The Price of Glory
Page 44
Edmonds, Sir J. (1) History of the Great War, Military Operations France and Belgium, London 1928-48.
(2) A Short History of World War I, London 1951.
Erbelding, E. Vor Verdun… aus dem Kriegstagebuch eines Front-offziers, Stuttgart 1927.
Ettighoffer, P. C. Verdun—Das Grosse Gericht, Gütersloh 1936.
Falkenhayn, E. von. General Headquarters, 1914-16, and its Critical Decisions, London 1919.
Falls, Cyril. The First World War, London 1960.
Ferry, Abel. Les Cornets Secrets, Paris 1958
Foch, Marshal. Memoirs, London 1931.
Foester, Wolfgang. Graf Schlieffen und der Weltkrieg, Berlin 1921.
Fonsagrive, F. En Batteriel, Paris 1919.
François Poncet, A. Discours de Réception à l’ Academie Française, 1953, Le Monde, 1953,
Frantzius, F. von. In Feld Unbesiegt, Munich 1921.
Fuller, J. F. C. Decisive Battles of the Western World, (Vol. III), London 1956.
Galliéni, General J. S. Les Carnets de Galliéni, Paris 1932.
Gaudy, G. Les Trous d’Obus de Verdun, Paris 1922.
Gaulle, Charles de. France and Her Army, London 1945.
Gehre, Ludwig. Die Deutsche Kräfteverteilung während des Weltkrieges, Berlin 1928.
Goerlitz, Walter. History of the German General Staff, 1657-1945, London 1953.
Gras, Gaston. Douaumont, 24 Octobre 1916, Verdun 1949.
Grasset, A. L. La Guerre en Action, Premier Choc 72 Division, Paris 1923.
Guedalla, Philip. The Two Marshals, London 1943.
Haack, Paul L. Mit der Kronprinzenarmee vor Verdun, Breslau 1917.
Hall, J. N., and Nordhoff, Chas. B. The Lafayette Flying Corps, Boston, 1920.
Hallé, Guy. Là-Bas avec Ceux qui Souffrent, Paris 1917.
Hanotaux, G. Le Général Mangin, Paris 1936.
Hein, Alfred. (1) In the Hell of Verdun, London 1930.
(2) Höhe 304, Leipzig 1942.
Hellot, General. Le Commandement des Généraux Nivelle et Pétain, Paris 1936.
Henches, Jules. Lettres de Guerre, Cahors 1917.
Herscher, E. Quelques Images de la Guerre (Woeuvre 1915 — Verdun 1916), Paris 1917.
Heuzé, Paul. Les Camions de la Victoire, Paris 1920.
Hindenburg, Field Marshal. Out of My Life, London 1920.
Hoeppner, Ernst. Deutschlands Krieg in der Luft, Leipzig 1921.
Hoffmann, Max. The War of Lost Opportunities, London 1924.
Hourticq, Louis. Récits et Réflexions, Paris 1918.
Humbert, Jacques. La Division Barbot, Paris 1919.
Illustrated London News. Bound editions, 1916.
Irwin, Will. The Latin at War, New York 1917.
Joffre, Marshal. The Memoirs of Marshal Joffre, London 1932.
Johnson, Douglas. Battlefields of the World War, New York 1921.
Jollivet, G. Le Colonel Driant, Paris 1918.
Jonas, Klaus. The Life of Crown Prince William, London 1961.
Joubaire, Alfred. Pour la France, Paris 1917.
Jubert, Raymond. Verdun, Paris 1918.
Junger, Ernst. The Storm of Steel, London 1929.
Kabisch, Ernst. (1) Ein Beitrag zum Problem der Verdun Schlacht, Berlin 1931.
(2) Verdun, Wende des Weltkriegs, Berlin 1935.
Kähler, Wilhelm. Vor Zehn Jahre — Bayerische Landwehr, Greifswald 1924.
Kiernan, R. H. The First War in the Air, London 1934.
Klövekorn, Leo. Deutsche Wille 1938; Mil Junglehrern zu den Kampfstätten um Verdun, and Fort Vaux, Berlin 1938.
Klüfer, Kurt von. Seelenkräfte im Kampf um Douaumont, Berlin 1938.
Kriegszeitschrijt der 50 Division. Die Kämpfe um die Feste Vaux, von Mitstreitern geschildert, Darmstadt 1916.
Kuhl, H. J. von. Der Deutsche Generalstab in Vorbereitung und Durchführung des Weltkrieges, Berlin 1920.
Kurenberg, Joachim von. The Kaiser, London 1954.
Lafont, Bernard. Au Ciel de Verdun, Pendant la Bataille, Paris 1918
Laure, General. Pétain, Paris 1941.
Lefebvre, H. Verdun, La Plus Grande Bataille de l’Histoire, Paris 1960.
Lefebvre-Dibon, P. Quatre Pages du 3e. Bataillon du 74e R.I., Paris 1921.
Le Temps. Bound editions, 1916.
Liddell Hart, B. H. (1) Reputations Ten Years After, London 1928.
(2) History of the World War, 1914-18, London 1934.
(3) The War in Outline, London 1936.
(4) Strategy of Indirect Approach, London 1941.
Liénard, J. La Littérature lnspirée par Verdun, Verdun 1929.
L’Illustration. Bound Editions.
Löhr, Theo. In der Hölle von Verdun, Rosenheim 1932.
Ludendorff, Erich. (1) My War Memories, London 1920.
(2) Urkunden der Obersten Heeresleitung, 1916-18, Berlin 1921.
Madelin, Louis. L’Aveu—la Bataille de Verdun et ľOpinion Allemande, Paris 1916.
Maier, Ludwig. Verdun in Grauen des Krieges, Attenhofer 1930.
Mangin, General. Comment Finit la Guerre, Paris 1920.
Marchal, Lt.-Colonel. La Bataille de Verdun Expliquée sur le Terrain, Verdun (no date).
Martel, Francis. Pétain, Verdun to Vichy, New York 1943.
Max of Baden, Prince. Memoirs, London 1928.
Mazenod, P. de. Les Étapes du Sacrifice, Paris 1922.
McConnell, J. R. Flying for France, New York 1917.
Méléra, César. Verdun, Paris 1925.
Menager, R. Les Forts de Moulainville et de Douaumont sous les 420, Paris 1936.
Michelin. Guide to the Battlefields, Verdun, Paris 1919.
Ministére de la Guerre, État-Major de l’Armée, Service Historique. Les Armées Françaises dans La Grande Guerre, Tome IV and Annexes, Paris, 1931-35.
Morel-Journel, H. Journal d’un Officier de la 74e Division d’Infanterie, Montbrison 1922.
Morin H. & Andrieu P. A ľÉcoute devant Verdun, Paris 1938.
Mornet, Daniel. Tranchées de Verdun, Paris 1918.
Mortane, Jacques. Histoire de la Guerre Aerienne, Paris 1921.
Muenier, P-A. L’Angoisse de Verdun. Notes d’un Conducteur d’Auto Sanitaire, Paris 1918.
New York Times. Monthly Magazine. Bound edition, New York, 1916.
Paquet, Colonel. Dans ľAttente de la Ruée, Paris 1928.
Painlevé, Paul. Comment j’ai Nommé Foch et Pétain, Paris 1923.
Palat, General B. E. La Grande Guerre sur le Front Occidental, Vols X-XII, Paris 1925.
Parsons, Edwin C. The Great Adventure, New York 1937.
Passaga, F. F. G. Verdun dans la Tourmente, Paris 1932.
Pastre, Gaston. Trois Ans de Front, Paris 1918.
Pellegrin, Colonel. La Vie d’une Armée pendant la Grande Guerre, Paris 1921.
Percin, General. Le Massacre de notre Infanterie, Paris 1921.
Pericard, J. Verdun. Histoire des Combats, Paris 1933.
Pétain, Marshal. La Bataille de Verdun, Verdun 1929.
Pierrefeu, Jean de. French Headquarters, 1915-1918, London 1924.
Pionnier, E. Verdun à la Veille de la Guerre, Paris 1917.
Poincaré, R. Au Service de la France; Neuf Années de Souvenirs, Vol. VIII, Paris 1926-1933.
Poirier, J. La Bataille de Verdun, Paris 1922
Queri, Georg. Die Hämmernde Front, Berlin 1916.
Radtke, E. Douaumont—Wie es Wirklich war, Berlin 1934.
Raynal, Colonel. Le Drame du Fort Vaux, Paris 1919.
Regele, Oskar. Feldmarschal Conrad, Munich 1955.
Reichsarchiven
Beumelburg, W. Vol. I, Douaumont, Oldenburg 1925.
Gold & Reymann. Vol. XIII, Die Tragödie von Verdun 1916, 1 Teil, Die Deutsche Offensiveschlacht, Oldenburg 1926.
Schwenke & Reymann. Vol. XIV, Die Tragödie von Verdun, 2 Teil, Das Ringen um Fort Vaux, Oldenburg 1928.
Gold & Reymann. Vol. XV, Die Tragödie von Verdun, Die Zermürbungsschlacht; 3 Teil, Toter Mann—Höhe 304; 4 Teil, Thiaumont—F
leury, Oldenburg 1929.
Reichkriegsministerium. Der Weltkrieg, 1914-1918, Vol. X, Berlin 1936.
Renouvin, Pierre. The Forms of War Government, New Haven 1927.
Renouvin, Preclin, Hardy. L’Époque Contemporaine II, Paris 1938.
Repington, Col. C. â C. The First World War, London 1920.
Reynolds, Quentin. They Fought for the Sky. New York 1957.
Ritter, Hans. Der Luftkrieg, Berlin 1926.
Robert, Henri B. Impressions de Guerre d’un Soldat Chrétien, Paris 1920.
Romains, Jules. Men of Good Will, Vols. 15-16, Verdun, London 1926.
Rouquerol, General. Le Drame de Douaumont, Paris 1931.
Rupprecht, Crown Prince of Bavaria. Mein Kriegstagebuch, Munich 1929.
Salisbury-Jones, Sir G. So Full a Glory, London 1954.
Serrigny, Bernard. Trente Ans avec Pétain, Paris 1959.
Spears, E. L. Liaison, 1914, London 1930.
Stéphane, M. Verdun; Ma Derniére Reléve au Bois des Caures, Paris 1929.
Sturgkh, Graf. Im Deutschen Grossen Hauptquartier, Leipzig 1921.
Supf, Peter. Das Buck der deutschen Fluggeschichte, Berlin 1935.
Taylor, A. J. P. The Struggle for Mastery in Europe, 1848—1914, Oxford 1954.
Thimmermann, H. Tatsachenbericht (Verdun, Souville), Munich 1936.
Thomasson, Lt.-Col. R. de. Les Préliminaires de Verdun, Nancy 1921.
Thomazi, A. Les Marines à Terre, Paris 1933.
Thellier de Poncheville, Abbé. Dix Mois à Verdun, Paris 1918.
Unruh, Fritz von. Verdun—Opfergang, Frankfurt-am-Main 1925.
Valéry, Paul. Réponse au Discours de Réception du Maréchal Pétain l’Académie Française, en 1931, Paris 1931.
Varillon, P. Joffre, Paris 1956.
Vial, F. Territoriaux de France, Paris 1918.
Werner, Johannes. Boelcke, Leipzig 1932.
Weygand, General. (I) Mangin (Discours), Paris 1929.
(2) Histoire de ľArmée Française, Paris 1953.
Wienskowski, Major von. Falkenhayn, Berlin 1937.
Wilhelm, Crown Prince of Germany. (I) The Memoirs of the Crown Prince of Germany, London 1922.
(2) My War Experiences, London 1922.
Williams, Wythe. Dusk of Europe, London 1937.
Wintringham, T. H. Mutiny, London 1936.
Witkop, Philip (ed). German Students War Diaries, London 1929.
Wolff, Leon. In Flanders Fields, London 1959.
Ziegler, Wilhelm. Verdun, Hamburg 1936.
Zieser-Beringer, H. Der Einsame Feldherr—Die Wahrheit Über Verdun, Berlin 1934.
Zoeberlein, Hans. Der Glaube an Deutschland, Munich 1934.
Zwehl, General von. (1) Maubeuge, Aisne, Verdun; Berlin 1921
(2) Erich von Falkenhayn, Berlin 1926.
Zweig, Arnold. Education before Verdun, London 1916.
REFERENCE NOTES
THIS book has made use of conversations with veterans of Verdun and their relatives, First War historians and military analysts, but above all published material. After the passage of nearly half a century, there is probably little of value that has not yet appeared in print; certainly no battle of the First War has had more written about it than Verdun. The foregoing bibliography contains published works that have all been used to greater or lesser extent by the author, but it is by no means complete. In terms of value, the material depends greatly on the date when it was written; among the analytic works, those published either under the fog of war or very shortly afterwards have obvious limitations, while in Germany many that appeared after 1933 bear the stamp of the Nazi distortion of History, and tend to glorify German deeds at Verdun while glossing over the errors. Of the eye-witness accounts, the best are those written closest to the events, but not published until the removal of the deadening hand of censorship.
Certain published sources have been used in almost every chapter. For details of operations and orders, there are the two official histories; of the Service Historique of the French Army and the Reichkriegsministerium. For objectiveness combined with occasional vivid depiction of the battle, the four semi-official volumes of the Reichs Archives are the best German material. Among French works, General Palat’s history is rare in that it makes no attempt to play down the disasters and défaillances occurring among the French forces. A good recent pictorial history of Verdun is provided by J-H Lefebvre (though based largely on material to be found in Pericard’s huge work). For a penetrating analysis of the German strategy, Wendt is outstanding. To anyone writing about the French in the First War, Jean Norton Cru’s Témoins is invaluable. This is almost a life’s work by a Franco-American professor which soberly evaluates and classifies every eye-witness account to appear on the French side, pricking many belles légendes. Unfortunately, nothing similar was produced in Germany, where in any case the eye-witness material is poorer both in quantity and quality. Of the books written by the various leaders, the Crown Prince’s, Poincaré’s and Pétain’s struck me as outstanding; Pétain’s is notable among such works for its brevity and its few attempts at self-justification. Liddell Hart’s brief characterisations of Joffre, Falkenhayn and Pétain in Reputations still seem just and true-to-life. Finally, it would be hard to write anything about Verdun without repeated reference to Churchill’s The World Crisis.
The following notes lists the principal source material used in each chapter, in addition to the above; works to be found in the bibliography bear the author’s name only; where there is more than one by the same author, the appropriate number is given; where a work is not listed in the bibliography the title is given in full.
Chapter One
On 1870, Michael Howard’s recent book The Franco-Prussian War is hard to beat; also Emile Zola’s La Débâcle for description of the humiliation of the French Army. Background of the years 1870–1914; Brogan, Chastenet (1 & 2). Re-creation of the French Army; de Gaulle, Weygand (2). German and French war plans; Fuller, Liddell Hart (1), Falls, Foerster.
Chapter Two
The initial clash: Churchill, Junger, Spears. Joffre and G.Q.G.: Liddell Hart (2), Spears, Pierrefeu, Desmazes, Joffre, Varillon.
Chapter Three
Personality of Falkenhayn: Zwehl (2), Wienskowski, Liddell Hart (2), Zieser-Beringer. The Kaiser’s life during the war: Kurenberg, Admiral Georg von Muller (The Kaiser and His Court), Sturgkh.
Chapter Four
Analysis of Falkenhayn’s strategy, here and later; Wendt, Foerster, Kabisch (2). Details of German preparation for GERICHT; Ettighoffer, Crown Prince (2), Bansi, Wendt. Terrain of Verdun; Johnson. French unpreparedness; de Thomasson. First warnings of German plans; principally Morin & Andrieu; Paquet, Cuneo.
Chapter Five
Waiting in the German lines; Ettighoffer, Unruh, Pericard. The ‘Waiting Machine’ quote is from Barbusse. German and French order-of-battle; Reichs Archives Vol. 13,1 Grasset, Palat. Life in the trenches and general background; Mornet, Barbusse, Ducasse &c. Hospital conditions; Duhamel (1 & 2).
Chapter Six
Best accounts of XXX Corps’ role in the battle, here and later; Grasset, Paquet, Palat. First moments of bombardment in Bois des Caures; Jollivet, Stéphane, Grasset. German account of initial attack; RA (13), Zwehl (1).
Chapter Seven
Fighting in Bois des Caures and death of Driant; Pericard, Jollivet, Stéphane, RA (13).
Chapter Eight
Interchanges between Generals Chrétien and Bapst; Becker, de Thomasson. The disaster at Samogneux; Zwehl (1), Queri, RA (13), Palat, Haig’s comment on the 37th African Division is drawn from Blake, and details of its breaking from Palat and Becker. Heroism of the ‘trainee corporals’; Delvert and Bouchor, Delvert (2), Palat. Last moments of XXX Corps and arrival of XX Corps; Muenier, Becker.
Chapter Nine
De Castelnau’s quote on the forts comes from Percin (Les Erreurs du Haut Commandement). German accounts of the capture of Fort Douaumont; above all von Klüfer, the C.O. of the Battalion of the 24th
Branden-burgers that made the capture, who devoted most of his life on leaving the army to compiling a minute by minute account of the capture. His book was not published until the eve of World War II, when interest in Douaumont had waned. Also RA (13), Radtke, Brandis, Bansi. Description of Fort Douaumont; Menager, Rouquerol, Lefebvre. French failure to occupy the fort; Passaga, Rouquerol, Marchal, Becker, de Thomasson, Pericard. French demoralisation after Douaumont; Lefebvre, Palat, Morel-Journel, Dubrulle.
Chapter Ten
Reactions at Chantilly to disasters at Verdun, and de Castelnau’s mission; Joffre, Pierrefeu, Ferry, Poincaré. Background to de Castelnau; Pierrefeu, Liddell Hart (2), Spears. Winston Churchill’s comment on ‘meeting an artillery attack’ is quoted from The London Magazine of November 1916.
Chapter Eleven
The ‘disappearance’ of Pétain; Serrigny. On the character of Pétain a great deal has been written, much of it violently biassed in one extreme or another. As one of the Instructors of Military History at the École de Guerre warned the author, ‘one should not rely too much on anything about Pétain that was written either in the heat of the First War, or of the Second War’. Principal sources referred to in this book; Pierrefeu, Liddell Hart (2), Serrigny, Laure (though written with a propaganda slant as the ‘official’ biography in Vichy days), Guedalla, de Gaulle, Bolton. François-Poncet’s Éloge to the Academie Française in 1953, moving yet balanced, is a classic. Aron’s view of Pétain in his latter days is also notably fair.
Chapter Twelve
Pétain’s arrival at Verdun; Serrigny, Lavisse (Histoire de France Contemporaine, Vol. IX), Pétain, RA (13). The Voie Sacrée; Pétain, Romains, Pellegrin, Heuzé, Irwin, Lavisse, Brogan.
Chapter Thirteen
Account of the first German setbacks at Verdun; Crown Prince (2), RA (13), Zwehl (1), Wendt, Kabisch (2), Unruh, Falkenhayn, Hoffmann, Marchal, Rupprecht.
Chapter Fourteen
The fighting for the Mort Homme and Côte 304; RA (15), Colin Frantzius, Johnson, Bouvard, Serrigny, Campana, Cochin, Laurentin, Pericard. The French disaster at Avocourt; Poincaré, Palat, Marchal.
Chapter Fifteen
For evaluation of French eye-witness accounts, here and elsewhere; Cru. The list of all sources used in this chapter would cover several pages, but — in addition to the authors given the highest ratings by Cru — the following have been particularly useful: Lefebvre, Pericard, Bartlett, RA (all vols), Unruh, Witkop, Debeney, L’Illustration, Irwin, New York Times, Bordeaux (1). For life of artillerymen at Verdun; Delvert (1), Henches, Fonsagrive, Humbert, Pastre. Again, Duhamel’s accounts of conditions for the wounded are outstanding; also Muenier.