. Taste that pussy for me.”

  Even though he had no way of knowing whether or not I was truly obeying, I did indeed comply. I put the dildo as far down my throat as I could until I began to choke.

  “I wish it was your dick. I want to suck all the cum out of that fat cock.”

  “Mmm. You touching yourself, baby?”

  “Yes, I have been. I’m so wet.”

  “Fuck yeah, you are.”

  “Stroke that dick fast for me, Theo. Tug on the sweet head and get some precum on your fingers for me?”