Three Times the Fun: A Reverse Harem Thanksgiving Love Story

by Blythe Reid

  “Now I want to put it in your ass,” Derek whispered into my ear.

  “And I want your pussy,” Jaxson whispered in my other one.

  Excitement flew through my chest and immediately I was more awake. I climbed carefully off of Jaxson and pushed him down on his back. I crawled over top of him and lowered myself down on his dick, smiling at the feeling of him inside of me. I leaned forward over the top of Jaxson and looked down into his eyes as Derek approached me from behind, spitting in his hand and rubbing it up and down his cock. He rubbed the head over my ass and very slowly pushed inside of me. I gasped in pleasure and pain, my body writhing beneath him. I looked up as Aaron approached, his cock solid in his hand. I smiled and opened my mouth, swallowing his dick into my throat.

  Beneath me, Jaxson began to move his hips up and down, sliding his cock in and out of me. Above me, Derek did the same thing, creating a pleasure I could barely understand. I looked up at Aaron, my mouth full with his cock and moaned sucking hard as it pushed out of my throat and back down again. After about ten minutes, the guys changed positions without even talking. Derek moved below me, Aaron behind me, and Jaxson in front of me. I took them all in again, this time feeling more pleasure than anything else. Our bodies moved in sync, my pussy grinding against Derek’s abdomen as he thrust his hips up and down, his cock sliding into my pussy. Aaron held tightly to my hips as he shoved his cock deep into my ass, and Jaxson groaned, throwing his head back as I sucked his cock hard and fast.

  I pulled my mouth back from Jaxson and reached up, stroking his cock with my hand as I began to moan louder and louder. The heat in my stomach had sparked, and now there was about to be an explosion. Aaron growled fucking me faster and faster, and Derek slid his cock in and out, biting down on his bottom lip as he stared up at me. I screamed out, gripping Jaxson’s dick hard in my hand and feeling waves of pleasure, unlike anything I had felt before. My entire body shook, and my eyes rolled back, my lungs holding in the breath as waves washed over me.

  Jaxson took hold of his cock and began to stroke it, watching me orgasm on top of the others. Derek push and pulled inside of me for a few more moments and then pulled his cock out and laid it between my belly and his, stroking in short, stout movements. Aaron pulled his cock from my ass and rubbed it hard, watching as I looked back at him and bit my lip. I could feel the hot, warm seed exploding from Derek and listened as he groaned, followed in chorus by Aaron who moved forward and came up and down my back in long hot streams. I looked forward at Jaxson who was beating his cock vigorously and smiled as his load shot forward, spraying across my face.

  I laid there for several moments catching my breath, listening to Derek’s heartbeat beneath me. When I had settled, I groaned, pulling myself up and off the bed, winking at the boys and escaping to the bathroom to clean off. I realized this was going to take a shower to accomplish.

  “I’m gonna jump in the shower, be out soon,” I said, smiling as the guys pulled on their clothes and wiped themselves down with clean towels.

  That was beyond erotic, and I knew that I would have to tell them I wanted all of them eventually, but at that moment, I was content.

  13

  It was Black Friday, I day I would usually dread because of the traffic and chaos, but I was happy to be out with the guys and my mother. We picked her up and headed over to Regency Square Mall where we knew it would be busy but not as much as the others. My mom seemed excited, and so was I. My mom and I split off from the guys, and they each went out and bought a gift for me. I thought the idea was sweet and thoughtful, but I also knew there was more behind it then just thoughtfulness. I knew that they were all trying to come up with a way to win me over individually, and I was starting to get anxious about the whole thing. I knew what I wanted, but I also knew there was a possibility that it wasn’t going to be something that they were comfortable with. I tried to put it out of my mind, but they made it pretty difficult to do so.

  Throughout the day, each one of them pulled me to the side. They wanted to tell me about how they felt about me, trying to convince me to pick them. It started with Jaxson.

  “I just wanted to tell you how special I think you are, and how amazing I think that we would be together,” he said. “We are both career driven and strong but have a serious zest for life outside of work.”

  Then it was Derek.

  “You are one of the most sensual and erotic women I have ever met,” he said. “I’ve been a playboy for so long I didn’t realize what it was like to fall for someone until I met you.”

  And last but not least, it was Aaron.

  “I was married for a couple of years,” he said. “She was my high school sweetheart. After that, I thought I was done until I met you that is. You are just amazing, and you have made me want to try again.”

  I told them all the same thing that I couldn’t just make a decision like that, it was too hard. By the end of the day I was exhausted, and I kissed and hugged my mom goodbye, knowing that I was leaving the next morning. I really didn’t want to leave my mom, and I almost felt guilty for being so preoccupied by all of this while I was with her. I never got to see her. We lived too far apart, but I promised that I would do my best to get back there by the summer, and this time come alone so that we could have some time together. The guys all thanked her again and headed for the doors of the mall, leaving me walking by myself.

  The guys decided that they were going to give me the silent treatment because I wouldn’t take the time and pick one of them. Part of me didn’t blame them, but the other part of me was angry because the decision was not that simple. I wanted all three of them, but being completely ignored was definitely not going to help me get what I wanted. In fact, the silent treatment was only going to drive a wedge between the four of us, something I knew I couldn’t let happen.

  I pulled my phone out of my pocket and stopped at the fountain in the middle of the mall, watching the water splashdown. I scrolled through my list and clicked on Hayden’s name, needing some serious girl advice. She always told it to me straight, and she would let me know if I was doing the right thing or not.

  “Hey girl,” she said happily. “You are coming home tomorrow! I am so excited.”

  “I know,” I said trying to sound happy.

  “Uh oh,” she said, seeing right through it. “What is wrong? Is it the love square you have going on over there?”

  “Yes,” I said grumpily.

  “Okay bring me up to speed because the last thing I knew you were getting ready to sleep with the third guy,” she said.

  “So, I’ve slept with all of them four times, twice all together in one room at the same time,” I explained, surprised that I wasn’t shocked by that at all.

  “I don’t even know how you keep up with all of that,” she laughed. “That being said, I think it’s pretty freaking awesome.”

  “Sounds awesome, right?”

  “Yeah,” she said enthusiastically.

  “Wrong,” I said with a sigh. “Now it has become a big giant drama filled mess.”

  “What in the world could have happened? You have literally been gone for five days,” she said chuckling.

  “They are being stubborn,” I said with a twitch of anger. “They are giving me the damn silent treatment.”

  “It sounds like a bunch of girls,” she laughed.

  “I know, right? Well, they aren’t speaking to me because they want me to choose one of them,” I explained. “It’s not that easy, though. I have feelings for all of them, and when we are all together, it’s like freaking magic. Obviously, I can’t talk to my mom about this, so I figured I would call you.”

  “Okay,” she said with thought. “Have you proposed the idea of all of you being together as one unit? I mean they have to at least think about it.”

  “No,” I said sighing. “I guess I was trying to let them come to that conclusion on their own or something.”

  “Um, earth to Mia,” she laughed. “That is not a conclusion t
hat very many people will come to on their own. You have to finesse that and explain it to them. Otherwise, that thought will never cross their minds, I promise you.”

  “You’re right,” I said. “Okay, I’ll call you later and let you know how it goes.”

  I got off the phone and hurried out to the sidewalk where the guys were waiting with a cab. The ride back to the hotel was absolutely silent, and I was happy to get out of the car. When we got upstairs, I shut off the television and asked the guys to all come sit down at the table. I wanted to talk to them. Begrudgingly they moved over to the table and sat there staring at me. I could tell they were trying hard to come off as grumpy.

  “What would you guys think about being together, all of us, as a unit?”

  “Like a foursome?”

  “Well, yes, like a foursome, Aaron,” I said trying not chuckle.

  They all looked around at each other, no one wanting to speak up about my proposal. It was so frustrating, and I realized that I couldn’t just expect them to jump right on board with it, I had to show them why it was a good idea. I sighed and stood up, pushing my chair back.

  “You all like this, right?” I took off my top and tossed it to the side.

  “And this,” I said unzipping my jeans and pulling them off, standing there in my black lace bra and panties. “I mean you want all of this, right? You like what you see?”

  One by one Aaron, Jaxson, and Derek nodded their heads, their eyes beginning to glaze over. Now it was time to show them exactly why there was no point in me picking.

  “Get on the bed,” Jaxson commanded. Good. They understood. That’s all I needed to know.

  14

  I crawled across the bed and sat there on all fours, watching as Jaxson climbed across the mattress toward me, gripping me by the hips and rubbing his cock over my pussy. I moaned loudly as he pushed his dick deep inside of me, gripping me tightly and filling me up. Aaron walked in front of me and knelt down on the bed, pushing the hair from my face. I looked up at him as he stroked his hard shaft, guiding it toward my lips and rubbing the tip over them.

  I opened my mouth and glanced behind him, watching as Derek pulled up a chair and sat down, his big cock in his hands. As they began to move inside of me, he began to stroke it, groaning as my body was ravaged by the others. It was incredibly hot watching him watch me get fucked, and I looked back up at Aaron, my eyes watering from his cock touching the back of my throat.

  I could feel the heat catching fire inside of me as Jaxson’s cock pushed deep into me and then out again. As my orgasm reached a fevered pitch, I looked over at Derek watching him stroke his cock as hard as he could. My back arched, and my mouth opened wide, my hand reaching for Aaron’s cock as I screamed out in ecstasy. As soon as my body had relaxed again, they switched, Aaron taking my pussy, Derek taking my mouth, and Jackson watching from afar. The way Aaron ground his hips into me drove me wild, and he leaned forward, wrapping his arm around my waist and rubbing my clit fast.

  I moaned, deep throating Derek’s dick, watching Jaxson rubbing his hand up and down his shaft. I sucked hard on Derek’s cock, whimpering as Aaron rubbed my clit faster and harder. God this was so sensual, I could barely contain myself. Ripples of ecstasy were burrowing deep into my groin, pushing me further and further to the edge. I reached my hand up and grabbed Derek’s cock, rubbing my hand up and down his slobbery erection. I screamed loudly feeling completely full and then not again as Aaron pulled his cock out before ramming it back in, his fingers still dancing heavily over my clit. I gripped onto Derek’s cock harder as I arched my back and leaned my head backward. I kept my eyes open, fixed on Jaxson jacking his dick fast in the corner, sweat beading on his forehead. My body exploded, and I came hard, my thighs beginning to shake beneath me.

  I came because of the feeling of Aaron’s cock inside of me. I came because of the feeling of Derek ramming his dick down my throat. But most of all, I came because Jaxson was sitting in the dark corner of the room watching every inch of my body. It was completely erotic and sensual when they watched me, and this was my perfect idea of arousing. I was putting on a show like I loved to do, and I could see the satisfaction in the palm of his hand.

  After that, I pulled myself from the bed and walked over to Jaxson pulling him from the chair and lining them up on the edge of the bed. My juices were rolling out of me, and my pussy was so damn wet. I wanted what they did before. I wanted to come so hard and so many times that I could barely walk the next day.

  “Fuck me like you did the second time,” I ordered, walking over to Derek, who was on the end and climbing onto his lap.

  I began to grind hard against him, feeling him fill me over and over as he thrust his cock deep inside of me. I wanted him to fuck me until I came, but this time I wanted to see him come too. As I began to ride him hard, I reached down and grabbed the box of condoms from my purse, pulling out the last three and tossing them to the guys. I sat up slowly, staring deep at Derek as he ripped the top off and folded it down his cock. I sat back down, pushing him back in me and continuing to grind against him.

  Derek reached behind me and grabbed my ass cheeks, pushing and pulling short, sudden bursts, raking my pussy across his skin and feeling his dick in my abdomen. The friction continued, getting faster and harder, Derek holding tight to my ass as he groaned. I reached up and grabbed his shoulders, screaming out as he came inside of me, pushing me over my edge. My back arched, and my body went hard, his hips still thrusting beneath me. Like before, though, before I could come down from my orgasm, Jaxson was grabbing my waist and pulling me over on top of him,

  He turned me around and sat me down in his lap, sliding his cock inside of me and reaching around my waist, plunging his fingers over my clit and rubbing hard and fast. He reached his mouth down and nibbled at my shoulder with his teeth, pushing his hips into me and grunting loudly. The sound of his voice and the fact that he was pushing me from my peak of orgasm, even higher, instantly made me cum, my body beginning to shake and writhe as he pushed me down on his dick and held on tightly, cumming hard inside of me.

  As my body shook, Aaron stood up, walking in front of me stroking his cock. Suddenly, Jaxson laid backward, pulling his cock out and sliding me over onto the bed. Aaron walked forward and grabbed my thighs, yanking me to the edge and picking my ass up in the air. Immediately he shoved himself inside of me, Jaxson getting on his knees next to me and rubbing my clit while Aaron fucked me hard. I screamed out, my arms flying backward and my mind no longer in control of my body. As Aaron’s huge cock dipped down into me, I could feel my body fighting the orgasm. Jaxson smiled and spit on his fingers, reaching back down and rubbing harder, gritting his teeth.

  As the warm wet fingers slid over me I erupted, my body shaking and writhing in orgasm. Aaron groaned, feeling my pussy closing in around him and pushed in deep and hard, growling as he came. I was too gone to even reach up so instead, I laid there, feeling the last remnants of the most intense session of sex I had ever had.

  “Wow,” I gasped, once I caught my breath. “I had five fucking orgasms. Five! I have never in my life had that many orgasms at one time. That was fucking amazing.”

  Aaron, Jaxson, and Derek were walking around the room, taking turns cleaning up and pulling on their boxers while I laid, sprawled on the bed. There was no way that they could deny the four of us were amazing together. I propped myself up on my elbows and looked up at them.

  “You know that was fun,” I said smiling. “If you want this pussy and you like fucking me than you all have to agree to be with me.”

  “It is fun,” Derek said. “But…”

  “But what?”

  “He’s unsure like I am, and Jaxson is,” Aaron said shrugging.

  “Fine,” I replied, jumping from the bed. “Then go sleep out there, I want the bed to myself. You guys have until tomorrow to make up your mind.”

  With that I shut the door, feeling good about my choice.

  15

  By the time
the sun came up, we were all up and ready to go to the airport. We rode in the cab, went through security, and took our seats, all without saying a word to each other. I was being indignant, I knew that, but I didn’t care. I was sitting by the window with Derek next to me, Aaron next to him, and Jackson across the walkway. The three of them looked over at me, and Derek cleared his throat.

  “We’ve made a decision,” he said. “None of us want to be without you, and we can’t lie, we make a really amazing team.”

  “I really like the sound of that,” I said smiling and unbuckling my seat belt.

  I got up and straightened myself looking down at Jaxson and mouthing for him to follow me. We moved to the front of the airplane and slowly opened the bathroom door, giggling as we shoved ourselves in there. I looked at Jaxson, and the smile moved from my face, immediately feeling the passion between us. I started pulling at Jaxson’s belt, undoing his pants and reaching inside, pulling out his already hard cock. He turned me around in the small space, and I put my hands up on the wall, feeling him yanking down my pants and my panties. He spread my legs and guided his cock into me, groaning as he moved deep inside. He reached around and held me by the waist, thrusting upward with his toes and hips, pushing deep in before pulling out just slightly and ramming it in again.

  I moaned softly, covering my mouth so that we wouldn’t be caught. Our movements were heated and short, our bodies folding into each other as he thrust faster and deeper. As the plane sped forward, I could feel the heat building in my stomach. He reached around and rubbed my clit, biting down on my shoulder as he pushed up into me, almost raising me off the ground. I grabbed hard to the wall and took in a deep breath my pussy vibrating in orgasm around his shaft. The pleasure flowed over me like a thick fog, and just as I began to recover he pulled out, jacking his cock hard and watching his seed flow into the bright blue water in the lavatory toilet. I pulled up my pants and caught my breath, feeling completely taken back by the sensuality of the moment.