All Hallow's Eve: The One Day It's BAD to Be Good

by Carolyn McCray

  “Screw that!” I’m staying right here until—”

  “Helen’s dead, Connor. And those were the body parts of God knows how many people. Probably our classmates’ body parts!”

  “Falling on your head!” Frannie interjected.

  “You got off lucky, Connor, but we don’t know when the killer will be back for you or any of us.”

  Connor looked between Cecilia and Michael. Then he, too, gulped.

  “Yeah. Okay. Do it. Pull them, man. Pull them out now!”

  As Michael moved down to Connor’s feet, Cecilia helped prop Connor up against the wall. “Frannie, grab his hand. Comfort him.”

  While her friend took Connor’s hand, Cecilia wasn’t quite sure how comforting it was as Frannie kept murmuring, “Oh, my God.” Over and over again.

  “Frannie, something a little more constructive, please.”

  “Oh, dear God! All that blood. All that blood.” Her eyes darted down the hallway. “He could be here. He could be behind any door. He could be coming right now.”

  Not exactly what I had in mind, Frannie, Cecilia thought.

  “Do you have him, Cecilia?” Michael asked.

  She nodded sharply. The hall seemed darker, more foreboding. Every time the walls shook from the music, Cecilia imagined body parts falling down upon her. Or that hawk mask swooping in and claiming them all. The sooner they got the nails out of Connor, the sooner they could get out of here.

  Michael gritted his teeth and gripped the steel spike. “One. Two.” He jerked the spike from Connor’s foot.

  “Ow!!! You didn’t say three!”

  “There’s just one more,” Michael said. “Take a breath.”

  Connor leaned his head back against the wall. Cecilia let up on his shoulder to give him a momentary break when Michael grabbed the other spike and pulled it from Connor’s foot.

  “You didn’t even say one!” Connor bellowed.

  “Come on, get him up,” Michael urged Cecilia.

  She didn’t have to be told twice. “Frannie, help me.”

  But her friend backed away. “That could have been me. Why wasn’t it me?”

  “Yeah, why wasn’t it her?” Connor questioned, as he leaned into Cecilia.

  “Guys!” Michael whispered harshly. “Listen.”

  Sure enough, there was a creak. A creak coming from the darkened hallway. Closer and closer.

  “Let’s just get the hell out of here!” Michael whispered.

  This time, no one argued.

  * * *

  Ruth watched as Diana Dahmer slid on his knees across the stage, holding a flashlight up to his face, making grotesque expressions. It seemed that the amps were tied into the same backup generator as the emergency lighting, because she could hear every foul note of the band’s song.

  She turned to the security chief. “I thought I said I wanted them offstage?”

  “Look, I’ve only got twenty men, and that’s including the station’s ushers.”

  Security had barely corralled a tenth of the teens, and even those kids were threatening to break free of the guards if they didn’t get Dahmer offstage. Fast. She turned to find Paxton trotting back from talking with some of the security guards from the other side of the ballroom.

  “No sign of Cecilia or the boys. They could be anywhere.”

  That did not calm her nerves any. She had to just be happy her son and the others weren’t with Helen in the “Pre-Morgue” turned real morgue.

  “Chief,” Ruth said. “I need that band offstage.”

  “Look,” he retorted. “I need some prioritization here. Half my men are out trying to round up the kids from the ‘fun rooms.’ ” He pointed toward the back halls. “I’ve got another set sweeping—”

  An usher in a tight ballerina tutu splashed with blood ran up. “Sir, we … I … found…” the girl gulped air. But as the gurney rolled up with a sheet over a body, it became pretty damn clear what she had found.

  Ruth found that her feet would not move forward. Even Paxton seemed rooted in place.

  “Boy or girl?” Paxton asked the ballerina.

  “Pretty sure it’s a guy, but he was… well… scalded.”

  “What…” Ruth tried to pull herself together as she stared at the bloodstained sheet that covered the body. “What does he look like?

  “Well,” the girl answered, “he’s kind of pink and—”

  “No,” Paxton interrupted. “She meant hair color? Eyes?”

  “Um, I wasn’t exaggerating. He’s just a big pink glob at this point.”

  Ruth went to step forward, but Paxton grabbed her arm and gave it a squeeze. “Let me.”

  She shouldn’t let him. It could be his nephew, but Ruth just couldn’t pull back that blanket.

  Paxton strode up to the gurney. But, once there, he stalled. She watched as he clenched his fingers into a fist to keep from shaking. He lifted the sheet gently. Ruth watched as he brought his sleeve up to his mouth.

  “I can’t. I can’t tell,” he said. Ruth’s heart sank. Was that her son under that sheet? How long would it take to know for sure? But then Paxton lifted the sheet higher. “Wait. It looks like there’s a tattoo.”

  Suddenly Ruth’s feet were moving, and she joined him. The usher had been right. Every inch of the boy had been melted. Skin swirled like candle wax. His features were simply gone. His nose was where his ear should be and his ear was on his forehead.

  Paxton pointed to the shoulder. “It looked like there used to be ink over the biceps.”

  He was right. While warped, the image did look like a skull with flames shooting out of its eyes.

  Her partner let the blanket fall back down. “It’s not Jer or Evan.” A flicker of a smile crossed his face.

  She too felt such a wave of relief she had to grab the side of the gurney. “No,” Ruth said, straightening up. “But it is someone else’s son.”

  Ruth turned to the security chief. “I want him,” she said pointing to Dahmer, “off the stage now.”

  The security chief indicated his radio. “I’ve sent three guys up there already. He refuses to get off. He says he wants the station to gets its money’s worth.”

  “Great,” Paxton said. “A devil worshipper with a work ethic.”

  “Look, I can send more guys—”

  Ruth shook her head. The time for delegating was over. As much as she wanted to head out into that crowd and check every single one of them to see if it was Evan, she had a bigger obligation—making sure every parent’s kid came home safe.

  “Don’t,” she said to the chief. “We’ll handle Dahmer. Once we get the band offstage, get this room locked down systematically, then go through all the ancillary rooms. Got it?”

  After the chief’s nod, Ruth headed backstage. Paxton was right beside her as they hauled ass toward the right of the stage.

  “Sorry I didn’t discuss the plan with you first,” Ruth said.

  “Well, it wasn’t very partner-ly. However, I do love to see you in action.”

  Ruth only wished there was more action. They should be searching for the boys rather than dealing with some singer’s inflated ego.

  “Any idea how we are going to get them offstage?” Ruth asked.

  Paxton indicated his gun. “I’ve already discharged my weapon in public. If I’ve got to fill out that paperwork, I might as well make it worth my while.”

  “Well, hopefully it won’t come to that.”

  Paxton put his finger in his ears and rubbed. “You say, ‘hopefully it won’t.’ I say, ‘hopefully it will.’ Tomato. Tomato.”

  Ruth couldn’t help but grin. She knew he was as worried about Jeremy as she was about Evan, but still he tried to cheer her up. Or he was serious. Which was fine by her.

  CHAPTER 9

  The group stopped in unison at the sound. The clang echoed off the long hallway, making it hard for Cecilia to know where it came from.

  “What was that?” Frannie whispered.

  “Probably th
e spike guy,” Connor moaned.

  Cecilia couldn’t blame him much. The floor beneath their feet was slick with Connor’s blood. Every step they took, Connor became weaker and weaker.

  “Shh!” Michael whispered, as Frannie caught a sob in her throat. “We’re got to figure out which direction the sound is coming from.”

  Cecilia held her breath as they waited. Then a creak came. From above them. Nausea rolled over her. Not again. But this noise sounded more like a footstep than the ceiling giving way like before. Sure enough, another footstep… then another. Someone was walking overhead.

  “There must be an attic,” Michael whispered.

  Another set of footsteps echoed down the hallway. That wasn’t just someone in the attic—there was someone else in the hall as well.

  “We’re exposed out here,” Cecilia whispered back.

  Michael tested the door nearest to him. The knob turned. “Hurry, inside.”

  Cecilia had to practically carry Connor as they entered.

  “Oh!” Frannie cried out, pointing to a crumpled figure in the corner.

  It looked like a girl. She was in a dress, except her head was bald. And her fingernails had been ripped off.

  “Is she dead?” Connor asked the question they were all thinking.

  Michael carefully closed the door behind them and, step by step, approached the still figure. Cecilia couldn’t let him do it alone. She crept behind him as he knelt down. He felt for a pulse.

  “She’s alive,” he breathed out. “Unconscious, but alive.”

  Cecilia snuck in closer. The girl lay at an unnatural angle. Her left leg was twisted back and her arm was trapped under her. But there was something about her eyes and cheekbones that seemed familiar.

  “Paula!” Frannie exclaimed above them.

  Cecilia looked back down at the girl. It couldn’t be Paula, could it? Paula from PE? “But what happened to her hair? She has long, black hair.”

  Michael scurried back. “Ugh. I think I found it.”

  He was right. At his feet was a pile of dark, shorn hair. Who had done this to her? And why? Why do any of this? She bet Paula wished that she’d had a party at her house, DJ and all.

  Connor hobbled up behind them. “Okay, so the spikes weren’t so bad.”

  Cecilia helped Michael get Paula into a more comfortable position. The girl roused only a little, then fell back into her stupor.

  “Was she drugged, like Frannie?” Cecilia asked.

  “I don’t know, but her pulse is weak.”

  They both knelt there. Clearly neither of them knew what to do. In the sparse light, Cecilia trembled. She could hear her own harsh breath. Tears sprang to Cecilia’s eyes. She didn’t want to be like Frannie, sobbing pitifully into her hands. She didn’t want to look weak, but who really was strong at a time like this?

  Michael put his arm around her. “We’ll figure it out.”

  “Yeah, well, I’ve figured it out,” Connor said, sliding down the wall. “I’m staying here.”

  Cecilia frowned as Michael’s arm dropped from her shoulders. She already missed the warmth and support.

  “We can’t. Not to reinforce Frannie’s hysteria,” Michael nodded to Frannie. “No offense, but the killer really could be coming back any minute.”

  Connor rubbed the wounds on his wrists where he had been bound. “And he could also be around the next turn. Or the ceiling above us is filled with guts. Or a thousand different things. With a guy this f—ed up, we just don’t know.”

  “But we’ve got to try,” Michael stated as he rose. “Quentin is still out there.”

  “And for that, man, I am sorry, Michael. But dude, I just can’t go any farther.”

  Frannie hugged herself, rocking back and forth. “Me, either.”

  “Guys! What if that were you still out there, like Quentin? Alone and terrified, hoping someone was coming for you? Well?”

  Cecilia stood as well, putting a hand out to Michael. “Come here.”

  At first, he just glared at her hand, like it was treasonous offering. But she smiled, hopefully with reassurance. Tentatively he took her hand and she drew him away from the others. His breath came in puffs, he was so angry. Cecilia couldn’t blame him. She could only imagine how she would feel if Frannie were still missing.

  “Michael.”

  “Not you, too,” he said, holding her gaze.

  “No, actually, I think we do need to be on the move… but back to the ballroom.” She hurried over to Michael. “They’ve got to listen to us now. With all this happening?”

  He shook his head, though. “No. We find Quentin, and then head back.”

  Cecilia put her other hand over his. “And let’s say we find Quentin in bad shape or worse. What are we going to do? We can’t even help Paula properly.” They both looked down at the unconscious girl. “This is bigger than we thought. We need help.”

  He gripped her hand. “But Quentin.”

  She groaned inwardly. How could she voice her fears to him? Especially with his eyes swimming in tears and his heart so heavy? She couldn’t. She couldn’t tell him she feared that his friend had already joined Helen. Her friend had told them nearly as much. And now, finding Connor and Paula? From the fragmented time line they had pieced together from Frannie, the killer had had Quentin and Helen twice the time. But she just couldn’t crush Michael in that way.

  “The best way to help Quentin is to get help. Lots and lots of help.”

  Michael took a deep breath in and closed his eyes, which seemed to steady his nerves. When he opened them again, he appeared stronger, more resolved. “All right, but you should stay here. If I don’t come back within a half an hour, you can try next.”

  Cecilia liked the way he tried to protect her, but if he didn’t come back in half an hour, well… She doubted she would be in any condition to follow.

  “Look, I’m normally the girl sitting in the back of the class hoping no one will call her name, but you can’t do this alone.”

  “I can,” he tried to reassure her, but his voice trembled.

  Cecilia put her hand out and cupped his face. “I know you could, but you don’t have to.”

  He leaned into her palm. “I really don’t want to go out there alone, but I really don’t want you in danger.”

  “I know, but I am…” Cecilia couldn’t finish the sentence. No matter how loath she was to suggest that Quentin was dead, she was even more reluctant to share her other concern. Actually, her other fear. “I think that… I think John may be behind this.”

  Michael didn’t seem surprised. If anything, he seemed energized by the news. “All the more reason for you to stay here.”

  Her eyes narrowed. “You thought the same thing?”

  “There are all kinds of rumors at school that he’s doping, and that the guy has got some serious mommy issues.” He looked down at Connor, Frannie, and Paula. “But as much as I hate the guy, it’s hard to imagine him doing this. All of this.”

  A few days ago Cecilia would have agreed, but after today? She had never seen so much rage before. Seeing John’s face contorted and blotched red, Cecilia could imagine him doing this just a little bit.

  “Which is why I can’t let you go alone,” Cecilia said, stroking his cheek with her thumb.

  He leaned in. She could feel his breath upon her skin. His warmth mingled with hers. His lips hovered over hers.

  “So are you two going, or what?” Connor asked.

  Michael backed away, blushing. “Yeah. Yeah. We’re going.”

  But as he turned back to their friends, he caught Cecilia’s hand and gave it a squeeze. “Look, guys, we are going to have to take the flashlight.”

  “But… but… that’s going to leave us in the dark,” Frannie said, looking ready to go all panicky again.

  Connor pulled Frannie closer to him. “We can handle it. Just haul ass like you were stealing home base, man.”

  “You know it,” Michael said, and then his voice became serious.
“Frannie, I need you to buck up, girl, for just a minute and push that dresser in front of the door after we leave.”

  Frannie, though, perked up, seeming to love the idea. Cecilia pulled Frannie into a hug. She wanted to stay hopeful, but this might be the last time they saw one another. What was the last thing she had said to Helen? That she was a hair spray addict? She didn’t want those to be her last words to Frannie.

  “Francesca,” Cecilia started, but her friend hugged her all the closer.

  “No. We are not going to have a Titanic moment here.” Frannie said. “You are going out and coming back. Got it?”

  Cecilia held back tears. “Got it.”

  She turned back to Michael, but Frannie grabbed her hand. “And if you find any chicken wings…”

  “I’ll be sure to get ranch dressing,” Cecilia replied

  Her friend gave a faint smile as Michael cracked the door open. He looked down both ways. “It looks clear.”

  Taking his hand, they exited. No sooner was her foot past the threshold that Frannie slammed the door closed behind them, locked it, and from the rumbling was moving the dresser already.

  “Guess it’s just you and me,” Michael commented, with a faint smile on his lips.