Playing to Win, A Forbidden Firsts Story

by Kinley Grey

  Carter met Amber's eyes. They were the color of burnished gold. Her body glowed in the setting sunlight and Carter wondered what the three of them must look like, here in the warm evening with the sun behind them and night coming on.

  Amber asked in a throaty voice, “Have you ever kissed a girl?”

  Carter stared at Amber's mouth. Her lips were half-open and so soft and inviting. She shook her head.

  “Would you like to kiss me, Carter?”

  Carter did want to kiss her. More than anything.

  Amber's hands were on her breasts, thumbing the nipples that rose up tight and pinched beneath her caresses.

  Violet's hands on her hips reached around to massage her buttocks, drawing her in closer until Carter could feel hot breath on her mound.

  Carter's body hummed with feeling, hovering inches away from climax. As she pressed her lips to Amber's and felt the other girl's tongue slip into her mouth, Violet dipped her tongue into her sleek folds below and fluttered against her clitoris, like a butterfly unfolding its wings.

  A wave of pleasure crashed through Carter, and now she kissed Amber hotly, their breasts surging together. Wave after wave of pleasure traveled her body, and she cried out her ecstasy against Amber's full lips, while Violet feasted on her from below.

  When her body stopped shuddering, Violet took her hand while Amber went to get the camera. Carter saw it was on a tripod now, and the red light was on.

  “We got the whole thing,” said Amber. “You were magnificent.”

  Amber started to put the camera away in a backpack as Violet reached for her shirt.

  Carter didn't want them to go. She didn't want to wait for Dan alone. And there was more: she wanted to touch them the way they'd touched her. She wanted to touch them and taste them, see them spread open before her. Desire rose up sharply as she gazed at their topless bodies and imagined more.

  She said, “Can you stay a while longer?”

  The girls shared a knowing glance, and Violet took Carter's hand. “I was hoping you'd say that,” she said, and climbed the steps into the RV.

  The Drive (Again) - Dan

  It had taken Dan a long time to get back to the main road and find someone willing to give him a ride into town. Once he was home he didn't even go into their apartment. He was just getting into his car when his cell phone rang.

  “Hi Dan,” it could have been Stacy or Carter, they sounded so much alike, but his caller ID showed Stacy's number. “How's everything going out there, having fun?”

  “Like you wouldn't believe,” Dan said as he backed his car out of his driveway. “Just one hitch: stupid RV wouldn't start this morning.”

  There was a brief silence on the line before she said, “Hey listen, I've got a confession to make. I sent you out there with a bad battery on purpose.”

  It took a moment for her words to sink in and when they did, Dan's anger flared up. “Why the hell would you pull a dumb-ass stunt like that? Are you crazy?”

  “Maybe a little,” said Stacy, her voice sounding unperturbed. “But I have some friends I wanted Carter to meet, and I really wanted them to hit it off.”

  “You could have told me so, Stacy.” Dan's words were clipped. “I would have cleared out.”

  “I know you would, but it wouldn't have had quite the same effect. Believe me, I've thought long and hard about this. Carter means the world to me and I want to show her. But I'm only going to get one chance, so everything has to be perfect.”

  “What are you talking about?” said Dan. “She idolizes you.”

  “That's not what I want from her,” she sighed, and Dan heard a note of longing in her voice. “But anyway, about why I called. Are you on your way back yet?”

  “Yep, I'm just about to the first turn-off.”

  “All right, I need to prepare you. I have a very strong suspicion that when you get back my friends are going to be there.”

  “Okay, fine, I'll stay out of their way.” Dan snapped. This was supposed to be his weekend with Carter, not some girls' night out.

  “Um, I don't think you'll want to do that.” Now Dan could hear her amusement. “In fact, I guarantee you'll want to join them. I just don't want you to be worried if you walk in on something you weren't expecting.”

  “Is that all?” Dan didn't like being laughed at.

  “One last thing. Tell Carter I may stop by tomorrow.”

  Dan rolled his eyes. Just what he needed. “Fine, whatever. Look, I've gotta go,” he said and ended the call.

  He'd been so thankful to Stacy for setting up this whole weekend, but not anymore. She'd clearly gone off the deep end. Sending them into the middle of nowhere with a bad battery was some crazy-ass shit. He was going to have to talk to Carter about her step-sister when he got back. He pressed down on the accelerator and sped toward the RV.

  Girls’ Night In - Carter

  Carter let Violet lead her into the bedroom. Amber followed with the camera, which she set up again on the tripod.

  “Do you trust us?” asked Amber.

  Carter nodded. She did trust them, though she couldn't say why.

  Amber undressed Violet while Carter watched, first removing her shorts, then her panties, until she stood naked in front of them. Her pubic hair was shaved into a small strip at the front, and on one of her narrow hips was a tattoo of a tiny purple flower. Violet crawled to the pillows on the bed and lay back, letting her legs fall naturally apart.

  Carter stood frozen, not sure she could go through with it.

  “Come here,” Violet held a hand out to Carter. “Just watch for now.”

  Carter got on the bed and knelt at Violet's feet while Violet leaned back on one elbow, opening her legs fully and spreading her pussy lips with one hand so Carter could see her secret places. Her pussy lips were slick with moisture, and Carter could see her clitoris nestled within, like a luminescent pearl. Violet dipped a single finger into her juices and circled the pearl, then rubbed it back and forth, slow strokes on each side of it and over the top.

  Again, she dipped her finger into her pussy but this time she brought it up to trace Carter's lips. Carter leaned forward and opened her mouth for the wet finger. It slipped inside and she savored the taste of the other woman and sucked gently at the finger. Then it was removed and Violet lay still on the bed, her eyes watching Carter with intense desire.

  Barely touching her, Carter leaned over and touched the tip of her tongue to Violet's swollen nub. Violet shivered at her touch and Carter grew bolder. She put her lips around the nub and suckled it. It was silky under her tongue, and hot, and when she licked it, Violet responded by moaning and raising her hips.

  Carter looked around for Amber, and the blonde woman eagerly joined them. She pushed Carter's knees apart and lay on her back between them, face full of Carter's pussy. Now Carter buried her face between Violet's legs, exalting in the feeling of Amber doing the same to her. Amber was nibbling on her clitoris, so she in turn scraped Violet's hard nub with her teeth until she cried out for her to stop.

  Carter was surrounded by pleasure, the giving and the receiving. She felt Amber's tongue begin to thrust deeply into her pussy and moaned, immediately doing the same to Violet. She reached her tongue in as far as it would go, pressing her face into Violet's hot sex.

  Then Carter froze as she felt Amber begin to explore even further back. Amber's tongue licked at her most private place, pressing on it, and slipping inside. Carter's heart was in her throat, and she knew she should tell Amber to stop but her mouth was full of Violet's pussy. She also realized she didn't want Amber to stop.

  Carter eyed Violet's tightly puckered asshole, then gave it a tentative kiss followed by a lick. Its texture was bumpy against her tongue and she pressed it more firmly, her tongue almost inside, while she dipped her index finger into Violet's slick, wet slit. When it was dripping wet, she began to massage Violet's asshole with it, slipping it in and out, shallowly. She deepened her strokes, and slid her thumb into Violet's pussy o
pening at the same time. Attaching her mouth to Violet's clitoris she sucked and stroked, loving the softness of her body and the slippery heat beneath her fingers.

  Violet began to rock her pussy into Carter's face, so she sucked harder, and pushed her fingers in faster and deeper, drawing the climax out of Violet. Violet's whole body tensed, her pussy spasming tightly around Carter's fingers. She cried out again and again, as Carter brought out her orgasm.

  Amber still explored Carter with her tongue, but now she pressed her fist against Carter's pussy. She twisted her hand slowly with an upward pressure that drove Carter mad with longing. Then the pressure was gone and she cried out in frustration when Amber slid out from beneath her.

  Amber was off the bed getting something out of the pocket of her shorts, and she asked Carter again, “Do you trust us?”

  Carter was so horny she didn't care what they did to her, as long as they kept doing it. She nodded, and Amber pushed her back on the bed and knelt on top of her, while Violet rapidly tied her hands above her head to the headboard.

  Amber got up and used a fingernail to stimulate Carter's nipple, then leaned down and stroked Carter's hair back from her eyes, almost lovingly.

  “You've got one helluva sister.”

  Carter was startled, “You know Stacy?”

  “We've... hooked up a few times. You remind me a lot of her.”

  “What does she have to do with any of this?” Carter asked, but she already knew. Stacy had put it in her mind to kiss a girl and then sent them out here, knowing she would do it.

  “We didn't know if you'd go this far,” Violet was saying, “but we told her if you let us we'd give you a night you'd never forget. That's what we're about to do.”

  Amber had come back with their backpacks and was removing a blindfold. “Some of what we do is going to feel incredibly good, and some of it is going to hurt like hell.”

  “Do you want to stop?” asked Violet.

  Carter's mouth was dry and she licked her lips, tasting Violet there. She took in Amber's face, still wet with her own juices and shook her head.

  “Good. Now relax, and prepare to enjoy yourself.” said Amber, as she slipped the blindfold over Carter's eyes.

  Carter's heart began to beat out of her chest. What were they going to do to her? She didn't want them to hurt her. She caught her breath anxiously at a touch on her stomach. It traced its way to her pussy and began to massage her clitoris firmly. She lifted her hips into the stroking hand, willing it to rub her faster, and it did. Then she cried out sharply as something clamped viciously down on first one nipple, then the other.

  The hand stroking her pussy increased its intensity, and the pain in her nipples faded to a glorious ache as a climax began to build deep within her. At that moment, one of the women knelt over her face, and Carter opened her mouth wide and filled it with pussy. The climax started in Carter's center and radiated throughout her entire body as wave after wave of pleasure rolled through her. Carter suckled and cried out, her voice muffled by the slick, wet heat above her.

  After the waves had passed, she expected the hand rubbing her clitoris would stop and they'd untie her. Instead, it kept at her. The rubbing went on steadily. It was so perfectly done it didn't de-sensitize her, and she was shocked when she felt the heat, impossibly, building at her core again.

  She gulped and sucked at the wet slit immediately above her, and the woman's hips began to grind into her face in a rhythm that Carter matched with deep thrusts of her tongue. The thighs on both sides of her face began to tremble and Carter heard the woman above her cry out with satisfaction, as her face was covered by the woman's juices.

  Carter's own pleasure was building again, and she took a welcome breath of air as the woman atop her moved to one side. Someone leaned over her and pulled at the cruel devices on her breasts. She gasped in pain and caught a familiar scent. “Dan?” she cried out.

  There was no answer. Instead, fingers entered her. Was that one, two... three fingers? She lifted her hips as she longed to be filled. A voice at her ear, maybe Violet, told her to relax. At that moment she felt unbelievable pressure as something pressed tightly against the opening to her pussy and tried to enter her.

  Cool hands soothed her tortured nipples with gentle strokes, but all Carter could feel was exquisite pain and pressure as her pussy spread and stretched around something much too big to fit inside her. She moaned in agony and fought against her bonds. A cool hand stroked her face tenderly while the cruel hand tore her apart. Then, the pressure eased as it slipped into her. She sensed movement deep inside now, like fingers curling in a fist. Then she groaned as the hand inside her began to twist slowly from side to side.

  A hot mouth found her clitoris and began to suck insistently. Just when Carter couldn't bear any more she felt something warm and rigid against her cheek and turned towards it, hungrily. She'd known Dan was here. His cock filled her mouth and he began to rock his hips forward and back, keeping time with the slow movements of the fist deep within her.

  As Carter's pleasure mounted, the power of her building orgasm scared her. She twisted her body, trying to get away, but the hungry mouth at her cunt drove her before it, and the fist twisting inside would give her no quarter. Dan held her head steady as he filled her mouth with his powerful movements. Hands and lips were everywhere upon her, soothing, stroking, kissing and punishing.

  Finally she submitted to the overwhelming sensations, and with a guttural cry that came from her most primal place, her climax was upon her. She was being ripped in two, her body shuddering as deep sobs tore from her throat. Her body arched, stretched upon the rack of her pleasure.

  When it was over, and the fist in her pussy had been slowly, carefully removed and the cum gently wiped from her chest, Dan took off her blindfold and tenderly kissed her trembling lips. Amber and Violet were gone. Dan untied her hands, and helped her get under the covers. He lay down next to her and wrapped them both in a soft blanket.

  “I love you,” he whispered into her ear, and Carter turned her face into his chest and began to cry as the emotions of the day overwhelmed her.

  What Dan Saw – Dan

  Dan was mentally cursing Stacy for sending them into the desert with a bad battery. He couldn't think of any good reason for her to do something like that. He was still fuming about it when he walked into the bedroom and straight into his dirtiest fantasy.

  This was the way Dan imagined Carter when he was alone: blindfolded and tied to the bed. The other two naked women, especially the blonde with the nice rack, were bonus. He didn't stop to question. He took in the whole scene as he went to Carter's side.

  He tugged lightly at the chain connecting the nipple clamps on her breasts and felt his balls tighten as she practically leaped off the bed, writhing in pain and calling his name. She was helpless and so gorgeous.

  He undid his pants and noticed the brunette working a rubber-gloved hand into Carter's pussy. Holy shit, he thought. She's going to fist fuck her.

  With one hand, Dan stroked his rigid cock while he used the other to soothe her tortured breasts and wipe the sweat from her forehead. He watched the brunette with her arm buried deep inside his girlfriend, then saw the blonde put her mouth on Carter's pussy and begin to suck. The scene made him unbelievably horny. He needed to be inside Carter now.

  Dan knelt next to Carter and touched her cheek with his cock. She turned to him immediately, mouth open and searching. He filled it and began to slowly stroke in and out.

  He could always tell when she was going to come, and she was very close now. She tried to twist away but he held her head firm, thrusting more deeply. He loved the way her mouth stretched around his hard cock, and the way the tears dripped from beneath her blindfold and onto the pillow below. She had never been more beautiful to him.

  Her orgasm began and she moaned and gasped around his cock filling her mouth. Her hot breath and convulsions sent him over the edge and he pumped his load onto her breasts. She lay there trembl
ing, slick with sweat and cum. He bent down and whispered in her ear, “I love you.” Then he cleaned her up and held her until she fell asleep. He didn’t even notice when the other two girls left.

  When Dan woke up the next morning, Carter was still fast sleep. He watched her, marveling at how perfect she was. He knew that last night had awakened something within her, something fierce and passionate. He wondered just how deeply she'd been affected.

  Carter stirred and opened her eyes, focusing on his face immediately. She smiled at him, her same sweet smile, then stretched luxuriously, pressing her naked body sensuously against his. He stroked her side and she shivered under his fingers.

  “I had the most amazing dream last night,” she said. Then she quickly added, “I hope you didn't mind.”

  “Are you kidding? You were fucking amazing.”

  “I feel fucking amazing. Like I could do anything.” She sat up, swinging her legs over the side of the bed. “First though, I need to eat something. I'm starving!”

  He saw her glance around for something to wear and he smiled sheepishly. She saw his look and raised her eyebrows. “You're kidding. You didn't bring me any decent clothes?”

  “Sorry babe,” he drawled. “I like you indecent.”

  She launched herself at him and landed sprawled across him. “I'll show you indecent!” she threatened.

  He laughed and pinned her arms to her sides, expertly flipping her onto her back and holding her in place with the weight of his body. “Do you promise?”

  His cock hardened as she fought helplessly beneath him and he relished her failed struggles to escape his grip. Her naked body writhed against his. He wanted her and he was going to have her. With his knee he nudged apart her legs and pulled back so he could see her face when he entered her. At that moment she reached up and sank her teeth into his nipple, hard. He lurched aside and she scrambled free. The throbbing in his cock was on par with the pain in his chest and he lay there, stunned for a moment.