Dee's Second Chance Times Two (Siren Publishing Ménage Everlasting)

by Marla Monroe

  “Everything is always more intense and special when you’re with someone you love and care about. It means you can relax and just feel. You’re not concentrating on doing it yourself. Just feel, baby girl. Feel how good we can make it for you,” Amos said.

  Andy’s hands rubbed up and down her back in a comforting way. With every pass of his hands against her skin, Dee let go a little more. Each time he reached her ass, he massaged each cheek then began the journey back up her spine to massage her neck.

  “You are so beautiful, honey. Are you comfortable like this? Are my knees poking you too much?” he asked.

  “I’m fine. I’m more than fine,” she drawled.

  Both men chuckled softly at her admission. She was so far gone at the feel of Andy’s finger sliding in and out of her ass, Dee couldn’t think of much else. God, she could come just like this. If Amos didn’t move on to something more, she just might.

  Dee was just about to ask for more when he withdrew his finger and more of the cool lubricant dropped on her back hole. The difference in temperatures elicited another round of chills along her skin.

  Then Amos was massaging the gel into her hole and this time there was a slight pinch as he slowly pressed two fingers into the tight space. When he met the resistance of the tight ring of muscle, he just massaged the area without pressing any deeper for a few seconds, then he pushed a little harder and the tips of his fingers slid through. The bite of pain didn’t even register as real pain at that point. All she could feel was the need for more.

  “Ahhh, so good,” she moaned out loud.

  Neither of the men said anything. She was relieved they didn’t laugh again or tell her it would only get better. Words right then were more than she could take. She needed to come to grips with what she was enjoying before she could accept their excitement that she wasn’t asking them to stop. Enjoying something this naughty seemed wrong, but deep down inside of her, Dee knew it wasn’t.

  What was the difference in her using a butt plug on herself sometimes when she got off when she was alone? No, it hadn’t felt anything close to this good, but still. She finally accepted that it was because they knew that she felt uncomfortable. Dee needed to stop worrying about what they knew about her sex life and move on. That was then, and this was now.

  Dee realized Amos had managed to get both fingers inside of her and was slowly pumping them in and out. She didn’t even feel the pinch of pain anymore. It felt amazing!

  “Baby. I think you’re ready for the first plug. Ready to try it?” he asked.

  “Yes.” She was definitely ready.

  His fingers disappeared again and seconds later, the pressure at her back entrance increased with the tip of the plug pressing against her ass. At first it didn’t really feel like anything, but then the pressure increased and the bite of pain morphed into a sharper pain as it spread her ass wider than she was used to.

  Dee almost asked him to stop when it surged forward and the pain slowly receded. Now all she felt was a fullness that wasn’t exactly uncomfortable, but it didn’t feel amazing like she had felt earlier.

  “That’s it, Dee baby. It’s all the way in. Are you okay?” Amos asked.

  “Yeah. It’s kind of large. I can definitely tell that it’s larger than the one I was using,” she told him.

  “You need to adjust to it before we go up a size,” Andy told her as he helped her stand up.

  “Up a size? Um, is that necessary?” she asked with a little less enthusiasm than before.

  Amos smiled down at her. “Yeah. We’re both a little bigger than this, baby girl. Look.” He picked up another butt plug from the towel he’d spread on the bed.

  “Oh, my. It already feels like a log poking inside of me. I can’t imagine anything larger.” Dee was beginning to doubt she would be able to go through with it.

  “After a few minutes, you’ll get used to it and we’ll move up one more. Then you can wear the plug tonight and we’ll take it out in the morning. When we do it again tomorrow night, you might be ready to handle both of us at the same time then, Dee Dee,” Andy told her with an encouraging smile.

  “Maybe. I’m not so sure about that now. This one isn’t exactly comfortable,” she admitted as she took a step away from the bed.

  After the third step, the movement of the plug deep inside of her stirred up something deeper—darker. A soft tingling began that turned into an itch. The more she walked, the stronger it became until she wanted to rub her pussy against something to get some relief.

  “Amos, I think she’s ready for the next one,” Andy said, nodding in her direction.

  “Come here, Dee. Let’s try the next one.” Amos held out his hand toward her.

  “Are you sure? This one is bothering me. Am I allergic to it or something?” she asked.

  “No, baby girl. It’s just your body adjusting to it and wanting something more. That’s what you’re feeling like, right?” he asked.

  “Yeah. I want to…” She trailed off, realizing what she’d been about to tell them.

  “Want to what, honey?” Andy asked.

  Dee searched his then Amos’s face and found no hint of amusement. Could she tell them what she’d been thinking? They were supposed to be honest with each other about everything. She couldn’t start breaking that promise already.

  “It makes me need to rub against something,” she finally admitted.

  “You need to rub your pussy on something to get some relief, right?” Amos asked her.

  “Yes. That’s what it feels like.”

  “Here’s my knee, Dee. You can rub on my knee if you want to. It might make me come, but that’s fine with me. Seeing you use me for what you need is a real turn-on, honey.” Andy stood up and almost jerked his slacks and boxers off all at one time.

  Kicking them away, he sat back down and spread his legs slightly so that she would have room to ride his knee. Dee couldn’t take her eyes off of his monstrous cock. It jutted out almost parallel to the floor. The massive mushroom head looked angry and painful.

  “Dee? Come on over. I’m all yours, honey.” Andy held out one hand and waited.

  She jerked her eyes from his shaft and looked at where his hand waited for her to take it. Dee reached out and took a step only to have the butt plug ignite her nerve endings all over again. Need so strong she almost whimpered poured through her body, burning a path from anus to clit.

  Dee grabbed Andy’s hand and let him pull her to stand in front of him. She whimpered then straddled one leg and gently rubbed her pussy up his thigh. He was sitting at the perfect height so that her clit dragged over the coarse hairs of his thick leg.

  “Oh, God!” she nearly yelled. “I need more.”

  Andy lifted his knee and ground it into her pussy at just the right angle. Dee lost it then and began riding his knee like a wanton dog in heat. She thrust and held on to his shoulders, digging her nails into his skin without realizing it until much later.

  She cried out in frustration as her climax seemed just out of reach, but then Amos was there and she could feel his naked skin pressing against her back, the hardness of his cock rubbing her low back. After a second, Amos backed off with a curse and began to twist the butt plug lodged deep inside of her as she ground her cunt on Andy’s hard knee. Almost immediately Dee exploded with a hoarse cry that was loud in her own ears.

  Once again, she seemed to float but her aching lungs dragged her back to the room and her men. She gasped for breath then burst out crying.

  Chapter Twelve

  “If she’s going to pass out every time she comes, we’re going to go crazy, Amos.” Andy wasn’t sure what to do.

  “I don’t think she will. I think this is all so overwhelming and new to her is all. Once the new wears off, she’ll act more normally. Look at her, Andy. I doubt she’s ever had an orgasm like we’ve given her before. No way she could get herself off like this and whatever other men she’s been with. They didn’t know the first thing on how to please a woman.”
Amos grinned at his brother. “We’re doing this for her. She’s ours, Andy.”

  Andy nodded his head slowly. Amos was right, but it didn’t ease the tension inside of him to see her unconscious no matter how good the sex they’d given her was.

  Seconds later, Dee’s eyes opened becoming impossibly wide.

  “What happened?” she asked, looking from one hovering brother to the other.

  “You passed out again,” Andy told her.

  “Don’t mind his grouchy face, baby girl. You worry him when you do that. How do you feel?” Amos asked, shaking his head at Andy.

  “Um, good I guess. Kind of relaxed and maybe a little sore,” she admitted.

  “Let’s change out that plug while you’re still pretty relaxed,” Amos suggested.

  Andy wasn’t sure if they should subject Dee to anything more, but at the sight of the medium-sized plug slowly being removed while leaving her ass flared open, all doubts slipped away. All he could think about was how good that wide open back hole looked to him. His dick throbbed with need.

  “Looks really inviting, doesn’t it, Andy,” Amos said in a raspy voice as he stared at the still-enlarged opening.

  “Better get the other plug in while it’s dilated, Amos. I don’t want it to hurt her,” Andy told his brother.

  No doubt Dee didn’t think she could handle the larger one, but he felt like it wouldn’t be bad at all after her amazing climax. The endorphins would be coursing throughout her bloodstream and her muscles would be limp with satiation.

  Andy watched as his twin lubed up the larger plug then squeeze a fair amount of the stuff into her opening before fitting the tip of the plug into the hole. He anxiously watched Dee’s face where it was turned to one side as she lay across the bed. He lay on his side so that he wouldn’t miss any twinge or shudder this way. A little pain wasn’t bad, but he refused to allow her to really hurt because of something they’d done.

  From the look of utter concentration on his brother’s face, Andy knew Amos was just as worried. He kept looking over at Andy to judge her reaction since he had a straight line of sight to her face.

  “She’s fine so far, Amos. I’ll let you know if there’s a problem,” Andy told him.

  He watched closely as Amos slowly maneuvered the plug in and out of her ass until it was fully seated. To his relief and surprise, Dee didn’t make a sound. In fact, her expression only changed from relaxed to one of concentration, but no pain showed at all.

  “Are you okay, honey?” Andy asked, unable to believe she’d managed the large plug without some slight pain.

  “Ummm,” she hummed. “I’m good.”

  “Did I hurt you, baby?” Amos asked, a note of anxious strain in his voice.

  “Hmmm, no. Just a pinch maybe, but I feel really full. I’m not sure I can move.” Her voice held no discomfort that Andy could hear.

  “Do you think you could handle one of us inside of you with it in?” Amos asked.

  “Amos. That can wait. We don’t want to push this. She’s done so well,” Andy snapped.

  “It’s okay, Andy. I’m fine. I want this. Remember? I told you I wanted us to make love tonight.” Dee told him.

  “I’m not sure it’s a good idea though. She’s bound to be sore from this without adding anything more.” Andy couldn’t believe his brother was going to try and push their woman like this. They’d nearly lost her already.”

  “Really, Andy. I want to. I’ll tell you stop if it’s too much. It feels so good now and I’m getting that itch back.”

  Andy couldn’t believe she was the same woman as the one who’d fought their attempts at telling her they were sorry and asking her to give them another chance. Instead, in her place was a sensual woman with needs that seemed to match their own. It was too good to be true which was why he was scared to push their luck.

  Amos lay back on the bed with Dee between them. He teased her nipples then stared into her eyes. Andy watched as she grinned back at his twin.

  “Climb on top of me, baby girl. You can ride me and control everything.”

  Andy watched as she slowly rolled over to her side before slowly climbing on top of his brother. He could tell from the stiff way she moved as she straddled Amos’s waist that the butt plug was working its way all around her ass. She obviously wasn’t sure how it felt about it until Amos grasped his dick with one hand and held it steady for her.

  “Just sink down on me, baby. Go as slow as you need to. I’m not going to force you to do anything you don’t want to do.” Amos’s voice was tight with strain, but he showed none of it in his expression.

  Andy didn’t know how his brother had found so much control. The man never showed restraint or control in anything he did except for maybe work. Even then he was the first to get excited or pissed off. This was a different man and Dee was the catalyst that brought it out in him.

  “Oh. My. God!” Dee hissed out. “That is freaking amazing! Every tiny move I make moves the plug in my ass.”

  “Easy, Dee Dee. Don’t force yourself down on me. Just go slow and let gravity help you. This is all about making you feel good. Hurting yourself would really ruin that,” Amos said.

  “Like you aren’t getting a little something out of this, too,” she quipped back then moaned as she sank a little farther.

  “Andy, give her your cock, man. She needs more than this,” Amos said around a groan.

  “I don’t want to overwhelm her, Amos. Next time. She’s barely gotten—umph!” Andy lost his breath when Dee swung her arm and punched him in the chest.

  “Stop it! You promised no trying to protect me or put words and feelings in my mouth. I want you in my mouth, Andy.” Dee stuck out her lips in an impressive pout.

  “I don’t think I said that exactly, honey,” he said, frowning. But the sight of her lips poked out had his dick itching to sink balls-deep between them.

  “Please, Andy. Don’t make me beg. I want to taste you. This all so unbelievable. I need both of you to keep me grounded. I don’t want to lose myself. Please, Andy.” Her eyes begged just as hard as her words.

  “Just pull back if you need to, honey. I’m not going to hold your head,” he said.

  Where he was going to get the energy to keep his hands off of her, Andy wasn’t sure, but he knew her hot, wet mouth would be a mixture of heaven and hell without being able to tug on her hair and massage her scalp. The idea of sliding his cock down her throat while his fingers speared her hair sent a wave of longing through him.

  Next time. I’ll hold off this time for her and next time I’ll play. Amos is right, we might get some satisfaction from it, but it is all about her pleasure this time. Hell, it will always be about her. She is fucking amazing.

  When he positioned himself on his knees with his cock bobbing in front of her face, Andy gazed down into her eyes as she slowly sank down on his brother’s shaft while she painted his cockhead with her wet tongue. That first touch of his flesh was almost more than he could handle. Hell, he’d had blow jobs in the past, but nothing compared to that one slow lick by his Dee.

  Without warning, Dee drew in just the crown and ran the tip of her tongue beneath the lip of the mushroom-shaped head. Andy hissed at the pleasure that coursed down his rod. Damn, but that was good. Dee sucked on the cap while her tongue licked over the tip then slid into the slit at the top. She hummed with his cockhead still secured by her lips. If he’d been standing up, Andy would have been on his tiptoes by now.

  “Oh, honey. That’s so fucking good. Damn, my balls are already swelling,” he admitted.

  “She’s squeezing my cock so much now that I’m already on the verge,” his brother admitted. “All I’m doing is trying to control my climax and keep my hands on her hips to stop her from coming down too fast and hard.”

  “She’s killing me,” Andy agreed.

  “Easy, baby girl. This isn’t a race. Just rock on me some. This is supposed to be a first step, not the whole show, Dee Dee.” Amos’s words sounded even more
strained than before.

  As if trying to tell them to fuck it, Dee surprised Andy by engulfing his shaft all the way to the root then swallowing around it. Andy saw stars and was pretty sure he shouted out.

  “Oh. Fuck!”

  * * * *

  Pride and excitement lit up Dee’s face with heat at Andy’s shout. She’d taken him by surprise and deep throated him. Not many people could do that without choking, but she could. It was something she’d found out by accident once but made sure she never did it again. It had scared her because she hadn’t been in control that time.

  Well this time, she was in control. Andy’s hands had come to her head and his nails dug into her scalp as if he couldn’t help himself, but he didn’t try and hold her head or control her. Instead, as soon as he realized what he was doing and Dee started to pull back on his hard cock, Andy jerked his hands back, mumbling apologies over and over.

  Dee slowly pulled off of his dick and smiled up at him. “It’s fine, Andy. That was the biggest thrill to know I shot your control to hell and back.” Then she sucked him deep in her mouth again and again.

  “Fuck, Dee. I’m going to come if you do that again. Hold back, honey,” Andy told her.

  “What the fuck did she do, Andy?” Amos demanded. “I thought she was going to strangle my fucking dick. She’s still got a damn vice grip on it.”

  “The woman can deep throat. I nearly lost it right then,” Andy told his twin.

  Dee chuckled around the thick flesh in her mouth. It must have vibrated along Andy’s shaft because he groaned low and deep.

  “Holy hell, babe. I think we are the most idiotic men in the world. We didn’t want to ruin you and scare you off all these years when in reality, you already knew a lot more about the birds and the bees than we anticipated. I’m holding on to my cum by a string. Are you close, baby girl?” Andy asked.

  Dee slowly pulled off of Andy’s cock to the tune of his groan in pleasure. “I’ve already come twice. I don’t think a third time is necessary. I’m having too much fun with the two of you to worry about that,” she told them.