Earthborn (Homecoming)

by Orson Scott Card

  “I should think that the children or the other teachers would report you the moment you’re seen,” said Akmaro.

  “Not at all,” said Edhadeya. “The girls appreciate my help. And so, I think, do the teachers.”

  “What does Shedemei say when she throws you out?” asked Didul.

  “It’s quite colorful,” said Edhadeya. “She keeps explaining to me that when she said I wasn’t supposed to wait, she meant that I shouldn’t just wait. That I should be actively involved in life, getting some experience to help me put my book learning into perspective.”

  “So why don’t you do as she asks?” said Akmaro.

  “Because I think that sneaking into her school and teaching without her spotting me is an excellent experience.”

  They all laughed at that. The subject eventually turned from Shedemei to speculations on what Rasa’s House must have been like, back on the planet Harmony, and from there the conversation drifted to talking about people who had seen true dreams from the Keeper. “We keep talking about true dreamers as if they were all ancient or far away,” said Luet, “but it’s worth remembering that every single one of us has had at least one true dream. I haven’t had any since I was little—but then, I haven’t needed anything as much as I did then. Have you dreamed since those old days, Didul?”

  Didul shook his head, not really wanting to talk about “those old days.”

  “I don’t really dream,” said Chebeya. “That’s not a raveler’s gift.”

  “But the Keeper still shows you things,” said Luet. “That’s the thing we have to remember—the Keeper isn’t just something that our ancestors believed in. She isn’t just a myth.” To everyone’s surprise, tears suddenly came to her eyes. “Akma keeps saying that we’re fooling ourselves, but we’re not. I remember how it felt, and it was different from any other dream. It was real. Wasn’t it, Edhadeya?”

  “It was,” said Edhadeya. “Pay no attention to your brother, Luet. He doesn’t know anything.”

  “But he does” said Luet. “He’s the most intelligent person I’ve ever known. And so vigorous in everything he says and does—he was my teacher when I was little, and he’s still my teacher now, except for this one thing—”

  “This one little thing,” murmured Akmaro.

  “Can’t you make him see, Father?” said Luet.

  “You can’t make people believe things,” said Chebeya.

  “The Keeper can! Why doesn’t the Keeper just . . . just send him a true dream?”

  “Maybe the Keeper does,” said Didul.

  They all looked at him in surprise.

  “I mean, didn’t the Keeper send dreams to Nafai’s older brothers?”

  “If it makes any difference,” said Edhadeya, “it was the Oversoul.”

  “I thought Elemak had at least one true dream from the Keeper,” said Didul. “Anyway, there was also Moozh. The one that Nafai wrote about—Luet’s and Hushidh’s father. The one who fought the Oversoul all the way, but he was really doing the Oversoul’s will the whole time.’”

  “You can’t imagine that Akma is somehow doing the Keeper’s will!” said Edhadeya. “Hating the poor earth people and wanting to get them excluded from the kingdom!”

  “No, I don’t mean that, I just mean—that you can resist the Keeper if you want to. How do we know Akma isn’t having true dreams every night, and then getting up in the morning and denying that the dreams meant anything at all? The Keeper can’t make us do anything. Not if we’re determined to fight him.”

  “That’s true,” said Akmaro. “But I don’t think Akma is dreaming.”

  “Maybe he dreams true so much that he doesn’t realize that other people don’t,” said Didul. “Maybe his intelligence is partly a gift from the Keeper, unfolding truth to him in his mind. Maybe he’s the greatest servant the Keeper has ever had, except that he refuses to serve.”

  “That’s a big exception,” said Chebeya.

  “All I’m trying to say is that it wouldn’t necessarily change Akma’s mind to have a true dream. That’s all I’m saying.” Didul went back to the sugared fruit Edhadeya had brought for desert.

  “Well, it’s a sure thing persuasion hasn’t done anything,” said Akmaro.

  Chebeya made a little high-pitched sound in her throat.

  “What was that?” said Akmaro.

  “That was me,” said Chebeya. “Giving the tiniest possible laugh.”

  “What for?”

  “Akmaro, Didul has made me see things in a new way. I wonder if we really ever have tried to persuade Akma.”

  “I know I have,” said Akmaro.

  “No, you’ve tried to teach him. That’s another matter entirely.”

  “All teaching is persuasion,” said Akmaro. “And all persuasion is teaching.”

  “Then why did we bother to invent two different words for it?” asked Chebeya teasingly. “I’m not accusing you of anything, Akmaro.”

  “You’re accusing me of not even trying to persuade my son, when you know I’ve tried till my heart has broken.” Akmaro was trying to keep his tone light, but Didul could hear the emotion behind his smile.

  “Please don’t be hurt,” said Chebeya. “We all know you’ve done your best. But we’ve also left it up to you, haven’t we? I’ve been content to be the loving mother who tries to keep the connection with Akma strong. I’ve left all the arguing up to you.”

  “Not all,” said Luet grimly.

  “Akma is here so little, I’ve been afraid to argue with him for fear of losing him entirely,” said Chebeya. “But because of that, perhaps he thinks that it’s only a matter between him and his father. That Luet and I are neutral.”

  “He knows I’m not,” said Luet.

  Akmaro shook his head. “Chebeya, there’s no need. Akma will grow out of this.”

  Tears started slipping down Chebeya’s cheeks. “No he won’t,” she said. “Not now. This whole business with Shedemei—”

  “Akma doesn’t have anything to do with that, does he?” asked Didul.

  “The people who brought charges against her,” said Chebeya, “they won’t give up. It can’t be a secret from them how the son of the high priest feels about things. They’ll find a way to use him. If nothing else, they’ll flatter him, agree with him. Akma is hungry to be loved and respected—”

  “We all are,” said Edhadeya softly.

  “Akma more than most, in part because he feels that perhaps he has never had the love and respect he wanted at home.” Chebeya reached out a hand toward her husband, as if to soothe him. “Not your fault. It’s just the way things looked to him, from the beginning, from those awful days back in Chelem.”

  Didul looked at the ruins of his meal in front of him, his face burning as he remembered how he had treated Akma. The picture came so easily to his mind, more vivid perhaps now than it had been at the time. Little Akma crying and sputtering in fury as Didul and his brothers laughed and laughed. Then Akma crying in pain, a very different sound, a terrible sound . . . and still they laughed. Still I laughed, Didul thought. Does Akma hear that sound even now? If it’s even half as clear in his mind as it is in mine . . .

  He felt a hand close over his. For a moment he thought it might be Luet who touched him, and he wanted to tear his own hand away in shame at his un-worthiness. But it was Chebeya. “Please, Didul. You’re so much a part of this family that we forget sometimes that you hear some things with different ears. No one blames you here.”

  Didul nodded, not bothering to argue. Chebeya turned the conversation to other things, and the rest of the meal passed in peace.

  When it was time for Edhadeya to go home, she asked Didul to walk with her. Didul laughed; he meant to seem amused but knew that he only sounded nervous. “Is it that you have something you want to say to me, or that everyone else has things they want to say without me?”

  “He’s so sweet, isn’t he?” Edhadeya said. “He couldn’t conceive of the idea that I might enjoy his company.”
>
  Once they were on the dark street, walking home by the light of the torch Didul carried, Edhadeya said, “All right, yes, there’s something I wanted to say to you.”

  “Well, then,” said Didul. “Here I am. Or is it so devastating you want to wait till we’re nearer your father’s house, in case I burst into tears, throw down the torch, and run away into the night?”

  “You know what I want to talk about.”

  “I shouldn’t come to Akmaro’s house anymore, is that it?”

  Edhadeya laughed, startled. “What! Why would I say that? They love you—are you so shy you can’t see it?”

  “For Akma’s sake. So they can win him back.”

  “It’s not you, Didul. No, I wanted to say the opposite. Or really, I wanted to ask you something first, and then say something—Didul, I wish I understood you better.”

  “Better than you do right now? Better than other people do? Or better than you understand other people?”

  She giggled, very girlishly. Suddenly an image flashed into Didul’s mind, of Edhadeya and Luet sitting on a bench together, laughing just that way. Schoolgirls.

  “I’m listening now,” he said. “I’ll be serious.”

  “Didul, your life has been very strange,” said Edhadeya. “You were unlucky in your father, but very lucky in your brothers.”

  “Pabul’s done well. The rest of us struggle.”

  “You improved with age—which is better than most of us do. Most of us start out innocent and deteriorate.”

  “As low as my beginning was, Edhadeya, I had nowhere to go but up.”

  “I think not,” said Edhadeya. “But please listen. I’m not harping on your past, I’m saying that you are much admired. Many people say it—Father hears reports from Bodika, you know. You are much admired. And not just among the Kept.”

  “That’s kind of you to say.”

  “Yes, well, I’m repeating what others say. That you’re a man of compassion.”

  “Whatever people tell me, I can always say I’ve done worse, the Keeper can still accept you if you change now.”

  “Please listen, Didul. I have to know something from your own lips. It seems that you love everybody, that you show compassion to everybody, and wit and a kind of easiness—everyone is comfortable with you.”

  “Except you.”

  “Because when you’re with me—when you’re with Akmaro—you’re shy, you’re not at ease. You feel—”

  “Above myself.”

  “Out of place.”

  “Yes.”

  “So someone might wonder: How do you really feel about Akmaro’s family? Do you love them? Or merely hunger for their constant forgiveness?”

  Didul thought about this for a moment. “I love them. Their forgiveness I’ve had for years. The parents. Luet, when she was old enough to understand. She was very young, and children are very forgiving.”

  “So again, someone might wonder—if you are confident of their forgiveness, why are you so shy, so guarded when you’re with them?”

  “Who is doing all this wondering, Edhadeya?”

  “I am, and be quiet. Someone might wonder, Didul, whether some of your shyness might be because you have some kind of special feeling for one of the family and yet you dare not speak of it. . . .”

  “Are you asking me if I love Luet?”

  “Thank you,” said Edhadeya. “Yes, that’s what I’m asking.”

  “Of course I love her. Anyone who knows her has to love her.”

  Edhadeya growled in frustration. “Don’t play games with me, Didul!”

  Didul held the torch farther up and away, so it wouldn’t light his face as he spoke. “Can you imagine anything worse than the day Akma finds out that I’m marrying Luet?”

  “Yes, I can,” said Edhadeya. “The worst thing would be if Luet were to spend day after day, year after year waiting for you, and you never come to her.”

  “She’s not waiting for me.”

  “You’ve asked her?”

  “We haven’t spoken of it.”

  “And she never will, because she fears that you don’t have any feelings for her. But she has them for you. I betray a confidence to tell you this. But you must make your choice based on all the information. Yes, it would gall Akma to have you for a brother-in-law. But this same Akma is already the enemy of everything his father stands for. And to spare his feelings, will you break the heart of Luet, who waits for you? Which is the greater wrong? To hurt the unforgiving one, or to hurt the one who has forgiven all?”

  Didul walked beside her in silence. They reached the door of the king’s house.

  “That was all I had to say,” she said.

  “Can I believe you?” he whispered. “That she cares for me? After all I did?”

  “Women can be insane sometimes in the men they choose to love.”

  “Are you? Insane?”

  “Do you want to know how insane I am, Didul? When Luet and I were younger, we fell in love with each other’s brothers. She finally settled on Mon, because he’s always been the one I was closest to. And I of course loved Akma from afar.” Edhadeya smiled mysteriously. “Then Luet grew out of that childish love and found something much finer in her love for you.” Edhadeya laughed lightly. “Good night, Didul.”

  “Aren’t you going to finish your story?”

  “I did.” She walked to the door; the guard opened it for her.

  Didul stood in the sputtering torchlight as the door closed.

  The guard finally spoke to him. “Are you from out of the city, sir? Do you need directions somewhere?”

  “No, no . . . I know the way.”

  “Then you’d better set out—your torch won’t burn forever, unless you plan to let the flame run right down your arm.”

  Didul thanked him with a smile and set off for the public house where he was staying. Akmaro and Chebeya invited him for dinner, but never to stay the night. It would not do for him to be there, even sleeping, should Akma choose to come home.

  Luet stopped loving Mon, but Edhadeya never grew out of that childish love for Akma. That must be a difficult situation for her. At least the man that Luet loved was loyal to the cause of the Keeper. Edhadeya, a dreamer of true dreams, the daughter of the king, loved a man who disbelieved in the Keeper and despised the Kept.

  Maybe I’m not the worst possible husband. Maybe I do have something to offer Luet, besides poverty and the fury of her brother and a memory of my cruelty to her when she was little. Maybe she should be given the choice, at least. Didn’t he owe it to her, to give her the chance to hear him talk of his love for her and ask for her to be his wife, so she could refuse him and cause him a small fraction of the humiliation and pain he had once caused her?

  He despised himself at once even for thinking this. Didn’t he know Luet at all, to think she would want to hurt him or anyone else? Edhadeya said she loved him. And he knew that he loved her. Akmaro had made it plain that he would give his approval. So had Chebeya, in a thousand small ways, talking about how much a part of the family he was.

  I will speak to her, he decided. I will speak to her tomorrow.

  He doused his dying torch in the pail at the door of the public house and went inside to spend a few hours wishing he could sleep instead of rehearsing over and over in his mind the words he would say to Luet, imagining over and over the way she might smile and embrace him, or weep and run from him, or stare at him in horror and whisper, How could you? How could you?

  At last he did sleep. And in his dream, he saw himself and Luet standing beneath a tree. It was heavy with a white fruit, but it was just out of reach—neither of them was tall enough to reach it. “Lift me up,” she said. “Lift me up, and I can pick enough for both of us.”

  So he lifted her, and she filled her hands, and when he lowered her back to the ground she took a bite and wept at the sharp sweetness of it. “Didul,” she whispered. “I can’t bear it if you don’t have a bite—here, from this place right beside where I
bit, so you can taste exactly what I tasted.”

  But in his dream he didn’t bite from the fruit at all. Instead he kissed her, and from her own lips tasted exactly what she had tasted, and yes, it was sweet.

  The trial was so well known that even before Didul was asleep, people were gathering in the large open court. At dawn, when the guards arrived, they had to herd the early arrivals to the front rows overlooking the court. The judge’s seat was, of course, in shadow, and would be throughout the day. Some thought this was for the judge’s comfort, protecting him from the summer heat, but in winter it could be bitterly cold in the shade, with no scrap of sun to warm him. No, the shade was to help keep the judge more or less anonymous. People could see most clearly where the light was; the complainants and the accused were in light continuously, and if either of them had brought a lawyer in to speak for them, he would strut the length and breadth of the sunlit area. No lawyer, however, would step within the judge’s shadow. Some thought this was out of respect for the king’s honor as embodied in his deputy, the judge. But the lawyers all knew that to step out of the light made them appear clumsy, weak, unaware, and would dispose the people against them. Not that the people had any voice in the decision, officially—though there had been notorious trials in the past where it seemed the judge had made his decision based solely on which outcome would be most likely to allow him to leave the court alive. But the lawyers knew that their reputation, their likelihood of being hired for other cases, depended on how the onlookers perceived them.

  The sun was halfway to noon when the accusers arrived, along with their lawyer, a loquacious angel named kRo. It was forbidden for an angel to fly in the court, but kRo had a way of opening his wings and sort of gliding as he walked back and forth, building up passion in himself and in the audience. It made him seem at once larger and more graceful than his opponent, and many human lawyers refused to take on cases that might put them head to head with kRo.