The Cortés Trilogy: Enigma Revenge Revelation

by John Paul Davis

  “I have a better idea. Once you’re ready, locate the local library and find out everything you can about the Godolphins. I want to know why their coat of arms is so similar to the Cortés one.”

  *

  Leaving Chris, Ben left the inn and walked south-east to the heart of Hugh Town. The storm had passed, the dark cloud replaced by bright sunshine. Although the ground was still wet underfoot, the road itself was clear apart from the occasional puddle, the majority of the water running away into nearby drains and gutters. Despite the wind, it was warmer than it had been, the walk along the coast brisk but fair. This was the best he had seen of the island. A tourists’ hotspot, its lovers had dubbed it.

  He was starting to think they had a point.

  He headed down the same alleyway he had seen the day before. Kernow was working in the boathouse.

  “What the hell happened to the Dunster?” Ben asked, seeing a large space where the boat had once been.

  Kernow emerged from a rolling ramp. “Don’t you be getting your knickers all in a twist. Work’s almost over. In a couple of days I’ll be transporting her along the road to the museum. I trust you wouldn’t object if the museum gets to keep her?”

  In truth he hadn’t even considered it. “As a matter of fact, I’m heading over there now. I don’t suppose you could direct me?”

  “Continue to the end of Thoroughfare, right on the Lower Strand and take a left along Church Street. Only an idiot would miss it.”

  “Thanks. So what was so important it couldn’t wait?”

  Kernow walked to the table and picked up a large container. It was a small chest, bronze and heavy, its exterior both covered with, and smelling of, silt.

  “Found it in the galley. I’m guessing it now belongs to you.”

  Ben accepted it, running his hands across the sharp metal lid. He tried opening it.

  “You need something to cut it with?”

  On second thoughts he decided to wait.

  Kernow grinned. “If you need me again, I’ll probably be in the North Atlantic.” He pointed towards the main stretch, a highly civilised area, with shops, restaurants, roads and people. “It’s an inn. Not an ocean!”

  *

  Ben followed Kernow’s directions. He dropped the box off back in his room and headed south-east again along Hugh Street. Over a day on the island, this was the first time he had really explored the town itself. Unlike the other settlements on St Mary’s, it was situated on an isthmus that connected the west and east parts of the island and was also unique in being independent. While the rest of the island – the rest of the Isles of Scilly – was technically part of the Duchy of Cornwall, Hugh Town had been sold to the inhabitants in 1949 and had remained independent ever since.

  The Museum of the Isles of Scilly was located about half a mile from the ferry terminal, about an equal distance from the sea on either side. Remembering what Kernow had told him, Ben headed left where Hugh Street met the Lower Strand, and right on to Church Street.

  The museum was a detached building located about halfway along the street on the left. Like most in the vicinity, it had an impressive yellow stone exterior, with brown-framed glass doors at the front. The word MUSEUM was written in black letters on a long white background. He smiled to himself as he entered. Kernow was right.

  You’d have to be an idiot to miss it.

  The museum was one of the main tourist hotspots on St Mary’s. Unlike the ones Ben was used to, it was a simplistic, old-fashioned treasure trove of local keepsakes that ranged from old coins to dog bones.

  Inside, it was deserted. Everything on display was accompanied by a simple description, a mere title and a few words. There were no hi-tech interactive features; as best he could tell, there wasn’t a computer in sight. For a museum, he couldn’t get over how small the place was.

  A woman emerged from a nearby doorway, wearing a smart black blazer and skirt, bright red lipstick, glasses, and her grey hair done up in a bun. She wore a name tag above her left breast.

  “Dr Phillips.” Ben offered his hand.

  “You must be Dr Maloney. I’m so glad you were able to spare the time. I’ve already heard so much about you.”

  He released her hand. “This is quite a selection you have here.”

  “You’re most kind. Thanks to the generosity of various benefactors, we now have access to far more research facilities than ever before.”

  “Actually, I’m kind of surprised that an island so small would have access to such things at all.”

  She smiled. “It wasn’t always this way,” she said, walking. “The museum dates back to 1967. Originally, we started five years earlier in the Wesleyan Chapel. Of course, back then we were only open in the summer months.”

  Ben followed her through a set of doors, now entering the heart of the museum. “In my experience, it’s often ones like that which prove the most authentic.”

  “You know, I’ve often thought exactly the same thing. The actual foundation was really quite by accident.”

  “Yes, I noticed from your website. It’s not often you can say about a scientific institution that it started with a gale.”

  The woman laughed. “That’s actually quite true. Back in 1962 we were having the worst storms,” she said, unclear from her appearance whether she was old enough to remember them. “Look here.” She showed him a display of old coins in a glass container. “The severe gales that summer were really something of a blessing in disguise. Over a period of many days, they uncovered the most rare of Romano-British finds. The locals here were really quite marvellous. Had it not been for their enthusiasm, the museum would probably never have gone ahead.”

  Ben looked at the coins before studying the items alongside them. He struggled to place them from sight alone, but judging from the descriptions, they were mainly household objects, ranging from metals to pottery.

  He followed her along the corridor, examining more exhibits as he passed them. “What kind of things do you specialise in?”

  “Our collections are really extremely diverse,” she said, stopping by one in particular. “Look at these.” She gestured to a small collection of stuffed birds, their colours ranging from green to gold. “The oldest we have is over 4,000 years old. As you’ll shortly see, we welcome all items of Scillonian fascination.”

  She headed for the nearest door and opened it.

  “Would you like to follow me?”

  14

  Dr Phillips took Ben on a complete tour, which took less than twenty minutes.

  The woman wasn’t exaggerating. The selection was small, but extremely diverse and included everything from medieval coins to fossilised shells, stuffed birds and other animals, to a wild flower display dating from a hundred thousand years ago. Had the circumstances been different, he knew his interest would probably have been more enthusiastic.

  Today, though, he had only one thing on his mind.

  She took him to the final part of the museum where the selection was by far the most extensive, the subject matter primarily nautical. Even prior to his visit, Ben was familiar with the islands’ history of shipwrecks, but what awaited was definitely a surprise.

  “What we have here are the remains of many of the recorded shipwrecks that have occurred around the Isles over the past five centuries.”

  Ben placed his hand to his chin, noticing from the descriptions that some of the wrecks dated back to the time of the Vikings.

  “Wow.”

  The woman smiled. “Take a look at this.” She gestured to her right. “What you see here are the remains of the great naval disaster.”

  The name rang a bell. The most common title given to the night of 22 October 1707. Four ships capsized, over 1,000 dead.

  The worst naval disaster in British history.

  “What vessel is this?” he asked of the remnants of wood on display, apparently once part of a ship.

  “One of the ships that capsized,” she replied. “Experts believe from its size it
might have been the Association. But we can’t tell for sure.”

  He nodded, silently examining the find. He knew that HMS Association had been one of the key ships in the conflict.

  “Tell me, what’s the oldest wreck there’s ever been in these parts?”

  “We have one over here that dates back to the Vikings, although technically this wasn’t wrecked in the Scillies,” she replied, walking Ben past the keepsakes from HMS Association, heading on to the next part of the display. “The next oldest is this.” She pointed to the scattered remains of another ship. On this occasion the remains were fragmentary and difficult to identify.

  Ben looked at the display, paying close attention to the inscription. “You don’t know the name?”

  “Unfortunately not. It was wrecked on the coast of Tresco in around 1305. Sadly, much was taken by the mob.”

  Ben nodded. “I was fascinated on my arrival to hear local folklore of a Spanish galleon going down somewhere in these waters. Is there any truth in that?”

  She smiled again. “As a matter of fact, the next oldest is this. I think you’ll find it most impressive.”

  She showed Ben another display, this one more comprehensive than the previous one. For the first time Ben smiled widely, inwardly struggling to believe what he was seeing. Although the fragments of wood, which were taking up much of the glass container in front of him, could have been from virtually anything, thanks to the descriptions alongside it he knew exactly what he was looking at.

  “The only vessel of its type to ever go down in these parts.”

  He looked at Dr Phillips and then again at the description accompanying the wreck. According to the printed text, the vessel was believed to be either of Spanish or Spanish Netherlands origin.

  “1555.” He smiled.

  “Yes, or at least that is what has been estimated.”

  “Why do you say that?” he asked, his interest fully piqued. “Could it be something else?”

  “The wreck here was discovered rather recently; in fact, it was only found in around 1978,” she began. “Sadly the site had already been the subject of a long salvage mission prior to the official designation in 1980.”

  Ben bit his lip, disappointed. Salvage prior to the site’s designation meant the good stuff had probably already been removed. “Where was it found?”

  “The wreck was found in an area called Bartholomew Ledge, located between St Mary’s and St Agnes.”

  Ben nodded. That coincided with the entry in TF’s diary.

  “Thanks to the great effort that went into the salvage mission, we were successful in putting together a picture of both the cargo and what the ship might have looked like. Look at this, for example.” She directed him to the next display. There were several corroded bronze artefacts on a shelf that, according to the description, were parts of a bell. “We believe much of the cargo was to be melted down when they returned to land. Most likely used for artillery purposes.”

  “You say it was discovered in 1978?”

  “That’s correct, yes.”

  “Now, and forgive me if I’m wrong,” Ben laughed, “but I was rather under the impression from my short time here that folklore of a Spanish shipwreck goes back a lot further.”

  She started laughing. “You’ve clearly done your research, Dr Maloney. As a matter of fact, folklore talks about members of the wrecked ship’s crew being stranded on both St Agnes and St Lide’s. Those on St Agnes, in particular, even claim to be descended from them.”

  “Any evidence?”

  “Alas, no. Folklore claims the ship was one from the second Spanish Armada of 1597 that got blown off course somehow and dashed to pieces on the rocks. Sadly, there’s no way of substantiating the rumour.”

  “How can you be sure about the date?”

  “As mentioned, efforts to name the ship itself have come up blank. One theory put forward is that it is the remains of the elusive San Bartolomé, which was one of the 1597 Spanish Armada ships and alleged to have gone down in this area. Since the structure of the ship was no longer intact when the wreck was found, it has not been possible to confirm this. However, among the finds was a chest of coins.”

  She walked on, passing a further two displays, both filled with remnants of wood and pottery from the same wreck, before stopping at a smaller glass cabinet that included six coins, two of which were badly damaged.

  “As you can see here,” she pointed out the most impressive of the coins, “the discovery of this provides helpful evidence about the ship’s possible identity. The date on which it sank can be no later than 1598 – the beginning of the reign of Philip III.”

  Ben looked at the coins, concentrating on the ones in the best condition. They were all silver and included a picture of the Spanish Crown. “What are the date ranges?”

  “The coins have all been dated between 1472 and 1555. Therefore logically the wreck occurred sometime after the last coin was minted and before the reign of Philip II ended.”

  Ben couldn’t argue with the logic. “What other theories have been put forward? Aside from the . . . sorry, what was that ship’s name again?”

  “The San Bartolomé,” she confirmed. “None. As far as I’m aware, no other Spanish galleon or ship from the Netherlands is reported to have been lost in these waters in either the 1500s or 1600s. The site continues to be monitored on a regular basis, and other pieces of wreck continue to be salvaged from time to time.”

  “I understand there’s another tradition similar to the Armada story?”

  “You must be talking about the conquistadors?”

  Ben raised an eyebrow, unsure whether he was surprised or not. “You’re familiar with the legend?”

  A wry smile. “Of course. The legend of Cortés is a famous one around these parts.”

  “Judging from my time here, I was almost under the impression it was something people didn’t like to advertise.”

  She walked him along the corridor and entered a tidy office with several filing cabinets, a large desk and numerous photographs on the wall recording prominent moments in the museum’s past. One immediately caught his eye. The then curator and several members of staff and volunteers were standing alongside the British monarch at the grand opening.

  She opened one of the filing cabinets and immediately started digging through the contents. “Fortunately, things like this aren’t as common as you might fear,” she said, removing something and passing it over. On closer examination, Ben saw it was a newspaper clipping dated 1992.

  Ben read it quickly, his eyes darting side to side. The words sickened him to the core. “You believe this to be true?”

  The woman was sceptical. “It’s only a theory.”

  It was a very disturbing one. According to the article, an amateur archaeologist from Somerset, England, had been found drowned in the waters off Tresco less than a week after coming to the Isles, searching for the remains of ships.

  “He was searching for Cortés’s gold?”

  “I honestly don’t know. It makes for good reading, doesn’t it?”

  Ben returned the newspaper clipping and drew his hands through his long, dark hair.

  “Interest in the Spanish galleon – the Bartholomew Wreck as we name it – has been ongoing ever since its discovery. Since my retirement from lecturing, I’ve been spending more and more time out here. Progress remains a priority.”

  Ben turned his attention to the surrounding artefacts displayed on the walls of the office. There were also several photographs of wrecks, particularly salvage operations. One was of the Bartholomew Wreck, dated 1980. Though the wreck was interesting, he personally doubted there was much to be found on the ship itself.

  “Where did the Cortés story come from? I mean, I’m assuming there’s evidence somewhere.”

  “I honestly don’t know. As we’ve already spoken about, tradition dates a wreck right back to the 1500s, probably the 1580s or 90s. The Cortés tale, if true, should have been much earlier. Of course,
Hernán Cortés died in 1547. There were coins on the vessel dated to 1555. Therefore, it couldn’t have been the same man.”

  Ben grinned. “But the tradition can’t be dated?”

  “The oldest version I’ve come across is this.” She leaned towards the nearby bookcase and passed him an old library-bound book.

  He flicked through the early pages, checking the copyright details. The book dated from 1812 – a history of the Isles of Scilly. “What am I looking for exactly?”

  “The book itself is only a partial history of the Isles – an antiquarian’s take on history and local lore, including the Cortés story. Unfortunately, in many places the author seemed incapable of telling the two apart.”

  Ben smiled. In other words it was historically worthless. “You mind if I borrow this?”

  “Of course. Be sure to return it before you leave.”

  The woman was a diamond. Despite the book containing written evidence for the legend, he knew it was still a long way from being an authentic history.

  “How about the wreckage? You think it was from a ship in the second Armada?”

  They left the office and returned to the area where the wreck was on display. “In truth, we don’t know. The size of the ship would be consistent with that – but the same is true of ships from the Spanish Netherlands. It is a fact that the San Bartolomé has never been found.”

  “How about bodies? Keepsakes? A captain’s log?” he said the last bit with a grin. “Nothing of the people?”

  “As far as I’m aware, nothing of the sort has been found. It can’t be ruled out, of course, that many of the crew successfully escaped before the ship hit the rocks. Any documents et cetera would have been destroyed by the sea. At least the content would no longer be legible.”

  That thought had already occurred to Ben. “Out of interest, what do you know about the Godolphins?”

  The question surprised her. “They were the leaseholders of the Isles between the 1500s and 1800s.”

  “Leaseholders?”

  “That’s right. As I’m sure you’re already aware, the island was governed on behalf of the Duke of Cornwall. The islands themselves all form part of the Duchy of Cornwall, established during the reign of Edward III, and include the estates that made up the original earldom, established by Richard, the brother of Henry III.”