Next Door Daddy

by Amy Brent

  “Of course not.” Maya shakily agreed before she finished off the drink and handed the glass to him. “Another please?”

  “I also don’t fuck drunk girls that aren’t capable of making a decision,” James warned her as she stared up at him. “Take it easy, Maya.” He went to fix her another drink and handed it to her before he sat down beside her with a beer of his own.

  James and Cory were here so much that they had their own rooms and clothes, so it was no surprise to her when James got up to take a shower for dinner. They had been flirting heavily, and Maya felt the slight effects of the alcohol as much as she felt the desire coursing through her. She rested back against the cushioned chair and let the breeze blow over her as she ran her hands through her curly hair. “I want you so much right now,” Maya softly whispered as she closed her eyes and focused on her throbbing pussy.

  Hands slipped over her legs, and Maya opened her eyes to see him going for her tiny shorts. “I can smell you, Maya. I can smell how wet you are for me.” James unbuttoned them and looked around to see if anyone was around.

  “Is there anyone on the beach?”

  “I am so glad your dad wanted a private setting,” James gratefully said before he slipped the denim down her thighs. “Jesus, you’re dripping.” He moved her tiny thong to the side and slowly traced the skin of her upper thighs with his thumbs. “Have you ever been fucked before, Maya?”

  “No. I always wanted you. The guys at school, have never turned me on the same way you do.” She moaned as she dropped her head back.

  “Cory as well?” James questioned her as she bit her lip hard. “I know he’s thought about you this way as well. Should we wait for him to get here?” He lifted his fingers to stroke her folds hard as she cried out and dropped her legs open.

  “God, no.” Maya groaned as he found her sensitive nub and slipped the tip of a finger inside of her. The sound of the waves dimmed in the background, and she thrust her hips up a bit to make him go deeper.

  James circled her clit as she lifted her hands and clutched the chair. There was a pressure inside of her that was rising to the surface, and Maya knew that it was going to overcome her in a way that nothing had before.

  She bit her lip and closed her eyes as a keening sound came from her throat. It changed to a yelp when he removed his hand from her body and opened her eyes to watch him crawl between her legs and meet her eyes as he breathed on her pussy hard. James leaned in and licked her firmly and slowly as she stared down at him. “You taste like honey.” He licked her several more times and then separated her and sucked her clit between his lips as she rocked forward uncontrollably.

  “James…oh, James.” Her voice was rising as she felt his mouth sucking her and his fingers stroking her and all of her senses started to combine as she felt the pressure release. He kept his movements hard and fast as she came and she dropped her hands to grasp his head and dig her red nails into his skin as he winced and raised a hand to grab hers.

  “Baby…you’re going to leave marks.” She dropped her arms to the side and rode out her orgasm as he nuzzled her and drank her in slowly.

  “What the fuck did you just do to me?” Maya asked as she felt her bones transform into jelly, and her body go lax on the chair.

  “Whatever it was, I like it. Take a shower with me and wash up for tonight.” James invited her as Maya stared up at him silently.

  She managed to stand and grabbed her things absently to put them into the house before he took me upstairs to the loft area where he and Cory stayed. There were two bedrooms with attached bathrooms up there and a loft area that served as space where they watched television and worked on their computers. Maya hadn’t been up there, and she followed him into one of the rooms as she looked slowly around.

  James loosened his shorts and Maya watched as he slid them down his toned legs in awe. He was bare underneath, and she admired his ass before he turned to face her and she stared at his long hard cock. “Take that shirt off and show me your body, Maya. I want to see all of you.”

  Maya lifted both shirts up and over her head before she dropped them onto the floor and fought the urge to cover herself. She blushed and looked down at her hands as he approached her and clutched her wrists in one large hand. Maya lifted her eyes to his, and he gazed intently at her for several seconds. “Come with me.” James took one of her hands and led her into the large bathroom, where he turned on the shower and tossed some clean towels on the counter. “In.”

  Maya stepped under the hot spray and closed her eyes as it slid down her skin. She felt him behind her, hard and pressing into her ass as he slid his arms up the side of her body. James moved his hands around to cup her full breasts and tease the hard nipples with his thumbs as she dropped back against him. James adjusted himself to rub his cock between her legs and she nibbled on her lip as more desire surged through her.

  She turned to face him once she couldn’t take it anymore and reached up to pull his face down to hers to give him a deep, hungry kiss. Their tongues moved together instantly as she slipped one of her hands down his neck and then over his shoulders. He was one of the most gorgeous men that Maya had ever seen, and she opened her mouth wider to give him full control. Her hand slipped over his back and down his side as she felt him shiver and groan softly. James took her hand and brought it down to his cock as he circled his palm over hers and showed her how to stroke it slowly.

  Their kiss deepened into a messy embrace as they ate at each other and she continued to stroke him as he rocked forward. She groaned as she pulled away to look down at him, dripping and desperate, and slipped down to her knees as he watched her silently. “I need to…I want you.” Maya looked at the purple head that was pointing up and away from her mouth and took it gently with one hand to take it deeply into her mouth and suck lightly. Her other hand slipped between her legs to touch herself and give herself anything like what he’d done to her outside.

  Maya’s body was sensitive, and she wept against his body for a moment as she slipped him deeper into her throat. James wrapped a hand in her wet hair and tugged her in a rhythm that he matched with his hips as she slid a finger inside of herself. “Yes, baby. Fuck yes.” James groaned as he rocked into her and increased in size as she moaned with him. “Swallow me.” He thrust and released inside of her mouth as she scraped a finger over her clit and weakened gently as she released along with him.

  Maya struggled to keep up with him as she sucked him down into her throat and tasted his come that was almost choking her. She pulled him closer with one hand by his ass and drank him in even deeper as he grunted and stared down at her.

  CHAPTER 3

  “What do we have going on here?” A masculine voice interrupted them once they had rinsed off and started to walk out of the shower. Cory was standing there smirking as Maya moved to cover herself shyly with one of the towels. “Fucking daddy’s little girl, James?”

  “Not yet,” James told him as he met Cory’s eyes through the steam of the bathroom. “We were waiting for you.”

  “It’s about damn time. I’ve been watching you blossom for years into this body.” Cory said with relief in his voice as Maya stared at him. He and James seemed too comfortable with each other, with this situation. Had they done this before?

  “Settle down, Cory,” James said as he walked forward and slipped his arms over Maya’s shoulders. “Nobody has touched her before. Maya is innocent…at least until today.” James suggestively said as he stroked her skin almost unconsciously. “I can assure you that she’s very passionate when she wants to be.”

  “I don’t doubt it,” Cory replied as he stepped forward and looked into her eyes. “Does it feel like you’re going to hell yet, James?”

  “In some ways, yes. We have an agreement, though. He’ll never know that any of this happened, but she wants this.” James said as he tugged on her long hair. “Don’t you, Maya?”

  “Yes,” She only had to utter one word before Cory’s eyes darkened and he s
tepped closer.

  “I promised her a nice dinner out tonight. She just arrived for a break from school.” James spoke sharply, and Maya blinked as Cory narrowed his eyes. “We have two weeks here alone with her, but we won’t be waiting that long.”

  “Dinner.” Cory agreed before he turned and walked out of the bathroom.

  “Drinks and dancing maybe, too,” Maya called out before she heard Cory sigh.

  “This isn’t about sex tonight, Maya. It’s about you feeling safe with us and your pleasure. We owe you more than just a fuck.” James promised her as he lifted her hair and kissed her neck. They had done such intimate things already, and her skin pebbled with the light press of his lips. “Get ready, beautiful. You are going to be wined and dined tonight before we have you.”

  James left the bathroom, and she sucked in a breath before she tucked the towel closely around her body. Her body was pulsing from the things they had already done, and she tried to imagine what it would feel like to have two men pleasing her like that. She walked downstairs and went into her bathroom to dry her hair and get something in it to control the frizz before she ran her fingers through it and walked to her closet.

  Maya felt beautiful as she pulled a clingy deep green dress out and held it up to her body. She returned to the bathroom to apply a little cream to her face to even it out, though not too much. She didn’t want to kill the glow that she had going. She applied some dark liner to her eyes and winged it out before she applied some mascara and looked over her collection if lip products.

  Maya put her dress on and turned as she watches the short ruffled bottom flare out around her thighs with her small spin. Maya smiled and turned to see the front of it cling to her breasts and waist that didn’t seem that big right now. If this was how she felt after some foreplay, then what was the sex going to do to her? Maya added some black heels and then dabbed a bit of dark gloss on her full lips to stain it with color before she added a layer of shiny gloss. She grabbed a small purse that she filled with a few necessities before she walked into the kitchen and opened the fridge.

  “Looking for something?” Cory asked from behind her as she jumped and pressed a hand to her heart.

  “You scared she shit out of me.” Maya gently reprimanded him as she reached for a bottle of wine that was in the door.

  Cory took it and poured her a glass before he took her in with his eyes. “You look stunning tonight.”

  “Thank you.” She looked him up and down in his black jeans and gray button up shirt before she met his eyes. “So do you.”

  “Are you sure about this? Are you sure about us?” He waved his hand in the air and looked thoughtfully at her as she sipped the wine.

  “I have always wanted this. I think it took me leaving and realizing that the boys there at school weren’t going to be the right choice for me.” Maya thoughtfully said as she kept looking at him. “Maybe after tonight, they’ll never be, but I have to try this.” He still looked worried. “I’m twenty. I am in college, and I can make big girl decisions like this.” Maya smiled at him. “You’re not that much older.”

  “Your father would disagree,” Cory told her before he stepped forward and took a sip from her glass.

  “This is our secret, Cory.” He stared at her before he pressed his lips against hers in a firm kiss. She parted her mouth and accepted his tongue willingly as she let her own dance with it slowly before the kiss deepened. Cory pressed her against the kitchen counter and slipped his hands over her hips to pin her there as he tilted his head to deepen it even further.

  “I don’t even want to go to fucking dinner. I want to eat you.” He grumbled as he pulled away enough to talk before he kissed her again.

  “I didn’t eat on the drive here, so I do need some food,” Maya softly went against his wishes, and he smiled.

  “You will need it because I am going to make you feel so good tonight,” Cory promised her before he stepped away and took a deep breath. James stepped into the kitchen dressed similarly to Cory and eyed them with a wicked gleam in his eyes.

  CHAPTER 4

  The three called for a car and took it to a five-star restaurant on the water where they both quizzed her about school. In some ways, James and Cory were like fathers to her since she’d known them for so long. In other ways, they were a fantasy that was going to come true. They ordered wine and sipped it as they ate fresh seafood and talked for a couple of hours after dinner.

  James then led her by the hand to the intersection as Cory followed. Maya looked slowly around as she wondered if anybody was looking at them. Did they know what she was planning?

  They went to a smaller club, one that men would take a girl to and not the kind of vapid place that any college guy would bring her. Everyone seemed to know the guys and she was given another drink as she raised an eyebrow at James. There was a band playing some catchy jazz with a woman singing, and Maya found herself captivated by the music as they settled into the booth in the corner. She leaned forward and sipped her fruity drink as she felt two hands on her thighs, each belonging to a different man.

  The men took turns teasing her to release with their hands on their thighs and under her lace underwear as she pressed back into the seat and lost her composure with all of it. Maya couldn’t decide who was better as she spread her legs and bit her lip to keep from crying out.

  They stayed until they couldn’t take it anymore and before they drank too much. Both Cory and James didn’t want her to be drunk for this, and they slipped her into the back of the sedan for the ride home. She leaned against James and found his lips in the dark. Cory slipped his hand under the soft material of her dress to cup her breast as her tongue danced with James’ and she wilted against them.

  They made it to the house, and James unlocked the door before he pushed her inside. Cory closed and locked the door behind him before he kissed her hard, and she clung to his neck. James moved behind her and lifted her dress to access her pussy as he stroked her clit hard and fast. She groaned against Cory as he lifted her and James followed them up the stairs as he made sure that Maya was safe. They fell onto one of the beds in one of the rooms, and she struggled to pull off her dress as James helped her. The only item of clothing that she wore underneath were the tiny panties, and she fell back on the bed as someone covered her and sucked a nipple into his mouth. Teeth dragged against her, and Maya cried out as she felt a pair of hands rip off her underwear and spread her thighs.

  Someone buried their mouth between her thighs and feasted on her as Maya slipped her hands into the hair of the man worshiping her nipples. Short hair. It was James, and she pulled him closer as she arched her back and panted from everything that was happening to her.

  Cory was the one tasting her this time as she came and James covered her mouth in a hungry kiss. It was intense, and she jerked up against him as she felt the drawn out release. Fingers slipped inside of her, and she helplessly clung to James as Cory massaged her tight walls.

  She was left alone for a moment and looked around in the dim room to see her men stripping off their clothes as her eyes glazed over. Even in the light that was on in the room showed off everything that they had to offer and she scooted up onto the pillows. Cory finished first and moved onto the bed to join her as he kissed her swollen lips. He still tasted like her. James sat down and pulled up a square wrapper and stared at it for a moment.

  Cory was slipping his fingers over her as James rolled the condom on and the men shared a look. It was as if they planned it this way and she stared down between her legs as James positioned himself before her. She was still wet from before, and he pushed gently inside of her as she moaned softly. Cory kept his finger moving over her as James pushed a little more with his mouth kissing her chest in little pecks of his mouth. He would lean in to suck her between his teeth here and there, and she moaned as James went even further. It didn’t hurt more than a slight pinch, and she begged him to go deeper as her body screamed silently for it. She wanted all of him and
all of Cory, and she reached her hand out to grasp Cory in her hand and stroke him as he pinched her nipple and moaned.

  James went all the way in as she looked down and saw their connection and then looked into his eyes. “I want you hard. I want you fast.” Maya softly told him in the room as she tightened her grip on Cory’s cock. James pulled back and started moving fast as he thrust inside of her over and over. Cory jerked as he came all over her hand and Maya let out a little scream as she felt James swell inside of her and slide against her as he grunted and thrust harder. “So good, James. I am so close. Come inside me.” She was babbling, but Maya didn’t care as she felt her body disconnect and lighten with her orgasm as she closed her eyes and lost track of where she was for a moment.

  It was Cory that took her next, on her knees as he drove himself into her and she clutched the headboard as she pushed back. Against him hard and fast. He didn’t wait too long after James to slide his condom on and tell her to turn over. It was painful in a way but so addicting, and she cried out with every thrust as she closed her eyes.

  They rested on the mattress with some cold wine for a few moments. They were still naked and tangled in each other, and Maya looked from James to Cory with a sated smile. “How do you feel?” James asked her as he met her gaze.

  “I knew that it was going to be like that. I knew that you were the right ones for me.” Maya responded as she stroked Cory’s chest with her hand slowly. “I can’t wait until we can do it again.”

  Within an hour, she was on her knees with Cory in her mouth as James took her from behind. Before she could come that way, she found herself riding Cory and sucking her essence off of James. It was overwhelming as she rocked against him with her back to him while Cory thrust up inside of her and James held her face so he could fuck it hard and fast.

  Cory came while she was swallowing everything that James gave her.

  She fell into sleep for a short period in the large bed before she’d wake up touching one of them or with one of them touching her. Maya’s body was so tired but needy as she took both of them two more times during the night, rough and hard. She fell into a deeper sleep in between them as she wondered how she could ever find something better than this.